Santorum: GOP needs to talk more about values

  • Thread starter Thread starter The_Rock
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I don’t think Rick Santorum is very in line with Catholic teaching in terms of war. Just war doctrine? Is our military spending very Catholic? Rick Santorum said in one of the debates that we shouldn’t remove a single penny from military spending. He said that it’s because the federal government is the only branch that has any military power. Are we using all those pennies well?

What about the death penalty? I only have this: issues2000.org/senate/Rick_Santorum.htm I don’t know how his positions have changed.

From what I understand, we, as Catholics, should only support the death penalty if it is absolutely the only possible answer. And in the US, the courts are way too broken to justify the death penalty.

I definitely like that he protects the unborn and marriage. I think he is a good pro-life role model. I hadn’t heard the story about his wife–that’s amazing.

There is a candidate who is pro-life, pro-just war doctrine, and anti-death penalty. He thinks the government should do less, not that PEOPLE should do less. He is not Catholic, but he strikes me as more Catholic than Rick Santorum. He has my support and my vote.
 
What about the death penalty? I only have this: issues2000.org/senate/Rick_Santorum.htm I don’t know how his positions have changed.

From what I understand, we, as Catholics, should only support the death penalty if it is absolutely the only possible answer. And in the US, the courts are way too broken to justify the death penalty.
Santorum rethinks death penalty stance
Tuesday, March 22, 2005
By Ann Rodgers, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
post-gazette.com/pg/05081/475366.stm#ixzz1dB1mu1JE
“I agree with the pope that in the civilized world … the application of the death penalty should be limited. I would definitely agree with that. I would certainly suggest there probably should be some further limits on what we use it for…
I never thought about it that much when I was really a supporter of the death penalty. I still see it as potentially valuable, but I would be one to urge more caution than I would have in the past”
Born into a family of police officers, he said, “support for the death penalty was part of growing up.”
Later, he said, “I was moved by the call of Pope John Paul II to be unconditionally pro-life.”
 
I don’t think Rick Santorum is very in line with Catholic teaching in terms of war. Just war doctrine? Is our military spending very Catholic? Rick Santorum said in one of the debates that we shouldn’t remove a single penny from military spending. He said that it’s because the federal government is the only branch that has any military power. Are we using all those pennies well?
Is our military spending Catholic? What would catholic military spending look like? Please explain, as distinct from foreign policy.
What about the death penalty? I only have this: issues2000.org/senate/Rick_Santorum.htm I don’t know how his positions have changed.

From what I understand, we, as Catholics, should only support the death penalty if it is absolutely the only possible answer. And in the US, the courts are way too broken to justify the death penalty.
Please tell me where it says in the catechism that good catholics can’t support the death penalty? Or that good catholics are forbidden from voting for a candidate who supports the death penalty. Is it one of the non-negotiables like abortion?
There is a candidate who is pro-life, pro-just war doctrine, and anti-death penalty. He thinks the government should do less, not that PEOPLE should do less. He is not Catholic, but he strikes me as more Catholic than Rick Santorum. He has my support and my vote.
I give up, you’re for Ron Paul? I can understand your frustration with the regular candidates, but I don’t think Ron Paul is the answer to ending Obama policies as Paul has no chance to win. His appeal is too narrow. And I would sure hate for the anti-catholic policies of the Obama administration to be allowed to continue for another four years because too many “true believer” catholics wasted their votes on a protest candidate out of a misplaced desire to vote “pure” catholic.

Ishii
 
Ishii: I like the signature. 😃
Thank you, Swiss Guy. I think it captures the difference between the Democrat party of today with that of the yesterday. Other than fear, the Democrat party offers up the secular leftist social agenda, higher taxes, and more spending too.

Ishii
 
I agree there’s a need for someone in the spotlight to discuss issues of morality.

Thank God we have His Holiness Benedict XVI.

I, for one, will not engage in Statolatry by waiting on some politician to be the white knight marshaling all the forces of righteousness behind him. If one could achieve salvation by the law and machinations of mankind then we would not require Christ.

