Reincarnation: Newsweek essay/Eck, Harvard

  • Thread starter Thread starter Nandarani
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
N

Nandarani

Guest
Hello, well, here we go again. I am certain I won’t be traveling back to Hinduism. And it makes perfect sense to me (thought it before I found it in Newsweek), that it could be said by a Newsweek essay contributor, by virtue of the all pervasiveness of the “new age” - that “we are all Hindus” - which is the title of the essay in the latest issue of Newsweek.

It mentions Diane Eck - who has been at Harvard for a long time, and who has always had this mentality through the years, saying, in essence, that it seems that there is less and less reason to believe in Jesus’ resurrection, or anything else about him. The article also states that 84 percent of people believe in reincarnation, now. SO… this hurts me - because I just have to realize I am powerless to do much about it other than live my faith.

Would someone from a Catholic perspective more versed than I get into the topic of reincarnation again? The article also implies that it is basically foolish to believe in looking to keep the same body in whatever form it would be. The article sums up the Hindu position as being that the soul is finally freed from the confinement of the body and all the encumbrances of having a particular mindset, etc. during the life just past of experience based on past karma.

[INSERTED somewhat off train of the post…If anyone can answer I would like to read what people who know more than I from a Catholic perspective would say abou this q… if someone is NOT Christian and or not Catholic… would they still be subject to purgatory? If so, a lot of people must be very surprised after death about what happens.]

Back to the train of thought about karma: This is so common an underlying idea now, just based on what people see around them, and what they conclude.

Please dive in and don’t feel, however, that you are dealing with someone who has not bee fully converted. I HAVE !.. it’s just that I understand the new age and Hindu mindset very very well - all the rationalizations that are not mentioned or talked about, including a sense of superiority over those who are following Christ. It is basically, as I know very well, an easy enjoyable path for many many people who want to be able to do their own thing.

It’s worth noting that the serious aspects of Hinduism are seldom put to the fore, now - the harder aspects having to do with meditation, self-denial, etc. But the bottom line is: even those aspects don’t center in Christ in the final analysis, but in “becoming God” one way or the other.

That’s why Self-Realizatoin Fellowship isn’t compatible at all with Christ, even though Christ is included as a figure in their collection of dieties. But that is another topic.
 
  1. A survey that shows “everyone believes it” does not mean truth.
  2. Hinduism is another proof that God truly have planted his “laws” into Man’s hearts.
  3. Catholic Faith is the maturity of all other faiths which is a result of Man’s pride: the “want to be able to do their own thing.” With Catholic Faith, one find’s help from God in order to Mature in faith.
 
Would someone from a Catholic perspective more versed than I get into the topic of reincarnation again? The article also implies that it is basically foolish to believe in looking to keep the same body in whatever form it would be. The article sums up the Hindu position as being that the soul is finally freed from the confinement of the body and all the encumbrances of having a particular mindset, etc. during the life just past of experience based on past karma. . . …
It always comes down to the lie of the oh-so-spiritual Enemy in his jealousy of flesh. It’s only in Christianity that one finds the full Truth of the goodness of the human body, because we know with the certainty of faith that God the Son took on that flesh for the salvation of the whole man. The appeal of a belief in reincarnation is precisely what you say - wanting to do what one desires with and to one’s body without fear of any ultimate consequences. This, of course, is counter the Incarnation of Christ AND His Resurrection, our guarantee that our bodies are created to join with our spirits in the fullness of the salvation that He won for us. We are not purely spiritual creatures to whom a body is of no consequence and so can flit from one to another until we are “enlightened”; the consequences of the actions prompted by our spirit (a gift of God) - for good or ill - are shared by the one body we receive.

Some articles on the subject:

catholic.com/thisrock/1991/9101chap.asp

catholic.com/thisrock/1995/9504frs.asp

catholic.com/thisrock/2005/0510dr.asp
[INSERTED somewhat off train of the post…If anyone can answer I would like to read what people who know more than I from a Catholic perspective would say abou this q… if someone is NOT Christian and or not Catholic… would they still be subject to purgatory? If so, a lot of people must be very surprised after death about what happens.]
Yes. And they will indeed be surprised - and may they and we all be happily so!!
 
  1. A survey that shows “everyone believes it” does not mean truth.
  2. Hinduism is another proof that God truly have planted his “laws” into Man’s hearts.
  3. Catholic Faith is the maturity of all other faiths which is a result of Man’s pride: the “want to be able to do their own thing.” With Catholic Faith, one find’s help from God in order to Mature in faith.
I just got back and have only read THIS message - will be offline for a while. THANK YOU… this is good because … it dovetails with what I believe, esp. #3. Certainly #1, too. In the US, however, we have strong strong new age stuff going on. And at the same time, evidence that young people are becoming very orthodox - not only in Catholicism. It’s heartening. If you want to expand on #2, that would be good. I’m interested. Maybe my view is that laws govern everything not all of which laws we have discovered, for sure. Which fact need not interfere with Christ being the ultimate only way.
 
Thank you, Frances, for your reply and the articles. It seems it is just much easier for many people these days to trust themselves in the final analysis, in everything. In spite of the self-contradiction and inner confusion. Faith in Christ seems more and more a GIFT.
 
One of the problems with New Age and New Thought “religions” is their utter rejection of the concept of sin and consequences. Because of this precept, they are forced only to accept what I call “the coloring book Jesus,” that is, the image of Christ as the gentle man sitting on a rock with arms open welcoming a group of little children, symbolic of His embrace for everyone without regard to their belief or their behavior. Adopting concepts of Eastern religions plays right into this, as it adds that element of “mysticism” that is notably absent from the life of Christ if you subtract anything He ever said or did as regards sin.

Once, at a dinner party, I got into a discussion with a New Thought minister about Jesus driving the money changers out of the temple. He said to me, “Yeah, Jesus really lost it. Just goes to show He was human.” He had no concept even of why what Jesus saw was so offensive to Him (and to the Father). It was just a day when even a highly enlightened fellow was preoccupied and lost control. He “lost control.” God Almighty losing control. What a concept!

Most if not all NA/NT views don’t even hold Christ as Divine, only somehow “attuned” to a relationship with God in a perfect way. Using a radio as an example, their view is Jesus was tuned right on the station being broadcast while the rest of us are off in the static, getting only a fragment of the broadcast here and there. So they, like Christians, are all about following the example of Christ, but there the similarity ends. They believe, in a Buddist sort of way, that our goal is to get tuned to the right frequency, and if we do we become like God. That is why you hear them use such terms as “co-create with God…” etc.

Most make no secret of their origins, and if you look into them, you will see an open admission that the founders of these movements cherry-picked elements of different religions and lumped them all together to form… something. What none of them can avoid, however, is the fact that all them have a fallible (human) interpretive twist on them. That means the entire “faith,” if you want to call it that, relies only on the original thoughts of one or two “enlightened” individuals. As time went on, more and more strange (to me) thoughts were added into this body of knowledge, and today much of it is there for the taking but not in a mandatory way. Much of what it is today is similar to going into a library and picking out a book that appeals to you. Believe pretty much what you want, what makes you feel good.

It’s a road that leads directly to emptiness.
 
Newsweek hasn’t been a newsmagazine in a while. It just pushes a certain viewpoint. And that viewpoint is New Age. It’s sad to watch.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top