S
seekingtofind
Guest
Honor thy mother and thy father. Who knew this would be the toughest commandment?
Last Christmas, we all traveled to my parents’ for the holiday. My mother has always been difficult. She has suffered from depression for as long as I can remember. She was physically and emotionally abusive to me and my sibling, so much so that I can hardly remember enjoying time with her. My father went along to get along. He worked A LOT, and I’m sure that had something to do with it, but she treats him like she treats us.
I adopted the role of the “good daughter” while my brother was the “wild child”. We both have a lot to work to do on our demons, but we’re both making progress.
My husband and I have three kids, a daughter and two sons. My mother only likes my daughter, and she’s made this clear on several occasions. Being the “good daughter”, I let her nastiness slide. Until this past occasion. She was very rude to my sons. They’re young boys and rambunctious, to be sure, but they are respectful and terribly sweet. The kind of kids whom elderly couples approach in restaurants to compliment them on their good behavior. They asked for crayons to color pictures. She snapped at them about the Legos they left on the floor in the basement. I have become so numb to her behavior that I noticed it but brushed it off. My brother did not. He got right up into her face and told her to cool down. My brother was always the one to stand up to her, but in his own defense, of course. Now he was defending my sons.
I was touched. And then I was angry. What a mess of emotions.
Later that night, my mother, who had been drinking, told me, “You know how you always say I like girls better than boys? I think you’re right!” I didn’t know what to say. I figured it was the alcohol talking, but when my brother came back in the room, she acted like she’d just told me about the weather and we were moving on now.
As soon as we could get out the next morning, we were out.
My brother called me and told me that I should not, under any circumstances, accept mother’s behavior. He and his wife were absolutely appalled. My kids are all old enough to notice the imbalance in how their grandma treats them.
My mother eventually sent me an e-mail asking me to call her. (Yes, this is how she operates.) I complied, and I finally got to the point where I felt brave enough to bring up her behavior and how it wasn’t going to happen again. She seemed SHOCKED that she had done anything wrong, and she actually told me she didn’t remember ANYTHING she did that day!
My father? Not involved at all. But after several false starts (we used to talk on the phone every week, now maybe once every few months), he’s not speaking to me since mother’s obviously upset with me.
We live three hours away from them. My brother lives five hours away from them, and we are on the way from my parents’ house to my brother’s. They visited my brother twice this summer and never even mentioned they might be coming our way. I didn’t bring it up, and the next time we spoke neither did my mother. I let it go, thinking they wouldn’t feel comfortable here. I can understand that, but I don’t hold any enmity against them. I just want them to try to be better grandparents to my kids. Not as in buying them things and fawning all over them, just as in not treating my daughter well and treating my boys hatefully!
We always host Thanksgiving at our house, since we’re halfway between my brother and my parents. Nobody called this year to tell me anything otherwise. On Thanksgiving, nobody showed up. I expected that, but since we’re usually all so good at sweeping things under the rug, I thought we’d just continue to do that.
This is the first time I’ve ever been truly angry with my mother, and my father, for that matter. I feel I have forgiven them many times. I feel that now that I’m a grown woman with my own family that I do not have to be responsible for their feelings. I’ve always been a good daughter to them. I’ve always tried to make them happy, even when they hurt me. Am I perfect? No way! But I really try. I admit my faults and make amends. This time is very different. It’s been almost a year and it feels like I’m finally growing up and learning that my loyalties lie with my family and not my parents. But I do think about them dying and us never resolving this and what a shame that would be.
I’ve found IMMENSE PEACE in my faith this past year. Another sticking point with mother. My parents stopped taking us to Mass before I was confirmed over some slight she felt from our parish priest. She has nothing but bad things to say about being Catholic. I teach RE, but I can’t talk about it with her without feeling like she thinks I’m some sort of Jesus freak. I finally decided this year to be confirmed, too, since she didn’t think that was the sort of decision an 8th-grader could make. She’s not too hip on that, either, and I don’t count on my parents showing up at Easter Vigil.
VERY confused about all of this. Wish my mother would take responsibility and try to do better so we could just move on. I can’t risk exposing my kids to more of this stuff until she does something. I feel very wrong about that, but don’t know what to do.
