Should I be watching this?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Krisvee
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
K

Krisvee

Guest
I’ve been wanting to know this for quite a while.

I have been watching a Japanese franchise called Kamen Rider that started all the way back in 1971.

The original show was about Takeshi Hongo who was kidnapped by the evil organization, Shocker, to be turned into a cyborg. Shocker meant for Hongo to be their weapon, but he turned their own technology against them in order to uphold justice and protect the world. Since then, Kamen Riders are still using the powers of monsters as protectors of humanity.

Hiroshi Fujiyoka has quoted saying:

“There’s a Shocker in everyone. It’s a hero who notices it for themselves, fights it, and overcomes it.”

This is to say that heroes grow from their mistakes and downfalls. Whatever monster you have within does not make you a monster. A hero uses what they have to do something worthwhile.

Even though it looks like a typical hero show, its premise is a nuanced take on what it means to be a hero, blurring the line between hero and monster. Kamen Riders can be heroes, but their powers also make them the same in some ways to the monsters they fight. Sometimes, fellow Kamen Riders are even the villains. Each show offers new lessons and new statements to make on the world, sometimes going so far as to comment on politics and war.

Some Rider shows are episodic, some are intense character dramas, and some comment on the human condition. In the end, it always comes back to protecting people and becoming something more than the monsters that the Kamen Riders share their powers with. It always comes back to making the world a better place and becoming a hero.

Some examples are Kamen Rider Fourze that focuses on friendship and an intense determination to help others work through their insecurities. It’s also about helping others feel accepted even if those people are considered outcasts. Kamen Rider Faiz, is a story about heroes whose powers come from a phone and yet serves as an ironically cautionary tale about communicating properly with the people you care about. Kamen Rider Ex-Aid, while video game themed, is about setting aside differences to work together for the benefit of everyone. Kamen Rider Build is about the importance of love and peace because even the most miraculous advancements can be corrupted and twisted into something evil or violent when you lose sight of those values.

They are meant to be the best of humanity, often coming from someone who otherwise would have been a completely average person. They are characters who face the worst the (supernatural) world can throw at them and who still come out finding a way to make the world better in light of that.

Accepting others for who they are and standing up for the freedoms of others, even just their right to do what makes them happy, is a big part of what Kamen Rider demonstrates year after year. It teaches to stick up for others, to do what we can because we have a responsibility to, as well as to simply be kind. It teaches us to be the best versions of us we can be and to take our weak points and grow from them. It teaches us not to let the Shocker within ourselves win.

That being said… is this something that I, as a Catholic, should watch?
 
Last edited:
Just to be sure, I don’t want any smoke or anything. I’m trying to keep this as civil as possible without stepping on any toes.
 
And may I ask why I shouldn’t?
The only thing you should never watch is pornography. The Church has not banned you from watching any other type of movie or tv show so don’t let an individual tell you what you cannot watch.
 
The only thing you should never watch is pornography. The Church has not banned you from watching any other type of movie or tv show so don’t let an individual tell you what you cannot watch.
What I’m pointing out is that these heroes are using powers that are inherently evil to do good. i.e. They are using the weapon of the enemy against said enemy, to do good. I’m asking whether or not I should watch it because of that.
 
It’s fiction, there’s nothing wrong with watching it. But if it bothers you, don’t.
 
What I’m pointing out is that these heroes are using powers that are inherently evil to do good. i.e. They are using the weapon of the enemy against said enemy, to do good. I’m asking whether or not I should watch it because of that.
It’s fiction. It’s entertainment. You are free to choose to watch it or not. The Church has no position on this.
 
You spent a lengthy post detailing a show that you are unsure if the morality of. Then asked an opinion. My opinion is that your time , as a Catholic, should be better spent on Holy things.
 
Hahahahahahahahahahaha!!!

It’d be nice to hear your reasoning behind such a sweeping condemnation as this. Avoid anything Japanese? Thank goodness some of the great missionaries to Japan didn’t agree with you there.

Japanese stories can come across as odd to Westerners who haven’t made any effort to understand the culture that gave rise to those stories. But once you dabble your toes a little bit in their cultural world, their stories make more sense.

Personally, I’ve come across several Japanese anime with incredible (and highly engaging) story lines, some of them bring up very interesting moral quandaries not explored in Western literature (at least, not that I’ve found). The anime “Death Note” leaps immediately to mind.
 
So a Catholic should only consume explicitly Catholic media? That’s pretty extreme.
It is rather extreme. I remember reading Pope Benedict stating somewhere (wish I could remember where) when speaking of literature that we all need to find a story that we can get caught up in.

Catholics aren’t required to read only explicitly “holy” things. A good story, well told, can help a person grow in the natural virtues in ways that an academic or theological treatise on the natural virtues simply can’t.
 
They’re a dying pagan nation with a high suicide rate and low birth rates. Their media reflects such and should be shunned.
Japanese people are loved by God as much as anybody else in the world. You may not agree with some cultural aspects but please tell me about a nation that never had anything less than great in his history and culture.
Plus, have you ever wondered how off putting is your comment to people of Japanese ancestry reading your post? Hint… there are, and more than one…
 
That doesn’t mean he/she can’t learn about other cultures by exploring the stories those cultures tell.
 
Japanese people are loved by God as much as anybody else in the world
Never said otherwise. But their popular media, at least what tends to make it to the west, is cancerous to the soul. Weebs are cringiest people on earth, and it’s better to avoid such content all together. . . .
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top