Saint Cyprian and the Pope

  • Thread starter Thread starter MilesVitae
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

MilesVitae

Guest
I recently read Saint Cyprian’s On the Unity of the Church.

I am troubled, primarily, not so much by anything he claims as by what he does not claim. while arguing that there is one Church whom it is necessary to be in union with, he never mentions the necessity of union with the Bishop of Rome. He even mentions Peter and Christ’s words to him in Matthew 16 (“you are peter…”) and John 20 (“feed my sheep”) in connection with the unity of the Church, but then makes no mention of his successors.

If he believed in the papacy as Catholics do, why would he not mention it in this context? If I’m not mistaken, this essay was even written in regards to schismatic groups who had set up a false claimant to the chair of Rome - and yet, no mention of the successors of Peter…?
 
It is possible the Chair of Peter was vacant when St. Cyprian wrote this essay. It was written in 251, but the Chair was vacant until mid-March of that year (and had been vacant since January of the previous year). It would be kinda hard to make a persuasive case for needing to be in unity with the successor to Peter at a time when there was no such successor to be found. Even if St Cornelius had already been named Pope, Cyprian may have still felt that making such a claim would weaken his argument after such a long and recent Sede Vacante period - his critics might argue, “Hey, we didn’t have a Pope for more than a year - how important could this unity really be?” And they would have a point. Then Cyprian would have needed to explain why a vacant Chair does not diminish the need to be in union with the Church - it would be a distraction from the point he was trying to make, and bog the discussion down in theological details.

But I’m not convinced he overlooks the successors to Peter. St. Cyprian starts out describing the special authority of Peter, and then how the other Apostles gained authority. True, he never says, “Oh, and by the way, Pope Cornelius is Peter’s successor” (assuming he had been named). But he never says, “Oh, by the way, I happen to be one of the successors of the Apostles.” I think that, by establishing the authority of Peter and the Apostles, he implies that such authority extends to their successors - else, why even bring it up?

On a side note - St. Cyprian was nicknamed ‘The African Pope’ (Carthage being in Africa). Of course, he was never actually Pope; the nickname reflected the enormous influence he wielded.
 
It is possible the Chair of Peter was vacant when St. Cyprian wrote this essay. It was written in 251, but the Chair was vacant until mid-March of that year (and had been vacant since January of the previous year).
Where’d you find this info? Very detailed!
 
…If he believed in the papacy as Catholics do, why would he not mention it in this context? If I’m not mistaken, this essay was even written in regards to schismatic groups who had set up a false claimant to the chair of Rome - and yet, no mention of the successors of Peter…?
Sorry, but reading this, I had to chime in on a related topic. I see this type of false reasoning all the time. “why didn’t he mention it if it is true?” and then the person uses that lack of mention as a reason to NOT believe something that is supported elsewhere.

Someone not mentioning things could be for several reasons. Most often because they were speaking to a group which was already familiar with this point or concept, so it needed not to be mentioned, OR had already been covered, OR was incorrectly taken for granted by the writer, aka ‘assumed’

But there can be other reasons as well… we don’t know. Regardless, NOT mentioning something, does not in and of itself, prove anything.

At least so long as the person didn’t say something that directly contradicted or disproved the other belief/statement.

For example… so long as St. Cyprian didn’t contradict the belief in the Papacy or the “chair of St. Peter” or “the position of Peter” over the other Bishops… then his lack of specifically mentioning the position of Pope is not that important.

We can all say: “Man! he should have mentioned it directly” or “Wish he had spoken to this specific point” - but his omission doesn’t disprove or weaken the arguments for the Papacy one way or another.

In fact him arguing for UNION and throughout all of Christendom, the fact that the Catholic church has the most unity and owes this to a single leader, actually DOES argue strongly for the Primacy of Peter, even if Cyprian didn’t actually mention it.

Sorry to go off on this tangent.

But my point is… the fact that he didn’t mention it in terms WE can understand it today (as in using the word papacy) isn’t a very compelling reason to not believe it, in light of OTHER support for the idea.
As theists often times point out to Atheists: “A lack of proof is not proof that something doesn’t exist”

PLUS, why is doctrine set by St. Cyprian? He was a 3rd century Bishop… true, but not the only person to write about unity, leadership, tradition, etc. within the Church.
 
