Sacramental Union, Idolatry?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Periannath
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

Periannath

Guest
I asked this question on the apologetics forum but I do not know if they will have the time to answer it. I am not Catholic and have background in the ELCA and AG. I believe in the real presence. Particularly, from the Lutheran tradition, I believe in Sacramental Union (sometimes called Consubstantiation incorrectly). I also have been considering Catholicism, although I am not ready to convert to it (an don’t know if I ever will be but I am not saying I wont). My concern is since ministers that do not share in the apostolic succession (according to the Catholic church) do not have the authority to do the Sacrament of Holy Communion then if I believe that Christ is literally present in communion at Lutheran and other churches and worship him there am I in danger of idolatry? Am I communicating this ok? It is a serious concern of mine. In prayer I have not felt convicted and do believe the Lord is present but considering the Catholic Church requires me to at least to some degree suspect that maybe the Sacrament is not able to be true and contain the real presence. Thanks much for your time and God bless!
 
I asked this question on the apologetics forum but I do not know if they will have the time to answer it. I am not Catholic and have background in the ELCA and AG. I believe in the real presence. Particularly, from the Lutheran tradition, I believe in Sacramental Union (sometimes called Consubstantiation incorrectly). I also have been considering Catholicism, although I am not ready to convert to it (an don’t know if I ever will be but I am not saying I wont). My concern is since ministers that do not share in the apostolic succession (according to the Catholic church) do not have the authority to do the Sacrament of Holy Communion then if I believe that Christ is literally present in communion at Lutheran and other churches and worship him there am I in danger of idolatry? Am I communicating this ok? It is a serious concern of mine. In prayer I have not felt convicted and do believe the Lord is present but considering the Catholic Church requires me to at least to some degree suspect that maybe the Sacrament is not able to be true and contain the real presence. Thanks much for your time and God bless!
I’m not sure I have an answer to your question, exactly, but I am reminded of a quote that a fellow CAF member sometimes uses as part of his signature. It is a quote from Cardinal Ratzinger (from 1993) before he became Pope Benedict XVI:

“I count among the most important results of the ecumenical dialogues the insight that the issue of the Eucharist cannot be narrowed to the problem of validity. Even a theology oriented to the concept of succession . . . need not in any way deny the salvation granting presence of the Lord in the Lutheran Lord’s Supper.”

(quoted near the bottom of the article linked below)
jsonline.com/news/milwaukee/29260024.html

I am also reminded of the Catechism of the Catholic Church’s teaching that “God has bound salvation to the Sacrament of Baptism, but he himself is not bound by his sacraments.” To me, this means that God’s grace, which he intends to confer through the valid administration of the sacraments of the Church, is still available in other ways.

Catholics believe that the elements of grace and holiness that are found outside the visible confines of the Catholic Church are indeed real. But they should help guide and direct people to full communion with the Catholic Church, where these riches can be experienced in even greater abundance.

Prayers and best wishes on your journey of faith!

PS - I am familiar with the ELCA, what is the AG?
 
I asked this question on the apologetics forum but I do not know if they will have the time to answer it. I am not Catholic and have background in the ELCA and AG. I believe in the real presence. Particularly, from the Lutheran tradition, I believe in Sacramental Union (sometimes called Consubstantiation incorrectly). I also have been considering Catholicism, although I am not ready to convert to it (an don’t know if I ever will be but I am not saying I wont). My concern is since ministers that do not share in the apostolic succession (according to the Catholic church) do not have the authority to do the Sacrament of Holy Communion then if I believe that Christ is literally present in communion at Lutheran and other churches and worship him there am I in danger of idolatry? Am I communicating this ok? It is a serious concern of mine. In prayer I have not felt convicted and do believe the Lord is present but considering the Catholic Church requires me to at least to some degree suspect that maybe the Sacrament is not able to be true and contain the real presence. Thanks much for your time and God bless!
Since you’re willing to deviate from the Church’s teaching on other matters like the theology of the Eucharist and apostolic succession, why does whether or not the Church considers you to be committing idolatry concern you one bit?
 
I asked this question on the apologetics forum but I do not know if they will have the time to answer it. I am not Catholic and have background in the ELCA and AG. I believe in the real presence. Particularly, from the Lutheran tradition, I believe in Sacramental Union (sometimes called Consubstantiation incorrectly). I also have been considering Catholicism, although I am not ready to convert to it (an don’t know if I ever will be but I am not saying I wont). My concern is since ministers that do not share in the apostolic succession (according to the Catholic church) do not have the authority to do the Sacrament of Holy Communion then if I believe that Christ is literally present in communion at Lutheran and other churches and worship him there am I in danger of idolatry? Am I communicating this ok? It is a serious concern of mine. In prayer I have not felt convicted and do believe the Lord is present but considering the Catholic Church requires me to at least to some degree suspect that maybe the Sacrament is not able to be true and contain the real presence. Thanks much for your time and God bless!
Right now you acknowledge what the Catholic Church teaches, but you do not believe this teaching. Since you still believe the Lutheran church is right and the Catholic Church is wrong on the matter, it seems you are doing what your conscience dictates.

