'Relics' from Medjugorje

  • Thread starter Thread starter starrball
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

starrball

Guest
I’ve been doing some reading and digging on Medjugorje on this forum and on the web and I choose to obey the church and wait on the official approval before putting any faith in these things.

Now, my question comes as what to do about a few items from Medjugorje that I recieved from a friend. I was very touched and felt blessed to recieve them, but now I worry that they may be more harm than good. Should I take them down? Hide them away in a drawer? Or get rid of them entirely, and if so how?

Or am I just being overly cautious now?

This stuff is all so confusing and I don’t want to take any chances.
 
While the church has not officially pronounced the Medjugorje apparitions as approved, there is no restriction on visiting the sites or in holding personal veneration for the messages associated with the visionaries, as far as I know. Even Fatima, which was widely reported as accurate by the secular media around the world, has not been proclaimed as dogmatic by the Church. We are free to believe or reject these apparitions.
 
I think you are perhaps being overly cautious. I personally understand the hesitation in embracing the prophesies of Medjugorje because of some of the conflicts with Church teaching. I am hesitant to believe it as well. However, the fact that the Church has not approved it does not mean that it is something evil that will harm you. They were nice gifts from a friend–look at them as that. 🙂
 
I’ve been doing some reading and digging on Medjugorje on this forum and on the web and I choose to obey the church and wait on the official approval before putting any faith in these things.

Now, my question comes as what to do about a few items from Medjugorje that I recieved from a friend. I was very touched and felt blessed to recieve them, but now I worry that they may be more harm than good. Should I take them down? Hide them away in a drawer? Or get rid of them entirely, and if so how?

Or am I just being overly cautious now?

This stuff is all so confusing and I don’t want to take any chances.
I think it depends on what the items are.

If it’s a Rosary or an older medal (say, a Miraculous Medal), I doubt there’s any harm involved.

However, if it’s a picture or medal specifically referring to the alleged apparitions, or an image of the “seers”, discuss it with your priest. 🙂
 
Ah, well there is a rosary from a different time. Other than that there is a ‘5 little stones’ prayer card with stones from the site as well as a standing crucifix, also with stones from the site.
 
Ah, well there is a rosary from a different time. Other than that there is a ‘5 little stones’ prayer card with stones from the site as well as a standing crucifix, also with stones from the site.
That sounds quite harmless, in my opinion. I don’t think stones are problematic in the least. They’re not “relics”, anyhow. 🙂
 
I agree that it doesn’t sound like you are referring to “relics” of any kind.

That said, you have no obligation to display in your home every religious item you have ever received. If it makes you uncomfortable, you can certainly put it away or give it away.
 
I understand your dilemma. Qithout infringing on the rules about discussing private revelations, I will just say that my in-laws are all very into Medjugorje, so much so that we all went there while vacationing in a nearby country. I still feel uneasy about it since I do see conflicts with some of the messages as well as some of the reported behavior of the ‘seers.’ I would not go back again without first hearing the Church’s ruling. As one poster said, even after such a ruling, it does not mean the Church is saying, ‘this is true.’ Rather, a positive ruling would mean, ‘a Catholic is free to believe this because it doesn’t conflict with public revelation, and the stories are credible.’ For now, I stand behind the views of the local bishop of Medjugorje.

-May the peace of Christ be with you.
 
I’ve been doing some reading and digging on Medjugorje on this forum and on the web and I choose to obey the church and wait on the official approval before putting any faith in these things.

Now, my question comes as what to do about a few items from Medjugorje that I recieved from a friend. I was very touched and felt blessed to recieve them, but now I worry that they may be more harm than good. Should I take them down? Hide them away in a drawer? Or get rid of them entirely, and if so how?

Or am I just being overly cautious now?

This stuff is all so confusing and I don’t want to take any chances.
A wonderful reason for the church not requiring any of the faithful to buy into apparitions even when the church validates them! I simply don’t buy any of them! Past (validated or not), present, nor will I in the future.
 