Thanks in advance for any and all advice. I’ve read through some similar posts here and have found some good stuff to ponder.
Last Christmas, we all traveled to my parents’ for the holiday. My mother has always been difficult. She has suffered from depression for as long as I can remember. She was physically and emotionally abusive to me and my sibling, so much so that I can hardly remember enjoying time with her. My father went along to get along. He worked A LOT, and I’m sure that had something to do with it, but she treats him like she treats us.
I adopted the role of the “good daughter” while my brother was the “wild child”. We both have a lot to work to do on our demons, but we’re both making progress.
My husband and I have three kids, a daughter and two sons. My mother only likes my daughter, and she’s made this clear on several occasions. Being the “good daughter”, I let her nastiness slide. Until this past occasion. She was very rude to my sons. They’re young boys and rambunctious, to be sure, but they are respectful and terribly sweet. The kind of kids whom elderly couples approach in restaurants to compliment them on their good behavior. They asked for crayons to color pictures. She snapped at them about the Legos they left on the floor in the basement. I have become so numb to her behavior that I noticed it but brushed it off. My brother did not. He got right up into her face and told her to cool down. My brother was always the one to stand up to her, but in his own defense, of course. Now he was defending my sons.
I was touched. And then I was angry. What a mess of emotions.
Later that night, my mother, who had been drinking, told me, “You know how you always say I like girls better than boys? I think you’re right!” I didn’t know what to say. I figured it was the alcohol talking, but when my brother came back in the room, she acted like she’d just told me about the weather and we were moving on now.
As soon as we could get out the next morning, we were out.
My brother called me and told me that I should not, under any circumstances, accept mother’s behavior. He and his wife were absolutely appalled. My kids are all old enough to notice the imbalance in how their grandma treats them.
My mother eventually sent me an e-mail asking me to call her. (Yes, this is how she operates.) I complied, and I finally got to the point where I felt brave enough to bring up her behavior and how it wasn’t going to happen again. She seemed SHOCKED that she had done anything wrong, and she actually told me she didn’t remember ANYTHING she did that day!
My father? Not involved at all. But after several false starts (we used to talk on the phone every week, now maybe once every few months), he’s not speaking to me since mother’s obviously upset with me.
We live three hours away from them. My brother lives five hours away from them, and we are on the way from my parents’ house to my brother’s. They visited my brother twice this summer and never even mentioned they might be coming our way. I didn’t bring it up, and the next time we spoke neither did my mother. I let it go, thinking they wouldn’t feel comfortable here. I can understand that, but I don’t hold any enmity against them. I just want them to try to be better grandparents to my kids. Not as in buying them things and fawning all over them, just as in not treating my daughter well and treating my boys hatefully!
We always host Thanksgiving at our house, since we’re halfway between my brother and my parents. Nobody called this year to tell me anything otherwise. On Thanksgiving, nobody showed up. I expected that, but since we’re usually all so good at sweeping things under the rug, I thought we’d just continue to do that.
This is the first time I’ve ever been truly angry with my mother, and my father, for that matter. I feel I have forgiven them many times. I feel that now that I’m a grown woman with my own family that I do not have to be responsible for their feelings. I’ve always been a good daughter to them. I’ve always tried to make them happy, even when they hurt me. Am I perfect? No way! But I really try. I admit my faults and make amends. This time is very different. It’s been almost a year and it feels like I’m finally growing up and learning that my loyalties lie with my family and not my parents. But I do think about them dying and us never resolving this and what a shame that would be.
I’ve found IMMENSE PEACE in my faith this past year. Another sticking point with mother. My parents stopped taking us to Mass before I was confirmed over some slight she felt from our parish priest. She has nothing but bad things to say about being Catholic. I teach RE, but I can’t talk about it with her without feeling like she thinks I’m some sort of Jesus freak. I finally decided this year to be confirmed, too, since she didn’t think that was the sort of decision an 8th-grader could make. She’s not too hip on that, either, and I don’t count on my parents showing up at Easter Vigil.
VERY confused about all of this. Wish my mother would take responsibility and try to do better so we could just move on. I can’t risk exposing my kids to more of this stuff until she does something. I feel very wrong about that, but don’t know what to do.
Thanks in advance for any and all advice. I’ve read through some similar posts here and have found some good stuff to ponder.