Relationship eroding because parents insulted children

  • Thread starter Thread starter seekingtofind
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

seekingtofind

Guest
Honor thy mother and thy father. Who knew this would be the toughest commandment?

Last Christmas, we all traveled to my parents’ for the holiday. My mother has always been difficult. She has suffered from depression for as long as I can remember. She was physically and emotionally abusive to me and my sibling, so much so that I can hardly remember enjoying time with her. My father went along to get along. He worked A LOT, and I’m sure that had something to do with it, but she treats him like she treats us.

I adopted the role of the “good daughter” while my brother was the “wild child”. We both have a lot to work to do on our demons, but we’re both making progress.

My husband and I have three kids, a daughter and two sons. My mother only likes my daughter, and she’s made this clear on several occasions. Being the “good daughter”, I let her nastiness slide. Until this past occasion. She was very rude to my sons. They’re young boys and rambunctious, to be sure, but they are respectful and terribly sweet. The kind of kids whom elderly couples approach in restaurants to compliment them on their good behavior. They asked for crayons to color pictures. She snapped at them about the Legos they left on the floor in the basement. I have become so numb to her behavior that I noticed it but brushed it off. My brother did not. He got right up into her face and told her to cool down. My brother was always the one to stand up to her, but in his own defense, of course. Now he was defending my sons.

I was touched. And then I was angry. What a mess of emotions.

Later that night, my mother, who had been drinking, told me, “You know how you always say I like girls better than boys? I think you’re right!” I didn’t know what to say. I figured it was the alcohol talking, but when my brother came back in the room, she acted like she’d just told me about the weather and we were moving on now.

As soon as we could get out the next morning, we were out.

My brother called me and told me that I should not, under any circumstances, accept mother’s behavior. He and his wife were absolutely appalled. My kids are all old enough to notice the imbalance in how their grandma treats them.

My mother eventually sent me an e-mail asking me to call her. (Yes, this is how she operates.) I complied, and I finally got to the point where I felt brave enough to bring up her behavior and how it wasn’t going to happen again. She seemed SHOCKED that she had done anything wrong, and she actually told me she didn’t remember ANYTHING she did that day!

My father? Not involved at all. But after several false starts (we used to talk on the phone every week, now maybe once every few months), he’s not speaking to me since mother’s obviously upset with me.

We live three hours away from them. My brother lives five hours away from them, and we are on the way from my parents’ house to my brother’s. They visited my brother twice this summer and never even mentioned they might be coming our way. I didn’t bring it up, and the next time we spoke neither did my mother. I let it go, thinking they wouldn’t feel comfortable here. I can understand that, but I don’t hold any enmity against them. I just want them to try to be better grandparents to my kids. Not as in buying them things and fawning all over them, just as in not treating my daughter well and treating my boys hatefully!

We always host Thanksgiving at our house, since we’re halfway between my brother and my parents. Nobody called this year to tell me anything otherwise. On Thanksgiving, nobody showed up. I expected that, but since we’re usually all so good at sweeping things under the rug, I thought we’d just continue to do that.

This is the first time I’ve ever been truly angry with my mother, and my father, for that matter. I feel I have forgiven them many times. I feel that now that I’m a grown woman with my own family that I do not have to be responsible for their feelings. I’ve always been a good daughter to them. I’ve always tried to make them happy, even when they hurt me. Am I perfect? No way! But I really try. I admit my faults and make amends. This time is very different. It’s been almost a year and it feels like I’m finally growing up and learning that my loyalties lie with my family and not my parents. But I do think about them dying and us never resolving this and what a shame that would be.

I’ve found IMMENSE PEACE in my faith this past year. Another sticking point with mother. My parents stopped taking us to Mass before I was confirmed over some slight she felt from our parish priest. She has nothing but bad things to say about being Catholic. I teach RE, but I can’t talk about it with her without feeling like she thinks I’m some sort of Jesus freak. I finally decided this year to be confirmed, too, since she didn’t think that was the sort of decision an 8th-grader could make. She’s not too hip on that, either, and I don’t count on my parents showing up at Easter Vigil.

