Reincarnation -true or false?

  • Thread starter Thread starter wcknight
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
W

wcknight

Guest
Is there any room for reincarnation within Christianity ???

Some other belief systems have this in their faith… is there any indication that Christianity could include this in its beliefs ?

I don’t think the concept appears anywhere in the Bible or in Catholic tradition. None of the visionaries who have encountered Jesus or Mary have mentioned such a thing. Surely IF it were likely someone would have been given a revelation as to whether it is possible or likely.
 
No…no place for it in the Christian faith.

Hebrews 9:27 And just as each person is destined to die once and after that comes judgment,

It goes against so many of the teachings of the church.
 
Another problem is the resurrection. If a soul is reincarnated over and over again, which of a person’s former bodies will the soul be resurrected into?
 
Nope, they don’t go together.

All the dead will rise again, not just “spirits” who have been several human beings each.

We are not spirits in any case. Each human being is Soul + Body. The soul is made to fit that unique body.

ICXC NIKA
 
The reason why I ask is after reading “Proof of Heaven” by Dr, Eben Alexander. I went to his web site and saw an interview of him by Larry King. In the interview he mentioned that, he now believed the soul reincarnated…

It was not mentioned in his book. I suspect he got this from his near death experience. Some others have mentioned this as well, and some researchers have found some evidence of this happening. It’s definitely possible that they are being misled.

No mysic or saint has ever mentioned this, so I suspect it is false. Certainly some of the visionaries who have encountered Mary or Jesus would have said something if this were true.
 
Yea…that’s the tricky thing about visions/dreams/neardeath etc etc…It’s up for personal interpretation and influence of the supernatural kind or other.
 
wcknight said:
The reason why I ask is after reading “Proof of Heaven” by Dr, Eben Alexander. I went to his web site and saw an interview of him by Larry King. In the interview he mentioned that, he now believed the soul reincarnated…

It was not mentioned in his book. I suspect he got this from his near death experience. Some others have mentioned this as well, and some researchers have found some evidence of this happening. It’s definitely possible that they are being misled.

No mysic or saint has ever mentioned this, so I suspect it is false. Certainly some of the visionaries who have encountered Mary or Jesus would have said something if this were true.
Click to expand...
Sadly, this happens a lot after NDE, including George Richie (whose 1944 experience, before the acronym was coined, was in a way seminal).

Having looked over the edge does not exempt one from later deception, of whatever kind. Richie’s written account of his NDE does not mention reincarnation.

ICXC NIKA
 
If reincarnation existed, then why did Jesus let himself be crucified? Think about it, the two dont work together.
 
Not quite reincarnation, but according to Jewish Hasidim, a person may descend into this world multiple times, until all 613 commandments are fulfilled.
 
wcknight said:
Is there any room for reincarnation within Christianity ???

Some other belief systems have this in their faith… is there any indication that Christianity could include this in its beliefs ?

I don’t think the concept appears anywhere in the Bible or in Catholic tradition. None of the visionaries who have encountered Jesus or Mary have mentioned such a thing. Surely IF it were likely someone would have been given a revelation as to whether it is possible or likely.
Click to expand...
The Church teaching:

CCC 1013 Death is the end of man’s earthly pilgrimage, of the time of grace and mercy which God offers him so as to work out his earthly life in keeping with the divine plan, and to decide his ultimate destiny. When “the single course of our earthly life” is completed, we shall not return to other earthly lives: “It is appointed for men to die once.” There is no “reincarnation” after death.
 
It is recognize for certain soul such John the Baptims was the reincarnation of Elija (not sure the spelling), but in general we have one shot. These idea that we have been in many lives and will continue to do so until we master our life is totally new age or Buddism and is not in agreement with the bible neither with Jesus teaching.

We have this life to be a good seed that will beare great fruits. Weeds, get toss out at the end.
 
In addition, the concept of Reincarnation indicates a false understanding of the relationship between Body and Soul.

The Soul is the animating principle of the Body, It is the Form of the Body and is thus unique to the Body. One Soul animates one Body.

Together they form the Material Composite ( Matter and Form) that defines a human being.

A human, as Pope John Paul II noted, is the UNION of Body and Soul.

A different body necessitates a different soul and thus is a different person.

No reincarnation, just Resurrection!
 
Robert_Sock said:
Not quite reincarnation, but according to Jewish Hasidim, a person may descend into this world multiple times, until all 613 commandments are fulfilled.
Click to expand...
  1. How does someone, in this teaching, return to the world from death if not by reincarnation?
  2. Since many Jewish commandments are without fulfillment in post-Temple Judaism, will they keep “descending” until the temple is restored?
 
