Russian Orthodox versus Roman Catholic

  • Thread starter Thread starter Judy57
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

Judy57

Guest
What is the difference between Russian Orthodox and Roman Catholics and there beliefs? I have goggled it and it comes up with Greek Orthodox. I have seen the word shunned just recently and was wondering if either the Russian Orthodox or Roman Catholics believe in shunning. I know that if you go to communion and have a mortal sin you are frowned upon, but I don’t think you are shunned (kicked out of the church) for smoking, using tobacco etc. I also know that you are always welcome back to church if you have been away awhile but only after confession. Not sure what the Russian Orthodox believe.

Thanks for all your help, God Bless.

Judy
 
The Orthodox aren’t big on shunning people, just because they don’t show up- and neither are we Catholics.

And smoking isn’t a sin, much less a mortal one. You’ll be kicked out of the church building if you’re smoking in church, but you won’t be kicked out of the church
 
Differences between Catholics and Russian Orthodox are primarily political, not doctrinal. The Russian Orthodox Church is controlled by the Russian government, and is not friendly at all to the Catholic Church. The Catholic Church recognizes that the Russian Orthodox have all seven valid sacraments.
 
The Russian Orthodox Church is controlled by the Russian government, and is not friendly at all to the Catholic Church.
Oh please. I am orthodox in a russian orthodox parish and No, it’s not controlled by the russian gouvernment. Politics have influence on people as every where on the world, but there are differences in cult and doctrine mainly (papal primacy, communion, mysteries instead of sacraments, …)
 
The Russian Orthodox Church Outside Russia may not be government controlled. It is, nonetheless, accurate to say that the Russian Orthodox Church is controlled by the Russian government.
 
Tell me of one doctrine that has changed under the pressure of the russian gouvernment. Poltics may support a church, which is not the same as control.
 
Of course, I did not say that “doctrine… has changed under the pressure of the russian government.” In fact, I pointed out that the Catholic Church recognizes the validity of all seven sacraments of the Russian Church.
 
I know, and I would not think you´ve got this view. It´s just that I read those statements a way too often. Look, it´s not that one have to be a Putin fan to be in the russian orthodox church. It´s in my eyes a bit dangerous to paint an image of a state controlled russian orthodox church as this would cause legitime questions of the theological accuracy and independence of the church, who is, even if not roman, still a catholic church.
As a non russian orthodox in a mainly russian parish, I can say that culture has its place in the chruch like everywhere in the world, but I didn´t recognize any gouvernmental influence in the divine liturgy, the moral theology, the bible exegesis and the spiritual practice. I hope this won´t change in the future.
 
When the Communists took over in Russia, they made the Catholic Church illegal.

Catholic Church property was confiscated and much of it was turned over to the Russian Orthodox Church.

When Pope John Paul II wanted to visit Russia, the Russian Patriarch opposed it and pressured the government not to allow him in… This was probably due to fear that the Pope would ask for Catholic property to be returned. Pope John Paul II had no such intention and never mentioned property. The Russian Patriarch claimed it was because he didn’t want the Pope to proselytize in Russia.

Jim
 
When the Communists took over in Russia, they made the Catholic Church illegal.

Catholic Church property was confiscated and much of it was turned over to the Russian Orthodox Church.
Not only the roman catholic church, all churches were under pressure back then. The years after the fall of the soviet union were years of fear of the future for most russians - cergy included. I don´t know the original statment of the patriarch back then and will therefore take this with a grain of salt, but I see now, in the past ten years, that the roman catholic and the russian orthodox church both grow again in russia, next to each other, and for this we should be grateful.
 
A trip to Moscow for Pope Francis?

That longtime dream trip was never realized. Joaquin Navarro Valls, then Director of the Holy See Press Office, once said that the trip was “an open door as long as it is not closed.” It has been so until now.

The trip was not impeded by political issues. The Pope had been invited to Moscow several times. The first invitation came from Gorbaciov during his visit to the Vatican on December 1, 1989. Gorbaciov’s successor, Boris Yeltsin, invited the Pope when he first met him on December 20, 1991, and after his second visit in February 1998. However, at the end of this last meeting, a spokesperson from the Kremlin underscored that a papal visit to Moscow could only take place after a “careful preparation” and a settlement in Catholic – Russian Orthodox relations.

