Should I Baby-Sit the Child of Lesbians?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Weltschmerz
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
W

Weltschmerz

Guest
I am a college student who baby-sits a lot in my community, and was asked by two “wives” to baby-sit their child. I would like to say yes-- the child is obviously innocent and has nothing to do with the situation so I see no problem in baby-sitting him. But I am not comfortable with the women’s lifestyle, so would I be condoning it in a way by sitting for a same-sex household?
 
I am a college student who baby-sits a lot in my community, and was asked by two “wives” to baby-sit their child. I would like to say yes-- the child is obviously innocent and has nothing to do with the situation so I see no problem in baby-sitting him. But I am not comfortable with the women’s lifestyle, so would I be condoning it in a way by sitting for a same-sex household?
While yes, the child is innocent in this ordeal, the women are not. Offering to sit is enabling their immoral lifestyle. I wouldn’t be complicit in it. But that’s just me.
 
Actually, I think it might be an opportunity to help the little one, and maybe even the two “wives” …assuming your faith is very strong and you are able to keep “His Armor” on well.
Maybe this would be a good thing to take to spiritual direction…
 
I’ve babysat for the children of many couples I felt were living lives outside of God’s teachings. The sins of the parents are not the sins of the child.

I would however let them know your beliefs and ask if they are sure they want you to babysit their child. Most parents I’ve sat for have appreciated my candor in telling them my belief system differed from theirs and that I didn’t want to be in a position of influence if they were not comfortable with that. I remember an Atheist couple saying they were glad I told them that I was a Christian and would respond to their child’s questions AS a Christian and that they were absolutely OK with that.

God bless
 
Obviously two wives cannot produce a child, so there is a man in the equation somewhere. At some point the child will figure this out and wonder about its daddy. That’s the sad part. As for babysitting, I’m undecided. You might be a positive influence in the child’s life.
 
I’ve babysat for the children of many couples I felt were living lives outside of God’s teachings. The sins of the parents are not the sins of the child.

I would however let them know your beliefs and ask if they are sure they want you to babysit their child. Most parents I’ve sat for have appreciated my candor in telling them my belief system differed from theirs and that I didn’t want to be in a position of influence if they were not comfortable with that. I remember an Atheist couple saying they were glad I told them that I was a Christian and would respond to their child’s questions AS a Christian and that they were absolutely OK with that.

God bless
I support this, that you should be upfront with the women before you start. Caring for a child is an honest living; the guardian’s lifestyle doesn’t really affect this, but could complicate the arrangement if communication isn’t honest.
 
Would you babysit the child if the mother was a functioning alcoholic? A single mom by choice? A single lesbian mother? A liar? An adulterer?

Are you yourself without sin?
 
Would you babysit the child if the mother was a functioning alcoholic? A single mom by choice? A single lesbian mother? A liar? An adulterer?

Are you yourself without sin?
Associating with open sinfulness often leads to more sinfulness. There is truth to the saying “One bad apple spoils the bunch”. Some people go into situations like this with the intention of being a “positive model or influence” and come out worse on the other end. Unless you are very strong in your faith, I would avoid the situation of colluding with an openly sinful situation.
 
Associating with open sinfulness often leads to more sinfulness. There is truth to the saying “One bad apple spoils the bunch”. Some people go into situations like this with the intention of being a “positive model or influence” and come out worse on the other end. Unless you are very strong in your faith, I would avoid the situation of colluding with an openly sinful situation.
If I were to take this advice I would almost have to lock my doors and windows, shut the blinds and cut my self off from the human race. Worst of all I wouldn’t even be able to talk to myself.

To my knowledge only Jesus and Mary were without sin.

God bless
 
Fifty years ago, I was the kid faithful Catholics were wondering about because my parents weren’t married and my father took off before I was born. Family friends and realtives, Catholics all, had a good number of conversations about the morality of my “situation,” how sad it was that I was likely to turn out “just like my mother,” if it was sinful to let their kids play with me, would they be sinning if I went to their house, if I should be allowed to attend Catholic school, etc. Many of these talks occured right in front of me, as if my out-of-wedlock birth made me somehow immune to harsh words.

My first grade teacher, a sister, stood me in front of our class and told my classsmates that I was a “bastard.” She then went on to explain what that word meant. She told them they would be sinning if they played with me at reces. This was a small town, everybody knew everybody. She told them my father’s name, which is how I learned it, and told them that my mother had always been “loose.” All this to six-year-olds. Yeah.

So, from where I’m sitting I’d much rather see kids and their parents accepted. Just accepted. No pity. No condemnation. No judgement, which seems to be a favorite activity of people who think they live in Moral HIghgroundsville. Just accepted.

Babysit for 'em.
 
Wow, Karow… that is some story! Yet you became/stayed a Catholic nonetheless. Many would have fled the Church from such an experience.

(And my opinion for the OP, for what its worth, is to babysit - if you only sit for the sinless, you won’t have much work. I can guarantee that lesbianism is not contagious in the least.)
 