At the point in time when you do come to firm belief that the Catholic Church’s position is the correct one, **then **it would be a serious matter for you to continue to receive communion in a non-Catholic ecclesial community and certainly to “worship” the bread/wine which you know to be only bread/wine.
 
I’m not sure I have an answer to your question, exactly, but I am reminded of a quote that a fellow CAF member sometimes uses as part of his signature. It is a quote from Cardinal Ratzinger (from 1993) before he became Pope Benedict XVI:

“I count among the most important results of the ecumenical dialogues the insight that the issue of the Eucharist cannot be narrowed to the problem of validity. Even a theology oriented to the concept of succession . . . need not in any way deny the salvation granting presence of the Lord in the Lutheran Lord’s Supper.”

(quoted near the bottom of the article linked below)
jsonline.com/news/milwaukee/29260024.html

I am also reminded of the Catechism of the Catholic Church’s teaching that “God has bound salvation to the Sacrament of Baptism, but he himself is not bound by his sacraments.” To me, this means that God’s grace, which he intends to confer through the valid administration of the sacraments of the Church, is still available in other ways.

Catholics believe that the elements of grace and holiness that are found outside the visible confines of the Catholic Church are indeed real. But they should help guide and direct people to full communion with the Catholic Church, where these riches can be experienced in even greater abundance.

Prayers and best wishes on your journey of faith!

PS - I am familiar with the ELCA, what is the AG?
Thank you very much. By AG I ment the Assembiles of God.
 
Right now you acknowledge what the Catholic Church teaches, but you do not believe this teaching. Since you still believe the Lutheran church is right and the Catholic Church is wrong on the matter, it seems you are doing what your conscience dictates.

At the point in time when you do come to firm belief that the Catholic Church’s position is the correct one, **then **it would be a serious matter for you to continue to receive communion in a non-Catholic ecclesial community and certainly to “worship” the bread/wine which you know to be only bread/wine.
I guess the matter is, is it really only bread and wine. To truely consider the Catholic view (which I am thought I am not yet convinced) I must suspect the validity of Lutheran communion. This could mean that I am commiting idolatry, even if I don’t think I am (which is a problem to me). It seems to me, though, that there is room in Catholic teaching to understand that there could be real prescence in the Lord’s Supper even if it is not totally valid in sense of done by a minister with proper succession.
 
It seems to me, though, that there is room in Catholic teaching to understand that there could be real prescence in the Lord’s Supper even if it is not totally valid in sense of done by a minister with proper succession.
No, there isn’t.
 
I guess the matter is, is it really only bread and wine. To truely consider the Catholic view (which I am thought I am not yet convinced) I must suspect the validity of Lutheran communion. This could mean that I am commiting idolatry, even if I don’t think I am (which is a problem to me). It seems to me, though, that there is room in Catholic teaching to understand that there could be real prescence in the Lord’s Supper even if it is not totally valid in sense of done by a minister with proper succession.
No, there isn’t any room in Catholic theology for seeing some kind of “real presence” (in the bread) in Lutheran ceremonies of the Lord’s Supper. The Holy Father spoke of a “salvation granting presence of the Lord” not a “real presence in the Eucharist” nor a “Eucharistic presence.” In other words, there can certainly be some Christian benefit (for those who are otherwise unaware) when they participate in a remembrance of the Lord’s Supper, but the fact remains, and cannot be changed, that when this happens, the bread and wine used remain nothing more than bread and wine–there is no sacramental Presence of the Body/Blood of Christ. There is no change in the bread and wine, there is no consubstantiation, transubstantiation, nor any other change of any kind. That is not to deny the overall presence of Christ in such a gathering, but to add to that a sacramental presence in the bread somehow exists is simply not true.

