Sad to Understand Evangelicals

  • Thread starter Thread starter dad_o_six
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

dad_o_six

Guest
The other day, I heard two Evangelicals talking about their book, “Spagetti for the Soul,” on Christian radio. They didn’t make a big deal of it, but obviously they were both raised Catholic and they both felt that the Church did not convey to them a living and breathing faith. They were, instead, drawn to an Evangelical or non-denominational form of Bible-Christianity.

Here’s my dilemma: Though I believe that the Catholic Church is the one true faith, I also perceive regularly that the practice of the faith, especially since moving to the Northeast, is trivialized and has lost its meaning and impact. In fact, though I am repelled by the inevitable anti-Catholic jabs, I often find myself identifying more with Christian Evangelicals than with cradle Catholics.

This is very sad to me. I think the reason is that catechesis is sorely lacking. The other day, my kindergartener came home with a coloring from “Faith Formation” (apparently, CCD was no longer a good enough term). Her exercise contained the phrases comment: *“Jesus says, 'People who help others are important.” *In the center, the handout said, “I am important. I can help.” I understand that this curriculum was designed for kindergarteners, but that does not excuse a gross distortion of the Scriptures. This approved Catholic curriculum was guilty of two things the Evangelicals accuse us Catholics of doing. 1. This promotes a good works mentality. 2. It puts words into God’s mouth. My wife and I have started having CCD after CCD. We use what they learned as a building block into a more accurate discussion of the Christian faith. Next year, we will be homeschooling.

So, when I listen to these nice Evangelical ladies discussing Christianity I can not only see why they gave up Catholicism, but also why they unknowingly bring along so much of it in what they pass along–from St. Francis of Assisi to their family recipes. Perhaps they are subconsciously Catholic, they just were so poorly instructed that they cannot recognize it.
 
Hi dad-o-six,
I can empathize with you. I have started to see a lack of conviction and understanding within the laity of the Catholic Church lately. Part of it is, I was at one point a lukewarm Catholic without really knowing it, and only through a lot of investigation, reading the lives of the Saints, Catechism, etc, did I realize it. I have to admit I had a relatively weak education in my Catholic faith (and I grew up in the Northeast).

I think you’re doing the right thing, accurately teaching your children the richness of the Catholic faith. If you have time, you should offer your services to the Church to teach “faith formation”, or at least share some of your concerns. Maybe next year when you are homeschooling, you can share some of your teaching materials with your Church. Speak to your priest(s) about the concerns you have, they should know if there are issues with the classes, they are often very receptive to changes for the good of their parishioners. Maybe this would help others from leaving the Church to join other denominations.
 
Hi, I do see what you are saying, but perhaps it depends on the parish?

I find it very sad when people leave the Church because they don’t think it helps them spiritually…because what could be better than the Sacraments? I guess these people were never properly catechized, which is indeed sad. I think it’s really important to learn the faith well and understand it. It’s especially important to have good teachers who teach Catholicism as it is, not the watered down version.

A lot of people go to evangelical churches because they’re more emotion-based and “feel good”… 😦
I am still trying to understand all this.

God bless
 
@OP

Yes its hard to see some of the things that are passed off as relgious material but you must understand and see that these are for little kids. While this is so we must also do our best to show our children literal text but right now it is beyond their comprehension so we have to make it a little bit easier so they can follow along. It is easy to overload a young child and when you do this they get discouraged and end up hating the very thing they are suppose to love. We as adults though shouldn’t let this material discourage our Faith in the Catholic Church. We have the fullness of the Christian faith because we have our Lord in the Blessed Sacrament. Because we have Christ and will always have Christ in the blessed Sacrament there is nothing on this world that could ever take us away from it! The Church is Christs Mystical Body and we must wrap our arms around it and hold on for dear life…never to abandon it! The Church is on the road to calvery and we are duty bound to walk along side it instructing people that Christ is truly present here! Protestant Chruches have no sacrifical priesthood, no ability to forgive sins, no authority from God to bind or loosen anything on heaven or earth. Bible Christians are a contradiction since true Christians were Church Christians and thats what we Catholics are! We should never fall into dispare when it comes to being Catholic.
 
