Self defense? Defending others?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Vera_Ljuba
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Vera, there is a saying about what one should do when in a large hole of one’s own making with a shovel…I think you should consider that.

Whether the man wielding an axe in the direction of my cranium is an aggressor (not innocent) is a matter for me to judge. His existence is not a threat, but his actions may be judged so. I may act to stop his actions, even if my (judged necessary) response threatens death. And my act may be good, even if I later find my “aggressor’s” weapon was a toy.
 
Whether the man wielding an axe in the direction of my cranium is an aggressor (not innocent) is a matter for me to judge. His existence is not a threat, but his actions may be judged so. I may act to stop his actions, even if my (judged necessary) response threatens death. And my act may be good, even if I later find my “aggressor’s” weapon was a toy.
He is not “innocent” - you say. And the negation of innocent is “guilty”. The question is: “he is guilty of what”? He is certainly not guilty of murder, or even manslaughter… he is guilty of scaring you. But is scaring someone such a horrible crime that is deserves an immediate death sentence?

Of course, I am just pulling your leg here. 🙂 Please forgive me. I certainly agree that in the stipulated scenario and according to your best judgment your life is in danger, and you use the necessary force to defend yourself.

But the real point is - which you keep avoiding - that in the OP’s scenario we deal with someone whose mere existence puts millions in danger. Carrying and spreading the virus will cause millions to die. And that is not a matter of judgment, it is a fact - in the thought experiment. Sure, if there is a way to deal with this kind of problem is isolating the carrier of the virus, that is the preferred method, and it should be followed. But real life does not care about our preferences. Sometimes the only available solutions are all “immoral”. But staying “put” is also “immoral”. And in such a case what are you going to do? The only acceptable answer (in my opinion) is to case as little harm as possible.

You know the Hippocratic oath: “First, do no harm”. But what if all the possible venues (including doing nothing) cause harm? You can do the right thing and minimize the harm, or you can “wash your hands” and let the events unfold as they may. (I keep wondering why Pontius Pilatus is depicted as a “bad guy”? He just “washed his hands”, did he not?)
 
But the real point is - which you keep avoiding - that in the OP’s scenario we deal with someone whose mere existence puts millions in danger. … Sure, if there is a way to deal with this kind of problem is isolating the carrier of the virus, that is the preferred method, and it should be followed. But real life does not care about our preferences.
In fact, I’ve avoided nothing. The problem is, you don’t study the responses you’ve received - perhaps you are bent on trying to establish a point, rather than seeing there is another moral framework which operates on different principles. And God’s commandments are precepts in this system.

It is good to note that - in the real world - the mere existence of persons who have no malice, who are non-aggressive, and who are “innocent” - is NOT a threat. There is in fact no motivation to kill them in preference to something more appropriate.

But even if we suspend reality, I and others have explicitly said to you that we may not murder as a means to bring about some other good. Yet this does not mean that other licit actions - potentially risking death - are not possible. But if none can be found, then (in the unreal scenario you have created) a great tragedy may befall us all.
Sometimes the only available **solutions **are all “immoral”.
That’s true only if by “solution” we recognise what you mean - actions which bring about a desired/good outcome. But outcomes alone do not determine morality of actions. Sometimes “sh*t” threatens to happen, and we are **not free **to do what might prevent it because the act itself would be evil. Typically, the atheist rejects this idea - they declare we are responsible for whatever bad outcomes we did **not **act to prevent. And “before the atheist”, we are responsible, but “before God” we are not.
But staying “put” is also “immoral”. And in such a case what are you going to do? The only acceptable answer (in my opinion) is to cause [or allow] as little harm as possible.
I appreciate your qualifier “in my opinion”. The Catholic system however parts company with you, because in this statement you imply that any action (no exceptions) could be moral - depending on the situation, *and the morality is being judged based on outcomes *(typically body counts in the usual array of desperate scenarios considered). The underlined portion is why I have described your thinking as “consequentialist” - the primary guide applied (as we see in your scenario) is to see that particular outcomes are achieved/avoided, and you hold that avoiding grave outcomes justifies…potentially…anything that in physical terms is less grave than the outcome avoided. For you this takes primacy, but for the Catholic it is secondary:
  • first we must not do what is intrinsically evil (forbidden by divine law);
  • second, me must act well-intentioned;
  • third, of those acts passing the above hurdles, we must act in the expectation that our act will cause more good than harm.
*ccc 1754 The circumstances, including the consequences, are secondary elements of a moral act. They contribute to increasing or diminishing the moral goodness or evil of human acts (for example, the amount of a theft). They can also diminish or increase the agent’s responsibility (such as acting out of a fear of death). Circumstances of themselves cannot change the moral quality of acts themselves; they can make neither good nor right an action that is in itself evil. *

