SF students without vaccinations barred from class

  • Thread starter Thread starter TheTrueCentrist
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Can you please provide a reference to your statement with emphasis on the vaccines that required for admission a California public school.
Vaccines derived from aborted children:

christianpatriot.com/vaccines.htm

Vaccines required by California Schools:

sduhsd.net/tp/immunization.html

Comparing the two lists, you can see that there are no US approved alternatives for Rubella.

I’m not sure on Hep B or Varicella.

I hope that helps.

Pax and God Bless.
 
I agree with the principle that you try to express through this statement; however, we must make sure that we do not allow for what you call “physical evil” by neglect. Failing to protect the innocent, when possible, is not a moral action either.
I think I agree with what you are trying to say as well, but would ammend your statement to:

Failing to protect the innocent, when possible IN A MORAL MANNER, is not a moral actio neither.

One can not combat sin, by committing sin.

Pax and God Bless.
 
Vaccines derived from aborted children:

christianpatriot.com/vaccines.htm

Vaccines required by California Schools:

sduhsd.net/tp/immunization.html

Comparing the two lists, you can see that there are no US approved alternatives for Rubella.

I’m not sure on Hep B or Varicella.

I hope that helps.

Pax and God Bless.
In the first link there is a generic statement that says"U.S. Vaccines Derived From Abortion". I think that you have to specify what derived from abortion really means. There is a huge difference between a direct derivative and a remote derivative. Just look at the case of rubella, the vaccine work was a consequence of the abortion and the abortion was not caused because of the search for a vaccine. The primary concept is not to do evil even for a good outcome; however, we must remember that out of every evil there is a greater good. We are not to renounce the greater good because it came from evil, if that were true than we should reach the extreme case of aborting babies that were conceived because of sinful habits. If the Church says that we can do something that means that we are either not cooperating with sin or that we are choosing the lesser of two evils. The Church will never teach us that is fine to give free assent to sin.

My point is that if we have a vaccine that was developed from aborted babies and now its production does not call for abortion then it is not immoral to use it. However, if to ensure its production you need aborted fetuses then it is immoral to use that vaccine because we are really creating a demand and a rationalization for abortion.
 
In the first link there is a generic statement that says"U.S. Vaccines Derived From Abortion". I think that you have to specify what derived from abortion really means. There is a huge difference between a direct derivative and a remote derivative. Just look at the case of rubella, the vaccine work was a consequence of the abortion and the abortion was not caused because of the search for a vaccine. The primary concept is not to do evil even for a good outcome; however, we must remember that out of every evil there is a greater good. We are not to renounce the greater good because it came from evil, if that were true than we should reach the extreme case of aborting babies that were conceived because of sinful habits. If the Church says that we can do something that means that we are either not cooperating with sin or that we are choosing the lesser of two evils. The Church will never teach us that is fine to give free assent to sin.

My point is that if we have a vaccine that was developed from aborted babies and now its production does not call for abortion then it is not immoral to use it. However, if to ensure its production you need aborted fetuses then it is immoral to use that vaccine because we are really creating a demand and a rationalization for abortion.
The “the evil is already done” argument has never been very convincing to me. Have you ever seen one of the lampshades the Nazis made from the skin of people murdered in the concentration camps? Or the socks made from their hair?

Would you have such a lampshade in your house? You need light- and the person is already dead anyway. What about the socks? Your feat need to stay warm, and the evil act has already been committed. You using the lamp or the socks doesn’t automatically mean anyone else will be killed or oppressed.

Pax
 
However, in this situation, the aspect of passive cooperation is that which stands out most. It is up to the faithful and citizens of upright conscience (fathers of families, doctors, etc.) to oppose, even by making an objection of conscience, the ever more widespread attacks against life and the “culture of death” which underlies them. From this point of view, the use of vaccines whose production is connected with procured abortion constitutes at least a mediate remote passive material cooperation to the abortion, and an immediate passive material cooperation with regard to their marketing. Furthermore, on a cultural level, the use of such vaccines contributes in the creation of a generalized social consensus to the operation of the pharmaceutical industries which produce them in an immoral way.
Therefore, doctors and fathers of families have a duty to take recourse to alternative vaccines13 (if they exist), putting pressure on the political authorities and health systems so that other vaccines without moral problems become available. They should take recourse, if necessary, to the use of conscientious objection 14 with regard to the use of vaccines produced by means of cell lines of aborted human foetal origin. Equally, they should oppose by all means (in writing, through the various associations, mass media, etc.) the vaccines which do not yet have morally acceptable alternatives, creating pressure so that alternative vaccines are prepared, which are not connected with the abortion of a human foetus, and requesting rigorous legal control of the pharmaceutical industry producers.
**As regards the diseases against which there are no alternative vaccines which are available and ethically acceptable, it is right to abstain from using these vaccines if it can be done without causing children, and indirectly the population as a whole, to undergo significant risks to their health. However, if the latter are exposed to considerable dangers to their health, vaccines with moral problems pertaining to them may also be used on a temporary basis. **The moral reason is that the duty to avoid passive material cooperation is not obligatory if there is grave inconvenience. Moreover, we find, in such a case, a. proportional reason, in order to accept the use of these vaccines in the presence of the danger of favouring the spread of the pathological agent, due to the lack of vaccination of children. This is particularly true in the case of vaccination against German measles15.
In any case, there remains a moral duty to continue to fight and to employ every lawful means in order to make life difficult for the pharmaceutical industries which act unscrupulously and unethically. However, the burden of this important battle cannot and must not fall on innocent children and on the health situation of the population - especially with regard to pregnant women.
This is the key part of the Vatican statement. It says the temprorary use of such vaccines MAY be permissable if not using them would put children and the population at significant health risk. Otherwise, it would be right to ABSTAIN from using such vaccines.

