Seeking Direction on Discernment and Deception

  • Thread starter Thread starter Socrates4Jesus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

Socrates4Jesus

Guest
Hey, i want to say that in the past i’ve asked some tough questions and started some long discussions, and i want to thank everyone who patiently helped me out. People like you have a real heart like Christ’s.

My current question: I went to a Protestant forum i’ve frequented in the past (great bunch of people, there). I told them what i learned here about the biblical support for the Catholic concept of the Eucharist. Nearly everyone there told me i was not being spiritually discerning. Some suggested i was spiritually deceived. It got me thinking. If i am deceived, i won’t really know i am, will i? It seems that this is the nature of deception.

So, i’d like to ask you what i asked them, which they could not answer: What is spiritual discernment, and what is spiritual deception? If i discern what they are, then perhaps i’ll be in a better position to avoid being deceived, i believe.

🙂
 
discernment is a process that takes place properly only under guidance of the Holy Spirit, and ecclesially, that is, with the Church. Since Jesus founded the Catholic Church and promised that his Holy Spirit will guide her through the ages it is simply impossible that an individual “discerning in the Spirit” will come to conclusions that separate himself from the Church.
 
discernment is a process that takes place properly only under guidance of the Holy Spirit, and ecclesially, that is, with the Church. Since Jesus founded the Catholic Church and promised that his Holy Spirit will guide her through the ages it is simply impossible that an individual “discerning in the Spirit” will come to conclusions that separate himself from the Church.
Thank you for answering, Puzzle! But i’m puzzled about something: The answer you gave me is much the same several gave me at the Protestant forum. Spiritual discernment is being guided by the Holy Spirit, and the Spirit, they said, tells them true church is not the Catholic Church. So how do i know who has the Spirit of God and who has a spirit of deception?

🤷
 
Thank you for answering, Puzzle! But i’m puzzled about something: The answer you gave me is much the same several gave me at the Protestant forum. Spiritual discernment is being guided by the Holy Spirit, and the Spirit, they said, tells them true church is not the Catholic Church. So how do i know who has the Spirit of God and who has a spirit of deception?

🤷
Hi Soc,
Nice to see you back.

For those things that you are convinced are true, how did you discern their truthfulness?

At least one criterion I can think of that is near the top of the list is: Does the proposed truth lead us closer to dieing to self and getting closer to Christ?
 
Hi David. Good to be back!

In spiritual matters i’ve taken the meaning of the biblical text to be, to use a cliché, the gospel truth.

Regarding drawing closer to Christ, that’s my desire. But how does the desire determine the truth? I’ve met both Protestants and Catholics (like yourself) with this desire.
 
Hi David. Good to be back!

In spiritual matters i’ve taken the meaning of the biblical text to be, to use a cliché, the gospel truth.

Regarding drawing closer to Christ, that’s my desire. But how does the desire determine the truth? I’ve met both Protestants and Catholics (like yourself) with this desire.
Desire itself may not lead us to truth because we may settle for “good” when better and best are available. Desire should lead to the questions that reveal whether the proposed truth is in fact the “best”.
 
Desire itself may not lead us to truth because we may settle for “good” when better and best are available. Desire should lead to the questions that reveal whether the proposed truth is in fact the “best”.
Spoken like Socrates himself!

👍
 
I think this question is really the core issue in choosing a church home. Everyone thinks they have the “truth” and that the Holy Spirit has revealed it to them. But Jesus said many will be deceived. That’s actually one reason why I have confidence in the Catholic church. I’m no dummy, but I’m certainly not as smart as the doctors of the church. Augustine, Aquinas, Catherine of Siena, and so many others. These great theologians understood so much more that I will ever grasp. Protestants say that the Holy Spirit will lead each of us individually to the truth. We know that isn’t true because there is so much disagreement about fundamental truths. So who is the Holy Spirit guiding? The Magesterium of the church. In the book of Acts, the apostles have to make some decisions. They discussed them, prayed, and made a decision. The way it was phrased was that it seemed good to them and to the Holy Spirit. They decided what was right and conveyed that to the believers. Each believer didn’t choose on their own.

