I hope no one will mind if I tack on a question to this thread. The Catholics here seem to take the rosary in their stride, but, as a stranger, I can’t understand why so many people seem to build their prayer life around the same repetitive prayer over and over.
It seems to me their attention would wander, and then they wouldn’t be concentrating. The words would be coming out by rote, and not have any meaning. I recently heard a Catholic priest on the radio say it was against the Second Commandment to pray an empty prayer (i.e., when a person isn’t concentrating). I wouldn’t want to break the commandment.
Also I have a little problem with the idea of asking the Virgin Mary to pray for sinners. It seems like a vague request. Which sinner, what sin? What is the reasoning behind the request?
I’m asking these questions because a part of me is drawn to praying the rosary, but another part of me, well, finds it a little creepy. Can anyone help me?
Hi Aiden12,
I’m not yet Catholic, but will be going through RCIA this Fall. I’ve only been praying the Rosary for about a month now, but will gladly share my experiences with it thus far.
Yes, it is rather repetitive, however, for me, it allows me to stay focused on the prayer. As soon as my mind wanders, I know, because my prayer will go from “Hail Mary full of Grace!” to “Hail Mary full lunch hungy.” This stops me dead in my tracks, because I know I’m deviating from my prayers! In living a Protestant life, I’ve found it so easy to get lost in prayers, especially when praying very casually, e.g. “Hi God. Umm, forgive me of my sins. Please help me. <request, request, request>. Amen”. The prayers associated with the Rosary are very disciplined, which I believe is part of the point. It’s also something you prepare for in advance, such as finding a quiet place, away from distractions, and where you know you’ll have a few minutes (usually takes me 25 or so to do 5 mysteries). This isn’t to say it’s meant to replace casual prayer, as it’s not, however, it allows one to easily enter a time of intimacy with the Mother of God (obviously), but also with The Father, The Son, and The Holy Spirit!
As for what sinners we pray for, and what sin, I believe this is directed to everyone, though you should certainly include yourself. When I say those words, I briefly think of myself, and any sins I’ve commited (repented for or not), but then my thoughts change to mankind, stained by original sin, and all sinners, guilty of all sins (which we are all guilty of, at some point in our lifetime). We’re asking for Mary to pray for us, but also mankind, God’s creation, that we ALL might be saved (though this obviously isn’t possible, due to those who do not recognize Jesus Christ), however, it remains a humble request.
The Rosary itself, is a powerful tool. I’ve often found joy during my stressful day, occasionally dipping my hands into my pocket and feeling the cross and the beads. It reminds me that God is with me, regardless of the turmoil around me. When I feel temptation coming on, I pull out the Rosary and just hold on to it. I even hold it sometimes when I’m just praying normally, and not the actual mysteries!
Anywho, those are my thoughts. I’m sure you can get better answers/viewpoints than mine, especially from some of the veteran Catholics around here. If anyone is reading this, please feel free to jump in! I’m sure you’ll be a blessing to both myself and Aiden12!