Religion- just a mere theory

  • Thread starter Thread starter Against_Heresy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

Against_Heresy

Guest
I was in a discussion with another person and I made very good points on the existence of God and debunked one of Stephen Hawkings arguments, yet then as I began to mention religion, the person then said “religion is just a theory”.

How do I counteract the argument that religion is “just a theory”?
 
I would probably point out that a “theory”, in scientific parlance, is a large body of evidence that supports a fact. For example, the theory of gravity is a body of evidence that supports the fact that things fall when you drop them and it supports the law of gravity.

So really, being a theory, is not in the least bit a bad thing.
 
I was in a discussion with another person and I made very good points on the existence of God and debunked one of Stephen Hawkings arguments, yet then as I began to mention religion, the person then said “religion is just a theory”.

How do I counteract the argument that religion is “just a theory”?
What Farsight001 said. Perhaps he means “just a hypothesis.” At any rate, even something being a hypothesis is no grounds to dismiss it – you hypothesize precisely so that you can consider its value.

If your friend wants to a priori shut down conversation on the topic, he should just be honest that he’s an atheist and isn’t open to potentially having his mind changed on the topic.
 
I was in a discussion with another person and I made very good points on the existence of God and debunked one of Stephen Hawkings arguments, yet then as I began to mention religion, the person then said “religion is just a theory”.

How do I counteract the argument that religion is “just a theory”?
One could point out the word “theory” is meaningless, since Non-religious scientists use it to describe things they believe true all the time.

Mention to them the big bang and evolution are theories? But does that make them false?
 
Good answers by all.

I would also maybe try to get clarification - “What do you mean by that?” or “When you say religion is a theory, can you help me understand what you mean by that?”

That way you can address his objection or thoughts directly.

God bless,
Bryan
 
I was in a discussion with another person and I made very good points on the existence of God and debunked one of Stephen Hawkings arguments, yet then as I began to mention religion, the person then said “religion is just a theory”.

How do I counteract the argument that religion is “just a theory”?
Tell them that gravity is also “just a theory.” The fact that something is just a theory does not mean that it is false, and normally for something to be a theory in the academic sense, it requires a considerable amount of support to back it up. Theories are what reasonable people reach after examining evidence and doing research. They aren’t just random ideas people invent when they have consumed too much beer or been lounging around on the sofa too long.
 
I was in a discussion with another person and I made very good points on the existence of God and debunked one of Stephen Hawkings arguments, yet then as I began to mention religion, the person then said “religion is just a theory”.

How do I counteract the argument that religion is “just a theory”?
One description of religion might be: a premise that you cannot prove, but believe to be true, and act in accordance with it.

Your friend believes God does not exist. He cannot prove it, but believes it to be true. He is therefore religious. And in the same breath, lack of existence of God is just a theory.

It takes at least as much faith that the ordered universe is the result of … well, nothing, as to believe in a supreme being as the creative power. Maybe more.
 
Religion is just a theory is what people say when they know ABOUT God but they don’t KNOW God.

Once you have had a religious experience, then religion is no longer a theory but something you know is true.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top