WELL, we get our bodies back at the Resurrection. 🙂 That count?

In that case “Yes”

Coming back as an animal or something? :nope:
 
Chantal25 said:
It is recognize for certain soul such John the Baptims was the reincarnation of Elija (not sure the spelling), but in general we have one shot. These idea that we have been in many lives and will continue to do so until we master our life is totally new age or Buddism and is not in agreement with the bible neither with Jesus teaching.

We have this life to be a good seed that will beare great fruits. Weeds, get toss out at the end.
Click to expand...
That is not correct. John the Baptist was NOT the reincarnation of Elijah and the Church most definitely does not teach such a thing.
 
bygsunflower poster 2012
Dang tin,up tin t? d?ng nhanh chóng lên hon 5300 di?n dÃn, qu?ng cáo.
Vu?t qua câu h?i b?o m?t và mã an ninh captcha khi dang tin, up tin
Dang tin qu?ng cáo b?ng nhi?u tÃi kho?n m?t lúc
T?o nick hoÃn toÃn t? d?ng, t?c d? nhanh, 1000 nick 1 gi?, t? d?ng vu?t qua captcha và câu h?i ng?u nhiên
Lên l?ch up tin t? d?ng lên forum di?n dÃn rao v?t
Don gi?n, d? s? d?ng v?i ngu?i m?i b?t d?u.
T?o tÃi kho?n nick di?n dÃn t? d?ng
T? thêm, b?t các di?n dÃn dang tin.
Auto post bÃi nhanh 500 di?n dÃn ch? m?t 10 phút.
T? d?ng dò box link d? dang tin.
TÃch h?p Auto Reply + Pageview Hack.
Xu?t báo cáo dang tin.
Nh?p tÃi kho?n di?n dÃn qua file excel
T?o/d?i ch? ký t? d?ng
T?o/d?i Avatar t? d?ng
T?o/d?i thông tin cá nhân c?a account
H? tr? spin content (spintax, spyntax) trên tiêu d? và n?i dung nh?m t?o ra n?i dung khác nhau khi dang tin
Hu?ng d?n s? d?ng bygsunflower poster
Mu?n dang l?i tiêu d? cu ho?c chuyên m?c mÃ* tiêu d? cu ( vui lòng vÃo BYG–> Xóa d? li?u h? th?ng–>Xóa các topic dã post) xong dóng tab t?t m? d? c?p nh?t ( luu ý dùng d? tránh thu?t toán chim cánh c?t)
20/5/2012 tr? di có nhi?u di?n dÃn báo mail v? r?t ch?m vÃ* d? ta reg dc 600 mail, d? 30 phút - 4 ti?ng s? mail reg nh?ng di?n dÃ*n g?i v? >900 mail ( tuong duong > 1500 nick)

Fix l?i c?p nh?t 12/7 thu?t toán Penguin 1.0

Mu?n dang l?i tiêu d? cu ho?c chuyên m?c mÃ* tiêu d? cu ( vui lòng vÃo BYG–> Xóa d? li?u h? th?ng–>Xóa các topic dã post) xong dóng tab t?t m? d? c?p nh?t và thay d?i proxy . Có nhi?u chuyên m?c hon ,data trên 10.000 ->dang 1 l?n theo chuyên m?c t? 60- 300 bÃi + seo blacklink trên 1000 bÃi
12/7/2012 tr? di reg 1 l?n dc 750 mail, d? 30 phút - 4 ti?ng s? mail reg nh?ng di?n dÃn g?i v? >900 mail ( tuong duong > 1600 nick)
Luu ý : khi th?y reg nick b? l?i 100 và 301 nhi?u vÃ* reg mail du?c 100mail vui lòng xoá profile t?o l?i profile m?i nha (cái dó nó báo trùng profile nên ch? reg dc nhiu dó)

Fix l?i c?p nh?t 15/8 thu?t toán Penguin 1.4 thêm spam blog
*
1/10/2012 tr? di tang lu?ng 100 hay vì 50 lu?ng , tang timeout t? 50 lên 100 , thêm thu?t toán , tang boxlink
*
Luu ý : khi th?y reg nick b? l?i 100 và 301 nhi?u và reg mail du?c 100mail vui lòng xoá profile t?o l?i profile m?i nha (cái dó nó báo trùng profile nên ch? reg dc nhiu dó)**

