Sacraments and idolatry?

  • Thread starter Thread starter junostarlighter
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

junostarlighter

Guest
A free-methodist pastor writes:
The source of the Christian life, of course, is the God as Father-Creator, Christ as Son-Sacrifice, and the Holy Spirit as Life Giver-Empowerer, not the sacramental event. If we replace the Creator with any aspect of the creation as the source of life and the center of all, we verge on idolatry. Pagan religions of ancient times placed a value on their religious actions and sacraments as having a magical power, so that the very act itself had a mystical reality. Paul cautions against that to the Corinthians in 1 Cor. 11.
  1. What pagan practices is going on in 1 Cor. 11?
  2. I need help explaining how sacraments are not idolatry or pagan. Any help?
 
I would start with what a sacrament is. Just use the basic: instituted by Christ and it is an outward sign of an inward change of grace. Then, pick ONE AND ONLY ONE sacrament to use as an example. For a methodist, use baptism. Show how Christ required it, then show what happens in baptism. If he objects, ask him how is church sees Baptism.
 
The Sacraments are established by Christ. He has commanded us to use them, and He cannot command us to sin; therefore, using the Sacraments can in no way be sinful; certainly, it is not idolotry. (A wrong use of the elements of the Sacraments would be sacreligious, and could also be idolotrous under certain circumstances, but I assume you are referring to the right use of the Sacraments.)

It is more than I have space for to describe how each Sacrament was established by Christ; therefore I am going to refer you to a web site that I built. It is intended for the use of non-Catholic Christians, but you might also find it useful - it’s at jmcrae.christian.net/ - go there and then click on “Sacraments.”

God bless you in your efforts. 🙂
 
A free-methodist pastor writes:
  1. What pagan practices is going on in 1 Cor. 11?
None at all.
  1. I need help explaining how sacraments are not idolatry or pagan. Any help?
No you don’t. Make him prove his case that any sacraments within our most holy faith are ever asserted to be magical? He can’t do it and this article on my blog,
The Eucharist IS Scriptural will show that not only the New Testament but the ECF plainly state that they held to the same beliefs that we do today with regard to the Eucharistic Real Presence.

I’d say that this fellow doesn’t know what he’s talking about.
 
None at all.No you don’t. Make him prove his case that any sacraments within our most holy faith are ever asserted to be magical? He can’t do it and this article on my blog,
The Eucharist IS Scriptural will show that not only the New Testament but the ECF plainly state that they held to the same beliefs that we do today with regard to the Eucharistic Real Presence.

I’d say that this fellow doesn’t know what he’s talking about.
Hmmm…thanks. I’ll try that approach of making him prove a case and see where he goes with it.
 
Okay, so I called his bluff and it worked. Either he knows that I’m no ordinary college student and have done my homework or/and he doesn’t have a good idea on the Catholic faith concerning sacraments. Instead, he responded to what I had to say on the Eucharist in a previous email. I mentioned that the Eucharist is the source and summit of all Christian life and how all the sacraments are orientated towards it. He thought it was a pre-Vatican II view and asked me:
Would you say your view holds closer to the pre-Vatican II concepts or the post-Vatican II articulation? There seems to be emerging a strong interest among portions of the Catholic Church to reverse the modernizing influence of Vatican II and return to a much more classic, apostolic understanding and practice. Yet, others want to fully modernize the church and recognize women as priests and celebacy as a choice not a requirement. What a day to be Catholic! Then, all the controversies about schools closing…]plus other issues.
First I responded by saying that my views on the Eucharist were taken directly out of Vatican II as I cited Lumen Gentium 11, Presbyterorum Ordinis 5, and CCC 1324. I also wrote:
The idea of a post-Vatican II vs. a pre-Vatican II Church is misleading and a myth, as if Vatican II made radical changes in the Church’s teaching, which it did not do…]They did not change any dogma or ignore past teachings, but rather sought to explain teachings in a Christ-o-centric and Trinitarian viewpoint, as the Catholic Church subsisting in Christ’s Church and having its very life from within the Trinity. If anything, when you read the documents, you don’t sense much of a radical change, but rather a consistent continuity with constant Church teaching and Apostolic Tradition.
I know there are those who have wanted to take advantage of Vatican II to “modernize” the Church in their own image and likeness and say that they’re doing so “in the spirit of Vatican II.” Ironically, these very people who do so either haven’t read any of the documents or are grossly twisting them for their own ends; it’s always one of the two. Some people would say that the Church is in crisis because of this; I call it Church history. This isn’t just a problem that Vatican II has had to enjoy. Other councils of the Church have had similar problems after convening. The problems either get fixed or just fade away.
His response to me then was the following:
As an observer without your knowledge, it appears to me that the Catholic Church pre-Vatican II and post-Vatican II are vastly different. It does not appear that the events which occurred out of that council were merely explaining vagarities or making adjustments to misunderstood aspects. It was a radical change in demeanor and core, leading to a very different ethos. Just about every Catholic person I know except you identifies Vatican II as THE watershed of the Catholic Church, unique compared to every other council in history, at least as the modern communicant is considered.
Any insights to help me to respond to him? Much appreciated as always!
 
Any insights to help me to respond to him? Much appreciated as always!
Councils of the Church do have a way of changing its external appearance and disciplinary practices. For example, the Church after the Council of Jerusalem (Acts 15) looked a great deal different than the Church before that - all those Greeks, all that pork at the Church suppers, etc., where before, everyone in the Church had been Jewish, and Church suppers had been very kosher.

After the Council of Nicea, the Mass looked different than it had before, with new Scripture readings being read out (the Gospels were added to the Lectionary), and the Nicene Creed being recited after the readings - and the “radical switch” from the Mass being entirely in Greek, to being almost entirely in Latin, with some Greek (notably the Kyrie) being retained.

After Trent, the Church looked a lot different than it had before that, with stronger disciplines, more fasting (Lent was extended to 40 days and the Triduum became its own season), changes in how people received the Eucharist (on the tongue instead of in the hand, etc.), and less latitude for priests with regard to how they said Mass - there were specific rubrics in place which were much more detailed than had existed up to that time.

So, we are not surprised that after the Second Vatican Council, things look different than they did before, and that the disciplines have changed. This is perfectly consistent with our history. 🙂

That the disciplines and the outward appearance have changed does not signify that the teachings (doctrine, dogma, or morality) themselves have changed, any more than previous changes in these things ever signified changes in teaching.
 
Take a look/listen to some of THESE podcasts. These may help you give some very common sense responses to him.

Especially these: 12 Myths about the Catholic Church, What Happened to the Catholic Church, and The Eucharist.

~Liza
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top