The issue behind the scenes was that of the “Uniates”, which, in Russian Orthodox parlance, refers to the Catholics of the Byzantine Rite from western Ukraine, whose church properties had been given to the Orthodox Church after Stalin declared the former outlaws.

MondayVatican – Vatican » A trip to Moscow for Pope Francis? | MondayVatican
The tension by the Russian Orthodox Patriarch still exist.

Jim
 
That is categorically incorrect.

The dispute is as to what Roman primacy means, as well as whether it can be exercised while in schism.

(although there are factions of the RO that believe that Moscow should have primacy among the Orthodox, displacing Constantinople, but that’s more Russian nationalism than an actual religious position).

While the EO (and EC, for that matter) are heavily ethnic in outlook, the RO take this to their own level with their mania about “Third Rome.” Some even refer to Washington, DC, as “Fourth Rome” as part of the Third Rome obsession.

As for actual belief, there is no more between RO and RC and EO in general and RC.

As a practical matter, the ROC had been a department of the Russian Empire for centuries prior to the Bolshevik Revolution.
Tell me of one doctrine that has changed under the pressure of the russian gouvernment. Poltics may support a church, which is not the same as control.
AFAIK, no doctrinal changes. However, the influence is definitely there with regard to church relations. Bluntly, +Benedict and +Bartholomew probably could have healed the schism without the RO 500 lb gorilla in the room.
When Pope John Paul II wanted to visit Russia, the Russian Patriarch opposed it and pressured the government not to allow him in… This was probably due to fear that the Pope would ask for Catholic property to be returned.
I suspect they were far more concerned about what that pesky Polish Pope had enabled in his home country . . .

While the USSR certainly handed over Catholic property to the ROC (e.g., the entire assets of the Ukrainian church!), I think they confiscated far more. from them.

hawk
 
i’ve never heard the term “shunning” used in either the russian orthodox or roman catholic church

as has been posted previously here; the main difference is question of the primacy of the Pope

other than that: 90% of the catechism is the same
 
Last edited:
i googled “russian orthodox shunning” essentially; there in no such thing
 
Last edited:
This issue has been discussed many times before on this board, you can find a lot of resources,
whole books have been written on this topic.
The overall bottom line is: Things are complicated. 😉

While it may seem that RC and RO are not too far apart in terms of what they teach,
there are in fact substantial differences, both in theology and, more obviously, in practice.
Many RCs tend to think that the Orthodox are “stubborn” Catholics, who refuse to acknowledge
papal primacy but are otherwise pretty much the same. This is an unfortunate misconception.
You don´t have more than 900 years of schism just for nothing.

In my opinion, ethnophyletism and resulting lack of universality is the big problem the various Orthodox churches are grappling with in general.
There is no chance they will come to terms with that anytime soon, it is in their DNA, so to say.
On the other hand, there is so much in Orthodox practice which could be beneficial to Western Christianity as a whole.
Unfortunately, we have been concentrating on the Protestants for decades when they had really nothing much to offer.
A few concrete things that are in a way typical for the Orthodox include:
  • emphasis on fasting
  • beautiful and reverent liturgies
  • rich prayer life
  • infant communion
Especially, taking the first two again really seriously could be so beneficial to the Catholic church.
The Orthodox do take them seriously.
 
No offense to our faithful Russian Orthodox friends but I have heard reports that the Russian Orthodox church became compromised during the Soviet years. Then again Bella Dodd claimed the same of the Roman Catholic Church.

There is the old term “anathema” in the Roman Catholic Church that, for better or worse, isn’t heard too much these days. I’ve never met a priest who considers smoking tobacco to be a mortal sin; one claiming he knew Bishops who smoked. Most believe smoking pot is.
 
Last edited:
It is, nonetheless, accurate to say that the Russian Orthodox Church is controlled by the Russian government.
Can you tell us how the Russian Orthodox Church is controlled by the government or is that just unsupported hot air. President Vladimir Putin of Russia has strongly supported the rebuilding and restoration of the Russian Orthodox church, but he does not control it AFAIK.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top