F
FaustinaJulia
Guest
I love animals more than people it seems at times. However, over the years I learned to accept and understand the limitations and not expect a human response from a dog, for instance. For instance, I had a dog which had been given to me by someone that I was in love with. We raised the dog together and the relationship went south fast. However, the dog loved both of us even though he was technically mine.
As things got worse and worse between my boyfriend (who I was living with and could not leave at the time) and I, with a very volatile situation between us, it would have seemed natural to take it as a betrayal to see my dog not taking sides and apparently still loving the bf as much as before despite his treatment of me. However, in dog terms, we were all packmates and since both of us were higher ranking then him, he wasn’t going to “choose sides”. Perfectly normal, doggie logic.
As a matter of fact, I was very happy to see how much the BF cared about my dog since “accidents” could happen to a trusting animal very easily and if he had done something to require disciplining, and what dog doesn’t, I may have had to worry that he’d be mistreated. All of this, however really brought forward just how different a dog’s view of the world is from a human’s. The limitations are obvious and many times are part of why someone would feel affectionate towards such a creature.
I saw this dog make decisions every day and choose to act a certain way even when the rewards for doing something another way was potentially just as great. That is a sort of free will. I’ve never doubted that they had a level of free will just as I’ve never doubted that humans had a certain amount of instinctual responses which cause a greater tendency to “knee jerk response” to varying degrees in human beings. You also have to take into account the objective age which certain animals are capable of achieving in human development terms.
None of the ages an animal has been found to achieve have been anywhere near the age of reason. I think that is why an animal can have a sort of free will (within his capability) and be far more complex yet is still limited. Logically, the same would have to be true of an animal’s soul with some far more advanced then others but none truly to the level of a human soul. But as others have said here in so many words, Praise God for His wonders of all sorts from mountains to monkeys, from flowers to fawns, from magnificent dawns to devoted dogs!
As things got worse and worse between my boyfriend (who I was living with and could not leave at the time) and I, with a very volatile situation between us, it would have seemed natural to take it as a betrayal to see my dog not taking sides and apparently still loving the bf as much as before despite his treatment of me. However, in dog terms, we were all packmates and since both of us were higher ranking then him, he wasn’t going to “choose sides”. Perfectly normal, doggie logic.
As a matter of fact, I was very happy to see how much the BF cared about my dog since “accidents” could happen to a trusting animal very easily and if he had done something to require disciplining, and what dog doesn’t, I may have had to worry that he’d be mistreated. All of this, however really brought forward just how different a dog’s view of the world is from a human’s. The limitations are obvious and many times are part of why someone would feel affectionate towards such a creature.
I saw this dog make decisions every day and choose to act a certain way even when the rewards for doing something another way was potentially just as great. That is a sort of free will. I’ve never doubted that they had a level of free will just as I’ve never doubted that humans had a certain amount of instinctual responses which cause a greater tendency to “knee jerk response” to varying degrees in human beings. You also have to take into account the objective age which certain animals are capable of achieving in human development terms.
None of the ages an animal has been found to achieve have been anywhere near the age of reason. I think that is why an animal can have a sort of free will (within his capability) and be far more complex yet is still limited. Logically, the same would have to be true of an animal’s soul with some far more advanced then others but none truly to the level of a human soul. But as others have said here in so many words, Praise God for His wonders of all sorts from mountains to monkeys, from flowers to fawns, from magnificent dawns to devoted dogs!