Sending others to war

  • Thread starter Thread starter YourNameHere
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I do think Bush erred, I do think we already had military action, Operation Desert Fox that would keep Saddam in line, if he acted up.


I do think the Bush admin acted on intelligence but was naive.

I still fault much more the next administration that withdrew troops in 2010-2011 for the ensuing chaos in the region and the rise of ISIS.

Also, US involvement in wars in Libya and Yemen as well.

Giving Iran $150 billion in that deal, JCPOA and kicking the can down the road concerning North Korea.
 
Are you unaware that the former Deputy Director of the CIA, Michael Morell, sent Colin Powell an apology letter for the bad intel on Iraq WMD’s, which Powell used to try and sell the UN Security Counsel to approve the attack on Iraq ?

They didn’t buy it and we got into quagmire which destabilized the entire ME.

Jim
 
They also provide false intel to get us to act

Part of the bogus WMD intel on Iraq, came from Israel, which also wanted Saddam taken out,

Jim

The Brits gave us that intelligence, in fact, it’s about what every major intelligence agency said.

Can you back up your assertions here accurately? First time, I’ve hever heard that.
 
There was also some Iraqi defector who was telling us they had this stuff…

And as usual, a whole lot of something was transported out of Iraq, we don’t know what that was. The Russian convoy.

Addendum: In a manner of speaking, we may be holding Israel back, Israel could respond very forcefully towards threats from its neighbors and it begs the question of how would we act in turn if some geographical neighbor in the Western hemisphere was threatening us.

Then, we also have Saudi Arabia over there and some say, we do this for the Saudis.

Anyway, within limits of caution, this crisis is “appearing” to die down, it was sabre rattling and if I’m not repeating myself, I’m not sure if I support the sanctions that seem to be the cause of the trouble over there. There are some true experts on this matter. I certainly am not one.
 
Last edited:

Israeli General Criticizes Tel Aviv’s Role in Assessing Iraqi WMD Capabilities​

An Israeli brigadier general has accused Israeli intelligence of being involved, along with U.S and British intelligence services, in overstating Iraq’s prewar WMD capabilities, the Washington Post reported today (see GSN , Dec. 4).

In a report for Tel Aviv University’s Jaffee Center for Strategic Studies, Brig. Gen. Shlomo Brom said that Israeli intelligence provided “an exaggerated assessment of Iraqi capabilities,” leading to “the possibility that the intelligence picture was manipulated.”


FYI, other sorcesses have similar stories, like the Washington Post, but I’ve exceeded my free access and now they want me to subscribe to see the story.

Jim
 
Ultimately, there is no advantage over the long run for either Iran or the US to go to war with each other to pacify a few hotheads on either side.
But I think there is an advantage over the long run for Iran not becoming a nuclear power, the advantage is for the world.
 
Well, his agency’s wasn’t the only intel. Regardless, Saddam had WMD.

Saddam started a war with Iran and conquered Kuwait and threatened Saudi Arabia with invasion and was shooting at American and British planes and you think the Middle East was stable?
 
Ah! So an Israeli Brigadier General disagreed with his own intelligence service. Wouldn’t be the first time that happened in history. Just as an aside, Obama ignored all the U.S. intel when he cut and ran from Iraq, turning it over to ISIS.
 
We have taken a very interventionist stand in our foreign policy. Maybe it’s time to examine the incentives of those domestic persons and entities who gain from shoving our forces into so many corners around the world. The American people are not stupid; we’re just very unconvinced that there is value to this style of foreign policy. Yet many still wonder why Trump won the election. Because the American people are clearly tired of this interventionist policy and they said so.

More on topic: it’s turning out that the Iranians’ movements were defensive in nature, not offensive, as they were expecting the US to attack at any moment. But those movements were interpreted as offensive so as to fit Bolton’s narrative.
https://www.zerohedge.com/news/2019...e-intel-based-tehran-misreading-us-intentions

And there’s not even a consensus among the allies about the intelligence:
https://www.zerohedge.com/news/2019...ntel-unleashes-storm-behind-scenes-infighting
 
This really has to be one of the biggest non-stories of the year. Trump never said we were going to war. He did move some assets into the gulf because of some Iranian moves, Iran said it didn’t want war. Trump said he didn’t want war. Both got what they wanted…no war. Some said Bolton wanted war, but nobody can produce evidence of it.

It’s a big nothing.
 
In response to your comment regarding the prevention of Iran becoming a nuclear power being a longtime worthwhile goal:

I really don’t want to see iran become a nuclear power, however my concerns are - -who are we to dictate who can have it and who can not have nuclear power. We already have several countries like Russia, China, North Korea,Pakistan, India and Israel, all who could represent a potential threat. Israel in a desperate response I could see using nuclear weapons as a last resort or if they truly felt threatened. Certainly nothing stable about Pakistan. Pakistan and India are always in a shoving match. North Korea has a crazy leader. Why would Iran be denied if these countries have been allowed to continue bearing arms?I think we all know if a country wants to acquire any weapon they can somehow.
 