So for me, I rely on the authority of the Church. There is no other Church who has a 2000 year history of teaching. That isn’t to say that I don’t study the reasons behind the teaching of the church. Bible study is critical to faith formation. And reading the writings of the early church fathers is very helpful as well. Justin Martyr wrote around 150 about the real presence, and he described how the Christians worshipped. It reads just like a Catholic Mass. You can be encouraged by these writings and Bible Study to know the truth.

Finally, if you have doubts, go to Adoration and ask God to help you believe and discern. Go more than once!

Excellent question!
 
Thank you for answering, Puzzle! But i’m puzzled about something: The answer you gave me is much the same several gave me at the Protestant forum. Spiritual discernment is being guided by the Holy Spirit, and the Spirit, they said, tells them true church is not the Catholic Church. So how do i know who has the Spirit of God and who has a spirit of deception?

🤷
Simple - follow the one’s who follow Jesus - His Disciples. Can any of the non-Catholics you interacted with say that they are following a true disciple of Christ? Follow them back in time and see that from which they came. Most of these people can not trace their discipleship back more than a generation or two or three or to the secular men of the reformation attempt that departed from the 1,500 year old apostolic succession.

And here is the exact same scenario played out in scripture. Tell me who were followers of Christ.

John 6:35-71
35 Jesus said to them, "I
* am the bread of life; whoever comes to me will never hunger, and whoever believes in me will never thirst. **36 But I told you that although you have seen (me), you do not believe. 37 Everything that the Father gives me will come to me, and I will not reject anyone who comes to me, 38 because I came down from heaven not to do my own will but the will of the one who sent me.39 And this is the will of the one who sent me, that I should not lose anything of what he gave me, but that I should raise it (on) the last day. 40 For this is the will of my Father, **that everyone who sees **the Son and believes in him may have eternal life, and I shall raise him (on) the last day." 41 The Jews murmured about him because he said, “I am the bread that came down from heaven,” 42 and they said, “Is this not Jesus, the son of Joseph? Do we not know his father and mother? Then how can he say, ‘I have come down from heaven’?” 43 Jesus answered and said to them, “Stop murmuring 18 among yourselves. 44 No one can come to me unless the Father who sent me draw him, and I will raise him on the last day. 45 It is written in the prophets: ‘They shall all be taught by God.’ Everyone who listens to my Father and learns from him comes to me. 46 Not that anyone has seen the Father except the one who is from God; he has seen the Father. 47 Amen, amen, I say to you, whoever believes has eternal life. 48 I am the bread of life. 49 Your ancestors ate the manna in the desert, but they died; 50 this is the bread that comes down from heaven so that one may eat it and not die. 51 I am the living bread that came down from heaven; whoever eats this bread will live forever; and the bread that I will give is my flesh for the life of the world." 52 The Jews quarreled among themselves, saying, “How can this man give us (his) flesh to eat?” 53 Jesus said to them, "Amen, amen, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you do not have life within you. 54 Whoever eats 19 my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life, and I will raise him on the last day. 55 For my flesh is true food, and my blood is true drink. 56 Whoever eats my flesh and drinks my blood remains in me and I in him. 57 Just as the living Father sent me and I have life because of the Father, so also **the one who feeds on me will have life because of me.**58 This is the bread that came down from heaven. Unlike your ancestors who ate and still died, whoever eats this bread will live forever.” 59 These things he said while teaching in the synagogue in Capernaum. 60 20 Then many of his disciples who were listening said, “This saying is hard; who can accept it?” 61 Since Jesus knew that his disciples were murmuring about this, he said to them, “Does this shock you? 62 What if you were to see the Son of Man ascending to where he was before? 21 63 It is the spirit that gives life, while the flesh 22 is of no avail. The words I have spoken to you are spirit and life. 64 But there are some of you who do not believe.” Jesus knew from the beginning the ones who would not believe and the one who would betray him. 65 And he said, “For this reason I have told you that no one can come to me unless it is granted him by my Father.” 66 As a result of this, many (of) his disciples returned to their former way of life and no longer accompanied him. 67 Jesus then said to the Twelve, “**Do you also want to leave?” 68 Simon Peter answered him, “Master, to whom shall we go? You have the words of eternal life. 69 We have come to believe and are convinced that you are the Holy One of God.” **70 Jesus answered them, “Did I not choose you twelve? Yet is not one of you a devil?” 71 He was referring to Judas, son of Simon the Iscariot; it was he who would betray him, one of the Twelve. *

Where else in all of the world can a person go to SEE THE LORD every day of the year? Only the Catholic Church (and orthodox and a few minor apostolic sects) offer up the Bread of Life in the daily mass.