Murder does not get to first base. And by declining to murder, it may be that a great tragedy befalls us. But such is not the common experience.
 
It is good to note that - in the real world - the mere existence of persons who have no malice, who are non-aggressive, and who are “innocent” - is NOT a threat.
Of course they can be. Don’t tell me that you never heard of the concept of “endangerment”, where someone places others into danger, involuntarily and unintentionally. There are two meanings of the word “threat”. One is: “intentionally inflict damage, etc”, and two: “a person or thing likely to cause damage or danger”. You insist using only the first one, and I acknowledge both the first and the second one.

So we are allowed to defend against the first one (someone wielding an axe), but we are NOT allowed to defend against the second one (someone carrying a lethal virus)? Is that what the church “teaches”? We must just play possum and hope for the best? Does not sound reasonable, does it?
But even if we suspend reality, I and others have explicitly said to you that we may not murder as a means to bring about some other good.
Murder is a technical term, describing an act which is prohibited by law. Self-defense is NOT a murder.
That’s true only if by “solution” we recognise what you mean - actions which bring about a desired/good outcome. But outcomes alone do not determine morality of actions.
I purposefully avoid using the word “moral”, because what I consider moral, and what you consider moral are diametrically different.
Sometimes “sh*t” threatens to happen, and we are **not free **to do what might prevent it because the act itself would be evil. Typically, the atheist rejects this idea - they declare we are responsible for whatever bad outcomes we did **not **act to prevent. And “before the atheist”, we are responsible, but “before God” we are not.
God is more than welcome to state his opinion. Much as I respect you (and I do, despite our difference in opinion), you do not speak for God. Otherwise you are right. If there is am impending catastrophe, and provided that you could prevent it, and neglect to do so, you are held responsible for your inaction. This is exactly the point I am talking about. When there are only two possible outcomes, one MUST choose the one which causes less harm.
For you this takes primacy, but for the Catholic it is secondary:
  • first we must not do what is intrinsically evil (forbidden by divine law);
  • second, me must act well-intentioned;
  • third, of those acts passing the above hurdles, we must act in the expectation that our act will cause more good than harm.
The trouble is that you cannot decide if an action is “immoral” without taking all the circumstances and consequences into consideration. Do you have an objective epistemological method, which will decide if a physical act is “intrinsically evil”, or not? Objective means that using the method will give the same result for a believer or an atheist? Unfortunately that is unlikely, since you speak of some unspecified “divine law”, which term is not acknowledged by the atheist. Of course, it will be acknowledged and honored as soon as God himself declares it… not some self-proclaimed person or institution, who insists to speak for God. Up until that happens, we can only use the secular methods.

The fundamental problem is that you use “act” in two meanings. One is the physical action (or inaction), which is independent from the consequences, intents and circumstances… and the other one, the “moral act”, which includes all of the above. And you say that a morally good act must include all fonts, while the “immoral act” can be singled out without considering all the font. And that approach is unreasonable and irrational. 🙂

Indeed, we disagree on the most fundamental level. But at least we agree politely and respectfully. (By the way… check out my signature, it summarizes my point of view.)
 
Vera, the forum is about moral theology, hence my preparedness to use the word moral. Is it surprising you see the world differently when you hold there to be no accessible divine law. Were there no divine law, there would be no moral theology, only philosophy and ethics.

