Should I Break Things Off?

  • Thread starter Thread starter waanju
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I think you’re making way too much about “breaking up”.
If he goes away to a monastery or a seminary you’re broken up.
If you are apart and not dating openly, you’re broken up.
By pressuring him to “choose” you are appearing to be kind of selfish. If he leaves, he might not come back to you again if he feels like you manipulated him in to choosing, and I gather you want him to return to you.
Better to keep a friend. If it turns into more someday, great.
But if you care about him, you’ll just drop it.
Be cordial. But don’t force his hand.
Well, we’ve been dating openly for quite a while. Right now, the reason that we haven’t seen much of one another is that we’re on summer vacation from school, which puts us at quite the distance from each other. I think some sort of conversation needs to happen, because in our microculture, there are all sorts of traditions and everyday activities associated with “going steady”. He said he wanted me to act the same as before… Which I assume would include all those things. (Stuff like where people sit at Mass and how to go to the dorm at night and all sorts of other little things- my school is weird)
 
Perhaps all you need to say is that you think you should break it off. He is discerning and you want to look for someone that is not, someone that is fully open to a relationship and where it may lead. Wish him the best and tell him you will pray for his happiness whatever his choice ends up being.

Do not leave the door open by saying you will be there if he decides he wants you instead. That isn’t fair to either of you.

May God bless you and guide you. 🙂
Okay, thank you. Now to work up the courage!
 
:banghead:
Really?
Sorry, I’m just being dumb (I assume this was over “just have to decide what to say”). There’s really only one thing to say “I can’t go on dating you while you’re discerning. It’s not fair to me to be dragged through uncertainty and it’s not fair to you to be distracted from focusing on discernment.”
If you mean about waiting for school, I think it would be sort of rude not to say that in person, wouldn’t it?
 
Sorry, I’m just being dumb (I assume this was over “just have to decide what to say”). There’s really only one thing to say “I can’t go on dating you while you’re discerning. It’s not fair to me to be dragged through uncertainty and it’s not fair to you to be distracted from focusing on discernment.”
If you mean about waiting for school, I think it would be sort of rude not to say that in person, wouldn’t it?
it doesn’t matter as long as you say it.
And mean it.
 
A while ago, I had a relationship end when my boyfriend felt a call to the priesthood. Now, it looks like it might be happening again, with my (serious) current boyfriend feeling a pretty strong attraction to the religious life. It was hard enough the first time- I just can’t wrap my mind around it possibly happening twice!
I’d appreciate prayers for him to discern God’s will and for me to accept and love it.
I have been on the other side of this–twice. When I was a young adult in college I felt a call to priesthood. However because of the timing I had to wait another year to enter the seminary. That meant I spent another year at the same university, including continuing to travel overnight as a member of the basketball team’s pep band. ( I can say I had more opportunities for both good and bad relationships in that year than in the previous four years combined, whew! Our Adversary seemed to be working overtime.)

I decided that because I had said “yes” to what I believed was a call, it would no longer be moral and honest to engage in “dating” activities. Clearly people were wondering why I was not taking advantage of the various opportunities for relationships–both good and bad. Once I was accepted to the seminary I met with three of the young women to explain my lack of response to them.

I spent several surprisingly fulfilling years in the seminary but could not continue due to a list of mysterious health problems that my doctors struggled to understand or even treat well. After many years of unresolved health problems it seemed clear my health would not be suitable for priesthood.

At that time a long-time female friend from a church youth group clearly was not satisfied with just a friendship. Since my doctors did not have any solutions to my problems I finally agreed to start a dating relationship. She helped me with my health by buying books and recommending various alternative doctors. She just would not give up on me.

Eventually with a tip from a doctor who once had a somewhat similar list of debilitating symptoms I was found to have a heavy metal problem. I had grown up in a family business where lead exposure is expected. I started to respond to treatment.

