This is a great discussion, for me anyways…James, you are so spot on, which leads me back to the point that originally grabbed my attention: love as a state of being, vs. an act of will. You point out that it essentially all boils down to love for the creator and His creatures…love will cover a multitude of sins; but does an act of will lead to the state of being (love)? Is one greater than another? Or have I entirely missed the point altogether? I wonder if those well-versed in Aquinas would have insight on this?
I don’t know about Aquinas - he is too deep for me. :hypno:
But essentially - as I see it - If we are called to be perfect as our heavenly Father is perfect and our Heavenly Father IS Love…then what are we called to be?
Choosing heaven or hell really boils down to choosing to embrace either love or hate.
Now we can say that there are gray areas, where we neither hate totally or love totally, but what do we want to become?
As to the question of an act of will becoming a state of being…I would suggest we consider someone like a soldier. First he chooses to become a soldier - but he is not one yet, except in his desire and determination. He goes to training and over time, trough discipline and sacrifice, he becomes what he has chosen. His thoughts and his reactions are geared to specific responses to various situations.
OR
Consider to the professional baseball player. He “chose” to be a ball player at a young age but he was not yet a ball player. Through years of practice and sacrifice he becomes that which he has chosen. It is seen in his actions on the field.
In both of the examples above, the choice is seen in how they think and move and most importantly how they react.
For the Christian, choosing to be a disciple of Christ - Choosing Love is the same. We must train, we must condition ourselves, we must
“become” that which we have chosen. In Christianity we call this “sanctification”.
It’s not something we put on to “cover sin” but something we embrace to overcome sin.
Hope this helps a little.
Peace
James