Rosary

  • Thread starter Thread starter Churchman25
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

Churchman25

Guest
I dont know If anyone has attempted this but I had an idea of taking a regular rosary chaplet but the thing is, is each bead for your hail mary would = 1 rosary so then after you say the first ten rosaries you say an our father and do that same thing until you get all the way around. Then say a Hail Holy Queen.
 
I dont know If anyone has attempted this but I had an idea of taking a regular rosary chaplet but the thing is, is each bead for your hail mary would = 1 rosary so then after you say the first ten rosaries you say an our father and do that same thing until you get all the way around. Then say a Hail Holy Queen.
You mean you’d end up saying 50 Rosaries?

Well, if you were a member of a monastic order or a cloistered religious, maybe. Most of us wouldn’t have the time for that. Or have I misunderstood? 🙂
 
Unless I am misunderstanding, it seems that would take an extremely long time. Are you saying that for each Hail Mary bead you would say 5 decades of the Rosary?
 
I dont know If anyone has attempted this but I had an idea of taking a regular rosary chaplet but the thing is, is each bead for your hail mary would = 1 rosary so then after you say the first ten rosaries you say an our father and do that same thing until you get all the way around. Then say a Hail Holy Queen.
I think you meant to say that “after the first ten Hail Marys” , instead of “after you say the first ten rosaries”.
 
Frankly, why can’t people simply pray the Rosary the way it was intended?
 
Because there have always been a zillion different versions, and God loves to inspire people to create their own versions of private devotions?

Although the Church particularly encourages particular devotions, you will find all sorts of less popular forms also being encouraged in particular times and places. When I read Fr. Merlo’s famous prayer book Paradisus Animae, it had something like 12 different Rosary versions and some huge number of chaplets. When I read an Irish prayer book from the very early 1800’s, it had different chapters and Rosary versions, too. When you research Rosary history, you run into all sorts of different Mysteries being used in the Middle Ages, before things shook down to the famous fifteen. So then I felt better about the Luminous Mysteries…

Don’t discourage people from using their legitimate options. They have a lot of them. And while it may be frivolous to experiment too much instead of focusing on prayer, there are people who really need to make a prayer their own before they can really feel comfortable enough with a prayer to persevere with it.
 
Er… chaplets, not “chapters.” (Yeah, I don’t get along well with the “predictive text” on my tablet.)

I forgot to mention St. Dominic’s famous “Nine Ways of Prayer.” He was a guy who liked to pray in all kinds of different body positions, many of which would tend to surprise people if they saw somebody doing it in a parish church before Mass, and his friars recorded these habits. I always thought that running across this had just provided me with academic knowledge. But if you live long enough, you might occasionally see someone praying prostrate before the Blessed Sacrament tabernacle, or using some of the other postures. So if you’re sure they’re okay and not sick, it’s good to recognize what they’re doing and not be bothered by it.

Also, I forgot to mention that there’s an old mystery novel that uses the multiplicity of chaplets as a plot point. It’s Anthony Boucher’s book, Nine Times Nine.

Boucher was Catholic, and he had a short series with a religious sister as detective. (There are also a couple short stories with Sister Ursula, if I recall correctly. I forgot to say that she also appears in Rocket to the Morgue, best known for Boucher’s loving parody of all his best science fiction writer friends, and for his depiction of the odd intersection of JPL’s founder with some very odd occult groups.)

The series actually takes seriously the fact that a sister can’t get out and go detecting every five minutes, so Boucher had to be a little bit ingenious about how to have it work.) He also created a fictional chaplet devotion for the book, with a fictional history set in the Old West. And of course the nun was a member of the fictional Order of Martha of Bethany, which also had a fictional history that we hear about!

Unfortunately, I don’t see any ebook reprints of The Case of the Seven of Calvary (his first mystery, with a linguistics student at the conservative Berkeley of his day as the hero) or of Nine Times Nine, and I think it’s been a while since his other novels have been reprinted even in paperback. But they are all good (and have good morals), although some of them are very disconcertingly different from what we think a 1930’s or 1940’s American mystery “should be” like. (But he was a very good editor and anthology-story-picker, so keep an eye out for his anthologies, too.)

Anyway… I guess I just wanted to say that proliferation of devotions is a Catholic cultural marker, in some ways. We should be friendly or neutral toward this tendency, unless people are really freaking out about it.

(Corrected some mistakes I made. It’s been a while since I read my copies of Boucher!)
 
I think you meant to say that “after the first ten Hail Marys” , instead of “after you say the first ten rosaries”.
If I understand him correctly, he means that on every Hail Mary bead (except the three in the beginning, apparently) one would pray a five-decade rosary. In this case, “after you say the first ten rosaries” would be accurate.

It has never occurred to me to do this, mainly because (1) I take 25 minutes to pray a five-decade rosary and (2) my schedule of parish service + household management is usually very full. At the rate of (1), I would need almost 21 hours to do what the OP suggests. That wouldn’t leave me any time for (2), as I do need to sleep from time to time. Once I factor in breaks for praying the LOTH and attending Mass each day, there just wouldn’t be time to do anything else.
 
Well, if you weren’t saying the whole thing every day, I guess you could do that. You would want to figure out a way to save your place between days, though.

Or I guess you could do it if you had a lot of time on your hands, like if you were sitting up with somebody who was at the hospital and doing a lot of sleeping.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top