Scientists Give Animals Consciousness

  • Thread starter Thread starter cornbread_r2
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I love animals more than people it seems at times. However, over the years I learned to accept and understand the limitations and not expect a human response from a dog, for instance. For instance, I had a dog which had been given to me by someone that I was in love with. We raised the dog together and the relationship went south fast. However, the dog loved both of us even though he was technically mine.

As things got worse and worse between my boyfriend (who I was living with and could not leave at the time) and I, with a very volatile situation between us, it would have seemed natural to take it as a betrayal to see my dog not taking sides and apparently still loving the bf as much as before despite his treatment of me. However, in dog terms, we were all packmates and since both of us were higher ranking then him, he wasn’t going to “choose sides”. Perfectly normal, doggie logic.

As a matter of fact, I was very happy to see how much the BF cared about my dog since “accidents” could happen to a trusting animal very easily and if he had done something to require disciplining, and what dog doesn’t, I may have had to worry that he’d be mistreated. All of this, however really brought forward just how different a dog’s view of the world is from a human’s. The limitations are obvious and many times are part of why someone would feel affectionate towards such a creature.

I saw this dog make decisions every day and choose to act a certain way even when the rewards for doing something another way was potentially just as great. That is a sort of free will. I’ve never doubted that they had a level of free will just as I’ve never doubted that humans had a certain amount of instinctual responses which cause a greater tendency to “knee jerk response” to varying degrees in human beings. You also have to take into account the objective age which certain animals are capable of achieving in human development terms.

None of the ages an animal has been found to achieve have been anywhere near the age of reason. I think that is why an animal can have a sort of free will (within his capability) and be far more complex yet is still limited. Logically, the same would have to be true of an animal’s soul with some far more advanced then others but none truly to the level of a human soul. But as others have said here in so many words, Praise God for His wonders of all sorts from mountains to monkeys, from flowers to fawns, from magnificent dawns to devoted dogs! 👍
 
I saw this article a while ago. This is non-news and makes people wonder about all the money that’s going into research… is this what they’re doing all day? Can’t they do something a little more productive? I hope they do.
What worries me is the agenda of the euthanasia promoters. If its AOK to put down a cat, whats the big deal about “putting down” a human? They already say that, so will this “discovery” further their “cause”?
P Singer…:eek:

Let `em try to prove that animals have “abstract” thoughts: concepts, contemplation, self-awareness…
 

For some interpreters, the real issue is that the concept of a spiritual rational soul is no longer viable. This is because both humans and non-human animals are doing the same thing regarding highly complex tasks. Or since consciousness and/or sentience is found in both humans and non-human animals, from a natural science position, both are equal species.
That’s what I was afraid of.
 
I think it’s important to have our intuitions confirmed, or not, by actual data.
Your statement really gets to the heart why the declaration is significant. The scientists are offering a physical explanation of the behaviors which so many ordinary people have already observed.

As a way of comparison, Isaac Newton didn’t discover gravity. People were well aware of its practical effects. What he did was explain why gravity worked as it did.

Or as another comparison, the practical use of inoculation as a protection against smallpox was understood centuries before the germ theory of disease was discovered. That inoculation worked was accepted, but the reason why was unclear until science could explain it.

The neuroscientists in this declaration are saying that they now understand the “why” of certain animal behaviors.
 
What worries me is the agenda of the euthanasia promoters. If its AOK to put down a cat, whats the big deal about “putting down” a human? They already say that, so will this “discovery” further their “cause”?
P Singer…:eek:
Some interpreters will see this as beneficial to their cause. Why not?
Let `em try to prove that animals have “abstract” thoughts: concepts, contemplation, self-awareness…
This is a very good point. Nonetheless, in some sections of 21st century science, interpreters are shifting from animals to humans. For example, some interpreters consider “thinking” in relationship to an emerging cultural awareness and not part of the intellective faculties of the individual spiritual soul.
 
Unless black holes are on the list, I fail to see why Dr. Hawkings presence has anything to do with this.
 
Your cat recognized itself in the mirror? That ability would be unique among cats or dogs. (Didn’t you mention this a while back? It sounds familiar to me.) However, as I stated, birds have been found to have mirror recognition.
He certainly reacted differently to itself in a mirror than he did to other cats.
 
Your statement really gets to the heart why the declaration is significant. The scientists are offering a physical explanation of the behaviors which so many ordinary people have already observed.

As a way of comparison, Isaac Newton didn’t discover gravity. People were well aware of its practical effects. What he did was explain why gravity worked as it did.