I got into a small debate with someone (the same person that I got into a debate about St. Irenaeus, those you read my last thread) about Cyprian belief in the Papacy, whic may help. I am going to start a little into the lettter, as well as took some thins out.

…

However, in order for the bishops to have the same binding and loosing authority as the Pope, they must be in union with him. The same for the apostles and Peter; the apostles have the same binding and loosing authority as Peter if they are in communion with him because Jesus gave Peter the power before the other apostles. Giving Peter the power first (as well as the keys to His kingdom) makes him the leader. You are just refuting yourself when you said Peter is just the symbol of unity because that is the main job of a leader (keeping and being the symbol of unity). That is exactly what Cyprian is talking about in his treatise on the Unity of the Church: Jesus gave the power to Peter first to establish unity, making him a leader. Other apostles are like Peter (have the authority to bind and loose) if they are in union with him:

The Lord speaks to Peter, saying, I say unto you, that you are Peter; and upon this rock I will build my Church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it. And I will give unto you the keys of the kingdom of heaven; and whatsoever you shall bind on earth shall be bound also in heaven, and whatsoever you shall loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven. And again to the same He says, after His resurrection, Feed my sheep. And although to all the apostles, after His resurrection, He gives an equal power, and says, As the Father has sent me, even so send I you: Receive the Holy Ghost: Whose soever sins you remit, they shall be remitted unto him; and whose soever sins you retain, they shall be retained; yet, that He might set forth unity, He arranged by His authority the origin of that unity, as beginning from one. Assuredly the rest of the apostles were also the same as was Peter, endowed with a like partnership both of honour and power; but the beginning proceeds from unity. Which one Church, also, the Holy Spirit in the Song of Songs designated in the person of our Lord, and says, “My dove, my spotless one, is but one. She is the only one of her mother, elect of her that bare her.” **Does he who does not hold this unity of the Church think that he holds the faith? ** (Treatise 1:4)

…

…It is clear that he believes the Bishop of Rome holds sits in Peter Chair because he said it in his writing about Cornelius succeeding Fabian in Peter Chair:

Cornelius was made bishop by the judgment of God and of His Christ, by the testimony of almost all the clergy, by the suffrage of the people who were then present, and by the assembly of ancient priests and good men, when no one had been made so before him, when the place of Fabian, that is, when the place of Peter and the degree of the sacerdotal throne was vacant; which being occupied by the will of God, and established by the consent of all of us, whosoever now wishes to become a bishop, must needs be made from without; and he cannot have the ordination of the Church who does not hold the unity of the Church. (Epistle 51: 8)

…

When Cyprian wrote to Pope Cornelius, he called the Church of Rome the root and matrix of the Catholic Church:

Some persons, however, sometimes disturb men’s minds and spirits by their words, in that they relate things otherwise than is the truth. For we, who furnish every person who sails hence with a plan that they may sail without any of-fence, know that we have exhorted them to acknowledge and hold the root and matrix of the Catholic Church. (Epistle 44:3)

That is the same language he used when talking about Peter. After saying that Jesus made Peter the source of unity in paragraph 4 of his Treatise on Unity (Treatise 1:4), he compared this source to light and roots in paragraph 5:

The Church also is one, which is spread abroad far and wide into a multitude by an increase of fruitfulness. As there are many rays of the sun, but one light; and many branches of a tree, but one strength based in its tenacious root; and since from one spring flow many streams, although the multiplicity seems diffused in the liberality of an overflowing abundance, yet the unity is still preserved in the source. Separate a ray of the sun from its body of light, its unity does not allow a division of light; break a branch from a tree—when broken, it will not be able to bud; cut off the stream from its fountain, and that which is cut off dries up. Thus also the Church, shone over with the light of the Lord, sheds forth her rays over the whole world, yet it is one light which is everywhere diffused, nor is the unity of the body separated. (Treatise 1: 5)

As rays gets its source from light and trees gets their source of strength from roots, so too the Jesus Christ establish His source of unity of the Church in Peter and his Chair. Where else did he call another church the root and matrix?

