Remorse for those who commit suicide?

  • Thread starter Thread starter RHannosh619
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Right, I don’t “judge” him or think he is going to go to hell because I really don’t know/nor care, but I don’t feel any remorse.
We should all care if anyone goes to hell. When we pray the Rosary we ask Jesus to take all souls to heaven. If we don’t mean that prayer I don’t think it’s a good idea to even say it.
I don’t know if its a bad thing or not, I just honestly believe that people do it to themselves, nobody forced them to do it, and I can’t find any “mercy” in my heart for people like that.
Do you know why people kill themselves? There are factors that lead them to such a desperate act. God is merciful; shouldn’t we try to be like God? These are people that God created and loves - they are His lambs and our brothers and sisters.
Idk if this is something I should be worried about, or if others feel this way too regarding issues like these.
It’s to the point that people who are actually saddened by such things annoy me…
To be honest, I’m very saddened by the attitude you describe…
I just try to get into the mind frame of someone who knows what they are about to do, and honestly want to think, “What am I doing? and why?”… Maybe I’m just blessed to never have to go through that but i don’t know…
I don’t see a lack of empathy as a blessing. We should all have compassion for suffering people. Jesus did and still does.
 
Good point’s guys… Thank you…

I suppose I should feel remorse for the guy, he must have been really really distressed and not completely mentally there…

I guess I feel this way because, I’m so incredibly scared of death it’s not funny. To the point where I’m always paranoid about things… I don’t know how I got this way, I never was like this before… A serious lack in my trust of God.

Any advice regarding that?
Do you think that your ideas about suicide are related to your fear of death (I understand that fear of death thing; it’s really hard to deal with)? I mean, do you feel that you would never commit suicide because of your fear and so you won’t (maybe subconsciously) feel compassion for someone who did commit suicide?

That kind of changes everything around and makes me feel a little bad about my last post. Sorry. Our minds can be so incredibly complicated.

I think you’re on to something in your thinking.
 
Back when I was a young girl ages 11–14 I was suicidal. I was gong through a deep depression and really not in my right mind. At the time I really saw no other way out of my situation. I am now a happy adult and am glad I made it through that and having been that way in the past it has helped me not only gain understanding of people going through that, but it has helped me reach out to them.

Instead of not caring for them and saying “why should I care, they did it to themselves?” we should be reaching out to these people in pain. I wish someone would have reached out to me. No one did. We need to try to prevent people from going to such extreme measures to get out of whatever situation they are in.

Also many people who are suicidal are mentally ill. My grandmother killed herself back in the 50’s due to acute paranoid schizophrenia. She obviously wasn’t culpable for this sin and wasn’t in her right mind. Most people who choose to commit suicide are usually not in their right minds and in need of help.

We should never be uncaring of the death of any other human being. Every human life is of so much value and should be cherished and when lost, mourned, no matter how we feel about how their life ended.
Beautifully said! 👍
 
Beautifully said! 👍
I agree with your assessment and it holds true for Hitler, too. Even Hitler (and Judas) were created by God and He loves them. As God is the only Being Who is truly omniscient He is the only Being who can see absolutely every single bit of a person’s essence. That’s why God is the only One Who can judge perfectly and show perfect mercy.

Who knows what went on with Hitler? I read somewhere (I can’t back it up) that there is some evidence that Hitler was psychotic. I tend toward the theory that he was demonic but I shouldn’t even say that because I have no way of knowing.

God knows, God loves, God is perfectly just. A person who has become so despondent that he/she can’t face life anymore is not necessarily choosing to be in hell. He/she may be desperately reaching out for the love of God. We choose where we go after we die on earth.

And God will show compassion and mercy to those who are compassionate and merciful.
 
Little Solider,

Thank you for your words. Hang in there! I’m praying for you, too! 😉
 
I used to think, folks that committed suicide were weak and taking the easy way out, or they were criminals escaping from punishment that they knew was inevitable. BUT about 30 years, I did what I always thought was unthinkable. I purposely ran my car up againat a tree (or what I thought was a tree). I was in a stressful job situation and I had very little sleep of several days.

To say the least I was not thinking very clearly if barely at all. Fortunately for me, I survived, ended up in a mental ward for a week, and recovered completely. IF anyone would have suggested that I was capable of such an action, I would have said it was impossible. And I think many folks were totally surprised that I could attempt such a thing.