Or as another comparison, the practical use of inoculation as a protection against smallpox was understood centuries before the germ theory of disease was discovered. That inoculation worked was accepted, but the reason why was unclear until science could explain it.

The neuroscientists in this declaration are saying that they now understand the “why” of certain animal behaviors.
Exactly. And I might add this is NOT part of some nefarious plot on the part of neuroscientists, comparative psychologists, and ethologists–at least not the ones I know who study animal cognition–to undermine the uniqueness of humans in an attempt to get rid of the need for the human soul and ultimately prove that all religion as well as the existence of G-d is false.
 
He certainly reacted differently to itself in a mirror than he did to other cats.
I believe you mentioned your cat didn’t react at all when he saw himself. This would be because he didn’t recognize his reflection in the mirror as being that of either himself or another cat.
 
For some of the uninformed, this wasn’t a study. It was a scientific declaration.

We may think it’s common sense, but you should realise there are a lot of people who think animals are nothing but robots. I imagine some of you would have lampooned Newton when he defined gravity too.

Anyway, nobody is suggesting that animals have an immortal soul, so there’s no need to be alarmed. 🙂
 
When scientists take the next logical step from this info and actually give the same courtesies and rights they extend to animals to children, this will impress me.
 
Anyone who claims to have already known the findings cited in the article based on the observations of their pets would, IMO, be mistaken, unless they had a pet octopus, elephant, whale, parrot, dolphin or any of the other animals cited. The conclusions re: this level of consciousness, as defined by the researchers, did not apply to all animals and probably not even to all species within the same genus. Interestingly, and probably not coincidentally, most of the species cited are social animals which may give us a clue as to why they’re so different from my dog Sweatpea.
Some interpreters will see this as beneficial to their cause. Why not?

This is a very good point. Nonetheless, in some sections of 21st century science, interpreters are shifting from animals to humans. For example, some interpreters consider “thinking” in relationship to an emerging cultural awareness and not part of the intellective faculties of the individual spiritual soul.
If researchers find abilities in certain non-human animals which were at one time thought to be unique to humans, the conclusion that (at least) those abilities * are * emergent properties resulting from natural processes and not supernatural intervention intended for humans only seems inevitable.

I’m confident that theologians can continue to define the soul in such a way as to make it perpetually immune from scientific investigation, but in the process it would seem that they’re also going to have to explain exactly what they mean by “intellective faculties of the individual soul”. Do those faculties include self-recognition? Elephants and other species seem to demonstrate that ability too. Do they include superior memory? Some apes outperform humans in some memory tests. Do they include the ability to recognize consciousness in others? Some non-human animals also seem to demonstrate that ability by planning ahead in anticipation of another animal’s assumed state of mind. If those abilities aren’t unique to humans, then what “intellective faculties” are we talking about?

Barring some astounding future discovery, non-human animals will never be considered to be our intellectual equals, but they don’t have to considered equals if this type of research makes people think twice about chaining an elephant to a tree while they beat it into submission.
 
cornbread_r2:
I’m confident that theologians can continue to define the soul in such a way as to make it perpetually immune from scientific investigation, but in the process it would seem that they’re also going to have to explain exactly what they mean by “intellective faculties of the individual soul”. Do those faculties include self-recognition? Elephants and other species seem to demonstrate that ability too. Do they include superior memory? Some apes outperform humans in some memory tests. Do they include the ability to recognize consciousness in others? Some non-human animals also seem to demonstrate that ability by planning ahead in anticipation of another animal’s assumed state of mind. If those abilities aren’t unique to humans, then what “intellective faculties” are we talking about?
None of the things you listed fall under the unique functions of the “rational soul”, from a Catholic perspective at least. Memory is not strictly a function of rationality, self-recognition certainly is not, and basic emotion has pretty much always been regarded as coming from the “animal” level of humans. These are all artificial “boundaries” between animals and humans that were erected by material scientists, not theologians, and now they’re being demolished by material scientists as well.

Rationality, in Catholic thinking, involves the ability to work with concepts and not just physical information. Humans don’t just recognize circles, we have a concept of “circular”. We apply these concepts to things that don’t directly relate to our physical experiences of the objects we receive them from. For example, if I say “the circle of time” you likely immediately have the concept of a time loop, or repeating pattern of time, yet this idea has no matching physical experience, and both “time” and “circle” are unrelated concepts. Our ability to take physical experiences, abstract them into ideas, and recombine these ideas into new concepts is the indication of an immaterial soul that works beyond the boundaries of physical experience. Our immaterial soul is certainly tied to physical experience, as we come to our concepts through our physical senses, but it is not limited by physical experience.