In another letter, Cyprian explicit tells us what he believe what the Roman Church is:

After such things as these, moreover, they still dare— a false bishop having been appointed for them by, heretics— to set sail and to bear letters from schismatic and profane persons to the throne of Peter, and to the chief church whence priestly unity takes its source; and not to consider that these were the Romans whose faith was praised in the preaching of the apostle, to whom faithlessness could have no access. (Epistle 54:14)

You already showed that Cyprian believe Peter is the symbol of unity. Why does he believe the Roman Church hold that source of unity if he believes all the bishops sit in Peter Chair? In what letter did Cyprian say other bishops hold that source of unity other than Rome?

…
 
(continue)

As far as the baptism controversy, it is (to me) one of the most interesting historical events to learn about the Church after the apostles. Cyprian comment about bishop of bishops was not talking about Pope Stephen. In context, he was talking about the African bishops at the synod. He was saying each bishop is giving their own opinion about heretical baptism because that synod is not binding like Nicea. However, the result of that council was sent to the Pope to seek his approval.

You also quoted letter 74. That letter was not written by Cyprian. It was written to him by Firmillian. If you read the letter in context, you will see that Firmillian did not believe Pope Stephen did not sit in Peter Chair because of his decision not to rebaptize heretics (BTW, thanks to MarcoPolo for giving a good explanation on this christianforums.com/t7233352/):🙂

But what is the greatness of his error, and what the depth of his blindness, who says that remission of sins can be granted in the synagogues of heretics, and does not abide on the foundation of the one Church which was once based by Christ upon the rock, may be perceived from this, that Christ said to Peter alone, Whatsoever you shall bind on earth shall be bound in heaven, and whatsoever you shall loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven. And again, in the Gospel, when Christ breathed on the apostles alone, saying, Receive the Holy Ghost: whose soever sins you remit they are remitted unto them, and whose soever sins you retain they are retained. Therefore the power of remitting sins was given to the apostles, and to the churches which they, sent by Christ, established, and to the bishops who succeeded to them by vicarious ordination. (74:16)

From what is said, Firmillian believe the remission of sin was given to the apostles, and that power was passed down to their successors (the bishops). Even though Pope Stephen agrees, he believes that power ultimately comes from the God and He can work through anybody (even heretics) if they use the proper baptism formula (the Trinitarian baptism). As a result, Firmillian questioned whether Stephen holds to the seat of Peter.

You also cited in that letter Firmillian believe Pop Stephen did not observe things that were handed down from the beginning (which represents Tradition). Well, Firmillian wasn’t either. He and other African bishops were only observing a tradition that did not stretch back to the beginning (the apostles). Rebaptizing heretics was a practice in Africa.

Seeing that rebaptizing heretics was not clear in Scripture and Tradition, Cyprian submitted to the authority of the Pope because of his belief that the Bishop of Rome sit in Peter Chair. You can tell by what Augustine said about Cyprian and him (African Bishop) practicing what Pope Stephen decided:

Do you share with us our unity; let us share with you your contrition and let charity cover the multitude of sins. Seek counsel from the blessed Cyprian himself. See how much he considered to depend upon the blessing of unity, from which he did not sever himself to avoid the communion of those who disagreed with him; how, though he considered that those who were baptized outside the communion of the Church had no true baptism, he was yet willing to believe that, by simple admission into the Church, they might, merely in virtue of the bond of unity, be admitted to a share in pardon. For thus he solved the question which he proposed to himself in writing as follows to Jubaianus: “But some will say, ‘What then will become of those who, in times past, coming to the Church from heresy, were admitted without baptism?’ The Lord is able of His mercy to grant pardon, and not to sever from the gifts of His Church those who, being out of simplicity admitted to the Church, have in the Church fallen asleep.” (Against Donatists, On Baptism 2: 13: 18)

Cease, then, to bring forward against us the authority of Cyprian in favor of repeating baptism, but cling with us to the example of Cyprian for the preservation of unity. For this question of baptism had not been as yet completely worked out, but yet the Church observed the most wholesome custom of correcting what was wrong, not repeating what was already given, even in the case of schismatics and heretics… (2: 7: 12)

Why did Cyprian practice what Pope Stephen declared if he believes Bishop of Rome did not hold primacy and him and other bishops sit in Peter Chair as well? If the Apostolic Tradition was so clear, why did Cyprian submitted to Pope Stephen decision if he strongly believes this teaching did not come from the apostles? Why were the African Bishops accepted the teaching they disputed, which you can clearly see in Augustine writings?