I’m not so sure the young people of Iran won’t rise up in revolution if war does break out.
So this time the nation we invade will greet us as liberators? 4th times the charm eh? :roll_eyes:The people of Iran aren’t as religiously fanatical as they were in the 60s, but I doubt they’d love a foreign Invader.
Iran wants to be the dominant power in the Middle East
Why on Earth should America care? Neo-Cons love to spit on our founding fathers who warned us to not get involved in foreign affairs.
and force Shia on the populations of Sunni countries.
Do you have any facts to back this claim? Manny Muslim nations have large Shia populations such as Iraq Yemen or Syria, if these people wish to align them self’s with Iran what business is it of ours?
Israel is a valuable ally. It’s our primary source of intelligence in the region.
Great then you and yours can fight and die for them.
 
So this time the nation we invade will greet us as liberators?
Who said anything about invading? Knock out their infrastructure, naval and air forces and let internal strife take it from there. I don’t want any war, but there’s definitely no need to invade Iran.
 
I really don’t want to see iran become a nuclear power, however my concerns are - -who are we to dictate who can have it and who can not have nuclear power. We already have several countries like Russia, China, North Korea,Pakistan, India and Israel, all who could represent a potential threat. Israel in a desperate response I could see using nuclear weapons as a last resort or if they truly felt threatened. Certainly nothing stable about Pakistan. Pakistan and India are always in a shoving match. North Korea has a crazy leader. Why would Iran be denied if these countries have been allowed to continue bearing arms?I think we all know if a country wants to acquire any weapon they can somehow.
We may be the most active, but we are hardly the only OECD country pushing to limit nuclear proliferation.

190 countries have signed the Treaty on Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons
120 countries have signed a treaty to ban nuclear weapons

Your desire to step back and not show leaderships is quite sad.
"If not us, then who"
 
Hardly. It saddens me that as a country that purports freedom, we run a policing effort of other countries around the world that are not under our sovereign control. Why not allow countries in closer proximity to Iran exhibit this leadership? We are on the other side of the globe. Patriotism should not mean approval of proliferation of military force throughout the world.

We live in a world where there are many bad players, not just Iran and North Korea. No reason why Pakistan is entitled to have nuclear weapons, but they do and we are not trying to take them away. Add China, Russia, North Korea, etc… Pakistan has been a harbor to terrorists and a thorn in the side. The signing of a document of non-proliferation is not an assurance of anyone fulfilling that obligation. To my knowledge Pakistan has not signed or assented to anything. Other countries have ratified or assented to it. but what does that mean? I don’t think in most cases we are taking their word for it. Do we believe China? Russia? I think not.

In spite of this, we are the only nation that has used nuclear weapons in warfare. One could argue in the long run it, saved lives. Maybe, maybe not. But it does say that even rogue countries (as of yet)have not been the first ones to push the button.

Leadership does not equate to being policemen of the world. We are not exhibiting freedom to others if we run herd or strongarm other countries by military or economic force, While we are doing that, we also run a tight relationship with countries like Saudi Arabia, a very oppressive country. I would be much more convinced of moral sincerity if they would impose the same military and economic sanctions on them as we want to do with Iran. Saudi Arabia has been a prime source of terrorists and are running a terrible war in Yemen where thousands are dying of starvation and disease. I love America and believe in defending it’s freedom, if we are attacked (primarily on American soil), but that feeling does not mean we run an empire).There are exceptions to everything of course, but we have have military bases in different countries all over the world, more than all of the other countries of the world combined. Name any country that is even remotely close in that endeavor.

One of the main arguments about Iran is it’s potential threat to Israel, Israel has nuclear weapons. They have an incredibly well trained military. I don’t think Israel would hesitate to use nuclear weapons if they need to. I think Iran knows this, as well and would be foolish to attempt military action against them.
 
Hardly. It saddens me that as a country that purports freedom, we run a policing effort of other countries around the world that are not under our sovereign control. Why not allow countries in closer proximity to Iran exhibit this leadership? We are on the other side of the globe. Patriotism should not mean approval of proliferation of military force throughout the world
That was long winded, I think you are saying that no country should ‘police’ other countries.

If I give you that then I demand we also shut down our refugee programs and build that full wall. Go full isolationist.
 
I am for non-interventionism but not isolationism. We still need to trade with other countries and maintain diplomatic relationships. I am still in favor of the wall and limited immigration where people at vetted.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top