sex ed in schools

  • Thread starter Thread starter angell1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

angell1

Guest
frankly, I am quite concerned at what I hear these about what kids are taught in schools regarding this

I went to public school, only graduated 6 years ago and we never had any of this stuff. that was only one talk about not following g strangers because they could potentially take advantage of you and also a talk on puberty and on on the dangers of STI’s. no talk about contraception, no handing out condoms, nothing about various positions etC…

and obviously we studied the reproductive system in grade 12 biology.

I am a bit confused on what should or shouldn’t be allowed in schools though. I definitely agree that the parents should tak about most of that stuff at home.

but what about theology of the body for example, in high school? or the puberty talk and the sti one?

or learning about the reproductive system in biology of anatomy? does the church see any issue with that?

or should we just avoid it all together? not that I know how that would be possible since it seems to be everywhere
 
Students should absolutely learn about reproduction in biology class. Biology is the “study of life” and sexual reproduction is critical for most species, including our own.

I go back and forth on what should be covered in health class. If we’re having a health curriculum then it makes sense to me to cover it, even though the best case scenario is for loving, engaged parents to be teaching a lot of it to their children themselves. I went to public school K-12. In sixth grade we learned the basics of puberty and related personal hygiene (most of which I already knew), in eighth grade we learned about what all that stuff was for (having a baby, we saw a video of live human birth, which IMO was fine.) At that point really it was other kids saying gross things rather than what I was taught in school that was way more problematic.

At some point from 10th-12th grade you had to take a health class that did actually cover contraception and STDs, though abstinence was heavily emphasized. The health class also covered nutrition and exercise, and drug use, and went into some of the more scientific stuff. We did see pictures of what those diseases looked like, which was disturbing, but really solidified for me at least that I didn’t want to be involved in it (even though I wasn’t Catholic at the time and didn’t have much of a moral opinion either way on premarital sex).

Honestly I think for a public school what I had was not bad. I never experienced the worst of what some people have described happening in public school sex ed, and my district always had a dedicated health teacher (so they weren’t bringing in PP or some nonsense). Parents were always notified and some did opt their children out.

I don’t think teaching theology has any place in a public school, although some of the stuff about women’s cycles (that women often first encounter when learning NFP) would have been really amazing to know. We were told “you can get pregnant anytime” which is in most cases false but at the same time, I know why they said it.
 
Pupils in local Catholic schools in this area were taught how to use the various forms of contraception.
 
Students should absolutely learn about reproduction in biology class. Biology is the “study of life” and sexual reproduction is critical for most species, including our own.

I go back and forth on what should be covered in health class. If we’re having a health curriculum then it makes sense to me to cover it, even though the best case scenario is for loving, engaged parents to be teaching a lot of it to their children themselves. I went to public school K-12. In sixth grade we learned the basics of puberty and related personal hygiene (most of which I already knew), in eighth grade we learned about what all that stuff was for (having a baby, we saw a video of live human birth, which IMO was fine.) At that point really it was other kids saying gross things rather than what I was taught in school that was way more problematic.

At some point from 10th-12th grade you had to take a health class that did actually cover contraception and STDs, though abstinence was heavily emphasized. The health class also covered nutrition and exercise, and drug use, and went into some of the more scientific stuff. We did see pictures of what those diseases looked like, which was disturbing, but really solidified for me at least that I didn’t want to be involved in it (even though I wasn’t Catholic at the time and didn’t have much of a moral opinion either way on premarital sex).

Honestly I think for a public school what I had was not bad. I never experienced the worst of what some people have described happening in public school sex ed, and my district always had a dedicated health teacher (so they weren’t bringing in PP or some nonsense). Parents were always notified and some did opt their children out.

I don’t think teaching theology has any place in a public school, although some of the stuff about women’s cycles (that women often first encounter when learning NFP) would have been really amazing to know. We were told “you can get pregnant anytime” which is in most cases false but at the same time, I know why they said it.
sorry, should have clarified.

I was thinking more for catholic schools.
 
Pupils in local Catholic schools in this area were taught how to use the various forms of contraception.
yeah, I’ve heard similar things in my country. not sure why people don’t see a problem with that considering the church’s teachings
 
frankly, I am quite concerned at what I hear these about what kids are taught in schools regarding this

I went to public school, only graduated 6 years ago and we never had any of this stuff. that was only one talk about not following g strangers because they could potentially take advantage of you and also a talk on puberty and on on the dangers of STI’s. no talk about contraception, no handing out condoms, nothing about various positions etC…
At the (secular) school I went to, we had talks about what to do if you are being pressured into having sex by a boyfriend/girlfriend and also by friends. We had another talk about puberty, and we had lessons on different types of contraception, including a lesson in which different leaflets were handed around for us to read, and different types of contraception were shown to us through a box.

