Regarding Penance: Opinions Requested

  • Thread starter Thread starter Bellator
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

Bellator

Guest
To My Fellow Catholics:

I write to you in hope that through your opinions, I may gain knowledge that shall enable me to better formulate my spiritual life.

My question is this: what comes to mind when one hears the phase, “to do great penance.” Penance, as we know, often considered as a physical manifestation of contrition for our sins, although the term can be carried to acts of suffering done in reparation for others. If one were to “enact great penance,” how would he proceed? Of course, this question cannot be answered in a single sentance, for forms of penance are as diverse as there are individuals, but it is my hope that my fellow Catholics will share their opinion on the matter.

Sincerely,
Bellator
 
Since repent means to change, I’ve always held “penance” to be the things you do to change.

So I don’t think of penance and punishment the same way. Punishment is atonement for something I did wrong. Penance is something I do to improve myself and bring myself back into good graces with God. They may be the same activity, but maybe not. A person can spend his whole life doing punishment for sins and crimes without any change of heart – I would not call what they are doing, “penance.”

But I may be totally wrong.

Alan
 
Penance does remove the punishment. When we go to confession we are forgiven and brought back to a state of grace. However we have to make reparation for our sin. Either now, or in Purgatory. But we are brought back to grace regardless of the penance.

In the ancient church a penance was harsh, long and exact. In other words when you finished with your penance all the punishment for those sins were removed.

In modern times the meager penance assigned to us does not fully expiate all the punishment. So the church issues indulgences which are like super penances. I would say the best way to do a “Great penance” is to concentrate on gaining indulgences. A plenary indulgence removes fully all punishment due to us in purgatory. Partial indulgence only removes part of it.

catholic.org/clife/prayers/indulgw.php
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top