The document makes no judgement on whether or not that health risk does or does not exist. I think it could be quite possible that it might exist in some circumstances and not in others. Someone in a country such as the United States with a relatively advanced hygiene and sanitation may not be at risk while someone in a country with poor hygiene and sanitation such as China could be. There are also reasonable arguments to be made that use of such vaccines does itself put the population in danger of health problems by creating “super bugs” that are resistant to the vaccines.

It’s not as clear cut and dried as many pro-vaccine folks seem to say. If those who refuse the vaccines were putting their children at great health risk, one might expect to see a large number of sick unvaccinated children as evidence. As far as I am aware, that data doesn’t exist, because unvaccinated children aren’t more sickly than the vaccinated ones.

The Church has said such vaccines MAY be permitted in specific circumstances XYZ. It has not said that everyone, everywhere is living under specific circumstances XYZ. Furthermore, it has said if you are NOT living in those circumstances, then it is right NOT to use the vaccines in question.

Pax.
 
The “the evil is already done” argument has never been very convincing to me. Have you ever seen one of the lampshades the Nazis made from the skin of people murdered in the concentration camps? Or the socks made from their hair?

Would you have such a lampshade in your house? You need light- and the person is already dead anyway. What about the socks? Your feat need to stay warm, and the evil act has already been committed. You using the lamp or the socks doesn’t automatically mean anyone else will be killed or oppressed.

Pax
Are you enjoying the benefits of living in a country that has been taken over through violence and lack of respect of treaties that were imposed on other people? Are you enjoying benefits from living in a country that was developed also through the systematic and immoral exploitation of people?

My point is that there is nothing intrinsically wrong in taking advantage of a good that comes out of an evil action. The problem is that it becomes immoral for us to take advantage of that good if by doing so we will create a realistic occasion to further sin. We must also remember that when we must choose the least between evils we are still doing something immoral but our culpability is diminished.
 
Are you enjoying the benefits of living in a country that has been taken over through violence and lack of respect of treaties that were imposed on other people? Are you enjoying benefits from living in a country that was developed also through the systematic and immoral exploitation of people?
You’d have to be more specific on what you mean.

For example, if you are referring to someone like Cortez “systematically exploiting people”, people often overlook the fact that a great many Indians FLOCKED to Cortez, because he saved them from the Aztecs who were sacrificing human beings on their altars.

So I need to know what you are referring to, before I agree to the basis of your question that I’m living in such a country.

I will fully agree that there is violence and evil in the past and the present of the United States though. The thing is, I can’t think of any other country that doesn’t have violence and evil in it’s past and present. I have to live somewhere, and I am working on making the place I live a more holy one.

I don’t have to use vaccines derived from murdered children. Abstaining is an option. Abstaining from living someplace is not an option. (Suicide is a mortal sin). So I don’t think your comparison is a good one.

Pax.
 
You’d have to be more specific on what you mean.

For example, if you are referring to someone like Cortez “systematically exploiting people”, people often overlook the fact that a great many Indians FLOCKED to Cortez, because he saved them from the Aztecs who were sacrificing human beings on their altars…
I was really thinking at people that used slaves, that exploited people in railroad construction, in mines, in foundries etc.
…I will fully agree that there is violence and evil in the past and the present of the United States though. The thing is, I can’t think of any other country that doesn’t have violence and evil in it’s past and present. I have to live somewhere, and I am working on making the place I live a more holy one…
I understand what you are saying but don’t you think that if we follow that logic we would also have a direct obligation to make reparation.
…I don’t have to use vaccines derived from murdered children. Abstaining is an option. Abstaining from living someplace is not an option. (Suicide is a mortal sin). So I don’t think your comparison is a good one.

Pax.
You do not have use vaccines but you have a moral obligation to protect the well being of other people especially your children.