[continued]

James
 
[from prior]
What followers of Christ in these verses left Him and who stayed? Those in John 6:66 DEPARTED from Christ’s presence after the teaching of His Body and Blood was REJECTED. Who to this day still calls themselves with their lips a follower of Christ but who refused to bring Christ to their lips, kiss and eat Him and REJECT His teachings on His Body and Blood? Who else do we have as an example of a lip service Christian who was so audacious to kiss Christ on the cheek while betraying Him and turning Him over for crucifixation? Judas the traitor? Who STAYED with Christ and kept Him in their presence because He had the words of ever lasting life? The Apostles? Who to this day 2,000 years late is the ONLY church calling itself apostolic and founded on the Christ’s appointed Peter who spoke those famous words: ‘Simon Peter answered him, “Master, to whom shall we go? You have the words of eternal life. 69 We have come to believe and are convinced that you are the Holy One of God.”’

Your decision is easy my friend. Come to the Catholic Church and SEE Christ every day in the holy mass and eat of His body and drink of his blood. Remove yourself from the skeptics and those who turned their back on Christ’s teaching. Man does not live by bread alone but by every word that comes out of the mouth of God. What goes out of a man is not what makes him unclean but by what goes into him. Christ is the Living Word of God - eat it so you too may have eternal life and keep Him ever in your presence.

👍

James
 
I think this question is really the core issue in choosing a church home. Everyone thinks they have the “truth” and that the Holy Spirit has revealed it to them. But Jesus said many will be deceived. That’s actually one reason why I have confidence in the Catholic church. I’m no dummy, but I’m certainly not as smart as the doctors of the church. Augustine, Aquinas, Catherine of Siena, and so many others. These great theologians understood so much more that I will ever grasp. Protestants say that the Holy Spirit will lead each of us individually to the truth. We know that isn’t true because there is so much disagreement about fundamental truths. So who is the Holy Spirit guiding? The Magesterium of the church. In the book of Acts, the apostles have to make some decisions. They discussed them, prayed, and made a decision. The way it was phrased was that it seemed good to them and to the Holy Spirit. They decided what was right and conveyed that to the believers. Each believer didn’t choose on their own.

So for me, I rely on the authority of the Church. There is no other Church who has a 2000 year history of teaching. That isn’t to say that I don’t study the reasons behind the teaching of the church. Bible study is critical to faith formation. And reading the writings of the early church fathers is very helpful as well. Justin Martyr wrote around 150 about the real presence, and he described how the Christians worshipped. It reads just like a Catholic Mass. You can be encouraged by these writings and Bible Study to know the truth.

Finally, if you have doubts, go to Adoration and ask God to help you believe and discern. Go more than once!

Excellent question!
Thanks, Orchanian! I think the argument of many Protestants is that the Magesterium of the church has itself be deceived. How should i prove them wrong?
 
[from prior]
What followers of Christ in these verses left Him and who stayed? Those in John 6:66 DEPARTED from Christ’s presence after the teaching of His Body and Blood was REJECTED. Who to this day still calls themselves with their lips a follower of Christ but who refused to bring Christ to their lips, kiss and eat Him and REJECT His teachings on His Body and Blood? Who else do we have as an example of a lip service Christian who was so audacious to kiss Christ on the cheek while betraying Him and turning Him over for crucifixation? Judas the traitor? Who STAYED with Christ and kept Him in their presence because He had the words of ever lasting life? The Apostles? Who to this day 2,000 years late is the ONLY church calling itself apostolic and founded on the Christ’s appointed Peter who spoke those famous words: ‘Simon Peter answered him, “Master, to whom shall we go? You have the words of eternal life. 69 We have come to believe and are convinced that you are the Holy One of God.”’