VERY confused about all of this. Wish my mother would take responsibility and try to do better so we could just move on. I can’t risk exposing my kids to more of this stuff until she does something. I feel very wrong about that, but don’t know what to do.

Thanks in advance for any and all advice. I’ve read through some similar posts here and have found some good stuff to ponder.
 
I can relate to your post since I come from a very dysfunctional background where males were/are treated poorly. I’ve had struggles with my own mom because she overlooks too many grave sins, acts passive/aggressive towards proper boundaries and just plain expects people to tolerate bad sin, act like it’s nothing and just get along. These types of behaviors don’t work for parents trying to raise their kids right.

I have a large crew of young people, 6 of them males, and I wish I had limited if not avoided my mom outright. We as adult children are not supposed to have to protect our own children from our parents. It is so inherently understood that parents are to be good to their children that God didn’t bother writing that parents are to honor/love/cherish their kids. It’s just an unspoken given in that commandment of “honor your parents”.

In your case, as in mine, we have to render honor at a distance that keeps our minor children safe from a parent’s bad behavior. You can pray for your mom and offer Masses for your parents. But unfortunately, you’ll have to keep a safe distance, with lines of communication open as much as possible for the circumstances.

Your duty to protect your children comes before your duty to honor your parents with your physical presence in their lives. So pray, pray, pray and put it in God’s hands. Hopefully your folks will have a change of heart.
 
I am very sorry you are going through this. And I agree you have to protect your sons. However, believe it or not, you also have to protect your daughter. You don’t want her to get a false sense of being more deserving that her brothers. Nor should she be taught to believe boys are inferior.

I really have no practical advice but to pray for your parents

CM
 
Do you have any insight on why your mother behaves as she does? The disliking boys, specifically? Do you know if she was always difficult? Have you ever spoken to your dad about it?

The reason I ask is, sometimes it is easier to deal with a difficult person if you understand why she is the way she is.

My first advice would be, try not to expect things from her that she is unable to give.

The second would be, don’t assume things. Ask questions, clarify what you want, speak up for yourself. From my reading of your op, it seems you assumed that everyone would come to your house for Thnqksgiving, but no one showed up. Did you ever actually invite anyone? Failing to communicate specifics with others can cause a lot of problems and hurt feelings.

Does your mother have a drinking problem?

Lastly, if she can not be trusted to be kind to your sons, I would keep them away from her until you can get to the bottom of the situation.
 
Later that night, my mother, who had been drinking, told me, “You know how you always say I like girls better than boys? I think you’re right!” I didn’t know what to say. I figured it was the alcohol talking, but when my brother came back in the room, she acted like she’d just told me about the weather and we were moving on now.
That right there sums it all up. Alcohol. Does she have a history of problems related to alcohol?
My brother called me and told me that I should not, under any circumstances, accept mother’s behavior. He and his wife were absolutely appalled. My kids are all old enough to notice the imbalance in how their grandma treats them.
Your brother is absolutely correct.
 
Your children come first along with your husband.

It is our responsibility as parents, first of all, to protect those children God has entrusted to us.

Don’t do anything that seems like 'crawling" to your parents. It will only convince them they are right. They are not.

Each of your children is a precious unique gift of God entrusted to you and your husband, and no one else has the right to indicate otherwise. I would never tolerate anyone treating any of my children as less important that the others.

The family not coming to Thanksgiving without contacting you when it is what is always done, is childish. They knew you’d go to all that effort, and they let you do it without letting you know they wouldn’t come.

I would think, just act like an adult, and if the others wont act like adults it is their choice.
Maybe periodically send them cards, be pleasant and Christian, answer quietly in your ‘adult’ when they carry on in their ‘child’ (which they are), maybe quietly tell them your legitimate concerns, but please don’t let them upset you.
I know that’s hard. I’m pretty steamed up about this and I don’t even know you all.
But I am and can’t help being a passionately caring mother. Defend my kids with my life, stuff. And your boys shouldn’t have to be subjected to what your brother was. Have you let him know that you feel for him? Maybe he needs to know that you know he was treated with injustice?