****Fix l?i c?p nh?t 29/11/2012 *thu?t toánPenguin ***2.0

Ph?n m?m dang tin post 2013 HQForumPoster

********- H? tr? forum **********VBB, **XenForo, phpBB3, IPB3

- Ch?c nang dang tin RONGBAY t? d?ng

- Ph?n m?m d?u tiên và duy nh?t t?i Vi?t Nam hi?n nay h? tr? Forum Xenforo*

- T?o tÃi kho?n forum (Không dang ký l?i khi trên Profile dã có user/pass)*

- T?o tÃi kho?n forum b?ng tay*

- T?o tÃi kho?n Email Yahoo bán t? d?ng.*

- Ki?m tra tÃi kho?n s?ng hay ch?t*

- KÃch ho?t mail t? d?ng*

- Dang tin ->**** Up tin → ****Up tin theo l?ch

- Spam ki?m bÃi- SEOKeywords*

- Spam khách tham ( trang profile)

- T?o ch? ký;**** ****Thay d?i avatar

- H? tr? gi?i mã deathbycaptcha.com, captchatrader

- H? tr? spintax ( cách dùng c ho?c b )

- H? tr? g?i tên ( cách dùng namvietnv002, forums.catholic-questions.org, 03:05:59, 18-01-2013 )

- Luu l?i câu h?i ng?u nhiên
  • CHNN Server - Online
  • Nh?p xu?t d? li?u d? dÃng*
- C?i ti?n thu?t toán T?o nick cho VBB, tang t? l? dang ký thÃnh công thêm 20%***

*- Thêm kh? nang t? d?ng tr? l?i CHNN th? 2 cho VBB *
**

- Thêm ch?c nang “*Xóa forum không ph?i là VBB” ? "T?o tÃi kho?n", giúp b?n l?c forum d? dÃng hon.

- Thêm kh? nang t? phát hi?n forum Xenforo trong danh sách VBB->VBB-D

- Fix ch?c nang nh?p vÃo forum VBB-A ->VBB-D (không nh?p vÃ*o du?c)

- C?i ti?n thu?t toán T?o nick cho VBB, tang t? l? dang ký thÃnh công thêm 20%*

*- Thêm kh? nang t? d?ng tr? l?i CHNN th? 2 cho VBB
*

- Thêm ch?c nang “*Xóa forum không ph?i là VBB” ? "T?o tÃi kho?n", giúp b?n l?c forum d? dÃng hon.

- Thêm kh? nang t? phát hi?n forum Xenforo trong danh sách VBB->VBB-D

- Fix ch?c nang nh?p vÃo forum VBB-A ->VBB-D (không nh?p vÃo du?c)
*

[phan mem dang tin (http://www.bygsunflower.net/) | [ph?n m?m dang tin (http://www.bygsunflower.net/)[** ** (http://www.bygsunflower.net/)| [phan mem seo (http://www.bygsunflower.net/)** | [ph?n m?m seo (http://www.bygsunflower.net/)[ ** (http://www.bygsunflower.net/)
bygsunflower.net
Liên h? :mr :Vu 092.295.2095
 
thistle said:
That is not correct. John the Baptist was NOT the reincarnation of Elijah and the Church most definitely does not teach such a thing.
Click to expand...
Elijah came again through John the baptism. There are a few Gospels that mention this but here is one from Matthew 11:11-15

Truly, I say to you, among those born of women there has risen no one greater than John the Baptist; yet he who is least in the kingdom of heaven is greater than he. From the days of John the Baptism until now the kingdom of heaven has suffered violence, and men of violence take it by force. For all the prophets and the law prophesied until John; and if you are willing to accept it, he is Eli jah who is to come. He who has ears to hear, let him hear
 
Personally I believe in reincarnation. Judaism also believes in it & Christianity is essentially an evolved form of Judaism
 
GEddie said:
  1. How does someone, in this teaching, return to the world from death if not by reincarnation?
  2. Since many Jewish commandments are without fulfillment in post-Temple Judaism, will they keep “descending” until the temple is restored?
Click to expand...
  1. Yes. you’re right.
  2. There is a limit in how many times a person can be reincarnated; I believe I read where this limit is 10 times. I have never read where this limit is based on the restoration of the Temple.
 
Chantal25 said:
Elijah came again through John the baptism. There are a few Gospels that mention this but here is one from Matthew 11:11-15

Truly, I say to you, among those born of women there has risen no one greater than John the Baptist; yet he who is least in the kingdom of heaven is greater than he. From the days of John the Baptism until now the kingdom of heaven has suffered violence, and men of violence take it by force. For all the prophets and the law prophesied until John; and if you are willing to accept it, he is Eli jah who is to come. He who has ears to hear, let him hear
Click to expand...
One wee problem with that.

Elijah *** DID NOT DIE***!! He left this world in his breathing human body!

So just how can someone reincarnate who never dis-incarnated???

ICXC NIKA
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top