The quote from then-Cardinal Ratzinger is only an edited snipet of what he actually said. I am most curious to know the actual context of his words, and especially to know what words were removed, as evidenced by the use of the elipses. A little research reveals the text that was removed. It’s enlightening:

I count among the most important results of the ecumenical dialogues the insight that the issue of the eucharist cannot be narrowed to the problem of ‘validity.’ Even a theology oriented to the concept of succession, such as that which holds in the Catholic and in the Orthodox church, need not in any way deny the salvation-granting presence of the Lord.
usccb.org/seia/koinonia.shtml#4 Paragraph #107

As you can see, the words in bold were removed because they clearly express a difference between valid orders for Catholics/Orthodox and a lack of valid orders for Lutherans. The fact that an essential part of the Cardinal’s sentence was edited-out raises serious concerns in my own mind that the entire quote might be used to mean something other than what he actually meant.

Here’s the reference, although I don’t know if it’s available in English
Briefwechsel von Landesbischof Johannes Hanselmann und Joseph Kardinal Ratzinger über das Communio-Schreiben der Römischen Glaubenskongregation," Una Sancta, 48 (1993): 348.
I have been unable to research that one any further.
 
I guess the matter is, is it really only bread and wine. To truely consider the Catholic view (which I am thought I am not yet convinced) I must suspect the validity of Lutheran communion.
And you should. Martin Luther was only a Priest, not a Bishop. Since only a Bishop can validly ordain Priests or consecrate other Bishops, the line of Apostolic Succession was broken.
. . . It seems to me, though, that there is room in Catholic teaching to understand that there could be real prescence in the Lord’s Supper even if it is not totally valid in sense of done by a minister with proper succession.
I do not see how there could be. Jesus gave the Apostles the authority to consecrate the Bread and Wine into the Body and Blood of Christ. It is either valid or it isn’t. Without Apostolic Succession, it isn’t. There can’t be “real presence” if it is not “totally valid.” Sort of like be a “little bit pregnant.”
 
No, there isn’t.
Why not? I guess I need more clarity on why a valid order of priest is essential to a valid eucharist? Is it not the Word of God that makes a sacrament a sacrament, as Augustine rightly taught?
Thanks much and God bless.
 
No, there isn’t any room in Catholic theology for seeing some kind of “real presence” (in the bread) in Lutheran ceremonies of the Lord’s Supper. The Holy Father spoke of a “salvation granting presence of the Lord” not a “real presence in the Eucharist” nor a “Eucharistic presence.” In other words, there can certainly be some Christian benefit (for those who are otherwise unaware) when they participate in a remembrance of the Lord’s Supper, but the fact remains, and cannot be changed, that when this happens, the bread and wine used remain nothing more than bread and wine–there is no sacramental Presence of the Body/Blood of Christ. There is no change in the bread and wine, there is no consubstantiation, transubstantiation, nor any other change of any kind. That is not to deny the overall presence of Christ in such a gathering, but to add to that a sacramental presence in the bread somehow exists is simply not true.

The quote from then-Cardinal Ratzinger is only an edited snipet of what he actually said. I am most curious to know the actual context of his words, and especially to know what words were removed, as evidenced by the use of the elipses. A little research reveals the text that was removed. It’s enlightening:

I count among the most important results of the ecumenical dialogues the insight that the issue of the eucharist cannot be narrowed to the problem of ‘validity.’ Even a theology oriented to the concept of succession, such as that which holds in the Catholic and in the Orthodox church, need not in any way deny the salvation-granting presence of the Lord.
usccb.org/seia/koinonia.shtml#4 Paragraph #107

As you can see, the words in bold were removed because they clearly express a difference between valid orders for Catholics/Orthodox and a lack of valid orders for Lutherans. The fact that an essential part of the Cardinal’s sentence was edited-out raises serious concerns in my own mind that the entire quote might be used to mean something other than what he actually meant.

Here’s the reference, although I don’t know if it’s available in English
Briefwechsel von Landesbischof Johannes Hanselmann und Joseph Kardinal Ratzinger über das Communio-Schreiben der Römischen Glaubenskongregation," Una Sancta, 48 (1993): 348.
I have been unable to research that one any further.
On the elispe.
I don’t think the elispe was meant to distort or hide any fuller meaning of the Pope’s statement. At least as I understood, I understood that “sucession” reffered the type of apostolic succession observed in the pre-reformation churches.

On a 'salvation granting prescence of the Lord"
Wouldn’t a salvation granting prescence of the Lord include his body and blood?

"Jesus said to them, “I tell you the truth, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you have no life in you. Whoever eats my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life, and I will raise him up at the last day.” (John 6:53, 54, NIV)

Peace.
 
On the elispe.
I don’t think the elispe was meant to distort or hide any fuller meaning of the Pope’s statement. At least as I understood, I understood that “sucession” reffered the type of apostolic succession observed in the pre-reformation churches.