If you perceive a problem with catechesis in your parish, get involved. If you do not get involved, you become part of the problem not the solution. Before I get accused of attacking home-schoolers, let me observe that many of my best catechists are home-schoolers, who are concerned about good catechesis for their own children, but because they feel so strongly, and by definition are themselves well versed in the faith and skilled at passing it on, they offer their time and talent to all the children of the parish, which is as it should be. This fortress mentality of Catholic formation for my kid and hang the rest defies explanation in my estimation.
 
Actually, PuzzleAnnie your right. I’m an Adult going through the RCIA. I believe you hit the nail right on the head. Even though I’m still, learning of my new faith I think people have forgotten that part of being Christian is an obligation to use our talents in some way to benefit the faith. Going to church every Sunday simply just isn’t enough. Everyone must do more. I beleive thats even in the Bible somewhere. While faith alone is TRUE I still believe we must all do more. Just my 2 cents.
 
If you perceive a problem with catechesis in your parish, get involved. If you do not get involved, you become part of the problem not the solution. Before I get accused of attacking home-schoolers, let me observe that many of my best catechists are home-schoolers, who are concerned about good catechesis for their own children, but because they feel so strongly, and by definition are themselves well versed in the faith and skilled at passing it on, they offer their time and talent to all the children of the parish, which is as it should be. This fortress mentality of Catholic formation for my kid and hang the rest defies explanation in my estimation.
I agree with PuzzleAnnie too. Perhaps the tide is starting to turn with more people getting involved and questioning bad catechesis. Maybe dad_o_six there might be a few people around in your parish that are feeling the same way ?
 
Apologetics is a more appropriate forum for my post and I thank the host for the move and apologize for my imprecision.😉

Hmmm. I was pleased to hear that I’m not alone in my concerns. I do have some hesitancy on the point of time and talents, however. One of my concerns with the Church today is that so much focus is placed on the laity. For example, my parish has so many Extraordinary Ministers of the Eucharist that they are practically tripping over one another. This was sort of my point on the little artwork that my daughter brought home. In my more sinister moments (and I am a rather sardonic fellow at times) I’ve toyed with the idea of having the artwork laminated and pin it to one of the Eucharistic Ministers on my way out of church. “I’m important. I can help.” My point is that I don’t think being Catholic is supposed to be so focused on volunteerism and social justice. Sure, these things are of course important. But loving others without loving God first is empty.

Another concern that I have concerns working with other people’s children. I was a soccer coach this year and I found it to be entirely nerve-racking–my issue, no one else’s. With my kids, I can be myself. With other people’s kids, I’m always second-guessing. In today’s litigious society, having any type of responsibility with other people’s children is terrifying to me.

The other concern I have is with my opinions versus those of the liberal establishment around me. My diocese just ran off a very conservative bishop–IMO the best man for the job–because of his conservative views. Imagine what they would do to me. And in today’s society, some people will stop at nothing to get their way.

So, I’m not about to jump in to volunteer as a religious formation teacher or aid at this time. Sure, I have a lot of ideas, but I would really rub some people the wrong way and who knows what they would do to get rid of me.
 
I get so frustrated at the ongoing Barney-ization of the Catholic faith, at least in the West. I am reminded daily of what Paul wrote:

You need milk, not solid food;
for every one who lives on milk is unskilled in the word of righteousness, for he is a child.
But solid food is for the mature, for those who have their faculties trained by practice to distinguish good from evil.

Today the typical diet fed to Catholics, both as regards catechesis and as regards liturgy, is not just milk, but cotton candy dipped in milk and sprinkled with marshmallows. Far too many Catholics are treated as if they were eternally 8 years old. It is a crime, pure and simple.
 