Your decision is easy my friend. Come to the Catholic Church and SEE Christ every day in the holy mass and eat of His body and drink of his blood. Remove yourself from the skeptics and those who turned their back on Christ’s teaching. Man does not live by bread alone but by every word that comes out of the mouth of God. What goes out of a man is not what makes him unclean but by what goes into him. Christ is the Living Word of God - eat it so you too may have eternal life and keep Him ever in your presence.

👍

James
Thank you, CFLJ! I’ve spent much time contemplating John 6 and asking questions of thoughtful Protestants and thoughtful Catholics like yourself. My indecision is based in part on this:
“For my flesh is true food, and my blood is true drink.”
(John 6:55)
Catholics like yourself tell me Christ meant:
“For my flesh is **[actually] **true food, and my blood is [actually] true drink.”
(John 6:55)
Protestants tell me He meant:
“For my flesh is **[like] **true food, and my blood is [like] true drink.”
(John 6:55)
How do i determine the truth?
 
How to know the Magesterium isn’t deceived:
John 16:13: the church will be guided by the Holy Spirit into all truth.
Luke 10:16: Apostles will speak with Christ’s own voice.
1 Tim 3:15: Church is called the pillar and foundation of truth.

Rabbi Gamaliel, the teacher of St. Paul, said in Acts that the Pharisees and Scribes should leave the apostles and Christ-followers alone. If it was not of God, it would disappear. If it was of God, nothing could stop it. If the Church was wrong, it wouldn’t be around 2000 years later.

Also, everyone relies on something or somebody to help them understand the Bible. They read commentaries and judge those commentaries as right or wrong. So when they say they are relying only on the Bible, they are fooling themselves. We can’t rely only on the Bible because we have to understand history to understand some of the Bible. Our world today is so different from that of 2000 (and 4000) years ago. Rather than believing that Matthew Henry is right, or Kay Arthur, or Beth Moore, or whoever people rely on for understanding, I choose the Magesterium. We all choose someone. Again, that doesn’t mean that we blindly follow them - we must study and learn and gain understanding of the teachings. It’s good to say, I believe because the Church said so, but it’s even better to say, and here’s why the Church takes this position.

Your other post:
Jesus meant It is (or is like) my body/blood: John 6 is so clear about this - Jesus said you must eat my flesh and drink my blood. The Greek word used for eat is “chew.” And when people questioned this, Jesus reaffirmed what he said - three times! And many disciples left him. If he had been misunderstood, why wouldn’t he call them back and correct the misunderstanding (as he had always done in the past)? He let them go - their faith wasn’t strong enough for this. But the apostles stayed. He invited them to go, but they said (through Peter) Where shall we go? You have the words of eternal life. Notice also that just before the Bread of Life discourse in John is the multiplication of the fishes. And we all agree that Jesus is the Passover Lamb. In the Passover, the Jews were required to eat the lamb that was sacrificed. So, too, are we required to eat the body of the Lamb of God. When the Israelites were wandering in the desert for 40 years, God sent them manna from heaven to eat. Jesus said He is the bread that came down from heaven. All the things he compared himself to (passover lamb, manna) were things you actually ate.

There is so much more. Read Scott Hahn or get some tapes. Get the Bible Verse Finder from Jim Burnham (San Juan Catholic Seminars). Once you start to study this, you will be ON FIRE with excitement.
 
Thank you, CFLJ! I’ve spent much time contemplating John 6 and asking questions of thoughtful Protestants and thoughtful Catholics like yourself. My indecision is based in part on this:

Catholics like yourself tell me Christ meant:
For my flesh is [actually] true food, and my blood is [actually] true drink."

(John 6:55)

Protestants tell me He meant:

“For my flesh is [like] true food, and my blood is [like] true drink.”

(John 6:55)

How do i determine the truth?
Here is where the primary sense of scripture prevails as the first sense unless there are words directing us otherwise (as in “Jesus tell us what this parable means”). If you count it out Jesus goes well out of his way to repeat Himself 3 times that his body and blood are food and drink. He breaks all prior scriptural precedence. When he previously speaks in parables some disciple ALWAYS begs for an explanation or Jesus tells them something like “the meaning of this parable is:”. But that is not what happens here. Notice the deafening silence here? No one is asking Jesus for clarification - they know exactly what he means and they are very scared and troubled. The newer Jewish followers are also greatly disturbed. Notice they even complain : The Jews quarreled among themselves, saying in John 6:52: “How can this man give us (his) flesh to eat?” If there was ANY doubt that Jesus was speaking of a metaphor this verse annihilates it!