On a 'salvation granting prescence of the Lord"
Wouldn’t a salvation granting prescence of the Lord include his body and blood?

"Jesus said to them, “I tell you the truth, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you have no life in you. Whoever eats my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life, and I will raise him up at the last day.” (John 6:53, 54, NIV)

Peace.
The important distinction is that Christ is present in/with the community, but there is no sacramental presence of His Body/Blood in the bread itself–the bread remains nothing more than ordinary bread in a ceremony which remembers the Last Supper (eg a Lutheran ceremony).

The quote from John only reinforces the idea that we need the true and complete Eucharist–that is the means by which Christ gives us His Body and Blood. In accepting Christ fully, we also have to accept the means which He Himself gave to us.
 
The important distinction is that Christ is present in/with the community, but there is no sacramental presence of His Body/Blood in the bread itself–the bread remains nothing more than ordinary bread in a ceremony which remembers the Last Supper (eg a Lutheran ceremony).

The quote from John only reinforces the idea that we need the true and complete Eucharist–that is the means by which Christ gives us His Body and Blood. In accepting Christ fully, we also have to accept the means which He Himself gave to us.
I guess I see things differently. I believe Jesus’ true body and blood is present in, with and under the bread and fruit of the vine because he says so. It is his promise and the word of God that secures that he is present, not the conjuring of minister with valid “apostolic succession.” As St. Augustine said, “It is the word of God that makes a sacrament a sacrament.”

Also, ministers in the ELCA have historic sucession because the church of Sweden never gave up theirs and in entering a relationship with the Episcopal church all Bishops in the ELCA are ordained by Bishops from both bodies and ELCA pastors are ordained by bishops.
Peace.
 
I guess I see things differently. I believe Jesus’ true body and blood is present in, with and under the bread and fruit of the vine because he says so. It is his promise and the word of God that secures that he is present, not the conjuring of minister with valid “apostolic succession.” As St. Augustine said, “It is the word of God that makes a sacrament a sacrament.”
As you continue to explore the Catholic faith, this is a hurdle you will have to get over. What you describe above is definitely Lutheran teaching. It is also definitely NOT Catholic teaching, nor acceptable to hold this belief as a Catholic. The Eucharist is not present on faith, it is present only when consecrated validly by a priest with valid orders.
Also, ministers in the ELCA have historic sucession because the church of Sweden never gave up theirs and in entering a relationship with the Episcopal church all Bishops in the ELCA are ordained by Bishops from both bodies and ELCA pastors are ordained by bishops.
Peace.
The Catholic Church does not find these orders to be acceptable.

Again, if you continue to pursue the Catholic Church you will have to be open to the idea that the Sacramental reality is different than what you have been taught previously.
 
The original question was, is there a danger of idolatry if the OP considers Jesus really present in the Lutheran Communion? IMHO:
  1. No, if your understanding is that Jesus is spiritually present because He promised to be there where two or three are gathered in His name, and because you are symbolically participating in the Last Supper, “in memory” of Him.
  2. Yes, if you believe that He is Bodily present in the elements, because absent a valid consecration (which requires valid orders) the elements remain bread and wine. Such a communion service is only symbolic and the elements remain created goods which should not be worshipped.
You can discern a great deal of what a community (or an individual) believes about the Eucharist by observing what is done with “leftovers.” If they can be returned to non-sacramental use or mixed with unconsecrated material, there is no belief in a real change in the elements. If they are gathered (see Jesus instructions after the feeding of the multitude) and reserved or immediately consumed, that indicates an awareness of a real change. (Of course a person can be sincerely incorrect in their belief, I’m not addressing that here. As has been pointed out above, a person who innocently misunderstands the nature of the elements cannot be guilty of mortal sin.)
 
Peace to you, too, and welcome.
. . .I guess I see things differently. I believe Jesus’ true body and blood is present in, with and under the bread and fruit of the vine because he says so. It is his promise and the word of God that secures that he is present, not the conjuring of minister with valid “apostolic succession.”. . .
So, in your opinion each of us has the ability (if perhaps not the authority) to consecrate the bread and wine, and bring about the real presence?

And as an aside, you may want to refrain from using words like “conjuring” where Catholic priests are concerned - they are not wizards, and not magicians.
 
As you continue to explore the Catholic faith, this is a hurdle you will have to get over. What you describe above is definitely Lutheran teaching. It is also definitely NOT Catholic teaching, nor acceptable to hold this belief as a Catholic. The Eucharist is not present on faith, it is present only when consecrated validly by a priest with valid orders.

The Catholic Church does not find these orders to be acceptable.