Will pray for you all.
 
seekingtofind: I am concerned about your mother’s obvious drinking problem. Even a reasonable person can become dangerous when drunk. Your children should not have to put up with abuse from her. I don’t know what the extent of her meanness to your sons is but you need to consider your children first.

You may find it helpful to establish communication with your brother and his wife behind the scene so at least they know what is going on. In the case of my own, ahem, obnoxious mother I find when she threatens to cut me out of my inheritance, or whatever, I email my sisters the let them know what she said and my assertion that I don’t need or particularly want my parent’s money. Fortunately my sisters are reasonable enough to understand my position. In fact they reminded me that is my deceased father’s money as well as my mother’s.

And from my experience, if the parents are still married they will stick together. Good luck!
 
**
Later that night, my mother, who had been drinking, told me,** “You know how you always say I like girls better than boys? I think you’re right!” I didn’t know what to say. I figured it was the alcohol talking, but when my brother came back in the room, she acted like she’d just told me about the weather and we were moving on now.

As soon as we could get out the next morning, we were out.

My brother called me and told me that I should not, under any circumstances, accept mother’s behavior. He and his wife were absolutely appalled. My kids are all old enough to notice the imbalance in how their grandma treats them.

My mother eventually sent me an e-mail asking me to call her. (Yes, this is how she operates.) I complied, and I finally got to the point where I felt brave enough to bring up her behavior and how it wasn’t going to happen again. **She seemed SHOCKED that she had done anything wrong, and she actually told me she didn’t remember ANYTHING she did that day! **
Two references to drinking, one where she drank and then when she admitted that she didn’t remember anything (that is called “blacking out”). I wonder if your mother is an alcoholic and you have never known this. It might explain quite a few things. Does she have a drinking problem? Most people who drink until they can’t remember anything they did do have a serious drinking problem.

I recommend Al-Anon, which is a family support group for families and friends of alcoholics. You don’t even have to know for sure if your mother is an alcoholic, if her drinking bothers you, you qualify.

al-anon.alateen.org/

Try more than one meeting, because even though they are all based on the same basic structure, each one has its own character, they are not clones of each other. Until you learn how to detach from your mother and her behaviors, I would keep a healthy distance from her.
 
I think it’s great that you’re going to be Confirmed. 👍👍👍 I wouldn’t expect Mom to be a part of it though, based on what she’s said so far. Consider developing friendships with other sincere Catholics who are loyal to the Church and have children who are similar in age to yours. This is where you will find a welcome for your experiences about RE, the upcoming Easter Vigil and so on. If my mom was abusing alcohol and my family, I wouldn’t put myself at her house on Thanksgiving and Christmas Day . Maybe I’d meet her for dinner on neutral ground the week before. It’s amazing how well-mannered people can be when there are plenty of others around. I know there are people who tolerate this in the name of family and maybe I would under different circumstances. It’s one thing to have family members who are eccentric, argumentative, rude, or insulting, but being abusive - that’s crossing a line, imo. Only you and your husband would know if she crosses that line regularly with you & your children.

I’m sure you know this, but, be there for your parents. If they need help with something try to go the distance to lend a hand (leaving the kids with a sitter :D). It’s so important for you to pray and offer small sacrifices for them as well, and have your children do the same. You may very well be the only ones who are and we all need the prayers of others. I’ll pray for all you guys today. Hang in there. It’s a small miracle you’re to the point you are with your faith and you’re doing great. However, I don’t think you can have the kind of friend you’re looking for in your Mom right now, or the kind of Grandma that would be best for your children, but you can hopefully, stay connected. Other ways to keep the 4th commandment would be for you to accept your parents (not condone), with all their limitations, and let them know you care.
 
