Wow. What an amazing coincidence that this should be asked. I am currently engaging in an email debate with the very same Rick Jones! What’s more, i am keeping a record of all of our correspondance in order to use it if nescessary in a future defence of the faith. So far, Rick seems to be most concerned with calling priests “father”. I believe I am winning. I have posted our emails below. His are in blue. I will keep posting as i recieve more emails from Rick. Enjoy!
p.s. I am fairly new to the faith - please feel free to correct me if i have made any errors. (excuse my spelling - my keyboard is a bit sticky sometims. Like just then.)
Robert.
Dear Rick;
I am a 15 year old catholic who stumbled across this site and read your info on my religion. You seem to feel quite strongly against catholicism, a view i oppose. Howeaver, i always sincerely seek the Lord, and if you can show me why catholicism is wrong i will instantly convert.
For this reason i challenge you to an e-mail debate on the following key issues:
- Supremicy of Peter / Roman Pope
- Mary
3.Scripture and tradition
(please feel free to suggest three areas yourself)
I know that you do not recognise either the church’s authority or tradition, so as evidence i will use only the scriptures (the KJV bible) and historical / logical evidence which can be historically proven.
I await your response.
Regards,
Robert.
Robert,
If you will go to the link below, you can read an entire book I wrote on the very subjects you mentioned in your email. The book quotes 37 main doctrines from the 1994 catechism, then quotes the Bible on the same subject. That is my side of the debate. If you feel anything I said is incorrect, that can be the starting point.
I look forward to hearing from you.
Rick
(I read the pages from Rick’ book regarding my first topic, Peter and the Pope)
Dear Rick:
Thank you for your responce. I took your advice and began to read the articles linked. I started reading the ones concerning the topics i suggested, as these seem to be the topics which most devide catholics and protestants. So I began by reading your article on Papal infallibility.
With respect, i believe you have misunerstood this teaching. “Papal infallibility” does not mean that the Pope can’t sin. Nore does it mean he is right all of the time. For example if he said in a sermon that Jesus was the son of Joseph, he would not be speaking infallibly. He ony is infallible uder these coditions:
- He must be acting in the role of St. Peter, or speakig ex cathedra (this does not mean Peter was always right, either)
- He must not contradict the Bible, tradition or earlier infallible decarations. So, if the pope contradicted God’s word he woul never hav been speaking infallibly at all.
No one else is held to be infallible, ever. The Magestirium you referred to is actually the teaching of the Church. This is believed to be infallible because it is supported by scripture and tradition. No other catholic can claim to ever be personally infallible.
We believe this because Peter is the junior pastor under the command of the senior pastor (Jesus) of the church and is the stand in shepherd of the flock (church) (John 21: 15-17). Luke 10: 16 states “he who heareth you (apostles) heareth me.”So the Holy Spirit is speaking through Peter. Another reason we believe this is because Peter is the rock (Petros) on which the church is built (I have a feeling this may cause some debate!) and the Gates of Hell cannot prevail against the church. If deception were to be taught in the church,. This would be a victory for Satan, don’t you think?
With regard to the Pope being the Vicar of Christ, I want to make several points:
-
Code:
Although referred to in the Catechism Vicar of Christ is not one of the Pope’s official titles.
-
Code:
“Vicarivs” is a Latin word used in this context to mean servant or underling who stands in his master’s stead. Jesus commanded Peter to feed the sheep because the true shepherd (Christ himself) was going up to heaven. Therefore Popes merely do Christ’s job of preaching and leading while Christ is away.
-
Code:
Of course the Holy Spirit is the true governor of the church. The Pope merely acts as its head on earth, as I have said. He is still subordinate to God.
With regard to Papal supremacy and Peter being made head of the church, scripture makes this obvious: Matthew 16:18: you are Peter…
With regard to the issue of calling priests “Father”, it should be pointed out that this verse does not mean we can literally never call anyone Father except God. It means we cannot credit anyone else with our existence or make anyone else our God. Paul himself stated that he “begat people in Christ”.
With regard to the wealth and splendour of the Vatican, we can say that God wants his temples to be beautiful. You only need to look at the Old Testament to find out that God SPECIFICALLY COMMANDED his house be made opulent.
The Pope is in charge of protecting the flock on earth while Jesus is away. He is the rock on which the church is founded. When you take away the rock and allow private scriptural interpretation, the flock fractures. It is estimated that there are over 30,000 denominations of Christianity. Which one has the right Bible interpretation?
Sorry I have not given details of some of the verses I have quoted – I do not have a bible to hand. Hope to hear from you soon.
Regards,
Robert.