Cyprian disagreed with Pope Stephen, so. That doesn’t mean he didn’t believe the Bishop of Rome is not the leader. Cyprian wasn’t the first and not the last. People disagree with the president, but he is still the leader of the United States.
 
Where’d you find this info? Very detailed!
St Cyprian of Carthage is my favorite ECF. I have often cited his essay on Unity and knew from memory that it was written in 251. I also knew that that Cyprian was Bishop during a long *Sede Vacante. *On a hunch, I checked good ol’ WikiPedia and my hunch paid off.

I had heard this same argument before (but had never looked into the timeline). The version of Cyprian’s essay in the 39-volume collection of the writings of the Early Church Fathers by protestant editors Roberts & Schaff includes a footnote (#3105) (written by the editors) which says,
[Here note that our author’s *entire ignorance
of any Centre of Unity, of any one See as the test of communion; in short, of any one bishop as having more of Peter’s authority than others,—is a sufficient disproof of the existence of any such things. Otherwise, how could they have been overlooked in a treatise devoted to the subject of unity, its nature and its criteria?This particular collection, being out of copyright, is widely available in many forms. So this line of questioning is familiar to me.

Another Cyprian fun-fact: He ardently opposed the idea that heretical sects could administer valid Baptism (he was later overruled). In his writings, he would not even use the word “Baptism” in such a context - he said, “Those made wet by heretics.” I think that’s funny.
 
It is possible the Chair of Peter was vacant when St. Cyprian wrote this essay. It was written in 251, but the Chair was vacant until mid-March of that year (and had been vacant since January of the previous year). It would be kinda hard to make a persuasive case for needing to be in unity with the successor to Peter at a time when there was no such successor to be found. Even if St Cornelius had already been named Pope, Cyprian may have still felt that making such a claim would weaken his argument after such a long and recent Sede Vacante period - his critics might argue, “Hey, we didn’t have a Pope for more than a year - how important could this unity really be?” And they would have a point. Then Cyprian would have needed to explain why a vacant Chair does not diminish the need to be in union with the Church - it would be a distraction from the point he was trying to make, and bog the discussion down in theological details.

But I’m not convinced he overlooks the successors to Peter. St. Cyprian starts out describing the special authority of Peter, and then how the other Apostles gained authority. True, he never says, “Oh, and by the way, Pope Cornelius is Peter’s successor” (assuming he had been named). But he never says, “Oh, by the way, I happen to be one of the successors of the Apostles.” I think that, by establishing the authority of Peter and the Apostles, he implies that such authority extends to their successors - else, why even bring it up?
During Cyprian’s time, wasn’t the term “chair of Peter” used to refer to the sees of Rome, Alexandria, and Antioch together, rather than to that of Rome alone? Do you know from what point in history onward this term was used to refer to the see of Rome, and how widespread the practice was?
On a side note - St. Cyprian was nicknamed ‘The African Pope’ (Carthage being in Africa). Of course, he was never actually Pope; the nickname reflected the enormous influence he wielded.
Was this monicker given during Cyprian’s time or in later centuries? (I’ve read that the bishop of Alexandria was first given the title pope, a fact(?) offered as evidence that the bishop of Rome did not have authority in the early centuries of Christianity resembling that claimed today.)
 
During Cyprian’s time, wasn’t the term “chair of Peter” used to refer to the sees of Rome, Alexandria, and Antioch together, rather than to that of Rome alone? Do you know from what point in history onward this term was used to refer to the see of Rome, and how widespread the practice was?
I used the phrase “Chair of Peter” in its modern context to refer to the Bishop of the See of Rome. As far as I know, the actual concept of a “Chair” as a representation of the “seat of authority” of a Bishop did not come about until many centuries later. I have never heard that the representation was applied to the Pope (or the collective Bishops of Rome, Alexandria, and Antioch) during St. Cyprian’s lifetime.

As I have said, I based the timeline of my post on a Wikipedia list of Popes (ie, the Bishops of Rome in particular - the actual successors of St. Peter as Bishop of Rome). Regardless of what the term “Chair of Peter” might have meant to people of the time, this timeline establishes that the See of Rome in particular was vacant from January of 250 through March of 251 (owing in large measure to the Decian persecution, which had taken the life of (Pope) St. Fabian in January of 250 and had impeded the election of his successor for 15 months).

