Should I shred Mom's check?

  • Thread starter Thread starter esieffe
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
E

esieffe

Guest
I am a Catholic convert. My Dad is a Retired Episcopal priest. I have been taking care of a of my best friend / relative through five years of alcoholism. Forgive me but it is late, and I feel kind of emotional right now, just bear with me.

Since I was a kid, I put money in the collection plate. All my life I have donated money, time, sweat and my heart in helping others. I am the only male with two sisters. My sisters have used my mother as a bank in years gone by to the tune of thousands of dollars. I have ruined my life taking care of this alcoholic relative. I feel like I am a good and honorable person.

Recently, we were told by the bank we had 30 days to pay up on the mortgage, or the house would go up for sale on the courthouse steps March 2. I have always been close to my parents. I respect my Dad for many reasons, not just because he is my father, but he is a priest and a published intellectual / theologian, at least I thought he was.

For the first time I alluded to the fact that I was desperate and some money might help me out a great deal in this situation. I have never asked them for money. My Dad got mad at me during this humble and humiliating phone call I made and handed my mother the phone, saying in the background, “dont give him any money.”

I told Mom just to keep her money. It seems now he is “allowing” her to give me some money from her social security check, it came today in the mail. He said to me, “you allowed this to happen, you could have thrown him out at any time. “Yes” I said, but he is an alcoholic, therefore mentally ill, and at this point, tough love could kill him. Would you throw one of us out under these circumstances? I very well might” said my father the Priest.

This check will help. It is only 500.00 so it won’t save the mortgage, but it would by gas for the car or serve as a deposit somewhere, but I am on the edge of simply feeding it to the shredder. I am a male and he holds me to a higher standard than my sisters. He always has. I used to have more wealth than he has, but I always gave. I gave too much end the end like a fool and his money. He never has chucked out a dime to charity . Now due to pressure from my Mom he is condescending to throw a little of her money in my direction. Since my bad judgement about being caring for others has brought me to financial ruin, he is treating me like someone would treat their son if he were a drug addict. I am NOT the bad guy here. I am the guy who goes out and helps people.

I would almost rather live under a bridge then to cash this check. But, it is cold outside. What would you do? I am very angry and hurt. Again I have never asked them for anything, and I only hinted around it this time. Not only do I feel like shredding this check, but I feel like telling him to just cut me out altogether. He is supposed to be a priest, and yet he is a self absorbed, sanctimonious, agnostic. Whats up with that?

Pope Francis hit it right on the head with the poor and charity. I am so mad, I cannot think clearly. But am I committing the sin of pride? Or do I just have an stuck up egomaniac father? Please share your thoughts.

PS: I read over this, and it sounds like I am making myself to be a saint. So I did an edit. I am not a saint. Despite the fact that I am charitable, when I was young, I could have earned free passage at the lust suite in hell. I will be lucky to make it to heaven. I have much to make up for.
 
If you decide not to use it, void it and send it back without comment. You don’t have a right to demand even a parent to give you alms, but you do have the right to decide that the help you are getting comes with the wrong kind of strings for you to accept.

Go talk to your own pastor. That might help you a lot.
 
If you decide not to use it, void it and send it back without comment. You don’t have a right to demand even a parent to give you alms, but you do have the right to decide that the help you are getting comes with the wrong kind of strings for you to accept.

Go talk to your own pastor. That might help you a lot.
Thanks. You are right. I am judging my Dad by what I would do as a Dad. Maybe that is why he still has money and I don’t. As I said, a fool and his money are soon parted. GB.
 
OK, I’m not even sure I have all the facts correct in my mind, but I’m thinking that your dad is reacting to the fact that you have been carrying this alcoholic friend/relative and neglected your own well-being. People have previously said that maybe in trying so hard to help this person, you have kept him dependent and not really helped him conquer the addiction. Sometimes our perceived help is actually a hindrance.
I’m not a fan of “tough love” but this is your chance to get this person in your life into another setting. You need to take care of yourself. Your dad doesn’t want to fund this other person’s problem. If the money was helping you alone, I’d bet he wouldn’t be so angry. I think he may feel that you are being used, and is frustrated.
I don’t know…it just occurred to me as I was reading your post…
God bless you for caring so much about others. But God does not wish us to be a doormat either. I am praying for you. I know what it’s like to be fearful of losing the security of a home. Be assured of my prayers.
pianist
 
Pianistclare said,
God bless you for caring so much about others.
I echo that too esieffe and will also keep you in my prayers. God bless you.