Again, if you continue to pursue the Catholic Church you will have to be open to the idea that the Sacramental reality is different than what you have been taught previously.
I do not believe it is present on faith. It does not matter what the one coming to the table believes, Jesus’ body and blood is present. This is not based off of faith but off of the Word and promises of God. Jesus taught us to do this and taught nothing of their needing to be “valid orders of priesthood.”

Also, why is a valid priest neccessary according to catholic teaching and why are those orders considered invalid?
Thanks.
 
The original question was, is there a danger of idolatry if the OP considers Jesus really present in the Lutheran Communion? IMHO:
  1. No, if your understanding is that Jesus is spiritually present because He promised to be there where two or three are gathered in His name, and because you are symbolically participating in the Last Supper, “in memory” of Him.
  2. Yes, if you believe that He is Bodily present in the elements, because absent a valid consecration (which requires valid orders) the elements remain bread and wine. Such a communion service is only symbolic and the elements remain created goods which should not be worshipped.
You can discern a great deal of what a community (or an individual) believes about the Eucharist by observing what is done with “leftovers.” If they can be returned to non-sacramental use or mixed with unconsecrated material, there is no belief in a real change in the elements. If they are gathered (see Jesus instructions after the feeding of the multitude) and reserved or immediately consumed, that indicates an awareness of a real change. (Of course a person can be sincerely incorrect in their belief, I’m not addressing that here. As has been pointed out above, a person who innocently misunderstands the nature of the elements cannot be guilty of mortal sin.)
Would you say that in Catholic communion Jesus is present: body, blood, Soul and Divintey?

As far as communion in the Lutheran church I do believe they do remain bread and wine (no change) but that according to the promise of Christ and his Word he meets us there, even his body and blood that is present in, with and under (pointing to the mystery of this) the bread and wine.
 
Peace to you, too, and welcome.

So, in your opinion each of us has the ability (if perhaps not the authority) to consecrate the bread and wine, and bring about the real presence?

And as an aside, you may want to refrain from using words like “conjuring” where Catholic priests are concerned - they are not wizards, and not magicians.
As to your first question, possibly, I do not know. I don’t think authority should be disscussed as something we own, or have the right to. In reality the authority comes from Christ and his Word, could anyone do a communion service? Maybe, again, I don’t know. I will have to think about this say the least. Currently, though, I see no reason as to why not. Generally, however, it should be done by a minister- since he is called of God and the community to minster the Word of God and the Sacraments to them.

Sorry for using the term conjur, that was not very helpful. I used it, though, to emphasize that if there is a “power” invested in men through an apparent “order” to change the substance of bread and wine to body and blood it seems a lot like a conjuration or a magical thing. If, however, it is God who acts through his Word spoken by a man according to his promise this seems more like an act of God.

Also, no one has responded to my quote of Augustine, “It is the word of God that makes a sacrament a sacrament.” Is this not the case or does the Catholic church not except this teaching of Augustine. (I understand that I could be wrong in understanding what he ment by it) however reading about him and his sacramental theology has been consistent with the way I am understanding this.
Peace.
 
Would you say that in Catholic communion Jesus is present: body, blood, Soul and Divintey?
Yes
As far as communion in the Lutheran church I do believe they do remain bread and wine (no change) but that according to the promise of Christ and his Word he meets us there, even his body and blood that is present in, with and under (pointing to the mystery of this) the bread and wine.
I believe the official teaching of the Lutheran tradition is that the elements contain BOTH the substance of bread and wine AND the substance of Jesus’ Body and Blood (“consubstantiation”). Luther himself was a passionate believer in the Real Presence (he also had a great devotion to the Blessed Virgin). However over the years most of the Lutheran-origin denominations have moved further and further away from belief in the Real Presence.

The quote from Augustine is not contrary to the teaching of the Church. The fact is that it is the Holy Spirit, not the priest, who changes the bread and wine into the Body and Blood. I remember a professor of sacramental theology, years ago, who used as an example - if a crazed priest, duly ordained but unhinged, were to run into a bakery and pronounce the Words of Institution over the bread case, the contents would NOT become the Body of Christ. It’s NOT magic - it is the work of God.

But God has established a priesthood and a liturgy just as He did in the Mosaic covenant.* Jesus chose the Twelve, and the Apostles selected and ordained their successors, and passed along the authority Jesus had given to them. He did not breathe on all His disciples, only on that group, hand-picked and trained. The notion that the “priesthood of believers” is the equivalent of the ordained priesthood is a novel development, as is the notion that the local community can ordain an individual without the involvement of a bishop in the line of Apostolic succession.

*Numbers 16 is somewhat instructive here . . . .
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top