I added to my post while you were writing this but I am going to elaborate more on my point. In a lot of cases vaccination can only be the choice between two evils and often choosing the least of the two does not yield the same answer for everybody because our behaviors are really to be judged on the action, the intent, and the circumstances. We follow a categorical form of belief but we must remember that it does not negate some form of utilitarianism, and that is proven by the fact that we must grow in virtue to make the right call.
 
I was really thinking at people that used slaves, that exploited people in railroad construction, in mines, in foundries etc.

I understand what you are saying but don’t you think that if we follow that logic we would also have a direct obligation to make reparation.

You do not have use vaccines but you have a moral obligation to protect the well being of other people especially your children.

I added to my post while you were writing this but I am going to elaborate more on my point. In a lot of cases vaccination can only be the choice between two evils and often choosing the least of the two does not yield the same answer for everybody because our behaviors are really to be judged on the action, the intent, and the circumstances. We follow a categorical form of belief but we must remember that it does not negate some form of utilitarianism, and that is proven by the fact that we must grow in virtue to make the right call.
Your comments are well thought out.

I still think no one has established that in the United States in 2011, not vacinating your children with the vaccines derived from aborted children, places that child or society at a significant health risk. Health is impacted by a wide array of factors, nutrition, sanitation, prayer, family life, adequate clothing and shelter, and on and on. Vaccines pose health risks of their own, up to and including death for at least some vaccines. More and more people are not vaccinating their children. Has this led to an increase danger to public health? It’s hard to say. One can argue that it hasn’t, or one can argue that it has, but the bulk of people who are still being vaccinated are protecting the unvaccinated. What I am trying to say is that the supposed benefit of using the vaccines, which we are only permitted to use if failing to do so would put the population at a significant risk, does not seem clear. And in order for me to even consider taking a step that DOES encourage a culture of death, we need that CLEAR evidence.

PAX
 
Your comments are well thought out.

I still think no one has established that in the United States in 2011, not vacinating your children with the vaccines derived from aborted children, places that child or society at a significant health risk. Health is impacted by a wide array of factors, nutrition, sanitation, prayer, family life, adequate clothing and shelter, and on and on. Vaccines pose health risks of their own, up to and including death for at least some vaccines. More and more people are not vaccinating their children. Has this led to an increase danger to public health? It’s hard to say. One can argue that it hasn’t, or one can argue that it has, but the bulk of people who are still being vaccinated are protecting the unvaccinated. What I am trying to say is that the supposed benefit of using the vaccines, which we are only permitted to use if failing to do so would put the population at a significant risk, does not seem clear. And in order for me to even consider taking a step that DOES encourage a culture of death, we need that CLEAR evidence.

PAX
I think that the common good for vaccination has been proved by history, just look at smallpox and polio. The risk of a loss is outweighed by the rewards, here I am talking about side effects and not abortion. Epidemiology is a clear scientific method to assess this situations and ignoring it is choosing to be ignorant. However, I do not think that this does automatically imply that it is a moral thing. I am not an utilitarian and I think that the category of killing an innocent cannot be overridden.

Saying that someone is protected because others are vaccinated is a false assumption both from an epidemiological point of view and from a moral one. The epidemiological one says that most of these diseases are still around and that we can have healthy carriers too, it also says that vaccines have non-zero failure rate. That is why the statistics of vaccination relies on the strength of combined probabilities.

The moral argument also shows a fallacy because we cannot say that we can choose to do what is moral because (as long as) other people choose to do something immoral and we are still safe. This is an immoral way of thinking because it implicitly relies on the wish that someone else is going to do something immoral.
 
I think that the common good for vaccination has been proved by history, just look at smallpox and polio. The risk of a loss is outweighed by the rewards, here I am talking about side effects and not abortion. Epidemiology is a clear scientific method to assess this situations and ignoring it is choosing to be ignorant. However, I do not think that this does automatically imply that it is a moral thing. I am not an utilitarian and I think that the category of killing an innocent cannot be overridden.

Saying that someone is protected because others are vaccinated is a false assumption both from an epidemiological point of view and from a moral one. The epidemiological one says that most of these diseases are still around and that we can have healthy carriers too, it also says that vaccines have non-zero failure rate. That is why the statistics of vaccination relies on the strength of combined probabilities.

The moral argument also shows a fallacy because we cannot say that we can choose to do what is moral because (as long as) other people choose to do something immoral and we are still safe. This is an immoral way of thinking because it implicitly relies on the wish that someone else is going to do something immoral.
I agree it would make no sense to not vaccinate your children because you thought it was immoral, but hope others would. That’s not what I am advocating. I was simply referencing the current fact, that we live in a population that is mixed- some vaccinated, some not. So drawing conclusions about the health of that population based upon vaccinating or not vaccinating is difficult, because the population is mixed, as well as all of the other factors that play into public health. My understanding from speaking with many doctors and nurses over my life, is that doing a good job washing your hands will do more to protect you from disease than any vaccine.

