SHOULD you commit or NOT?

  • Thread starter Thread starter johto760
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

johto760

Guest
Hi guys,

earlier this morning, I was conversing with a non-catholic friend about what commitment is, in terms of RELATIONSHIPS (boyfriend/girlfriend). My confusion came after asking this question to him:

@QUESTION TO FRIEND
“Would you commit to someone if she is committed to someone else?”

again, we’re talking about BOYFRIEND/GIRLFRIEND relationships here.

@ANSWER OF FRIEND
his answer was:
“YES, I would hold up with my COMMITMENT to her as long as I can, even if she is CURRENTLY committed to another, because I’m sure that one day, if my commitment isn’t going anywhere, GOD will wake me up, and make me realize in his time”

I’m aware that God knows the right time for everything, and to us, the RIGHT time isn’t always obvious at the PRESENT. I’m also aware that CHANGE is the only constant in this world, so there’s always the possibility, no matter how small that, IN THE FUTURE, God will make a way so that, the girl/boy you are committed to TODAY, WILL BE committed to you in the future… but I can’t quite remove this nagging question in my mind:

@QUESTION THAT MADE ME CONFUSED
“IS THIS WHAT BEING TRULY COMMITTED ENTAILS? That, even though the person you are so in love with and so committed to TODAY is already committed to someone else, you’re still going to hope that, IF YOU HOLD ON TO YOUR COMMITMENT/LOVE for as LONG AS YOU CAN, GOD will make a way for that person to leave his/her CURRENT commitment and COMMIT TO YOU?”

Maybe I’m asking this question because I’ve never really felt those “INTENSE EMOTIONS” that almost everyone seems to be bragging about when their in love, that’s why I have no way of CONFIRMING if my friend’s answer is what TRUE COMMITMENT is all about…

From my point of view:

“LOVING SOMEONE, SO IMMENSELY as to GIVE YOUR COMMITMENT TO THAT SOMEONE who is already LOVING SOMEONE ELSE, is just plain GOD-LIKE, I don’t think anyone should try to commit themselves to one person who can’t love them back, God experiences this situation everyday, I know that we should strive to be like Jesus Christ but is THIS SITUATION (loving someone who can’t love you back TODAY) a CHRIST-LIKE act or are the once believing that they SHOULD COMMIT TO SOMEONE THAT MUCH, EVEN THOUGH THEIR LOVE IS UNREQUITED just fooling themselves?”

I know of LOVING YOUR ENEMIES, but being COMMITTED TO LOVING SOMEONE who just WON’T Love you back because she/he is ALREADY COMMITTED TO SOMEONE ELSE, is this part of the LOVE YOUR ENEMIES that JESUS CHRIST taught us?
 
Another thing that I THINK got me confused is that I was thinking about COURTSHIP, and what I’ve read, so far, about CATHOLIC COURTSHIP is this (summarized):

-“courtship prepares us for marriage”

from what I understand:

“COMMITMENT COMES as you guard your emotional and physical intimacy while in a courtship relationship”

here’s a paragraph from:
revolutionoflove.com/singles/courtship/courtship.html

“In courtship, both the man and woman are aware of the importance of the decision they are making, regarding marriage. They are responsible to be honest and open with each other. They choose to guard carefully emotional and physical intimacy for the sake of the other, protecting themselves each from unnecessary heartache and pain if the relationship does in fact break off. If the relationship continues to lead toward marriage they will also discover the great joy of being faithful and self-sacrificing to one another. Their marriage will be blessed with untold joys because they will share in each other’s physical affection in total self-giving and pure love. And the wait will only make the expression of physical intimacy that much more exciting and wonderful.”

This paragraph tells me that:

"If the relationship isn’t going anywhere near marriage, then breaking up would be the best decision since they don’t want their “UNCONTROLLED FEELINGS” to make their decisions about MARRYING SOMEONE for them.
If the relationship isn’t going anywhere near marriage, then breaking up wouldn’t hurt so much because they GUARDED their physical and emotional intimacy.