I get so frustrated at the ongoing Barney-ization of the Catholic faith, at least in the West. I am reminded daily of what Paul wrote:
You need milk, not solid food;
for every one who lives on milk is unskilled in the word of righteousness, for he is a child.
But solid food is for the mature, for those who have their faculties trained by practice to distinguish good from evil.
Today the typical diet fed to Catholics, both as regards catechesis and as regards liturgy, is not just milk, but cotton candy dipped in milk and sprinkled with marshmallows. Far too many Catholics are treated as if they were eternally 8 years old. It is a crime, pure and simple.
I agree. For whatever reason, we seem compelled to teach to the least common denominator, repeatedly presuming that we need to begin again explaining the faith to someone who knows absolutely nothing.

Chuck
 
The other day, I heard two Evangelicals talking about their book, “Spagetti for the Soul,” on Christian radio. They didn’t make a big deal of it, but obviously they were both raised Catholic and they both felt that the Church did not convey to them a living and breathing faith. They were, instead, drawn to an Evangelical or non-denominational form of Bible-Christianity.

Here’s my dilemma: Though I believe that the Catholic Church is the one true faith, I also perceive regularly that the practice of the faith, especially since moving to the Northeast, is trivialized and has lost its meaning and impact. In fact, though I am repelled by the inevitable anti-Catholic jabs, I often find myself identifying more with Christian Evangelicals than with cradle Catholics.

This is very sad to me. I think the reason is that catechesis is sorely lacking. The other day, my kindergartener came home with a coloring from “Faith Formation” (apparently, CCD was no longer a good enough term). Her exercise contained the phrases comment: *“Jesus says, 'People who help others are important.” *In the center, the handout said, “I am important. I can help.” I understand that this curriculum was designed for kindergarteners, but that does not excuse a gross distortion of the Scriptures. This approved Catholic curriculum was guilty of two things the Evangelicals accuse us Catholics of doing. 1. This promotes a good works mentality. 2. It puts words into God’s mouth. My wife and I have started having CCD after CCD. We use what they learned as a building block into a more accurate discussion of the Christian faith. Next year, we will be homeschooling.

So, when I listen to these nice Evangelical ladies discussing Christianity I can not only see why they gave up Catholicism, but also why they unknowingly bring along so much of it in what they pass along–from St. Francis of Assisi to their family recipes. Perhaps they are subconsciously Catholic, they just were so poorly instructed that they cannot recognize it.
I teach Kindergarden CCD at my parish, and they actually have a different curriculum then 1-5th grade. I dont know if the same applies to your parish, but this may be the case. The focus is on “God loves us”, and to give and overall watered down understanding of God. While we do read out of childrens bibles, we have themes such as “praying to God is good”, “All saints are good”. I personally think it is good to get all students on the same page, because many of them know this information already. But some dont, and giving the students the bibles to read out of, helps them all grow in their faith. Our coloring pages usually do not have bible verses on them, just the name of the picture. But on their workbook pages they do have a bible verse or more, and it says where in the bible it comes from. Maybe you could talk to the Religious Ed. office, and ask if theres a different curriculum starting in 1st grade? Hope it all works better. Its definitely good to take home the information and continue the lesson!
 
What do people feel should be some of the “Catholic” things taught in Catholic elementary schools that currently are not ?
 
I just wanted to add, kind of to my own surprise, that as I have been reading about the Catholic concept of salvation on this website, I have come to realize that I have been believing in works based salvation all this time. Basically, if you’re a good person, you will get into heaven, but the truth is much more complex than that.

I was raised Catholic and went to Catholic school from 3rd grade to High School. I did not lapse because of disagreement with Catholic the concept of salvation (i.e. Sola Fide did not steal me away) but rather, in part, because I thought that I could just “make up” for any mistakes later.