Wow. Thanks to all of you for reading my rant and taking the time to offer advice. I really appreciate it!

In regards to drinking, my parents both drank quite heavily until a rather heavy binge that forced my mother to choose between booze and kids. She was raised by an alcoholic mother, drunk-all-the-time and mean. I’ve thanked my mother numerous times for making the choice to quit drinking when she did. My father was less enthusiastic about her decision, but he did, too. We didn’t grow up with alcoholics, but we DID grow up with alcoholic problems.

I remember VERY distinctly when my grandma babysat us once. She had been drinking, and I was pestering her about when my mommy and daddy would be back. I was little, maybe three or four, and you know how many times a little kiddo can ask the same question! But she lost her patience and slapped me in the face. She IMMEDIATELY knew that she had done something VERY wrong. She confessed to my parents when they returned, and I remember mother and grandma having a very heated discussion. My mother told her that she would never, under any circumstances, be allowed around her grandkids if she was even sipping a beer. And she stuck to it. I never saw my grandma drunk, and I saw grandma quite often.

My parents strongly discouraged any form of drinking while I was growing up. My brother drank alot, and it caused a lot of trouble in the family. I don’t drink myself, although I occasionally have a glass of wine. I just never developed a taste for it. And, quite frankly, my mother scared me to death with the idea that grandma’s variety of uber-alcoholism ran in the family and I might “catch” it, too.

That’s why it’s so weird that both mother and father drink now. Mother drank about seven beers that night (my brother counted!). Honestly, though? She was well aware of what she was doing. She frequently lost her temper with us growing up, yelling at us, calling us names, saying horrible things, slapping us…and then, when the phone rang, she would somehow be able to snap right out of it and carry on a conversation like nothing had happened. Looking back, it seems downright psychopathic now.

I also believe mother was sexually abused as a child. My grandpa was actually questioned about molesting a little girl. Grandma tried to commit suicide and was institutionalized for a year. I knew about grandma’s suicide attempt, but I didn’t know the reason for it. I assumed depression. Mother insists grandpa was never charged, but they had to move because of the scandal (!). I’m not a psychiatrist, but some of her behaviors can be explained by the trauma of sexual abuse. And it even might help explain her treatment of my kids. Again, I’ve let things slide because I am well aware of at least the alcoholism she grew up with, let alone the sexual abuse that may have happened at the hands of her own father.

I’ll add another wrinkle. Mother has been having “spells” since I was about 12. She would say she was numb on one side of her body, or her feet would fall asleep, etc. One time she even fell down the stairs, claiming numbness. No local doctor ever figured it out. But she always claims to be sick. I write off so much of her behavior because I assume it’s her illness, whatever it is. At one point she was convinced it was MS. But we never talked about it after my brother started acting out. And he was acting out because of her! I actually asked her about both the drinking AND the “MS”, and she denied both. She just didn’t remember, plain and simple.

Both my brother and I have struggled our entire lives with depression, each of us being hospitalized once. Suicidal, catatonic, the whole nine yards. I’ve turned to God (and medication…I think God definitely guided the scientists who created anti-depressants!). My brother has turned to counseling to help. One thing he told me just haunts me. He said his counselor told him that he “doesn’t have to be that scared little boy anymore.” I still cry when I think about that. He was always the tough one, but he only acted that way because he was just as scared as I was.

Communication is sorely lacking in my family, for sure! But please don’t think I went through a bunch of fuss making Thanksgiving dinner. I do have five mouths to feed! My parents and my in-laws don’t get along (surprised?), so we don’t share holidays. Well, this year it was my in-laws’ turn to eat here. We had a nice time, even though I was praying HARD for the strength to let go of my angry thoughts!!!