The historical argument that certain diseases have declined as vaccination has become more widespread is problematic as well, because vaccination is not the only variable at play. Public sanitation has improved improved for one thing. Public health has not universally “gotten better” either, we have high rates of mental illness, cancer, an obesity “epidemic”, etc. Of course one can not lay the blame for all of these things squarely at the feet of vaccination either, because again- there are lots of variables. People today are exposed to far more radiation then folks of a 100 years ago. They live more sedentary lives. They eat more junk food. The majority of American women use some form of chemical contraception, and many have had an abortion. Our society is in spiritual decline, families are broken, etc, etc. There are lots of things going on which can impact health positively or negatively. There are a lot of things we can form educated opinions on, but don’t have hard and fast data.

One thing we do have hard and fast data, on is that some vaccines are derived from murdered children, and murder is a mortal sin.

Pax and God Bless.
 
I think what one of our priorities must be as Catholics is education regarding this issue. Most people can’t even weigh the decision of what is the lesser evil- using an imoral vaccine, or not, because they don’t know the vaccines are derived from aborted children.

I didn’t until a year or two ago.

If everyone did know, then there is at least the chance, of the public demanding a change in the situation- using alternative vaccines availabe in Japan or Europe which are NOT derived from aborted children, for example.

This is why it’s important for us to discuss the topic more than saying “the Vatican has spoken, move on”. Doing that misses the point of what the Church said. Because even IF, the risk of not using the vaccines is significant enough, the Church tells us that they may then only be used TEMPORARILY, until we are succesful in getting the situation changed.

Pax.
 
I think what one of our priorities must be as Catholics is education regarding this issue. Most people can’t even weigh the decision of what is the lesser evil- using an imoral vaccine, or not, because they don’t know the vaccines are derived from aborted children.

I didn’t until a year or two ago.

If everyone did know, then there is at least the chance, of the public demanding a change in the situation- using alternative vaccines availabe in Japan or Europe which are NOT derived from aborted children, for example.

This is why it’s important for us to discuss the topic more than saying “the Vatican has spoken, move on”. Doing that misses the point of what the Church said. Because even IF, the risk of not using the vaccines is significant enough, the Church tells us that they may then only be used TEMPORARILY, until we are successful in getting the situation changed.

Pax.
I completely agree with you on this, and I think that not taking action to inform people and ask for change it is immoral because it creates a demand and a rationalization for the present status.
 
I completely agree with you on this, and I think that not taking action to inform people and ask for change it is immoral because it creates a demand and a rationalization for the present status.
Ok, so even if one arrives at the conclusion that such vaccines are permissible where one lives, based on Church teaching (which as I’ve pointed out the Church has said is POSSIBLE, not CERTAIN), any answer given to the question along the lines of “yes, the vaccines are permitted, the Church says so”, MUST be accompanied by something along the lines of “but use of these vaccines is cooperation with evil and promotes a culture of death, we have a duty to do what we can to change things so the vaccines are no longer used”.

I appreciate your thoughtful comments and reasonableness and courtesy. Have a great day and God Bless!

Pax!
 
Same in Kansas. For a child to attend a licensed daycare the parents have to present documentation that all vaccinations are current.

I figured in California they’d be requiring that all girls be vaccinated for HPV by third grade.
Even a dog must be vaccinated to be licensed or boarded. Why do we treat our children worse than dogs? I don’t think kids are engaging in oral sex until 4th or 5th grade, so HPV in 3rd might be premature. As we know from a past president, oral sex is not sexual relations.
 
Even a dog must be vaccinated to be licensed or boarded. Why do we treat our children worse than dogs? I don’t think kids are engaging in oral sex until 4th or 5th grade, so HPV in 3rd might be premature. As we know from a past president, oral sex is not sexual relations.
Dogs are property and the vaccination laws are not for the protection of the recipients at all. The laws concerning vaccinations are due to protect the property and well being of others. Children are not property and the laws that mandate vaccinations are first for the well being of the recipients and then for the well being of the people in general.
 
Dogs are property and the vaccination laws are not for the protection of the recipients at all. The laws concerning vaccinations are due to protect the property and well being of others. Children are not property and the laws that mandate vaccinations are first for the well being of the recipients and then for the well being of the people in general.
Have you ever seen a rabid animal? It is humane to vaccinate with them. It is also a public health issue, just as it is with children. It is also more humane to vaccinate a child. If you don’t believe me, ask anyone who has known someone with polio. Children are not property, but they are under the control and responsibility of their parents on health matters. If a child were given the choice of having an intramuscular injection or not, I think I can guess what most would choose.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top