Also, I believe that I left because the CC doesn’t do as good of a job as it could in the transition between child /adolescent to adult, otherwise I wouldn’t be struck by the difference it what I was believing and what the CC actually teaches. It’s not the CC’s fault entirely, obviously, I could have sought out the truth more but such is the impetuousness of youth. 🙂
 
I am not a Catholic but I have been seeking to have a deeper, clearer understanding of the Sacrament of the Eucharist. I have several Catholic co-workers that I went to for answers. I presented them with lines 1365-1367 of the Catechism and they openly admitted that they didn’t have a clue how to answer my questions. The part that was disheartening is that it didn’t bother them one bit. When I listen to EWTN radio, I hear the hosts and guests speak of the importance of understanding why the church does what it does, but for some reason the mentality of many cradle Catholics in my circle of family and friends is that only the priests need to have a deep understanding of the faith and that their understanding sort of covers over the lay peoples’ lacking. Many Protestants don’t know a lot about their faith either but it seems that many protestant churches emphasize all church members diligently studying the Bible which develops more understanding of their faith. I think little children can understand a lot more about man’s sinful nature and our need for a savior than what we often give them credit.
 
I am not a Catholic but I have been seeking to have a deeper, clearer understanding of the Sacrament of the Eucharist. I have several Catholic co-workers that I went to for answers. I presented them with lines 1365-1367 of the Catechism and they openly admitted that they didn’t have a clue how to answer my questions. The part that was disheartening is that it didn’t bother them one bit. When I listen to EWTN radio, I hear the hosts and guests speak of the importance of understanding why the church does what it does, but for some reason the mentality of many cradle Catholics in my circle of family and friends is that only the priests need to have a deep understanding of the faith and that their understanding sort of covers over the lay peoples’ lacking. Many Protestants don’t know a lot about their faith either but it seems that many protestant churches emphasize all church members diligently studying the Bible which develops more understanding of their faith. I think little children can understand a lot more about man’s sinful nature and our need for a savior than what we often give them credit.
I guess I’m not surprised. I’d invite you to start a thread on your questions here, and I think you’ll get some of the answers you seek. I guarantee you’ve got people looking up those lines even now. 🙂
 
I am not a Catholic but I have been seeking to have a deeper, clearer understanding of the Sacrament of the Eucharist. I have several Catholic co-workers that I went to for answers. I presented them with lines 1365-1367 of the Catechism and they openly admitted that they didn’t have a clue how to answer my questions. The part that was disheartening is that it didn’t bother them one bit. When I listen to EWTN radio, I hear the hosts and guests speak of the importance of understanding why the church does what it does, but for some reason the mentality of many cradle Catholics in my circle of family and friends is that only the priests need to have a deep understanding of the faith and that their understanding sort of covers over the lay peoples’ lacking. Many Protestants don’t know a lot about their faith either but it seems that many protestant churches emphasize all church members diligently studying the Bible which develops more understanding of their faith. I think little children can understand a lot more about man’s sinful nature and our need for a savior than what we often give them credit.
This is probably beyond the original scope of the thread, but I feel a need to respond. The Catholic Church is the only religion in the history of the world that clearly affirms both humanity/the body and spirituality. My understanding is that the Eucharist is the intersection of both material Being and spiritual Being. Compare this to Hinduism or Buddhism, in which material being is merely suffering and illusion. Only Jesus was fully human and fully divine, affirming the importance of both my mortal life and my immortal soul, as well as yours and every human being’s. Protestantism, as it has taken away the material sacraments and ecclesiastical authority, is evolving toward something like Hinduism, but more akin to vague, 12-step inspired, empty spirituality. This is especially true of the mainline Protestant churches and maybe why I can sometimes identify with Evangelicals more that cradle Catholics who are often indistinguishable from mainline Protestants in their actual beliefs.

One of the things that is sorely lacking from Cathechesis, especially for teens, is a clear distinction of what it means to be Catholic versus Protestant. Are we that afraid to offend? I submit we cannot define who we are without giving a serious response to who we are not. On this measure, the Evangelicals are light years ahead of the Catholic church in America.
 
I would like to respond to those who in this thread who have advised former Protestants to “get involved” with catechesis.

I’ve been Catholic now for five years, after 47 years of enthusiastic and excessive involvement in the evangelical Protestant church. I was involved primarily in music and teaching ministries in the Protestant churches that I was involved with.