And it is again reconfirmed as literal when the Jews run away and stop following Christ in John 6:66. JEWS simply don’t cower and flee from mere metaphors and literary expressions. These are the same Jews who fought to a man and killed themselves rather than surrender at Masada 35 years later and fought an unwinable siege against the Romans when the temple was destroyed and the Jews were barred from ever entering Jerusalem again.

No, the Jews were afraid at this point that Jesus was asking them to literally to ignore all their teachings about Kosher laws and then do the impossible - eat a man who called himself God! They were exasperated and probably thought Jesus was insane. How ironic it is that Kosher salt is used to make food that comes from the cursed earth clean [ref: Genesis Adam’s consequence of sin] and here Jesus is essentially saying that He is utterly pure and clean (Kosher) since He comes down from heaven just like the manna did. The Jews go nuts over this since they knew He was speaking literally and it was too much for them to believe and accept.

Here I have to almost laugh at the Protestants who want to break with their fundamentalist traditions in the only place in scripture that they will do it just to buck Catholic teachings. Here The Protestant reveals their double-standard and yes they want to do just as you say insert a new word ‘LIKE real flesh’ where there is no such word. It’s the same merry-go-round they get into with their doctrines on Once Saved Always Saved to account for those who sin even after professing belief. They will say “one must not just believe - one must truly truly believe.” :rolleyes: And then in practice they will keep adding on new “truly’s” each time somone sins and gets a new baptism or rededicates himself to Christ rather than just admit they are sinners and go to confession, repent and forgive 70 x 7 times like Christ told us to since God is merciful.

So Catholics don’t need to add the words “actually” since Christ already said it with his signature expression “Amen Amen” (or verily verily) in verse John 6:53: Amen, amen, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you do not have life within you.

Not only that but it all fits perfectly with all the topological aspects of both the OT and NT and Christ being the Pascal Lamb and sprinkling the blood on the door lentils (the cross beams) and the meal in the upper room etc. etc. Even the place of Christ birth in a manger in Bethlehem (translated as “house of bread”) where sheep and animals eat is just so blatant than only pride or Satan could blind somone from making the connections.

It is so frustrating trying to get the blind to see things so bright and shiny that even through purposely closed eyelids one should still be able to feel the heat of the truth on one’s face if they would not turn their back and face what should be so glaringly and intensely obvious!

It’s nothing but stubborn pride…

James
 
How to know the Magesterium isn’t deceived:
John 16:13: the church will be guided by the Holy Spirit into all truth.
Luke 10:16: Apostles will speak with Christ’s own voice.
1 Tim 3:15: Church is called the pillar and foundation of truth.

Rabbi Gamaliel, the teacher of St. Paul, said in Acts that the Pharisees and Scribes should leave the apostles and Christ-followers alone. If it was not of God, it would disappear. If it was of God, nothing could stop it. If the Church was wrong, it wouldn’t be around 2000 years later.

Also, everyone relies on something or somebody to help them understand the Bible. They read commentaries and judge those commentaries as right or wrong. So when they say they are relying only on the Bible, they are fooling themselves. We can’t rely only on the Bible because we have to understand history to understand some of the Bible. Our world today is so different from that of 2000 (and 4000) years ago. Rather than believing that Matthew Henry is right, or Kay Arthur, or Beth Moore, or whoever people rely on for understanding, I choose the Magesterium. We all choose someone. Again, that doesn’t mean that we blindly follow them - we must study and learn and gain understanding of the teachings. It’s good to say, I believe because the Church said so, but it’s even better to say, and here’s why the Church takes this position.