I am SO GRATEFUL for the pull back into the Church. I’ve heard so much criticism about Catholicism for so many years. If anything, I should be repulsed! But I feel such a strong tug. To think I sat in a pew as a kid for at least a few years and really didn’t hear anything. It’s starting to make sense to me now, and for the first time in my life I actually BELIEVE I’m a child of God and He loves me in all my imperfection. The way I was raised? It was impossible for me to think I was worthy of that kind of unconditional love. Mess up once and you felt the wrath. Make a mistake and you’ve ruined your parents’ day, if not their entire lives. As far as my parents are concerned, that’s how it will always be, I fear. But I have a husband who tells me he loves me and shows me he loves me every single day and three children whom we both love and smother to the point of no return and get it all returned in spades. 🙂

My kids have great relationships with my in-laws. Normal grandma-grandpa, cousin, aunt-uncle kind of stuff. Now, those folks DO fawn on them. But I don’t mind. My kids aren’t spoiled, and they appreciate that classic type of doting. 🙂

Thank you again for reading. It feels good to write all of this out, kinda purging!
 
This is the first time I’ve ever been truly angry with my mother, and my father, for that matter. I feel I have forgiven them many times. I feel that now that I’m a grown woman with my own family that I do not have to be responsible for their feelings. I’ve always been a good daughter to them. I’ve always tried to make them happy, even when they hurt me. Am I perfect? No way! But I really try. I admit my faults and make amends. This time is very different. It’s been almost a year and it feels like I’m finally growing up and learning that my loyalties lie with my family and not my parents. But I do think about them dying and us never resolving this and what a shame that would be.
I think this is the crucial paragraph in your post. You have grown up and see their behaviour for what it is. You’ve had enough of bullying and that is a good thing. I don’t think this is about your mother insulting your sons but about you and her. She has been controlling all of your life and now has taken a natural step forward: it is time to take it out on the kids. Of course she does not think she has done something wrong because you have never really stood up to her to make her think otherwise. And yes, your husband and children are your priority, as well as your mental and emotional health.

You say you are concerned abo9ut your parents dying and having this issue unresolved. Perhaps you could write a letter, let them know how you really feel about the way you were brought up and treated throughout yoiur life. Mention the incident with your sons and explain why that hurt you. Just let it all out. They deserve to hear about this. However, they might not respond in the way you’d like. maybe nothing will change. Maybe (probably) they will get extremely defensive and deny it all. And maybe they will make a positive step forward. Whatever the case, don’t regress to the obedient little girl role but remain the strong woman who has her priorities sorted out.
 
Honor thy mother and thy father. Who knew this would be the toughest commandment?

Last Christmas, we all traveled to my parents’ for the holiday. My mother has always been difficult. She has suffered from depression for as long as I can remember. She was physically and emotionally abusive to me and my sibling, so much so that I can hardly remember enjoying time with her. My father went along to get along. He worked A LOT, and I’m sure that had something to do with it, but she treats him like she treats us.

I adopted the role of the “good daughter” while my brother was the “wild child”. We both have a lot to work to do on our demons, but we’re both making progress.

My husband and I have three kids, a daughter and two sons. My mother only likes my daughter, and she’s made this clear on several occasions. Being the “good daughter”, I let her nastiness slide. Until this past occasion. She was very rude to my sons. They’re young boys and rambunctious, to be sure, but they are respectful and terribly sweet. The kind of kids whom elderly couples approach in restaurants to compliment them on their good behavior. They asked for crayons to color pictures. She snapped at them about the Legos they left on the floor in the basement. I have become so numb to her behavior that I noticed it but brushed it off. My brother did not. He got right up into her face and told her to cool down. My brother was always the one to stand up to her, but in his own defense, of course. Now he was defending my sons.

I was touched. And then I was angry. What a mess of emotions.

Later that night, my mother, who had been drinking, told me, “You know how you always say I like girls better than boys? I think you’re right!” I didn’t know what to say. I figured it was the alcohol talking, but when my brother came back in the room, she acted like she’d just told me about the weather and we were moving on now.

As soon as we could get out the next morning, we were out.