With this in mind it is easy to see how animals are conscious in Catholic thought. They have unique experiences and emotions, they can recognize things, they can even place “balls” with “balls” and “blocks” with “blocks” based on physical features. These are all traits of the physical brain, not the immaterial mind. When a chimpanzee composes a poem about a long-wilted flower that exists only in the memory, and uses that image as a metaphor for lost youth, then we will have some evidence of an immaterial mind at work. If the chimpanzee simply remembers which box the flower was placed in a week later, all we have is evidence of retention of physical experience. That some animals may be better than humans at such retention and application isn’t all that surprising, any more than dogs being better at smelling, and dolphins being better at swimming. 🙂

Incidentally, these things were already believed and understood by the likes of Aquinas almost a thousand years ago. That matter has “emergent properties” is a very, very old Catholic philosophical belief, and has not interfered with the distinction between material and immaterial souls in the least.

Peace and God bless!
 
Um, duh! I have been a long time pet owner, and I can say most of my pets have a larger range of emotions than some humans I’ve met.
My cat, Butters, is one of the most amazing creatures I’ve even seen. He will love on you when your good to him, but if you tease him too much he will find an item that belongs to you and pee on it to show he is mad.
 
OK, so we now have science agreeing that animals can think…

That they are arriving at this point in 2012 says a lot of the scientists involved.

And I am not so certain it is all good.
 
When scientists take the next logical step from this info and actually give the same courtesies and rights they extend to animals to children, this will impress me.
ASPA, around 1890, backed the first guilty verdict for child abuse. 👍:tiphat::hmmm:
 
The scientists are not telling me any thing new. They have not ran into Nicky (a100 lb + akita) and the ‘devil kitten’ (no fear). ::whacky::bowdown2::yukonjoe::onpatrol:
 
Um, duh! I have been a long time pet owner, and I can say most of my pets have a larger range of emotions than some humans I’ve met.
My cat, Butters, is one of the most amazing creatures I’ve even seen. He will love on you when your good to him, but if you tease him too much he will find an item that belongs to you and pee on it to show he is mad.
I think you are shortchanging humans. I know some who do exactly the same thing as your cat.
 
Exactly. And I might add this is NOT part of some nefarious plot on the part of neuroscientists, comparative psychologists, and ethologists–at least not the ones I know who study animal cognition–to undermine the uniqueness of humans in an attempt to get rid of the need for the human soul and ultimately prove that all religion as well as the existence of G-d is false.
nefarious plot?

Please. please take notice of my terminology in bold.

“For example, some interpreters consider “thinking” in relationship to an emerging cultural awareness and not part of the intellective faculties of the individual spiritual soul.” Interpreters are not always the same as the authors of a paper. Nick Clairmont the author of the linked article acts as an interpreter.

I have had access to some of the actual research papers, including animal cognition. I deeply respect the honesty and dedication of the scientists who gave a great deal of time to these projects. And I read the fine print.
Furthermore, please PM me with the citations and links if possible for the published work of the people you know.

The actual Cambridge Declaration on Consciousness linked in the news article states important observations from research. What is most valuable is the open statement regarding the limitation of this area of scientific research. This appears in the introduction which in my copy is in bold type.

While I have not studied the Declaration in depth, a very brief scan picked up the terminology “artificial arousal” and “deep brain stimulation” which are valid methods in this type of research. Personally, I would love to get a hold of the methods and materials sections of the research papers.

Coming from a Catholic perspective, there is nothing basically wrong with this statement in the closing. "Consequently, the weight of evidence indicates that humans are not unique in possessing the neurological substrates that generate consciousness. This refers to the material/physical anatomy, human and otherwise.
As many posters have pointed out – this is old news.

Going back to the basic idea that interpreters are not necessarily the same as the working scientist, what is happening is that the idea of “not unique” is being re-interpreted by some people as the rational mind being solely a natural phenomenon. This was evinced in some of the CAF posts when I first landed here.

My point is that off line there is a battle over human origin and human nature. In my personal opinion, we need to recognize that in this century, the basic material concept of evolution, such as humans and non-humans having similar characteristics, is by definition limited to our decomposing anatomy. We cannot allow all the valuable information, (and it is valuable in the medical arena), which led to the Cambridge Declaration on Consciousness to lull us into thinking that everyone accepts the spiritual, immortal, non-material soul.

Blessings,
granny

The human person is worthy of profound respect.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top