That being said, Rick Santorum would certainly make a better president than a majority of the Republican field and, of course, President Obama. I would be happy to vote for him.

Though, I can’t help but think he would be more good on the streets in a Public Square Rosary Rally.
 
I agree there’s a need for someone in the spotlight to discuss issues of morality.

Thank God we have His Holiness Benedict XVI.

I, for one, will not engage in Statolatry by waiting on some politician to be the white knight marshaling all the forces of righteousness behind him. If one could achieve salvation by the law and machinations of mankind then we would not require Christ.

That being said, Rick Santorum would certainly make a better president than a majority of the Republican field and, of course, President Obama. I would be happy to vote for him.

Though, I can’t help but think he would be more good on the streets in a Public Square Rosary Rally.
Well said, ExLibris. But one does not engage in statolatry when working within our system to help reform our laws so they better reflect right reason and Catholic social teaching. We must work within our system while keeping our eyes on the real goal which lies on the other side of this life. I think there are people - within the Catholic church - who have allowed themselves to become obsessed with using politics as a means to build a heaven on earth.

Ishii
 
TheRock: Thank you. I appreciate it. 👍
Is our military spending Catholic? What would catholic military spending look like? Please explain, as distinct from foreign policy.

Please tell me where it says in the catechism that good catholics can’t support the death penalty? Or that good catholics are forbidden from voting for a candidate who supports the death penalty. Is it one of the non-negotiables like abortion?

I give up, you’re for Ron Paul? I can understand your frustration with the regular candidates, but I don’t think Ron Paul is the answer to ending Obama policies as Paul has no chance to win. His appeal is too narrow. And I would sure hate for the anti-catholic policies of the Obama administration to be allowed to continue for another four years because too many “true believer” catholics wasted their votes on a protest candidate out of a misplaced desire to vote “pure” catholic. What? Wasted votes? When? And since when is a desire to vote “pure” Catholic misplaced?

Ishii
Military spending that doesn’t involve unnecessary wars and unnecessary killing of innocent human beings is definitely a step in the right direction.
2267 Assuming that the guilty party’s identity and responsibility have been fully determined, the traditional teaching of the Church does not exclude recourse to the death penalty, if this is the only possible way of effectively defending human lives against the unjust aggressor.
If, however, non-lethal means are sufficient to defend and protect people’s safety from the aggressor, authority will limit itself to such means, as these are more in keeping with the concrete conditions of the common good and more in conformity to the dignity of the human person.
Today, in fact, as a consequence of the possibilities which the state has for effectively preventing crime, by rendering one who has committed an offense incapable of doing harm - without definitely taking away from him the possibility of redeeming himself - the cases in which the execution of the offender is an absolute necessity “are very rare, if not practically nonexistent.”
Does that work? The way the US justice system operates is not in line with that. If I can choose someone who is anti-abortion who is also anti-death penalty, I’ll go with him.

Yes, I support Ron Paul, and I respectfully disagree with your assessment that he cannot win. Overall, I don’t understand what you’re saying. I shouldn’t vote for Ron Paul in the primaries? I should vote for Rick Santorum, who is showing even less success in the polls? Ron Paul will not run 3rd party in the general election, as he said on Fox News Sunday last weekend. I will give him my full support until the GOP chooses a candidate. Also, I don’t agree with your voting morality. Should I vote for evil just because evil is likely to win? Thank you for basically saying that a vote for Ron Paul is as good as a vote for Barack Obama. If that’s the case, based on his popularity, a vote for Rick Santorum is even more of a vote for Barack Obama.

I am Catholic, in the sense that I believe in and worship God according to the teachings of the Catholic Church, before I am an American, a conservative, a Constitutionalist, or anything else of that sort. The most important decisions I make are the ones that keep me walking closely with the Lord. And that is why I support Ron Paul for the GOP candidacy and for president.
 
