It is good to note that - in the real world - the mere existence of persons who have no malice, who are non-aggressive, and who are “innocent” - is NOT a threat.
Of course they can be. Don’t tell me that you never heard of the concept of “endangerment”, where someone places others into danger, involuntarily and unintentionally. There are two meanings of the word “threat”. One is: “intentionally inflict damage, etc”, and two: “a person or thing likely to cause damage or danger”. You insist using only the first one, and I acknowledge both the first and the second one.
So we are allowed to defend against the first one (someone wielding an axe), but we are NOT allowed to defend against the second one (someone carrying a lethal virus)? Is that what the church “teaches”? We must just play possum and hope for the best? Does not sound reasonable, does it?
But even if we suspend reality, I and others have explicitly said to you that we may not murder as a means to bring about some other good.
Murder is a technical term, describing an act which is prohibited by law. Self-defense is NOT a murder.
That’s true only if by “solution” we recognise what you mean - actions which bring about a desired/good outcome. But outcomes alone do not determine morality of actions.
I purposefully avoid using the word “moral”, because what I consider moral, and what you consider moral are diametrically different.
Sometimes “sh*t” threatens to happen, and we are **not free **to do what might prevent it because the act itself would be evil. Typically, the atheist rejects this idea - they declare we are responsible for whatever bad outcomes we did **not **act to prevent. And “before the atheist”, we are responsible, but “before God” we are not.
God is more than welcome to state his opinion. Much as I respect you (and I do, despite our difference in opinion), you do not speak for God. Otherwise you are right. If there is am impending catastrophe, and provided that you could prevent it, and neglect to do so, you are held responsible for your inaction. This is exactly the point I am talking about. When there are only two possible outcomes, one MUST choose the one which causes less harm.
For you this takes primacy, but for the Catholic it is secondary:
- first we must not do what is intrinsically evil (forbidden by divine law);
- second, me must act well-intentioned;
- third, of those acts passing the above hurdles, we must act in the expectation that our act will cause more good than harm.
The trouble is that you cannot decide if an action is “immoral” without taking all the circumstances and consequences into consideration.
Do you have an objective epistemological method, which will decide if a physical act is “intrinsically evil”, or not? Objective means that using the method will give the same result for a believer or an atheist? Unfortunately that is unlikely, since you speak of some unspecified “divine law”, which term is not acknowledged by the atheist. Of course, it will be acknowledged and honored as soon as God himself declares it… not some self-proclaimed person or institution, who insists to speak for God. Up until that happens, we can only use the secular methods.
The fundamental problem is that you use “act” in two meanings. One is the physical action (or inaction), which is independent from the consequences, intents and circumstances… and the other one, the “moral act”, which includes all of the above. And you say that a morally good act must include all fonts, while the “immoral act” can be singled out without considering all the font. And that approach is unreasonable and irrational.
Indeed, we disagree on the most fundamental level. But at least we agree politely and respectfully. (By the way… check out my signature, it summarizes my point of view.)