If the relationship isn’t going anywhere near marriage (due to infidelity, or uncertainty of the other, or lack of REAL, AUTHENTIC CONNECTIONS, COMMUNICATIONS, or lack of common interests, or lack of MUTUAL UNDERSTANDING), then CONTINUING THEIR COMMITMENT TO EACH OTHER might make them unhappy, since being MATRIMONIALLY MARRIED IS A COMMITMENT THAT SHOULD LAST FOR THE REST OF THEIR LIVES,

if they push themselves so far as to continue their relationship until their married, even though they don’t SEE the relationship as being FIT, then aren’t they just letting their EMOTIONS take over their decisions? aren’t they just leaving their MARRIAGE to chance?, aren’t they just showing that BEING MARRIED ISN’T SO MUCH AS IMPORTANT, AS LONG AS I COULD BE WITH THIS PERSON RIGHT HERE? EVEN THOUGH WE LACK COMMON INTERESTS/TOPICS/IDEAS or we lack MUTUAL UNDERSTANDING, as long as HE/SHE is a great kisser, or when he/she embraces me, I feel like heaven or when I look at him all I want to do is touch him I will continue to marry this person, isn’t this kind of thinking of the world rather than of a man/woman striving to be holy for Christ’s sake (literally)?"

Just thinking about HAVING A RELATIONSHIP with someone who CURRENTLY just doesn’t love me the way God wants us to love each other in purity/holiness/chastity, makes me want to give up on that woman and find someone else that puts GOD first, and is striving also to live a pure, holy and chaste life, SO THE ANSWER that my good ol friend gave me about my question above just makes me ask the @QUESTION THAT MADE ME CONFUSED (as I am, just recently, and still striving for purity/holiness/chastity in every area of my life ^_^), I’ve been at a point where I wasn’t even thinking about being pure, or being chaste, or living like Jesus Christ, and I’ve concluded that LIVING THE LIFE, IS LIVING IN THE WAY AND THE TRUTH AND THE LIFE OF CHRIST…
 
I can relate to some of what your friend is saying. I am not a young person, so maybe there is some difference. However, I met, late in life, a man with whom I am deeply, passionately, fully in love with. I am not “available” at this time, and might never be. Our relationship has never, ever been physical, not even a handshake, not matter what we might have wanted. I have spent 18 months in his presence, and 3 years away from him. I find missing him to be almost overwhelming at times.

I may never see him again, because I am “unavailable,” yet. However, I cannot imagine for an instant of not loving him. I suppose that could be considered “commitment,” as I only want to be with him, and not anyone else on this earth. If that means that I live alone forever, then it will be that way.

Even if he forsakes me, and goes on to marry someone else, I would still be just as deeply in love with him as I am now, although a much sadder woman.
 
Thanks for sharing that tear-jerking response,
I’m sorry if my thread made you remember all that,…

I guess, COMMITMENT is to be judged in a relationship-to-relationship basis then,… Some will experience Love this intensely, some may not, and with more than 10 billion lives living today, this topic might get really complicated… so I’m gonna have to accept that:

“SOME WILL EXPERIENCE THIS KIND OF COMMITMENT, SOME MAY NOT”…

GOD LOVES YOU>
 
@QUESTION THAT MADE ME CONFUSED
“IS THIS WHAT BEING TRULY COMMITTED ENTAILS? That, even though the person you are so in love with and so committed to TODAY is already committed to someone else, you’re still going to hope that, IF YOU HOLD ON TO YOUR COMMITMENT/LOVE for as LONG AS YOU CAN, GOD will make a way for that person to leave his/her CURRENT commitment and COMMIT TO YOU?”
No.

This is stupidity, or extreme immaturity.
 
Romantic love is not something that will come and go as you please. In fact, it would be rather suspicious if you were able to kindle it or put it off at will. This said, cultivating an unreturned interest in someone else, feeding it, is not a good idea. Nor can you have a relationship with someone without that person’s participation. And you can’t live married to an imagination of someone. Some kind of faithfulness despite a lack of reciprocity certainly befits someone who’s a man of his word but there are limits and the mediaeval-style unrequited love hype must be avoided.

It’s probably different when we look at someone who’s “currently” (not for a long time and without indications of this being a permanent arrangement) in a relationship with someone bad for him or her (someone abusive, cheating, lying etc., with whom the object of our interests insist on sticking), and when we see someone who’s in a happy relationship with mutual love shared with someone else. In the latter case, I believe we shouldn’t interfere.
 
Boyfriend/girlfriend relationships are a type of commitment based relationships, otherwise they would be plain friendships. Many marriages are grown out of boyfriend/girlfriend relationships. I would never consider dating anyone who was dating someone else. If someone expressed interest in me while I was dating someone else I would immediately not be interested in them even for a friendship. To me that brings to light a moral character in a person that doesn’t interest me on any level for a deeper commitment of a valid real friendship or loyal relationship.
 
The person who has “fallen in love” with someone who is unavailable is not ready for a true relationship - he can stay on the sidelines, filled with longing and romantic notions of “someday.” It is foolish to say he is “committed” when he is anything but committed. In fact, to do such a thing, he should be committed all right - to an institution.

People who long for someone who loves someone else need counseling.

🤷:doh2:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top