Sense and reason on transubstantiation

  • Thread starter Thread starter myfavoritmartin
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

myfavoritmartin

Guest
Do your senses and your reasoning suggest to you that the wafer has become Christ?

I am both sensible and reasonable, i voted NO

Sense

a. Natural understanding or intelligence, especially in practical matters: The boy had sense and knew just what to do when he got lost.
b. The normal ability to think or reason soundly. Often used in the plural: Have you taken leave of your senses?
c. Something sound or reasonable: There’s no sense in waiting three hours.

Reason
  1. To use the faculty of reason; think logically.
  2. To talk or argue logically and persuasively.
 
Senses, no.
Reason, yes.

I cannot vote. 😦

sense-

1.any of the faculties, as sight, hearing, smell, taste, or touch, by which humans and animals perceive stimuli originating from outside or inside the body.2.these faculties collectively.3.their operation or function; sensation.4.a feeling or perception produced through the organs of touch, taste, etc., or resulting from a particular condition of some part of the body: *to have a sense of cold. *
 
Yes, sense and reason based upon faith in our Lord Jesus Christ and his Church and what they profess.
 
Senses, no.
Reason, yes.
Ditto. Only by divine revelation can we know to discern the body and blood (as Paul worded it) of Christ in the Eucharist.

I think a parallel question is: “Do your senses and reason detect God as a consubstantial Trinity?”
 
You sure do sound like an atheist, MFM. Flesh and blood do not reveal it to us, but our Father who is in heaven.

You need to make a choice, MFM. Do you believe in Jesus Christ because of your senses and reason, or do you believe in Jesus Christ because of your faith? You are a Christian who argues against Catholic specifics like an atheist. Your own beliefs cannot stand up to the standards you attempt to apply to Catholic beliefs. Do you have faith, MFM? Or do you just have the unavoidable conclusions of your senses and reason?
 
You sure do sound like an atheist, MFM. Flesh and blood do not reveal it to us, but our Father who is in heaven.

You need to make a choice, MFM. Do you believe in Jesus Christ because of your senses and reason, or do you believe in Jesus Christ because of your faith? You are a Christian who argues against Catholic specifics like an atheist. Your own beliefs cannot stand up to the standards you attempt to apply to Catholic beliefs. Do you have faith, MFM? Or do you just have the unavoidable conclusions of your senses and reason?
If you think i sound like an athiest Mike, you don’t know me well at all.
I’ve been given the gift of faith and by that my senses and reason confirm it.
If as you suggest, that my own beliefs don’t stand up to the same standards then you are saying that scripture will not hold up to those standards, because my beliefs are solidly grounded in scripture.
 
If you think i sound like an athiest Mike, you don’t know me well at all.
I’ve been given the gift of faith and by that my senses and reason confirm it.
If as you suggest, that my own beliefs don’t stand up to the same standards then you are saying that scripture will not hold up to those standards, because my beliefs are solidly grounded in scripture.
If you had seen Jesus on a dusty road in Galilee, would you have “sensed” the God of all creation in the sweaty man passing you by?

Would you have “reasoned” that He must be the savior of the world based on what you saw or heard or smelled?
 
Friend,

Where is the flaw in this logic?

The Bible [entire Bible] is the Inspired and truth of God.2 Tim. 3:16

God say’s very clearly that “This is MY Body, this is My Blood, I am the Bread of life come down from heaven, TRULY, TRULY my flesh is REAL FOOD and My Blood is Real Drink.” [Mt. 26:26-28, Mk. 14: 22-24, Lk. 22: 19-21, John 6: 40-68, Paul in 1st. Cor. 11: 23-29.]

So God say’s it is true.

Does it not follow then that denial of this truth is in reality denial of God Himself. Dare one call God a liar? :hmmm::signofcross:

Love and prayers,
 
No answer.

Devine revelation tells me that Christ is present in the Eucharist; my senses and reason leave me no reason to doubt what has been handed on.

Chuck
 
When the words of consecration are spoken and the bell(s) ring, my senses tell me that which is dogmatically defined by Sacred Scripture, which comes out of the whole deposit of faith, which is Sacred Tradition, and is authoritatively taught by the Magesterium of the Catholic Church, has indeed happened.