However, I have struggled with teaching involvement in the Catholic Church. It seems like it should be a natural fit, doesn’t it? Well, it isn’t. Those of us who came from Protestant fellowships know that something is different about us. Yes, we are fully Catholic, but we have an entire baggage car of knowledge and background to deal with. We are not cradle Catholics and we don’t understand what it means to be cradle Catholic.

For example, I still struggle with the concept of liturgical abuse. I understand intellectually why it’s important to preserve the Liturgy of the Mass. But I shake my head over the anal-retentiveness of many of the people on this forum–at least, that’s how it appears to me.

Do you see what I’m getting at?

I personally don’t think it is wise to put most evangelicals in positions in the Catholic Church where they are teaching children and teenagers. I think that some of our “baggage” will inevitably slop over into our teaching and this will bring about the changes in the Catholic Church that so many Catholics see and decry.

A while back, I did a post where I described how the music in the Mass is changing and how I believe that much of that change is due to Protestants becoming Catholic and bringing with us our vibrant, lively, emotional music–yes, I love it and frankly, I think a lot of what passes for reverent in Masses now is merely dull and lifeless compared to some of the great gospel hymns that I grew up on .

You see? There it is again!

The example that I intended to give was the “alcohol” example. I was raised in a family and in a church that believed that consumption of any and all alcohol is wrong and that Christians should never drink alcohol. I still agree with this and I have argued on this forum for the complete abstinence of Christians from alcohol.

Do you honestly think I could tell a child or a teenager, with a straight face and clear eyes, that it’s OK for Christians to drink alcohol? It will never happen.

Finally, I believe that for their own spiritual development, most evangelicals should be kept away from teaching in the Catholic Church. Over and over again, in the evangelical churches, we saw movie stars, musicians, and other famous people become Christians (“ask Jesus into their heart”), and be swept up into “Christian celebrity” by the evangelicals, who booked them to teach and preach and sing. B.J. Thomas is an example–he was our “poster boy” for a few years. Then he made the “mistake” of saying that it was OK for Christians to sing secular music–and hoo, boy, did he get attacked! He eventually faded out of the evangelical scene–I hope he’s still a believer in Jesus, but I don’t know. I think that everyone scared him away. He wasn’t ready to take on the ministry of teaching.

I think a lot of evangelical Protestants would do well to simply “wait” and study and learn how to be Catholic before charging in to “fix up the lack of catechesis in the Catholic Church today, harumph harumph!”

If you think that the catechesis issue bothers Catholics, you should know what it does to evangelicals. It yanks our chain so badly that it causes us to doubt sometimes whether the Pope is a man or a mouse. We see so much wasted potential, so much that could be done. Honestly, more teaching went on in my evangelical churches in ONE YEAR than has happened in five years in the entire U.S.A. Catholic Church! It drives evangelicals totally nuts to see the sheer sitting around and doing nothing that we see in the Catholic Church. We want to start yelling, “Put that Rosary away and do some studying, people!”

Do you understand what I’m saying? I’ve tried to write this post to illustrate why you WOULDN’T want me teaching your Catholic children or teenagers, and why you would probably be hesitant to invite me to speak at your grown-up class! It’s just not a wise plan.

Certainly, there are exceptions. God has called some former evangelicals to be wonderful teachers in the Catholic Church. But I believe these people are the exception rather than the rule.
 
I would like to respond to those who in this thread who have advised former Protestants to “get involved” with catechesis.

I’ve been Catholic now for five years, after 47 years of enthusiastic and excessive involvement in the evangelical Protestant church. I was involved primarily in music and teaching ministries in the Protestant churches that I was involved with.

However, I have struggled with teaching involvement in the Catholic Church. It seems like it should be a natural fit, doesn’t it? Well, it isn’t. Those of us who came from Protestant fellowships know that something is different about us. Yes, we are fully Catholic, but we have an entire baggage car of knowledge and background to deal with. We are not cradle Catholics and we don’t understand what it means to be cradle Catholic.

