S
Son_of_Jonah
Guest
I apologize in advance for what is sure to turn into a novel, but I have relatively few places to turn, so…
My girlfriend and I started dating a relatively short while ago. I am 22 years old, a senior in college, and she is 18, a freshman. We were both born and raised Catholic, but there have been certain differences in our own life experiences that have accounted for some differing views as regards issues of sexuality in relationships, and these differences have caused a good deal of tension already.
For my part, I have been in a few relationships in my life, none very long, and none overtly sexual in nature. I am still a virgin and am committed to remaining so until I am married. In the past this has been the cause of the end of a couple of my relationships. To say that this time is different would be understating the case badly. We feel an emotional connection that surpasses anything we’ve experienced with other people. I love her very much, and I know she feels the same about me. In short, whatever else may follow in this account, breaking up is not an option for us. We are committed to doing whatever it takes to make this work.
As for her story…(which will be typed by her, so the continued use of the first-person does not indicate that I am still typing):
My pasts relationships haven’t been as easy. Starting with this, I am not a virgin like my boyfriend is, yet I am committed to help him see it to marriage. In no way do I want him to break his vow with God. However, my relationships in the past have made this one very tricky. I have had sexual relations (not necessarily intercourse) with five different guys. In my first, I was very naive, and the two of us “explored” a lot. Coming out of that, I felt horrible. When my second relationship came, I thought I had found something different. I thought I had found an emotional connection that I hadn’t ever had before. But this guy had been with a lot of girls in the past, and I always felt the need to prove myself. I was afraid I would lose him and be hurt if I didn’t cave to his wants (but I was unwilling to have sex with him). About six months into the relationship, I found out he cheated on me…long story short, I think it has effected the rest of my relationships since then. Skipping ahead, my last relationship before the one I am in now was abusive. We had sex three months into the it, and after the first time, everything went downhill. Often I would say no, but he would pressure me and push me until he got what he wanted. I also found out that at one time, I fell asleep and he proceeded to do the deed…
I feel like through the course of all of this, I no longer know how to have a relationship without the physical part. While I have been hurt so much by this in the past, I cannot figure out a way to accept that this doesn’t NEED to be a part of a relationship. We struggle because, while I know we will not have sex until we are married, I believe that we can do other things. I show intimacy through a physical means, while he uses emotions instead.
Now back to the guy…
The fundamental difficulty is this: through the various differences in our respective relationship experiences, we view the reality of sexual intimacy differently. My concern is entirely motivational. To me, any physical act motivated out of a desire to fulfill some sort of sexual drive is wrong. Making out, even, can then be something sinful if used in the wrong context. To me, this means that there can be no compromise on the issue. As she indicated above, my girlfriend doesn’t quite agree. She understands why I feel the way I do, why I so strongly espouse the Church’s position on this issue, yet she feels that she cannot accept that position herself. We have, of course, talked about this a number of times. We have set boundaries, rules, limits, etc. and, owing to our youth and human drives, have failed a number of times. I feel that we have gone too far physically. She feels that we have not. I feel that I have, in the heat of the moment, pushed too hard, and she feels guilty for the same reason.
Almost done, I promise… Now she feels that she has developed a dependency upon the fulfillment of sexual desires. I know I cause her some untold level of pain in my refusal to engage in any sort of sexual activity. I also go too far myself in trying not to hurt her at all. I have, a number of times, recommended that we speak to someone - anyone - about this, but she feels so hurt and guilty about her own past that the thought of opening up to someone else is nearly out of the question. And so I turn to this forum, as she obviously agreed we should, owing to the level of anonymity you provide. Furthermore, as a community obviously grounded in the teachings of Christ and His Church, you are poised to offer the best advice for a pair of Catholics hoping beyond hope to make this work.
So what can we do? Friends of hers have suggested means of satisfaction that I find reprehensible myself - whether or not I would ever find out about them - because I believe it in no way helps treat the root of our problem. As I mentioned above, breaking up is out of the question for us. So how can we approach this relationship in such a way as to successfully turn away from our own selfish needs to fulfill sexual drives, to become completely content with each other emotionally until such a time as the expression of love can be physically realized in its God-ordained and appropriate context?