Your other post:
Jesus meant It is (or is like) my body/blood: John 6 is so clear about this - Jesus said you must eat my flesh and drink my blood. The Greek word used for eat is “chew.” And when people questioned this, Jesus reaffirmed what he said - three times! And many disciples left him. If he had been misunderstood, why wouldn’t he call them back and correct the misunderstanding (as he had always done in the past)? He let them go - their faith wasn’t strong enough for this. But the apostles stayed. He invited them to go, but they said (through Peter) Where shall we go? You have the words of eternal life. Notice also that just before the Bread of Life discourse in John is the multiplication of the fishes. And we all agree that Jesus is the Passover Lamb. In the Passover, the Jews were required to eat the lamb that was sacrificed. So, too, are we required to eat the body of the Lamb of God. When the Israelites were wandering in the desert for 40 years, God sent them manna from heaven to eat. Jesus said He is the bread that came down from heaven. All the things he compared himself to (passover lamb, manna) were things you actually ate.

There is so much more. Read Scott Hahn or get some tapes. Get the Bible Verse Finder from Jim Burnham (San Juan Catholic Seminars). Once you start to study this, you will be ON FIRE with excitement.
Thank you, Orchanian. What i am seeking are definitions of spiritual discernment and spiritual deception. As Socrates said:
How can a man understand the name of anything, when he does not know what the thing is?
(Theaetetus, 147)
I want to understand whether i’m being spiritually discerning or spiritually deceived. And i agree with Socrates that know what spiritual discernment and spiritual deception are is essential to this.

So, i’m grateful for your assistance. What i think you are telling me is that

spiritual discernment = accepting the opinions of the Magisterium regarding spiritual matters.

spiritual deception = rejecting the opinion of the Magisterium regarding spiritual matters.

Am i understanding you correctly?
 
Here is where the primary sense of scripture prevails as the first sense unless there are words directing us otherwise (as in “Jesus tell us what this parable means”). If you count it out Jesus goes well out of his way to repeat Himself 3 times that his body and blood are food and drink. He breaks all prior scriptural precedence. When he previously speaks in parables some disciple ALWAYS begs for an explanation or Jesus tells them something like “the meaning of this parable is:”. But that is not what happens here. Notice the deafening silence here? No one is asking Jesus for clarification - they know exactly what he means and they are very scared and troubled. The newer Jewish followers are also greatly disturbed. Notice they even complain : The Jews quarreled among themselves, saying in John 6:52: “How can this man give us (his) flesh to eat?” If there was ANY doubt that Jesus was speaking of a metaphor this verse annihilates it!

And it is again reconfirmed as literal when the Jews run away and stop following Christ in John 6:66. JEWS simply don’t cower and flee from mere metaphors and literary expressions. These are the same Jews who fought to a man and killed themselves rather than surrender at Masada 35 years later and fought an unwinable siege against the Romans when the temple was destroyed and the Jews were barred from ever entering Jerusalem again.

No, the Jews were afraid at this point that Jesus was asking them to literally to ignore all their teachings about Kosher laws and then do the impossible - eat a man who called himself God! They were exasperated and probably thought Jesus was insane. How ironic it is that Kosher salt is used to make food that comes from the cursed earth clean [ref: Genesis Adam’s consequence of sin] and here Jesus is essentially saying that He is utterly pure and clean (Kosher) since He comes down from heaven just like the manna did. The Jews go nuts over this since they knew He was speaking literally and it was too much for them to believe and accept.

Here I have to almost laugh at the Protestants who want to break with their fundamentalist traditions in the only place in scripture that they will do it just to buck Catholic teachings. Here The Protestant reveals their double-standard and yes they want to do just as you say insert a new word ‘LIKE real flesh’ where there is no such word. It’s the same merry-go-round they get into with their doctrines on Once Saved Always Saved to account for those who sin even after professing belief. They will say “one must not just believe - one must truly truly believe.” :rolleyes: And then in practice they will keep adding on new “truly’s” each time somone sins and gets a new baptism or rededicates himself to Christ rather than just admit they are sinners and go to confession, repent and forgive 70 x 7 times like Christ told us to since God is merciful.

So Catholics don’t need to add the words “actually” since Christ already said it with his signature expression “Amen Amen” (or verily verily) in verse John 6:53: Amen, amen, I say to you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you do not have life within you.