In the meantime give thanks, cash the check, and love your dad (and mom) the best you can and of course pray for them.

The reprieve on the foreclosure may be just what God wants for you, especially since it came through BOTH your mother (willingly) and your father (albeit reluctantly).
 
From what I am able to gather from your post OP…it seems like you have been enabling this alcoholic for some time now, and I’m sure your father is worried and sick of seeing you do this.

You have good intentions and have tried to do good for this person. But there comes a point where you have to decide if you are part of the solution or part of the problem. Some people will not get better or try until they hit rock bottom.

There is obviously more to the history between you and your father than this situation. You sound very bitter toward him. You are an adult and make your own decisions. He and your mother don’t owe you any of their money. And how do you know he never donates any money? Perhaps he keeps it between himself and God?

I would agree with an above poster who suggested you discuss this with your own pastor. Your pastor may also be able to give you ideas on what to do about your housing problem. I will keep you in prayer.
 
OK, I’m not even sure I have all the facts correct in my mind, but I’m thinking that your dad is reacting to the fact that you have been carrying this alcoholic friend/relative and neglected your own well-being. People have previously said that maybe in trying so hard to help this person, you have kept him dependent and not really helped him conquer the addiction. Sometimes our perceived help is actually a hindrance.
I’m not a fan of “tough love” but this is your chance to get this person in your life into another setting. You need to take care of yourself. Your dad doesn’t want to fund this other person’s problem. If the money was helping you alone, I’d bet he wouldn’t be so angry. I think he may feel that you are being used, and is frustrated.
I don’t know…it just occurred to me as I was reading your post…
God bless you for caring so much about others. But God does not wish us to be a doormat either. I am praying for you. I know what it’s like to be fearful of losing the security of a home. Be assured of my prayers.
pianist
I was going to say this, but now, I don’t have to.

Principles are all well and good, but you could accept the check, pay your mom back as soon as you can with a note that said simply, “thanks for being there when I needed your help.”

And 5 years is too long to carry someone. Please, get help for them, and/or for yourself. What you see as helping may in fact be enabling and co-dependency.
 
I think it’s time to get ready to move. Sell stuff, work an extra job to save money for the move, and tell your alcoholic relative that he has one month to go and he is not moving with you. Also, it’s time to get into counseling and/or to go to Al-Anon. And go talk to a St. Vincent de Paul financial counselor.

Come to think of it, do you have any equity in the house? If so, sell the house as quickly as is reasonable and bank the money.

In future, allot no more than 10% of your income to charitable giving (unless you get really rich) and do a personal finance class (for instance Dave Ramsey’s Financial Peace University).

Also, think about how much money you’ve spent on this one derelict relative, and how much good you could have done with that money for people who would actually have benefited from the help. Your help has not improved this person’s life, and it has wrecked yours.
 
Here is a verse that didn’t make it into Matthew 25:

“I was an alcoholic and you made sure that I never needed to get dry.”

I would suggest rereading the Gospels and seeing how much of them is devoted to prudence and wise (but generous) management of resources.
 
I think it’s time to get ready to move. Sell stuff, work an extra job to save money for the move, and tell your alcoholic relative that he has one month to go and he is not moving with you. Also, it’s time to get into counseling and/or to go to Al-Anon. And go talk to a St. Vincent de Paul financial counselor.

Come to think of it, do you have any equity in the house? If so, sell the house as quickly as is reasonable and bank the money.

In future, allot no more than 10% of your income to charitable giving (unless you get really rich) and do a personal finance class (for instance Dave Ramsey’s Financial Peace University).

Also, think about how much money you’ve spent on this one derelict relative, and how much good you could have done with that money for people who would actually have benefited from the help. Your help has not improved this person’s life, and it has wrecked yours.
Very good advice.

You have a very good heart. Please share it with people that truly need and want help, not people that refuse to get help for their problem.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top