I am a college student who baby-sits a lot in my community, and was asked by two “wives” to baby-sit their child. I would like to say yes-- the child is obviously innocent and has nothing to do with the situation so I see no problem in baby-sitting him. But I am not comfortable with the women’s lifestyle, so would I be condoning it in a way by sitting for a same-sex household?
Would you be watching the child in your home or theirs? If their lifestyle makes you uncomfortable, you may be even more uncomfortable in their home. In which case, you can politely decline the work. There is nothing inherently wrong with caring for their child; it’s more a question of do you want the work under the conditions that will be present? By the same token you shouldn’t feel compelled to accept the work out of some sense of correctness.
Would you babysit the child if the mother was a functioning alcoholic? A single mom by choice? A single lesbian mother? A liar? An adulterer?

Are you yourself without sin?
Completely irrelevant. The babysitter’s relative sinlessness has no bearing on the decision to babysit. The only question is whether she would be comfortable doing so.

As for me, to your questions: maybe, yes, no, no and not if I knew about it. 🙂
 
I agree with those who said who are we to judge this couple? If they asked you to babysit their child and you feel comfortable doing it, then do it.
 
We all are praying with you for those three people. Babysit, pray over the child.

I don’t know if you can do a “secret” baptism as a lay person or not. :confused:

work on building a relationship, so you can be a positive influnce.
 
I am a college student who baby-sits a lot in my community, and was asked by two “wives” to baby-sit their child. I would like to say yes-- the child is obviously innocent and has nothing to do with the situation so I see no problem in baby-sitting him. But I am not comfortable with the women’s lifestyle, so would I be condoning it in a way by sitting for a same-sex household?
What is the age of the child?
 

We all are praying with you for those three people. Babysit, pray over the child.
I don’t know if you can do a “secret” baptism as a lay person or not.
work on building a relationship, so you can be a positive influnce.
Tell me would you be comfortable with say a Mormon rebaptizing your child in secret while they baby-sat?

As for the OP, if your comfortable enough I suppose. Honestly I find it so bizarre that people are going the “we are all sinners” talk and then at the same time try to fight gay marriage.
 
Associating with open sinfulness often leads to more sinfulness. There is truth to the saying “One bad apple spoils the bunch”. Some people go into situations like this with the intention of being a “positive model or influence” and come out worse on the other end. Unless you are very strong in your faith, I would avoid the situation of colluding with an openly sinful situation.
Umm, unless the OP has homosexual tendencies, I really doubt that she could come out influenced by the lifestyle of two lesbians.

The child is innocent. It’s not “enabling” to ensure that the immediate needs of a child are taken care of.

I would simply babysit, be kind to the child and the couple, and not pass judgment.

I work for a major corporation, and it has an open and very liberal policy on LBGT issues. Should I quit my job as well??? The world is filled with sinfulness, and we are ALL guilty of something.
 
Fifty years ago, I was the kid faithful Catholics were wondering about because my parents weren’t married and my father took off before I was born. Family friends and realtives, Catholics all, had a good number of conversations about the morality of my “situation,” how sad it was that I was likely to turn out “just like my mother,” if it was sinful to let their kids play with me, would they be sinning if I went to their house, if I should be allowed to attend Catholic school, etc. Many of these talks occured right in front of me, as if my out-of-wedlock birth made me somehow immune to harsh words.

My first grade teacher, a sister, stood me in front of our class and told my classsmates that I was a “bastard.” She then went on to explain what that word meant. She told them they would be sinning if they played with me at reces. This was a small town, everybody knew everybody. She told them my father’s name, which is how I learned it, and told them that my mother had always been “loose.” All this to six-year-olds. Yeah.

So, from where I’m sitting I’d much rather see kids and their parents accepted. Just accepted. No pity. No condemnation. No judgement, which seems to be a favorite activity of people who think they live in Moral HIghgroundsville. Just accepted.

Babysit for 'em.
Oh my gosh, are you SERIOUS???

This is positively AWFUL! I am so sorry you had to go through that… :(:(😦
 
Fifty years ago, I was the kid faithful Catholics were wondering about because my parents weren’t married and my father took off before I was born. Family friends and realtives, Catholics all, had a good number of conversations about the morality of my “situation,” how sad it was that I was likely to turn out “just like my mother,” if it was sinful to let their kids play with me, would they be sinning if I went to their house, if I should be allowed to attend Catholic school, etc. Many of these talks occured right in front of me, as if my out-of-wedlock birth made me somehow immune to harsh words.

My first grade teacher, a sister, stood me in front of our class and told my classsmates that I was a “bastard.” She then went on to explain what that word meant. She told them they would be sinning if they played with me at reces. This was a small town, everybody knew everybody. She told them my father’s name, which is how I learned it, and told them that my mother had always been “loose.” All this to six-year-olds. Yeah.

So, from where I’m sitting I’d much rather see kids and their parents accepted. Just accepted. No pity. No condemnation. No judgement, which seems to be a favorite activity of people who think they live in Moral HIghgroundsville. Just accepted.

Babysit for 'em.
Karow, it s like you just told my life-story. Sorry to hear about what you went through, sucks doesn’t it? Your faith is stronger than mine, that’s for sure.

OP, I think the child could do with having someone like yourself in their life, if for nothing but to at least to demonstrate to others how a devout Catholic handles situations like these. One cannot blame non-Christians for thinking we hate the LGBT community if we isolate ourselves from them completely and only focus on the negative.

Ultimately It is up to you but it is not a sin for you to do it and I personally encourage it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top