I was a lapsed catholic at the time, so I am very grateful that God gave me a second chance. Only God knows where I may have ended up had I been successful. I missed the tree and hit a light controller instead.

The Church used to not allow anyone who committed suicide to be buried in consecrated ground. But with a better understanding of mental illness, the Church has changed its rules and suicide is no longer considered an automatic excommunication and one way ticket below.

So yes, I have remorse for others who went though what I did. At least for the folks with mental illness, not much for the criminals or ones who are trying to avoid punishment.
 
Alot of these posts are utilizing the word “remorse”, which is based on having guilt for an offense, and being sorrowful or repentant of it.

I think we all mean “pity” or “compassion”, no?

No need to have “remorse” for a suicidal, unless of course we possess some guilt in facilitating their demise.
 
Hi Friends,

One of the reasons we as Catholics have difficulty trying to understand suicide is:

We believe God is infinitely merciful, and yet perfectly just.

Our human minds can not grasp that mystery of God’s.

I join with you in praying for those who have killed themselves, those who are left behind in such pain, and especially those who are contemplating suicide. May God have mercy on them all!

stjoe4u2
 
Alot of these posts are utilizing the word “remorse”, which is based on having guilt for an offense, and being sorrowful or repentant of it.

I think we all mean “pity” or “compassion”, no?

No need to have “remorse” for a suicidal, unless of course we possess some guilt in facilitating their demise.
x2 For a moment I thought “remorse” had a meaning that had escaped me for years. Suicide is a terrible thing, it definitely closes the door to what could have been. For me, I know I’m always two or three bad knocks from returning to the mental state where suicide is a desirable option, I actually beg God to not let things go so low that I will end my life in such a tragic fashion, not to mention what it would do to those who love me. Life has proven vicious at times and I fear it, I fear bad luck returning, I fear God’s punishment, trials and/or inaction. Purgatory will be such a relief in that respect because my salvation will be assured and no-one and nothing will be able to take away my joy of knowing eternal bliss is awaiting me shortly.
 
Suicide is always a grave act but there’s so much more to it than that. The first criterion for a mortal sin is that the sin must be a grave act. So suicide definitely meets that criterion. The second criterion is that the person who commits suicide must *know *hat suicide is a grave act. That could be true or perhaps not. The third criterion is that the person who commits suicide does so with full consent. I think that’s very, very rare. Who wakes up in the morning, feeling good and decides that today is the day to kill himself? People who commit suicide are usually extremely depressed or are psychotic or having an extreme adverse reaction to a medication (I was on one of those once; so many people killed themselves that it was taken off the market).

So suicide is not always a sin; I think it rarely is. You’ve mentioned mental disability, the inability to comprehend right from wrong, the (I’m adding mistaken) belief that they are doing the right thing. Those factors reduce culpability to the point where is may not be a sin at all but an act of someone who feels that he is already in hell and is suffering to the point where life is just too painful to bear and oh so easy to give up.

My husband took his own life when he was 26 years old. There are a lot of things he did wrong. He abandoned his family, including a wife and unborn son, he caused pain and suffering beyond belief to others, and he did not try to get help because he thought that only “sissies” took medication.

It’s not my place to judge him. But because I knew him I can say there were factors that reduced his culpability. I do not believe he is in hell. Actually I believe he is in heaven because of a plenary indulgence made on his behalf (I can always hope and I can always pray for him anyway).

The Church does not teach that people who commit suicide go to hell. A lot of people are confused about that.

I see a lot of caring and love in this thread and I want to say “thank you” because it’s made me feel a lot better about my husband and about me. I’m suicidal right now - I can’t help thoughts that enter my mind unbidden. But I won’t take action on these thoughts except to pray that they go away. And I ask for prayers from others in this thread, if they are inclined to do so (I would appreciate it very much as I’m having a very hard time right now).

One of the worst things that people said to me after my husband’s suicide was that he had been damned and that was what the Church teaches. Gee, thanks for your concern for my feelings and your lack of knowledge about real Church teaching! They made it sound like God was just waiting for my husband to pull the trigger so that He could gleefully damn him to hell. God loves us! He wants us to be with Him. Why would He allow a depressed, suffering, confused person to be damned?
I’m sorry to hear that. I also feel quite upset when I hear others say that everyone who commits suicide goes to hell First off most people who kill themselves have severe mental problems, which automatically makes them incapable of rational decisions. This leads me to believe that they are forgiven for this, especially if they are saved.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top