Because my original call to priesthood was so strong, I felt I had to confirm that I was too old or not sufficiently recovered to go back to the seminary. This was a very hard decision. I had grown to love my friend. I owed her SO much for all she had done for me. However, God loves both of us more than I love her. I needed to trust God and get a good decision before moving forward with marriage.

Not surprisingly, this was very painful for her. I tend to be the protective type so causing her pain was difficult for me. We knew we could no longer have a seriously dating relationship, however, we did not destroy our friendship. Since I did not yet know if my health history and age would disqualify me, we continued with a non-exclusive dating relationship. We would go to lunch together, take walks in the public park during daylight, but agreed that romantic activity would be inappropriate.

I think it is so important for couples to consider their romantic actions to be non-verbal communication. It must be honest like our verbal communication. Various actions communicate a level of unity. Some romantic activities and especially sexual activity cause an increase in body chemicals associated with “bonding”, for example, oxytocin.

We must act in ways that are consistent with the level of commitment in the relationship.

( continued in next post)
 
For more background, he started feeling really attracted to the religious life after spending some time visiting a monastery. He says he thinks he’s to be a monk, but that he doesn’t want to break up…
“Break up” from what, an exclusive dating relationship, a non-exclusive dating relationship, friendship?

Since he is “really attracted” to religious life and visited a monastery, you don’t have an exclusive, seriously dating relationship. At best you have a non-exclusive dating relationship.
I think some sort of conversation needs to happen, because in our microculture, there are all sorts of traditions and everyday activities associated with “going steady”. He said he wanted me to act the same as before…
Yes, you need to communicate. You’ll have to respect the fact he is “dating” the monastery. At most you’ll have a non-exclusive dating relationship.

If you love him, you’ll want what God knows is best for both of you. By respecting his freedom you show your love in a powerful way. This includes no manipulation.

Remind him that you will pray for him and for God’s will.

Remind him that you were not interested in breaking off the serious relationship but understand that he needs the space to discern. Let him know that you continue to care about him and would like to spend some non-romantic time with each other.

This will likely not be easy, especially for you. However, your respect for his freedom while continuing to be concerned about him will be a powerful testimony of your love for him. If his discernment results in a decision to not go to the monastery, he will likely find you even more admirable and attractive. Remember guys are more grateful for an emotionally supportive female friend–and wife–than they are likely to admit ; )

Btw, I got no indication from speaking to vocation directors, priests, etc that anyone felt I was a good bet at my age and with my poor health history. In subsequent years of treatment for heavy metals (it takes many years for lead to be cleared from bone) my biggest medical problem was resolved and several other moderately important problems were either resolved or impressively improved according to followup tests and symptom relief. My semi-natural doctor recommended that I stop taking the last of the medications I was on. I am just taking a handful of supplements and being careful with my diet. My health is clearly in the normal range for my age. My long-time female friend and I are shopping for a ring : )

I’m not suggesting that this will end in the same way for you. Honestly, I’m not so sure this has ended in the way God intended for me; however, I have to respect the decisions and inaction of appropriate members of church leadership.

I will remember you in prayer and wish you all the best.
 
Thanks again to everyone for the responses.
I spoke with him last weekend and decided to continue our friendship as just friendship, rather than an exclusive dating relationship. He apologized for the pain on my part and thanked me.
We’ve hardly seen each other and haven’t spoken since (which is strange, since we live in a very tiny, very close quarters, very tight knit community, and we mostly associate with the same people. I suppose he’s been keeping to his room a lot, somewhere I’ve obviously never been near.) When we do see each other (usually after Mass, Benediction, or Compline) he’s smiled at me, but said nothing. I’m trying to work on feeling towards him just the sort of love I feel toward my other friends, but it’s very difficult. Every time I see him, I want to rush up and be near to him, speak with him, hug him or something. I’m trying very hard to look cheerful and friendly instead of downcast, because I don’t want him to feel guilty or anything, but it’s still rather hard. Prayers would be appreciated!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top