I applaud your caution. The Bishop of Mostar was actually kidnapped and held by proponents of Medjugorje in an effort to force him to give approval to these apparitions. That is when he asked help from the Vatican.
Code:
    I posted a link to the diocesan bishop approved-Marian apparition "Our Lady of  American",  and people were concerned that it was not Vatican approved.   Rightly so  I guess to be concerned, however the important part of this apparition of the Immaculate Conception is that she offered and wants to be Patron Saint of the USA.    Oh what a Blessing  this would be.
Concerning the Church’s process of approval of apparitions, below is copied from Unity Publishing, Inc, a website devoted to the study of the approval processes concerning Catholic apparitions. If this author would post references like any scholarly project where people could then be given the opportunity to better study the original statements made by Vatican curia and diocesan bishops & other publicans on the Catholic Church. This would of course favor objectivity.
Code:
     "The doctrine of the Church is "to the judgment of the diocesan Bishop". Of course, there must be a period of time before the diocesan Bishop comes to a conclusion, and during this period of time one is not held responsible for a false belief. If, however, you continue to believe in a mystic that the local Bishop has "proved to be false", will you still "receive all the blessings as if it were to be true"? No! Because then you have violated the Fourth Commandment. "Honor your Father and your Mother" because no one can have God for their Father without having the Church for their Mother.
Below is copied from Unity Publishing, Inc, a website devoted to the study of the approval processes concerning Catholic apparitions. If this author would post references like any scholarly project where people could then be given the oppurtunity to better study the original statements made by Vatican curia and diocesan bishops & other publicans on the Catholic Church.

“But, Lord, I believed with all my heart.” (Matt. 7:21=24) "Not every one that saith to me, Lord, Lord, shall enter into the kingdom of heaven; but he that doth the will of my Father who is in heaven, he shall enter into the kingdom of heaven. Many will say to me in that day,

Lord, Lord, have not we prophesied in thy name, and cast out devils in thy name, and done many miracles in thy name?' And then will I profess unto them, I never knew you, depart from me, you that work iniquity.’ Every one therefore that heareth these my words, and doth them, shall be likened to a wise man that built his house upon a rock."

The important thing about this statement of Christ is that the person was surprised, he thought he was doing the will of God, and he thought that the power he had to perform miracles and give prophesies was also from God. But this power was not from God. Christ goes on to say what the rules are. “He who hears my word” means all his words. Read HIS WORDS in Matt. 18:17 which states, “And if he will not hear them [witnesses or the facts] tell the church. And if he will not hear even the Church, let him be to thee as the heathen and the publican.”

THE LOCAL BISHOP

“We are of God. [the bishops] He that knoweth God, heareth us. He that is not of God, heareth us not. By this we know the spirit of truth, and the spirit of error.” (1 John 4:6)

When John wrote his three Epistles he was over 100 years old and all the other apostles had already been martyred. Where he says “we” he means the descendants of the apostles, the bishops.

When you say, “What if the bishop is a bad bishop?”, you are saying that God has no power over His creatures. This powerless God of yours, can give prophesies and miracles to a mystic, but has no power over the very bishop that he commands us to obey to influence him to make the proper judgment. Therefore, you become your own bishops and your own Church. Then when you go up to heaven, He will say what? When you say I would rather believe in God than man, what you are really saying is I would rather believe in the mystic than the Church, and this is a Gnostic heresy.

Can a bishop make a mistake? Yes! But if you obey him, you are not sinning; but if you disobey him, you are, even if he made a mistake. However, I know of no private revelation in the 2000 year history of the Church that was condemned by a local bishop and later found to be true. I do know of private revelations that were approved by the local bishop and then found to be false. In fact one Pope lamented on his death bed that he almost brought the Church into its ruin by following a false mystic. That Pope was Urban VIII. "
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top