For example, I still struggle with the concept of liturgical abuse. I understand intellectually why it’s important to preserve the Liturgy of the Mass. But I shake my head over the anal-retentiveness of many of the people on this forum–at least, that’s how it appears to me.

Do you see what I’m getting at?

I personally don’t think it is wise to put most evangelicals in positions in the Catholic Church where they are teaching children and teenagers. I think that some of our “baggage” will inevitably slop over into our teaching and this will bring about the changes in the Catholic Church that so many Catholics see and decry.

A while back, I did a post where I described how the music in the Mass is changing and how I believe that much of that change is due to Protestants becoming Catholic and bringing with us our vibrant, lively, emotional music–yes, I love it and frankly, I think a lot of what passes for reverent in Masses now is merely dull and lifeless compared to some of the great gospel hymns that I grew up on .

You see? There it is again!

The example that I intended to give was the “alcohol” example. I was raised in a family and in a church that believed that consumption of any and all alcohol is wrong and that Christians should never drink alcohol. I still agree with this and I have argued on this forum for the complete abstinence of Christians from alcohol.

Do you honestly think I could tell a child or a teenager, with a straight face and clear eyes, that it’s OK for Christians to drink alcohol? It will never happen.

Finally, I believe that for their own spiritual development, most evangelicals should be kept away from teaching in the Catholic Church. Over and over again, in the evangelical churches, we saw movie stars, musicians, and other famous people become Christians (“ask Jesus into their heart”), and be swept up into “Christian celebrity” by the evangelicals, who booked them to teach and preach and sing. B.J. Thomas is an example–he was our “poster boy” for a few years. Then he made the “mistake” of saying that it was OK for Christians to sing secular music–and hoo, boy, did he get attacked! He eventually faded out of the evangelical scene–I hope he’s still a believer in Jesus, but I don’t know. I think that everyone scared him away. He wasn’t ready to take on the ministry of teaching.

I think a lot of evangelical Protestants would do well to simply “wait” and study and learn how to be Catholic before charging in to “fix up the lack of catechesis in the Catholic Church today, harumph harumph!”

If you think that the catechesis issue bothers Catholics, you should know what it does to evangelicals. It yanks our chain so badly that it causes us to doubt sometimes whether the Pope is a man or a mouse. We see so much wasted potential, so much that could be done. Honestly, more teaching went on in my evangelical churches in ONE YEAR than has happened in five years in the entire U.S.A. Catholic Church! It drives evangelicals totally nuts to see the sheer sitting around and doing nothing that we see in the Catholic Church. We want to start yelling, “Put that Rosary away and do some studying, people!”

Do you understand what I’m saying? I’ve tried to write this post to illustrate why you WOULDN’T want me teaching your Catholic children or teenagers, and why you would probably be hesitant to invite me to speak at your grown-up class! It’s just not a wise plan.

Certainly, there are exceptions. God has called some former evangelicals to be wonderful teachers in the Catholic Church. But I believe these people are the exception rather than the rule.
I understand where you are coming from, but I thnk much of what you are saying is still coming from an evangelical mindset.
The Protestant revolt, which includes evangelicals, based it’s philosophy on ‘knowledge’, which is directly a result of the Enlightenment. Historically, being a Catholic Christian is more than that. If it was all based on ‘knowledge’ the Church would have the divisions Protestantism has.
One can know very little about the deep things of theology, and yet be a devout Catholic. How? Those spiritual exercises like those Rosaries evangelicals think should be ‘put away’. Just like bodily exercise makes your body healthier, spiritual exercise makes your spirit healthier. That might INCLUDE knowledge, but is NOT LIMITED to knowledge.
The saints of the Middle Ages did not have access to Catholic Answers, they nevertheless were saints.
 
The other day, I heard two Evangelicals talking about their book, “Spagetti for the Soul,” on Christian radio. They didn’t make a big deal of it, but obviously they were both raised Catholic and they both felt that the Church did not convey to them a living and breathing faith. They were, instead, drawn to an Evangelical or non-denominational form of Bible-Christianity.