Cyprian wrote his essay on Church unity during a time of persecution, when the Office of the Bishop of Rome (to be more exact) either was vacant, or had recently been vacant for quite some time. Cyprian was writing to a hostile heretical audience - attempting to persuade them to rejoin the unity of the Church. The Office of the Bishop of Rome (the successor to St. Peter) was weak currency at the time (having been so recently overcome by pagan Rome), so he expressed his ideas in terms of the ultimate goal of unity with the Church of Christ (the ultimate point) without dwelling specifically upon the Office of Peter.
Was this monicker given during Cyprian’s time or in later centuries? (I’ve read that the bishop of Alexandria was first given the title pope, a fact(?) offered as evidence that the bishop of Rome did not have authority in the early centuries of Christianity resembling that claimed today.)
I don’t know. I do know that the title “pope” (from the Latin “papa”) was originally applied to many Bishops. It was not until about the Sixth Century that the title became reserved to the Bishop of Rome.
 
During Cyprian’s time, wasn’t the term “chair of Peter” used to refer to the sees of Rome, Alexandria, and Antioch together, rather than to that of Rome alone? Do you know from what point in history onward this term was used to refer to the see of Rome, and how widespread the practice?
It doesn’t seem like that if you read St. Cyprian letter 54:14. In there, not only he also said it is the chief principle unity and where unity takes it source. I have quoted from other parts of St. Cyprian writings in an earlier post in this thread that shows the Chair of Peter resides in Rome.

Although the early christians did not use the term explicitly, you can also see that early Christians also hold that the Chair of Peter resides in Rome. For example, St. Irenaeus in Against Heresy 3:3:2-3, he said Rome holds pre-emanate authority and every Church should follow the Roman Church. He went on to list Peter successors (all Roman Bishops).
 
I recently read Saint Cyprian’s On the Unity of the Church.

I am troubled, primarily, not so much by anything he claims as by what he does not claim. while arguing that there is one Church whom it is necessary to be in union with, he never mentions the necessity of union with the Bishop of Rome. He even mentions Peter and Christ’s words to him in Matthew 16 (“you are peter…”) and John 20 (“feed my sheep”) in connection with the unity of the Church, but then makes no mention of his successors.

If he believed in the papacy as Catholics do, why would he not mention it in this context? If I’m not mistaken, this essay was even written in regards to schismatic groups who had set up a false claimant to the chair of Rome - and yet, no mention of the successors of Peter…?
I believe he was referring to his own authority as a successor of Peter.

No, he was not claiming to be a rival ‘Pope’, he was claiming to be a successor of Peter because he was the legitimate church. He was the head of the synod in that part of the world.
 