Not only that but it all fits perfectly with all the topological aspects of both the OT and NT and Christ being the Pascal Lamb and sprinkling the blood on the door lentils (the cross beams) and the meal in the upper room etc. etc. Even the place of Christ birth in a manger in Bethlehem (translated as “house of bread”) where sheep and animals eat is just so blatant than only pride or Satan could blind somone from making the connections.

It is so frustrating trying to get the blind to see things so bright and shiny that even through purposely closed eyelids one should still be able to feel the heat of the truth on one’s face if they would not turn their back and face what should be so glaringly and intensely obvious!

It’s nothing but stubborn pride…

James
Excellent thoughts, James! It’s all i can do to resist the temptation to ask you to explain more! But resist i must, for my goal is to determine what spiritual discernment and spiritual deception are.

Are you saying the following?

spiritual discernment = allowing the primary sense of scripture to prevail, unless there are words directing us otherwise

spiritual deception = not allowing the primary sense of scripture to prevail, unless there are words directing us otherwise
 
Thank you, Orchanian. What i am seeking are definitions of spiritual discernment and spiritual deception. As Socrates said:

I want to understand whether i’m being spiritually discerning or spiritually deceived. And i agree with Socrates that know what spiritual discernment and spiritual deception are is essential to this.

So, i’m grateful for your assistance. What i think you are telling me is that

spiritual discernment = accepting the opinions of the Magisterium regarding spiritual matters.

spiritual deception = rejecting the opinion of the Magisterium regarding spiritual matters.

Am i understanding you correctly?
No, I wasn’t very clear there. Sorry. For me, I am reassured that the Magesterium has defined things, but I also investigate to understand. I trust that the Lord will not allow the Church to teach in error.

As for discernment, I have a book called the Discernment of Spirits by Timothy Gallagher. It’s based on the St. Ignatius. Ignatius identified 3 steps in discernment of spirits:
BE AWARE: Notice what is happening in your inner spiritual experience
UNDERSTAND: reflect on the stirrings you noticed to recognize what is of God and what is not.
TAKE ACTION (ACCEPT/REJECT): Accept what is of God and reject what is not.

The book might help you in your own discernment.

God bless you in your search!
 
No, I wasn’t very clear there. Sorry. For me, I am reassured that the Magesterium has defined things, but I also investigate to understand. I trust that the Lord will not allow the Church to teach in error.

As for discernment, I have a book called the Discernment of Spirits by Timothy Gallagher. It’s based on the St. Ignatius. Ignatius identified 3 steps in discernment of spirits:
BE AWARE: Notice what is happening in your inner spiritual experience
UNDERSTAND: reflect on the stirrings you noticed to recognize what is of God and what is not.
TAKE ACTION (ACCEPT/REJECT): Accept what is of God and reject what is not.

The book might help you in your own discernment.

God bless you in your search!
Blessings to you too! And thank you for the suggestion. It seems, however, that reading the book will be unnecessary. For the three attributes of spiritual discernment you have given to me are the very ones that several Protestants, Jehovah’s Witnesses, and Mormons have given to me. Yet, all of them disagree with one another and with the Roman Catholic Church regarding who Jesus is, and whether the Eucharist is Him!

It seems, then, that trusting one’s inner voice and considering what God might be saying through that voice is an extremely unreliable way to discern the truth. If you don’t have another way, that’s OK. I’ll keep asking until someone has an answer.
 
Anyone:

I do not believe this is not a trivial question i’m asking. It is one of the utmost importance! If you or i do not know what spiritual discernment is, we cannot possibly know for certain if we are spiritually discerning or spiritually deceived. Can we? To answer the question, “What is spiritual discernment,” is essential if we want to increase our faith, develop the faith of others, and protect ourselves from the greatest weapon of demonic powers–deception. Or does someone think i’m deceived in thinking this is an imperative truth to seek? Then again, perhaps knowing whether one is deceived or not is impossible?

🤷
If I do not know what something is, how could I know what qualities it possesses?
–Socrates (Meno)
 
The thoughtful Protestants to whom i asked the question were unable to answer. Can the helpful and insightful Catholics i’ve met here do no better?

🙂

What is spiritual discernment? What is spiritual deception?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top