Here’s my dilemma: Though I believe that the Catholic Church is the one true faith, I also perceive regularly that the practice of the faith, especially since moving to the Northeast, is trivialized and has lost its meaning and impact. In fact, though I am repelled by the inevitable anti-Catholic jabs, I often find myself identifying more with Christian Evangelicals than with cradle Catholics.

This is very sad to me. I think the reason is that catechesis is sorely lacking. The other day, my kindergartener came home with a coloring from “Faith Formation” (apparently, CCD was no longer a good enough term). Her exercise contained the phrases comment: *“Jesus says, 'People who help others are important.” *In the center, the handout said, “I am important. I can help.” I understand that this curriculum was designed for kindergarteners, but that does not excuse a gross distortion of the Scriptures. This approved Catholic curriculum was guilty of two things the Evangelicals accuse us Catholics of doing. 1. This promotes a good works mentality. 2. It puts words into God’s mouth. My wife and I have started having CCD after CCD. We use what they learned as a building block into a more accurate discussion of the Christian faith. Next year, we will be homeschooling.

So, when I listen to these nice Evangelical ladies discussing Christianity I can not only see why they gave up Catholicism, but also why they unknowingly bring along so much of it in what they pass along–from St. Francis of Assisi to their family recipes. Perhaps they are subconsciously Catholic, they just were so poorly instructed that they cannot recognize it.
“Before him will be gathered all the nations, and he will separate them one from another as a shepherd separates the sheep from the goats, 33 and he will place the sheep at his right hand, but the goats at the left. 34 Then the King will say to those at his right hand, ‘Come, O blessed of my Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world; 35 for I was hungry and you gave me food, I was thirsty and you gave me drink, I was a stranger and you welcomed me, 36 I was naked and you clothed me, I was sick and you visited me, I was in prison and you came to me.’ 37 Then the righteous will answer him, ‘Lord, when did we see thee hungry and feed thee, or thirsty and give thee drink? 38 And when did we see thee a stranger and welcome thee, or naked and clothe thee? 39 And when did we see thee sick or in prison and visit thee?’ 40 And the King will answer them, ‘Truly, I say to you, as you did it to one of the least of these my brethren, you did it to me.’ 41 Then he will say to those at his left hand, ‘Depart from me, you cursed, into the eternal fire prepared for the devil and his angels; 42 for I was hungry and you gave me no food, I was thirsty and you gave me no drink, 43 I was a stranger and you did not welcome me, naked and you did not clothe me, sick and in prison and you did not visit me.’ 44 Then they also will answer, ‘Lord, when did we see thee hungry or thirsty or a stranger or naked or sick or in prison, and did not minister to thee?’ 45 Then he will answer them, ‘Truly, I say to you, as you did it not to one of the least of these, you did it not to me.’ 46 And they will go away into eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life.” (Mt 25:32-46)

**Sounds like Jesus said that works, not faith, will determine who is a goat and who is a sheep!

"Not every one who says to me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ shall enter the kingdom of heaven, but he who does the will of my Father who is in heaven." (Mt 7:21)

The problem with our Protestant brothers and sisters is they claim to be ‘Sola Scriptura’, but they only use selected verses from ‘Scriptura’ as they see fit, often taking these verses out of context to try to prove a point like “faith alone.”

Perhaps we all need more Faith Formation!, Read Sacred Scripture and the Catechism!
**

Sancta Maria, Mater Dei, Ora Pro Nobis Peccatoribus!

mark
 
I would like to respond to those who in this thread who have advised former Protestants to “get involved” with catechesis.

I’ve been Catholic now for five years, after 47 years of enthusiastic and excessive involvement in the evangelical Protestant church. I was involved primarily in music and teaching ministries in the Protestant churches that I was involved with.