My brother called me and told me that I should not, under any circumstances, accept mother’s behavior. He and his wife were absolutely appalled. My kids are all old enough to notice the imbalance in how their grandma treats them.

My mother eventually sent me an e-mail asking me to call her. (Yes, this is how she operates.) I complied, and I finally got to the point where I felt brave enough to bring up her behavior and how it wasn’t going to happen again. She seemed SHOCKED that she had done anything wrong, and she actually told me she didn’t remember ANYTHING she did that day!

My father? Not involved at all. But after several false starts (we used to talk on the phone every week, now maybe once every few months), he’s not speaking to me since mother’s obviously upset with me.

We live three hours away from them. My brother lives five hours away from them, and we are on the way from my parents’ house to my brother’s. They visited my brother twice this summer and never even mentioned they might be coming our way. I didn’t bring it up, and the next time we spoke neither did my mother. I let it go, thinking they wouldn’t feel comfortable here. I can understand that, but I don’t hold any enmity against them. I just want them to try to be better grandparents to my kids. Not as in buying them things and fawning all over them, just as in not treating my daughter well and treating my boys hatefully!

We always host Thanksgiving at our house, since we’re halfway between my brother and my parents. Nobody called this year to tell me anything otherwise. On Thanksgiving, nobody showed up. I expected that, but since we’re usually all so good at sweeping things under the rug, I thought we’d just continue to do that.

This is the first time I’ve ever been truly angry with my mother, and my father, for that matter. I feel I have forgiven them many times. I feel that now that I’m a grown woman with my own family that I do not have to be responsible for their feelings. I’ve always been a good daughter to them. I’ve always tried to make them happy, even when they hurt me. Am I perfect? No way! But I really try. I admit my faults and make amends. This time is very different. It’s been almost a year and it feels like I’m finally growing up and learning that my loyalties lie with my family and not my parents. But I do think about them dying and us never resolving this and what a shame that would be.

I’ve found IMMENSE PEACE in my faith this past year. Another sticking point with mother. My parents stopped taking us to Mass before I was confirmed over some slight she felt from our parish priest. She has nothing but bad things to say about being Catholic. I teach RE, but I can’t talk about it with her without feeling like she thinks I’m some sort of Jesus freak. I finally decided this year to be confirmed, too, since she didn’t think that was the sort of decision an 8th-grader could make. She’s not too hip on that, either, and I don’t count on my parents showing up at Easter Vigil.

VERY confused about all of this. Wish my mother would take responsibility and try to do better so we could just move on. I can’t risk exposing my kids to more of this stuff until she does something. I feel very wrong about that, but don’t know what to do.

Thanks in advance for any and all advice. I’ve read through some similar posts here and have found some good stuff to ponder.
Great idea, the letter. Often, it’s enough just to have written the letter, without sending it. People get a great deal of perspective and relief just from setting it all down in print. But if someone really feels they need to send that kind of letter, they should be prepared for the possible fallout. People rarely respond well, and sometimes they get even nastier. The ones who respond well have already come to some kind of conscience about their own behavior. The ones who don’t respond well, haven’t.
 
Honor Later that night, my mother, who had been drinking, told me, “You know how you always say I like girls better than boys? I think you’re right!” I didn’t know what to say. I figured it was the alcohol talking, but when my brother came back in the room, she acted like she’d just told me about the weather and we were moving on now.

As soon as we could get out the next morning, we were out.

er.
until her drinking is addressed nothing will change
do what have to do to protect your children, and preserve your good relationship with your brother and his family but do not allow this person any more power over you. End the manipulation now. you can do that only by changing your own reaction and response pattern, and sometimes the only way to do that is eliminate the trigger, even if it means having no contact with her for the time being.

Only she can take the first step to change herself. It is up to your dad, you and your brother to decide if you will do what it takes to confront her problem and deal with it, or to enable her, deny the problem, play along with her game.

signed: it takes one to know one
 
I have no advice. Unfortunately I can sympthize. Listen to these awesome, good people here; they will steer you the right way.

:hug1:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top