Your first remark above continues to be wrong in conclusion. One can always defend oneself, but means are constrained. Your obsession with the need to end a man’s existence is the problem. We can defend against the virus - acting morally.

I’ve used murder as a moral term. It makes an appearance in divine law. I explained it further with a detailed papal quote elsewhere.

You construct your system of ethics presuming no divine law. I fail to understand why you don’t simply and readily see that this omission necessarily leads you to a different ethical system to one that incorporates a divine law? Your position is simply that you don’t believe in the divine law, so it has no part in your system of ethics. Ok, noted. 🤷 But God has stated his opinion - but you deny this. Ok, I accept that you do. 🤷 If one mathematician accepts that space is planar, he will get one set of results for his calculation of spatial distances. If another accepts that space is something other than planar, his calculations are different and will yield different results. The mathematicians will not perennially argue about their results, because they know why they are different. But you continue to argue about the results. Your real argument is whether there is a divine law. You say “no” (or at best “don’t know, so I’ll assume no”) and most here say “yes”. That’s a different debate to be had first - and on another forum.

PS. Your signature reflects and is consistent with your consequentialist thinking. You determine “right” using the principles you accept.
 
One question I’m having lately now is: Is it right to kill the aggressor?

What’s leading me to this question are some things.

1: Jesus said “If someone strikes you, turn the other cheek.” and “Love your enemy.”
2: When his apostles in the garden said they’d defend him from the Romans, he said they were thinking with their human hearts, not divine. (It’s in Matthew somewhere.)
3: Jesus, most definitely an innocent, did not kill the Romans who were going to kill him.

I know the Catechism condones it, but it’s something that makes me wonder now.
 
One question I’m having lately now is: Is it right to kill the aggressor?

What’s leading me to this question are some things.

1: Jesus said “If someone strikes you, turn the other cheek.” and “Love your enemy.”
2: When his apostles in the garden said they’d defend him from the Romans, he said they were thinking with their human hearts, not divine. (It’s in Matthew somewhere.)
3: Jesus, most definitely an innocent, did not kill the Romans who were going to kill him.

I know the Catechism condones it, but it’s something that makes me wonder now.
The aggressor may be ‘stopped’ and his threat ended. Christianity does not teach pacifism, and you misinterpret Scripture if you believe otherwise. This article discusses the subject:
plainsimplefaith.com/2014/05/qa-because-jesus-said-turn-the-other-cheek-is-self-defense-wrong/
[Not a Catholic source.]

There is then a second question about what extent of defence is acceptable. You may not set out to kill the aggressor - rather to stop his aggression. This does not preclude you taking an action which you know full well will see the aggressor’s death, if that is the action you judge necessary to give effect to your defence. You should use the least force you judge necessary to give effect to your defence.
 
Your first remark above continues to be wrong in conclusion. One can always defend oneself, but means are constrained. Your obsession with the need to end a man’s existence is the problem. We can defend against the virus - acting morally.
Really? In each and every instance? There cannot be any special set of circumstances where the minimal interference results in the death of the carrier of the virus? That is a very unlikely possibility.

But let’s suppose that eventually there will be a way to deal with the virus. When? And how many people will have to die until that happens? All because the person who could have nipped the epidemic in the bud failed to summon the necessary willpower to do what is right. Think about the Ebola, the HIV, the cholera, the bubonic plague and many others. If only those could have been stopped by killing the original carrier…

Yes, I do care about others. What happens to them is important (even in such a hypothetical scenario). Your “moral system” does not care. For you it is important to obey the alleged divine law. If that divine law would command you to go and kill, torture, maim and rape, you would obey. Abraham was willing to sacrifice Isaac - no questions asked, no hesitation. That is the “morality” based upon divine law. And that is why I reject it as a valid foundation for “morality”. There is nothing “moral” about (blind) obedience.

