Should you force yourself to do a private devotion because others seem to be drawn to it?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Eilish_Maura
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
E

Eilish_Maura

Guest
I am not talking about making serious and good efforts when you have a lapse about a practice you have decided to take up but really forcing yourself to do something (like the rosary) because others seem to be happy with it and yet you are not.
 
Subjective.

Let’s flip it around.

Should you force yourself to ‘refrain’ from doing a private devotion because others seem to be averse to it?

Both ways seem to be dependent on feelings and perceptions, and not at all on anything else.

Now my parents ‘forced’ me to keep a clean room when I was growing up and they ‘forced’ me into going to Mass when I would rather have either stayed in bed or ‘communed’ with nature.

Were they right to do so? You bet.

Private devotions, OTOH, are neither vital to public health (like keeping one’s room relatively free from toxic waste) nor mandatory to the faith (like attending Sunday Mass).

But is one being ‘forced’ to observe a devotion 'because others are drawn to it?" How? In what way?
 
Private devotions are just that - they are private. They are something you do in order to enhance your spiritual life and deepen your relationship with the Lord. You should not feel obliged to follow the private spirituality of others, rather, you should find a particular devotion that you like.

Personally, I love the Rosary and find it to be a very powerful way for me to connect with God through the eyes of his Mother. However, I recognize that this form of prayer does not suit everyone. Some people prefer lectio divina or they might pray the daily office. Do whatever suits you. No devotion should feel like a chore; you should love it and derive many benefits from it.
 
I would say, give it a serious try, to see what all the hype is about. Just because you take up a devotion one day, doesn’t mean that you are stuck with it for the rest of your life.

By “peer pressure” do you mean that when your friends ask you to go out with them, they stop in at a Church and pray the Rosary, and you feel kind of dumb just hanging around until they’re done?
 
To an extent I agree; with all the different private devotions in our faith, we should be seeking out one that will help us the most to grow in our faith. And to an extent, if one is ‘struggling’ with a devotion which we feel is ‘forced’ upon one, then it might seem that rather than grow in faith, we would falter. But that might not actually be so.

A HUGE majority of people in this country, at this time, have a BIG problem with obedience, authority, humility, etc. They have no problem doing things so long as THEY make the choice. But boy, how they chafe at doing things that they don’t choose! And the danger is that they can find themselves becoming narrow in their practices yet thinking themselves (because they ‘choose’ what they do) to be far more broad in their practices than they really are. . .and thinking that by their ‘choosing’ to do a practice they are ‘better’ than those who choose other practices, and ESPECIALLY think that they are better than those whom they believe never really ‘bothered’ to think or choose but who follow a practice or devotion because of their particular culture, or family tradition, etc. Or ‘peer pressure.’

I am not accusing anybody here of that mindset, but the fact remains that a lot of people, (and very sweet people too, otherwise) get their knickers in a twist over being ‘told what to do’ or at being anything less than totally free to take what they want from Christianity on their own terms.

I mean, look at the focus of this question, which really focuses not on the devotion per se but on SELF, SELF, SELF, and the notion of being FORCED, and the notion (heaven forbid) of being influenced by others to the detriment of one’s own ‘choice.’

Shouldn’t the focus of devotion be on GOD instead of our SELVES? And yes, devotion to the Saints and Mary, being ultimately to God, is just as much God-centered as devotion to Father, Son, and Spirit.
 
I have always recommended prayer but I have never tried to tell anyone exactly what kind.

I am very bothered when folks drag out the ‘never fails’ as if this or that set of words can dictate to God to get the outcomes we want.

I have struggled with several of the more ‘popular’ private devotions and have finally been able to leave them aside -

I have finally learned that we pray as we can - not as we can’t.
 
I have always recommended prayer but I have never tried to tell anyone exactly what kind.

I am very bothered when folks drag out the ‘never fails’ as if this or that set of words can dictate to God to get the outcomes we want.
Oh, I see - yes,I have friends like that, too. My usual strategy is just to say, 'Oh, that sounds very interesting. I’m glad you get something out of it," without “taking the hint” that I’m supposed to be doing this, too.

I try to avoid any kind of superstition in my prayer life - that doesn’t mean that I don’t like or pray the Rosary, but I’m not doing it in a superstitious way, if you know what I mean - like, I’m not praying nine Rosaries in a day in order to force God to bend His will to mine. (I have other strategies for doing that … 😛 )
 
Someplace I read:

Pray as you can; Not as you can’t. 👍
lol! Seems I’ve read that here a few times, too.

EM: the answer to your OP is no. If you were forcing a devotion, you’d be praying in vain, which Jesus condemns.
 
There are also those who ‘push’ this or that practice because of particular private revelation.

Peer pressure is more common that many might think. :cool:
 
Well, the ones who push…Ignore them. They’re wrong and it’s none of their business.

I’d do the same with anyone who tried to tell me I shouldn’t pray the rosary.
 
I am not talking about making serious and good efforts when you have a lapse about a practice you have decided to take up but really forcing yourself to do something (like the rosary) because others seem to be happy with it and yet you are not.
no, classic Christian spiritual direction would say a common mistake is to try and force oneself to undertake a devotion (other than of course Mass and the sacraments) which is not beneficial, praying the wrong way, with the wrong method, for your personality, or for you at this time of your life or in your current situation. “Discerning poorly the use of methods” is the label used by Segundo Galilea OCD for this “demon of prayer”. His little book Temptation and Discernment trans to English is available from ICS publications, Wash DC.
 
There are also those who ‘push’ this or that practice because of particular private revelation.

Peer pressure is more common that many might think. :cool:
I know the one you mean, and I get that a lot, too, from certain friends of mine. I just tell them, I’ve been to Confession, and I’m ready for that trumpet call whenever it may occur - and by the way, isn’t one of the signs of the Anti-Christ, that it tries to predict the exact moment of the end of the world? 🤷 😃
 
OUr parish has the novevna to our Lady every Monday immediatly following the 9:00 mass. I am not drawn to it so I leave right after the blessing of mass. I have had some people ask why I leave and I honestly tell them that it is not for me. They argue but then I just say that I have to get downstairs to work (which I do), and then they argue that it is only about 8 minutes more. Can’t win. Next time maybe I should ask them why they weren’t at the Divine Mercy service on the Second Sunday of Easter.
 
no, classic Christian spiritual direction would say a common mistake is to try and force oneself to undertake a devotion (other than of course Mass and the sacraments) which is not beneficial, praying the wrong way, with the wrong method, for your personality, or for you at this time of your life or in your current situation. “Discerning poorly the use of methods” is the label used by Segundo Galilea OCD for this “demon of prayer”. His little book Temptation and Discernment trans to English is available from ICS publications, Wash DC.
👍 …“pray as you can, not as you can’t” or “pray as The Spirit calls, not as He does not”…Of course, sometimes one may find prayer difficult in some way, but then the Spirit urges one not to abandon prayer, and this is a different matter entirely.

…Blessings - Barb:)
 
I try to avoid any kind of superstition in my prayer life - that doesn’t mean that I don’t like or pray the Rosary, but I’m not doing it in a superstitious way, if you know what I mean - like, I’m not praying nine Rosaries in a day in order to force God to bend His will to mine. (I have other strategies for doing that … 😛 )
:rotfl: :rotfl:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top