However, in order for the bishops to have the same binding and loosing authority as the Pope, they must be in union with him. The same for the apostles and Peter; the apostles have the same binding and loosing authority as Peter if they are in communion with him because Jesus gave Peter the power before the other apostles. Giving Peter the power first (as well as the keys to His kingdom) makes him the leader. You are just refuting yourself when you said Peter is just the symbol of unity because that is the main job of a leader (keeping and being the symbol of unity). That is exactly what Cyprian is talking about in his treatise on the Unity of the Church: Jesus gave the power to Peter first to establish unity, making him a leader. Other apostles are like Peter (have the authority to bind and loose) if they are in union with him:
The Lord speaks to Peter, saying, I say unto you, that you are Peter; and upon this rock I will build my Church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it. And I will give unto you the keys of the kingdom of heaven; and whatsoever you shall bind on earth shall be bound also in heaven, and whatsoever you shall loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven. And again to the same He says, after His resurrection, Feed my sheep. And although to all the apostles, after His resurrection, He gives an equal power, and says, As the Father has sent me, even so send I you: Receive the Holy Ghost: Whose soever sins you remit, they shall be remitted unto him; and whose soever sins you retain, they shall be retained; yet, that He might set forth unity, He arranged by His authority the origin of that unity, as beginning from one. Assuredly the rest of the apostles were also the same as was Peter, endowed with a like partnership both of honour and power; but the beginning proceeds from unity. Which one Church, also, the Holy Spirit in the Song of Songs designated in the person of our Lord, and says, “My dove, my spotless one, is but one. She is the only one of her mother, elect of her that bare her.” **Does he who does not hold this unity of the Church think that he holds the faith? ** (Treatise 1:4)
Doesn’t Cyprian say the other Apostles have an equal power?
Cyprian doesn’t say the Apostles must be in union specifically with Peter to have the same authority as him. I find this passage very frustrating because I cannot understand Cyprian’s language. What does the phrase “the beginning proceeds from unity” even mean, or “the origin of that unity, as beginning from one”? I’ve always found these phrases unclear.
When Cyprian wrote to Pope Cornelius, he called the Church of Rome the root and matrix of the Catholic Church:
Some persons, however, sometimes disturb men’s minds and spirits by their words, in that they relate things otherwise than is the truth. For we, who furnish every person who sails hence with a plan that they may sail without any of-fence, know that we have exhorted them to acknowledge and hold the root and matrix of the Catholic Church. (Epistle 44:3)
That is the same language he used when talking about Peter. After saying that Jesus made Peter the source of unity in paragraph 4 of his Treatise on Unity (Treatise 1:4), he compared this source to light and roots in paragraph 5:
The Church also is one, which is spread abroad far and wide into a multitude by an increase of fruitfulness. As there are many rays of the sun, but one light; and many branches of a tree, but one strength based in its tenacious root; and since from one spring flow many streams, although the multiplicity seems diffused in the liberality of an overflowing abundance, yet the unity is still preserved in the source. Separate a ray of the sun from its body of light, its unity does not allow a division of light; break a branch from a tree—when broken, it will not be able to bud; cut off the stream from its fountain, and that which is cut off dries up. Thus also the Church, shone over with the light of the Lord, sheds forth her rays over the whole world, yet it is one light which is everywhere diffused, nor is the unity of the body separated. (Treatise 1: 5)
As rays gets its source from light and trees gets their source of strength from roots, so too the Jesus Christ establish His source of unity of the Church in Peter and his Chair. Where else did he call another church the root and matrix?
First of all, he did not call Peter the root. Rather, it seems to be the Church itself which he is calling the sun, the root, the spring, etc.
Cyprian’s meaning in calling the Church at Rome the “root and matrix” is unclear, although it strongly suggests what you make it out to mean.
 
(continued)
In another letter, Cyprian explicit tells us what he believe what the Roman Church is:
After such things as these, moreover, they still dare— a false bishop having been appointed for them by, heretics— to set sail and to bear letters from schismatic and profane persons to the throne of Peter, and to the chief church whence priestly unity takes its source; and not to consider that these were the Romans whose faith was praised in the preaching of the apostle, to whom faithlessness could have no access. (Epistle 54:14)
I have seen several translations of this.

"Post ista adhuc pseudoepiscopo sibi ab haereticis constituto nauigare audent, et ad Petri Cathedram adque ad ecclesiam principalem unde unitas sacerdotalis exorta est ab schismaticis et profanis litteras ferre, nec cogitare eos esse Romanos, quorum fides Apostolo praedicante laudata est, ad quos perfidia habere non possit accessum

(After all this, they yet in addition, having had a false bishop ordained for them by heretics, dare to set sail, and to carry letters from schismatic and profane persons to the chair of Peter, and to the principal church, whence the unity of the priesthood [sacerdotal unity] took its rise [or has its source]. They fail to reflect that those Romans are the same as those whose faith was publicly praised by the apostle, to whom unbelief [or error, heresy, perversion of faith] cannot have access. Epistle 59:14; Giles, page 60)"
philvaz.com/apologetics/num44.htm

Is the source of priestly unity in Rome in a active, current sense? Or does he merely mean that the past origin of priestly unity (Peter?) was in Rome? I’m not very good with Latin, and the phrase I’m having trouble with is “exorta est.”
You already showed that Cyprian believe Peter is the symbol of unity. Why does he believe the Roman Church hold that source of unity if he believes all the bishops sit in Peter Chair? In what letter did Cyprian say other bishops hold that source of unity other than Rome?
The notion that all Bishops hold the chair of Peter is compatible with Catholic papal beliefs. Jesus refers to the priest-rabbis holding the chair of Moses - there was, none the less, one high priest. One can say that all Bishops sit in the Chair of Peter, while still maintaining that one bishop sits in the chair in a central, primal, supreme way.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top