My ability to believe it comes by faith, which is a gift from God. Faith has nothing to do with the senses, natural or spiritual. Faith operates beyond the senses. Once I believe, rational thought can support and sustain faith, but only ontologically and that limited to the existential plane of being. The metaphysical world transcends natural reason. While philosophy may well be the handmaid of theology, one cannot think themselves into faith. They might be able to think themselves into believing, but the demons believe and tremble, yet they have not faith.

In the end I’m on board with Anselm of Canterbury who said, “Seek not to understand that you may believe, but believe that you may understand.” Faith is the beginning of the Wisdom that comes from above.
 
Do your senses and your reasoning suggest to you that the wafer has become Christ?
40.png
myfavoritmartin:
I am both sensible and reasonable, i voted NO
Spoken like a true Pharisee. You see, the Pharisees wanted to kill Jesus because this dirty, poorly dressed son of a carpenter from that backwater Nazareth had the NERVE to call himslef the Son of God, thus making himself equal to God.

Just look at Jesus! Does he LOOK like tyhe Almighty God of Abraham? “Do your senses and your reasoning suggest to you that the carpenter’s son is God?”

Like you, the Pharisees voted NO.

They were wrong. So are you.
 
yeah, one more vote for bad poll here. No my human senses can’t disern that this is the flesh of our Lord. But my reason knows it is. If you can’t accept this, then truely… How can you accept anything else in the bible. Is transubstantiation really more miraculas than say, creating the entirty of the known and unknown universe?
 
Well, my reasoning is that Jesus actually *meant *what He said in John 6:32-71. I tend to take Him at His word. 🤷

Also, given that the early church fathers also believed in the Real Presence, my reasoning tells me that it is *extremely *unlikely that the disciples of the Apostles went so terribly astray so soon after Jesus’ ascension.

As for my senses, I understand that the Real Presence is a supernatural mystery that may not necessarily appeal to my physical senses. However, spiritually, my senses go off like alarm bells during the Consecration. 🙂

Also, my senses can be fooled. Right now, my senses tell me that my favoritmartin is not real because I cannot see, hear, smell, touch, or taste his physical form. Therefore, he must not exist. 🤷 Right?

All in all, I voted “yes.”
 
If you had seen Jesus on a dusty road in Galilee, would you have “sensed” the God of all creation in the sweaty man passing you by?

Would you have “reasoned” that He must be the savior of the world based on what you saw or heard or smelled?
Interesting. Isn’t it also possible that you HAVE seen Jesus (on his second coming) and didn’t recognize him?
 
Friend,

Where is the flaw in this logic?

The Bible [entire Bible] is the Inspired and truth of God.2 Tim. 3:16

God say’s very clearly that “This is MY Body, this is My Blood, I am the Bread of life come down from heaven, TRULY, TRULY my flesh is REAL FOOD and My Blood is Real Drink.” [Mt. 26:26-28, Mk. 14: 22-24, Lk. 22: 19-21, John 6: 40-68, Paul in 1st. Cor. 11: 23-29.]

So God say’s it is true.

Does it not follow then that denial of this truth is in reality denial of God Himself. Dare one call God a liar? :hmmm::signofcross:

Oh please!
First: God didn’t “very clearly” say that. The (human) authors of those books said that. Please be accurate. I could live with the inaccuracy if it wasn’t coupled with such arrogance.
Granted, the majority of posters here are Catholic, obviously, so us “nonbelievers” are in the minority. But even amongst your ‘Catholic’ counterparts, that tone rings awfully haughty.
Really, do you think that tone will convert any non-believers? If you tried that logic while standing outside a mosque, do you think you would convert anyone?
 
If you think i sound like an athiest Mike, you don’t know me well at all.
I’ve been given the gift of faith and by that my senses and reason confirm it.
If as you suggest, that my own beliefs don’t stand up to the same standards then you are saying that scripture will not hold up to those standards, because my beliefs are solidly grounded in scripture.
Pray tell us how your senses “confirm” (not a word you used in your poll, BTW) that Jesus Christ was and is God.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top