We would certainly appreciate your prayers, and any advice you might have would be most helpful. God bless.
My girlfriend and I started dating a relatively short while ago. I am 22 years old, a senior in college, and she is 18, a freshman. We were both born and raised Catholic, but there have been certain differences in our own life experiences that have accounted for some differing views as regards issues of sexuality in relationships, and these differences have caused a good deal of tension already.
For my part, I have been in a few relationships in my life, none very long, and none overtly sexual in nature. I am still a virgin and am committed to remaining so until I am married. In the past this has been the cause of the end of a couple of my relationships. To say that this time is different would be understating the case badly. We feel an emotional connection that surpasses anything we’ve experienced with other people. I love her very much, and I know she feels the same about me. In short, whatever else may follow in this account, breaking up is not an option for us. We are committed to doing whatever it takes to make this work.
As for her story…(which will be typed by her, so the continued use of the first-person does not indicate that I am still typing):
My pasts relationships haven’t been as easy. Starting with this, I am not a virgin like my boyfriend is, yet I am committed to help him see it to marriage. In no way do I want him to break his vow with God. However, my relationships in the past have made this one very tricky. I have had sexual relations (not necessarily intercourse) with five different guys. In my first, I was very naive, and the two of us “explored” a lot. Coming out of that, I felt horrible. When my second relationship came, I thought I had found something different. I thought I had found an emotional connection that I hadn’t ever had before. But this guy had been with a lot of girls in the past, and I always felt the need to prove myself. I was afraid I would lose him and be hurt if I didn’t cave to his wants (but I was unwilling to have sex with him). About six months into the relationship, I found out he cheated on me…long story short, I think it has effected the rest of my relationships since then. Skipping ahead, my last relationship before the one I am in now was abusive. We had sex three months into the it, and after the first time, everything went downhill. Often I would say no, but he would pressure me and push me until he got what he wanted. I also found out that at one time, I fell asleep and he proceeded to do the deed…
I feel like through the course of all of this, I no longer know how to have a relationship without the physical part. While I have been hurt so much by this in the past, I cannot figure out a way to accept that this doesn’t NEED to be a part of a relationship. We struggle because, while I know we will not have sex until we are married, I believe that we can do other things. I show intimacy through a physical means, while he uses emotions instead.
Now back to the guy…
The fundamental difficulty is this: through the various differences in our respective relationship experiences, we view the reality of sexual intimacy differently. My concern is entirely motivational. To me, any physical act motivated out of a desire to fulfill some sort of sexual drive is wrong. Making out, even, can then be something sinful if used in the wrong context. To me, this means that there can be no compromise on the issue. As she indicated above, my girlfriend doesn’t quite agree. She understands why I feel the way I do, why I so strongly espouse the Church’s position on this issue, yet she feels that she cannot accept that position herself. We have, of course, talked about this a number of times. We have set boundaries, rules, limits, etc. and, owing to our youth and human drives, have failed a number of times. I feel that we have gone too far physically. She feels that we have not. I feel that I have, in the heat of the moment, pushed too hard, and she feels guilty for the same reason.
Almost done, I promise… Now she feels that she has developed a dependency upon the fulfillment of sexual desires. I know I cause her some untold level of pain in my refusal to engage in any sort of sexual activity. I also go too far myself in trying not to hurt her at all. I have, a number of times, recommended that we speak to someone - anyone - about this, but she feels so hurt and guilty about her own past that the thought of opening up to someone else is nearly out of the question. And so I turn to this forum, as she obviously agreed we should, owing to the level of anonymity you provide. Furthermore, as a community obviously grounded in the teachings of Christ and His Church, you are poised to offer the best advice for a pair of Catholics hoping beyond hope to make this work.
So what can we do? Friends of hers have suggested means of satisfaction that I find reprehensible myself - whether or not I would ever find out about them - because I believe it in no way helps treat the root of our problem. As I mentioned above, breaking up is out of the question for us. So how can we approach this relationship in such a way as to successfully turn away from our own selfish needs to fulfill sexual drives, to become completely content with each other emotionally until such a time as the expression of love can be physically realized in its God-ordained and appropriate context?
We would certainly appreciate your prayers, and any advice you might have would be most helpful. God bless.