However, I have struggled with teaching involvement in the Catholic Church. It seems like it should be a natural fit, doesn’t it? Well, it isn’t. Those of us who came from Protestant fellowships know that something is different about us. Yes, we are fully Catholic, but we have an entire baggage car of knowledge and background to deal with. We are not cradle Catholics and we don’t understand what it means to be cradle Catholic.

For example, I still struggle with the concept of liturgical abuse. I understand intellectually why it’s important to preserve the Liturgy of the Mass. But I shake my head over the anal-retentiveness of many of the people on this forum–at least, that’s how it appears to me.

Do you see what I’m getting at?

I personally don’t think it is wise to put most evangelicals in positions in the Catholic Church where they are teaching children and teenagers. I think that some of our “baggage” will inevitably slop over into our teaching and this will bring about the changes in the Catholic Church that so many Catholics see and decry.

A while back, I did a post where I described how the music in the Mass is changing and how I believe that much of that change is due to Protestants becoming Catholic and bringing with us our vibrant, lively, emotional music–yes, I love it and frankly, I think a lot of what passes for reverent in Masses now is merely dull and lifeless compared to some of the great gospel hymns that I grew up on .

You see? There it is again!

The example that I intended to give was the “alcohol” example. I was raised in a family and in a church that believed that consumption of any and all alcohol is wrong and that Christians should never drink alcohol. I still agree with this and I have argued on this forum for the complete abstinence of Christians from alcohol.

Do you honestly think I could tell a child or a teenager, with a straight face and clear eyes, that it’s OK for Christians to drink alcohol? It will never happen.

Finally, I believe that for their own spiritual development, most evangelicals should be kept away from teaching in the Catholic Church. Over and over again, in the evangelical churches, we saw movie stars, musicians, and other famous people become Christians (“ask Jesus into their heart”), and be swept up into “Christian celebrity” by the evangelicals, who booked them to teach and preach and sing. B.J. Thomas is an example–he was our “poster boy” for a few years. Then he made the “mistake” of saying that it was OK for Christians to sing secular music–and hoo, boy, did he get attacked! He eventually faded out of the evangelical scene–I hope he’s still a believer in Jesus, but I don’t know. I think that everyone scared him away. He wasn’t ready to take on the ministry of teaching.

I think a lot of evangelical Protestants would do well to simply “wait” and study and learn how to be Catholic before charging in to “fix up the lack of catechesis in the Catholic Church today, harumph harumph!”

If you think that the catechesis issue bothers Catholics, you should know what it does to evangelicals. It yanks our chain so badly that it causes us to doubt sometimes whether the Pope is a man or a mouse. We see so much wasted potential, so much that could be done. Honestly, more teaching went on in my evangelical churches in ONE YEAR than has happened in five years in the entire U.S.A. Catholic Church! It drives evangelicals totally nuts to see the sheer sitting around and doing nothing that we see in the Catholic Church. We want to start yelling, “Put that Rosary away and do some studying, people!”

Do you understand what I’m saying? I’ve tried to write this post to illustrate why you WOULDN’T want me teaching your Catholic children or teenagers, and why you would probably be hesitant to invite me to speak at your grown-up class! It’s just not a wise plan.

Certainly, there are exceptions. God has called some former evangelicals to be wonderful teachers in the Catholic Church. But I believe these people are the exception rather than the rule.
I am a protestant convert still in RCIA. Our RCIA classes sometimes bug me with the teacher being somewhat liberal saying things like Jesus didn’t know who he was. But in general, the teaching has been fairly good. It is definitely better and more substantial than what I got in my protestant churches.

Another thing is, catholics generally are more quiet than protestants. You won’t find them saying “Amen” even if they really like what they are hearing. But I actually like this aspect about catholics because they use their time more for listening and digesting than empty talking. So I wouldn’t say that a roomful of quiet catholics are just sitting there doing nothing.

And praying the Rosary. That, in my opinion, is better than all the protestant books and teaching put together. I don’t care how educated and eloquant and seeming inspiring protestants are, a Rosary will do a lot more in changing people’s interior lives.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top