By the way, I do care about the carrier of this hypothetical virus. If there would be any other way to deal with the threat, I would choose that one. But there is none (in the hypothetical scenario).
Your signature reflects and is consistent with your consequentialist thinking. You determine “right” using the principles you accept.
And so do you. 🙂 Obviously and naturally. We both live our lives according to our principles.
 
Again, you express errors of understanding, but I see little merit in correcting the same error yet again.

You are clear that you reject the very existence of the divine law - as opposed to its meaning or implications - and that is the basis of difficulty.
 
You are clear that you reject the very existence of the divine law - as opposed to its meaning or implications - and that is the basis of difficulty.
You are correct. I reject the “divine law”, because there is no evidence for it. But I am willing to contemplate it - provisionally, for the sake of this discussion.

This divine law says that I am allowed to use deadly force to defend against an explicit and visible attack (like a wielded axe).

What does it say when I am in the danger to be exposed to a deadly virus, which will infect me if I get a bodily contact with the carrier, who is unaware of the result of this contact? If this carrier is unaware of this result, he or she is “innocent” of any malice. But he or she will still exposing me to a deadly danger. If the only way to avoid this contact is a deadly force, am I allowed to use this force?
 
You are correct. I reject the “divine law”, because there is no evidence for it. But I am willing to contemplate it - provisionally, for the sake of this discussion.

This divine law says that I am allowed to use deadly force to defend against an explicit and visible attack (like a wielded axe).

What does it say when I am in the danger to be exposed to a deadly virus, which will infect me if I get a bodily contact with the carrier, who is unaware of the result of this contact? If this carrier is unaware of this result, he or she is “innocent” of any malice. But he or she will still exposing me to a deadly danger. If the only way to avoid this contact is a deadly force, am I allowed to use this force?
At Church we always hear about how everyone is our brothers and sisters. A few days ago that finally hit me.

So let’s take the virus situation and look at it in another lens, in which the infected man isn’t some looming stranger, but your brother. If your brother was infected, would you not try to tend to them? Would you not risk yourself to save him? Would it be right for you to kill your brother?

That’s why it isn’t alright to take the life of the innocent.
 
At Church we always hear about how everyone is our brothers and sisters. A few days ago that finally hit me.

So let’s take the virus situation and look at it in another lens, in which the infected man isn’t some looming stranger, but your brother. If your brother was infected, would you not try to tend to them? Would you not risk yourself to save him? Would it be right for you to kill your brother?

That’s why it isn’t alright to take the life of the innocent.
Whether the other person is my brother or not (literally or figuratively) - is irrelevant. I would feel the same responsibility to protect the life of strangers as my own kin. That is what the church teaches.

The problem is not just endangering myself, but my non-action would also put untold millions of others into lethal jeopardy. I can choose to endanger myself, but I cannot make that decision for you. By non-action I would take the life of those untold millions.

Let me repeat. By acting you cause the death of one person. By inaction you cause the death of millions.
 
Whether the other person is my brother or not (literally or figuratively) - is irrelevant. I would feel the same responsibility to protect the life of strangers as my own kin. That is what the church teaches.

The problem is not just endangering myself, but my non-action would also put untold millions of others into lethal jeopardy. I can choose to endanger myself, but I cannot make that decision for you. By non-action I would take the life of those untold millions.

Let me repeat. By acting you cause the death of one person. By inaction you cause the death of millions.
Acting, even in a way that causes death, can be moral. But your requirement was to be allowed to directly and intentionally kill a good man, or the little girl next door, or a baby, or the unborn because you believe that that (bad) act will lead to good outcomes.
 
Acting, even in a way that causes death, can be moral. But your requirement was to be allowed to directly and intentionally kill a good man, or the little girl next door, or a baby, or the unborn because you believe that that (bad) act will lead to good outcomes.
Please do not change the stipulations of the thought experiment (there is no “little girl next door, or a baby or some unborn”). In the scenario your only option to stop the deadly disease is to remove the carrier of the virus. Preventing such an outbreak is definitely a “good act”. Inaction will result in an epidemic.

I am not saying that the kill is a “good” or “moral” act. It is the lesser of two evils. That is all.
 