At my school in the UK, there was no such thing as a health class, and we had an hour a week of PSHCE lessons (Personal, Social, Health and Citizenship Education). Whenever we had these talks, the boys and girls were separated, with the boys being led by a male teacher/guest speaker and the girls being led by a female teacher/guest speaker. No condoms were ever handed out, and nothing was said regarding the actual sex act.
and obviously we studied the reproductive system in grade 12 biology.
Wikipedia tells me that grade 12 is age 17/18 😛 . At my school, we covered the menstrual cycle and puberty in Biology at age 11/12, and then we went into more detail about hormones and ovulation and puberty at age 15/16. This was done because at my school, Biology wasn’t compulsory after 16. In my Biology classes, the boys and girls learnt together, it was just in the PSHCE classes we were separate.
I am a bit confused on what should or shouldn’t be allowed in schools though. I definitely agree that the parents should tak about most of that stuff at home.
I agree that the parents should talk to their children about it, but the problem is, so many don’t. I had to beg my mother to buy me some bras at age 11, and she only bought me crop tops until she told me I needed a bra. When I had my first period at age 11, (before we had covered the topic in Biology) I was only told “Don’t worry about it, I won’t happen again for a few months”, and “You need to use this”. I would have known a lot less had my friend not lent me a book telling me why it was happening.
but what about theology of the body for example, in high school? or the puberty talk and the sti one?
I agree with pensmama87 that theology shouldn’t be taught in secular schools, but my friend did learn about NFP in her Philosophy and Ethics class at age 15.

The STI talk was different in my school because it was one of the few sex education lessons the boys and the girls had together.
or learning about the reproductive system in biology of anatomy? does the church see any issue with that?
I don’t see why the Church would have an issue with people learning about the reproductive system - it’s necessary to know to be able to do NFP! 😃
or should we just avoid it all together? not that I know how that would be possible since it seems to be everywhere
Avoiding sex education would be a bad decision. Not all parents would talk to their children and explain to them, and children/teenagers can still get the wrong ideas, and need to be corrected. In my opinion, ignoring sex ed would only cause more problems - more teen pregnancies and more STIs and STDs, for example.

I know you’re asking for Catholic schools, but I think the principle is the same. The reproductive system needs to be learnt, and STIs/STDs need to be discussed as well, along with puberty. I would say that contraception should be discussed, not said “use this when you want to have sex”, but more knowing about the different types. Obviously, a Catholic school wouldn’t teach “use this when you have sex” :p, but knowing the different types of contraception and knowing how they work makes it easier to explain why the Church is against it.

Lou
 
Pupils in local Catholic schools in this area were taught how to use the various forms of contraception.
If you have first hand knowledge of that I’d send a letter to the education office of your diocese. Sometimes reports of what was actually taught/said are wildly exaggerated. But these days, you never know…
 
Students should absolutely learn about reproduction in biology class. Biology is the “study of life” and sexual reproduction is critical for most species, including our own.

I go back and forth on what should be covered in health class. If we’re having a health curriculum then it makes sense to me to cover it, even though the best case scenario is for loving, engaged parents to be teaching a lot of it to their children themselves. I went to public school K-12. In sixth grade we learned the basics of puberty and related personal hygiene (most of which I already knew), in eighth grade we learned about what all that stuff was for (having a baby, we saw a video of live human birth, which IMO was fine.) At that point really it was other kids saying gross things rather than what I was taught in school that was way more problematic.

At some point from 10th-12th grade you had to take a health class that did actually cover contraception and STDs, though abstinence was heavily emphasized. The health class also covered nutrition and exercise, and drug use, and went into some of the more scientific stuff. We did see pictures of what those diseases looked like, which was disturbing, but really solidified for me at least that I didn’t want to be involved in it (even though I wasn’t Catholic at the time and didn’t have much of a moral opinion either way on premarital sex).

Honestly I think for a public school what I had was not bad. I never experienced the worst of what some people have described happening in public school sex ed, and my district always had a dedicated health teacher (so they weren’t bringing in PP or some nonsense). Parents were always notified and some did opt their children out.

I don’t think teaching theology has any place in a public school, although some of the stuff about women’s cycles (that women often first encounter when learning NFP) would have been really amazing to know. We were told “you can get pregnant anytime” which is in most cases false but at the same time, I know why they said it.
This is VERY similar to what our current public school kids are taught. They get TOB in religoius education. I have no problem with either.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top