I don’t think Rick Santorum is very in line with Catholic teaching in terms of war. Just war doctrine? Is our military spending very Catholic? Rick Santorum said in one of the debates that we shouldn’t remove a single penny from military spending. He said that it’s because the federal government is the only branch that has any military power. Are we using all those pennies well?

What about the death penalty? I only have this: issues2000.org/senate/Rick_Santorum.htm I don’t know how his positions have changed.

From what I understand, we, as Catholics, should only support the death penalty if it is absolutely the only possible answer. And in the US, the courts are way too broken to justify the death penalty.

I definitely like that he protects the unborn and marriage. I think he is a good pro-life role model. I hadn’t heard the story about his wife–that’s amazing.

There is a candidate who is pro-life, pro-just war doctrine, and anti-death penalty. He thinks the government should do less, not that PEOPLE should do less. He is not Catholic, but he strikes me as more Catholic than Rick Santorum. He has my support and my vote.
Santorum feels the USA should be strong militarily and that is wrong how?

As for the death penalty, here is one of his statements: “I agree with the pope that in the civilized world … the application of the death penalty should be limited. I would definitely agree with that. I would certainly suggest there probably should be some further limits on what we use it for.”

Santorum is for smaller government, less taxes, and a more robust free economy.

He is also very strongly pro-life and very strongly supports traditional marriage.
 
Military spending that doesn’t involve unnecessary wars and unnecessary killing of innocent human beings is definitely a step in the right direction.
You’re confusing military spending with foreign policy. Military spending concerns what weapons should we research and develop, whereas foreign policy concerns whether we should go to war, pursue diplomacy and the like. With regard to foreign policy, I would say a naive, childish approach to foreign policy such as Ron Paul approaches with Iran is the height of irresponsibility, although I realize it might make some *feel *good.

youtube.com/watch?v=7W8MDjU2zgk
Does that work? The way the US justice system operates is not in line with that. If I can choose someone who is anti-abortion who is also anti-death penalty, I’ll go with him.
Fine. But show me where it says good catholics can’t also support the death penalty. Also, please not Santorum’s change of heart on the matter.
Yes, I support Ron Paul, and I respectfully disagree with your assessment that he cannot win. Overall, I don’t understand what you’re saying. I shouldn’t vote for Ron Paul in the primaries? I should vote for Rick Santorum, who is showing even less success in the polls? Ron Paul will not run 3rd party in the general election, as he said on Fox News Sunday last weekend. I will give him my full support until the GOP chooses a candidate. Also, I don’t agree with your voting morality. Should I vote for evil just because evil is likely to win? Thank you for basically saying that a vote for Ron Paul is as good as a vote for Barack Obama. If that’s the case, based on his popularity, a vote for Rick Santorum is even more of a vote for Barack Obama.
You’re welcome. And thank you for saying that a vote for someone other than Ron Paul is a vote for “evil”. My voting “morality” (as you call it) takes into account reality. I know that Ron Paul has no chance of getting the nomination (wouldn’t support him if he did). Btw, where did I say I was voting for Santorum? I like the guy but he has not demonstrated an ability to get beyond single digits. I want someone who can end Obama’s anti-catholic policies.
I am Catholic, in the sense that I believe in and worship God according to the teachings of the Catholic Church, before I am an American, a conservative, a Constitutionalist, or anything else of that sort. The most important decisions I make are the ones that keep me walking closely with the Lord. And that is why I support Ron Paul for the GOP candidacy and for president.
Hoo-rah. Vote for the 100% pure catholic authorized candidate (in your mind) and don’t complain when we get four more years of Obama. Btw, is Ron Paul in line with Church teaching on legalization of prostitution? Drugs?

Ishii
 
Thank you, Swiss Guy. I think it captures the difference between the Democrat party of today with that of the yesterday. Other than fear, the Democrat party offers up the secular leftist social agenda, higher taxes, and more spending too.

Ishii
It’s a shame what those rich secularists in the 60’s made the party become. 😦

I think Mark Stricherz wrote a book about that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top