Please do not change the stipulations of the thought experiment (there is no “little girl next door, or a baby or some unborn”). In the scenario your only option to stop the deadly disease is to remove the carrier of the virus. Preventing such an outbreak is definitely a “good act”. Inaction will result in an epidemic.

I am not saying that the kill is a “good” or “moral” act. It is the lesser of two evils. That is all.
I’ve changed nothing. Whether the carrier is a good man, the little girl next door, a baby or an unborn makes no difference. Surely that is plain?
 
I am not saying that the kill is a “good” or “moral” act. It is the lesser of two evils. That is all.
Earlier you seemed to say that killing the carrier to prevent the epidemic was “the right thing,” indeed the only possible right answer. Here you grant that it would be an evil, though a lesser one.

Catholic moral theology, as you likely know, does not countenance doing evil that good may come of it. The closest we get is double effect, whereby a good or neutral act may have an unintended evil side effect that we would avoid if we could.

This is not a matter of blind or uncaring obedience, but simply of a conviction that some acts are always wrong and cannot be made right by good consequences, and in fact that it is a pernicious deception to think that one is achieving good by doing evil.

On another point, I understand the desire to construct an ironclad moral dilemma to force discussion of the ethics of various options (though, like us, you seem to believe firmly that there is only one correct response; it just happens to be the opposite of ours). However, the initial responses that pointed out less-lethal ways to stop the virus carrier were useful in one respect. They demonstrated, despite your protestations that the respondents were the ones failing to face reality, that in the real-life situation steps could be taken to shield the general population without killing the unknowing carrier. Oddly enough, when these situations really do arise there is almost always a “third choice” that contrived dilemmas don’t permit. It’s the same reason the “guy who ‘must’ be tortured to prevent a ticking time bomb from going off” scenario, beloved of so many torture apologists (including, shamefully, some of my fellow Catholics) is a terrible foundation for a moral position: it’s something that never actually happens. Hard cases make bad law, as the saying goes, and lifeboat situations may be interesting to ponder but should not form the basis for one’s everyday moral behavior.
 
I’ve changed nothing. Whether the carrier is a good man, the little girl next door, a baby or an unborn makes no difference. Surely that is plain?
It is an attempt to bring in emotionalism. And, please stop calling me “Surely”. 🙂
 
Earlier you seemed to say that killing the carrier to prevent the epidemic was “the right thing,” indeed the only possible right answer. Here you grant that it would be an evil, though a lesser one.
The phrase “lesser of two evils” is a colloquialism.
Oddly enough, when these situations really do arise there is almost always a “third choice” that contrived dilemmas don’t permit.
Almost always simply does not cut it. The reason for presenting these “far-out” and “off-the-wall” scenarios is to show that a “moral” system must be applicable not only for everyday problems, but ALL the conceivable problems. Even for the most unlikely (but not logically impossible) ones.
 
The phrase “lesser of two evils” is a colloquialism.
LOL. Better not to mix your ethical systems. Evil for you resides primarily in consequences, thus for you, no evil is committed. We get that!
The reason for presenting these “far-out” and “off-the-wall” scenarios is to show that a “moral” system must be applicable not only for everyday problems, but ALL the conceivable problems. Even for the most unlikely (but not logically impossible) ones
This makes no sense. Catholic Moral Theology is applicable everywhere and everywhen. So is your flavour of Consequentialism/Proportionalism (AFAIK). Those systems both can answer the riddles posed - they just get different answers. Like the mathematicians calculating interstellar distances with a different understanding of the geometry of space.
 
It is an attempt to bring in emotionalism.
I can’t see emotionalism changing your assessment of body count Vera! But that’s not the point - you said I’d changed something - but I did not. Man, Woman, Child next door … makes no difference, right? You want to assert that any person can be directly and intentionally killed if that’s the only way to bring about a good end (avoiding more than the one death of the person killed). We part company there. We agree that innocent lives might be lost in pursuing a good end by good means - but no, they can’t be the target!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top