Sin= no praying nor attending Sunday mass

  • Thread starter Thread starter SecretGarden
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

SecretGarden

Guest
I attend church every week but I am not always able to attend a mass due to commitments beyond my control. I do not understand why not attending mass on the odd Sunday or not praying are considered a sin.

Can someone please help me with this?
Thanks SG
 
You must remember that the depth of our faith is not about legalism. Being “in sin” is more a mindset, a deep personal detachment from God. It might be better explained by way of analogy: when you love your friend and wish to talk to him, you say you are in the state of friendship with him; conversely, when you don’t particularly care whether you talk to him, or don’t visit him, you can hardly be called friends any longer. With God, refusing to pray or go to visit Him (on what’s almost like a birthday for Him) is like saying “sorry, I don’t know you”.

Sin is just the state of not-being-a-friend to God. When you love someone, you want union with him, but you also want good things to happen to him. It is good for God to be in union with His creatures, and it is good for God to talk to us. I don’t know why He wants it, because He certainly has no need! Whatever the case, God is not to be treated like a stranger. We pray in order to be united with God. We go to Mass in order to share stories of old times and consume Him, like at some sort of wonderful supernatural Tea. It’s really not that difficult to just say “hello”!

People would understand the relationship with God vs. no-relationship with God - dichotomy more if we wrote letters today, instead of using email (I think). Email is depersonalised, so all messages and communications are just quick shots. You can shoot off an email when you’re surfing the internet, and put almost no thought into it. This unfortunate speed of communication has hampered our ability to understand and appreciate silence - and especially our ability to think things through before talking. Can you imagine, these days, just sitting with your best friend in a quiet room and reading, hardly acknowledging each other, except by your decision to be together? This is what union with God is: just recognising that He is there, and that His essence/being is what fuels us. Can you say your car is fueled without having placed the gas pump into the aperture? You must seek God out, or He has nothing to work with. 🙂
 
Do you mind me asking what are the “commitments beyond your control”? May be there is something you can do/decisions you can make to free up every Sunday in order to fulfill your Catholic obligation.
 
Do you mind me asking what are the “commitments beyond your control”? May be there is something you can do/decisions you can make to free up every Sunday in order to fulfill your Catholic obligation.
Speak to your pastor. He can dispense you from going to Mass if there is truly a good reason that it would be very difficult.

However, just in case this has anything to do with family members wanting you to go to their non-Catholic service instead of Mass, that isn’t sufficient reason to miss Mass.
 
I attend church every week but I am not always able to attend a mass due to commitments beyond my control. I do not understand why not attending mass on the odd Sunday or not praying are considered a sin.

Can someone please help me with this?
Thanks SG
if you cannot get to Mass, because of circumstances beyond your control, or any other good reason, then you have no Mass obligation, and hence, there is not sin.
Not praying is considered a sin because it is ignoring your relationship with God. It is a sin for the same reason it would be wrong for a married couple living in the same house never to speak to each other.
 
I attend church every week but I am not always able to attend a mass due to commitments beyond my control. I do not understand why not attending mass on the odd Sunday or not praying are considered a sin.

Can someone please help me with this?
Thanks SG
If the situation is indeed beyond your control, then it is not a sin. We only sin if we deliberately miss Mass. If we cannot possibly go to Mass on a given Sunday, then the Church does not expect us to. God doesn’t ask the impossible from us.
 
I attend church every week but I am not always able to attend a mass due to commitments beyond my control. I do not understand why not attending mass on the odd Sunday or not praying are considered a sin.

Can someone please help me with this?
Thanks SG
Can you explain what you mean by saying you “attend church every week” but that you are not always able to “attend a mass”? It sounds as though you are attending a non-Catholic church, but not able to get to mass. Is that what you mean?

Gertie
 
I attend church every week but I am not always able to attend a mass due to commitments beyond my control. I do not understand why not attending mass on the odd Sunday or not praying are considered a sin.

Can someone please help me with this?
Thanks SG
Actually, if it’s beyond your control that no it’s not a Mortal Sin.
 
I attend church every week but I am not always able to attend a mass due to commitments beyond my control. I do not understand why not attending mass on the odd Sunday or not praying are considered a sin.

Can someone please help me with this?
Thanks SG
Can you give us an example of reasons beyond your control?
Did you realise attending Saturday evening Mass fulfills your Sunday Mass obligation. Many people, for example, have to work on Sundays so they attend Saturday evening Mass.

The Sunday obligation

CCC 2180 The precept of the Church specifies the law of the Lord more precisely: “On Sundays and other holy days of obligation the faithful are bound to participate in the Mass.” “The precept of participating in the Mass is satisfied by assistance at a Mass which is celebrated anywhere in a Catholic rite either on the holy day or on the evening of the preceding day.”

CCC 2181 The Sunday Eucharist is the foundation and confirmation of all Christian practice. For this reason the faithful are obliged to participate in the Eucharist on days of obligation, unless excused for a serious reason (for example, illness, the care of infants) or dispensed by their own pastor.119 Those who deliberately fail in this obligation commit a grave sin.

CCC 2182 Participation in the communal celebration of the Sunday Eucharist is a testimony of belonging and of being faithful to Christ and to his Church. The faithful give witness by this to their communion in faith and charity. Together they testify to God’s holiness and their hope of salvation. They strengthen one another under the guidance of the Holy Spirit.
 
I attend church every week but I am not always able to attend a mass due to commitments beyond my control. I do not understand why not attending mass on the odd Sunday or not praying are considered a sin.

Can someone please help me with this?
Thanks SG
it goes back to the Commandments…

if you can go to Mass and choose not to, that is a sin.

If you CAN’T attend Mass on a given Sunday, either because you are too sick, or something other reason that you really can’t control or have any say over, that is not a mortal sin.

Keep in mind you can also keep the Sunday obligation by going to the Saturday vigil Mass; some parishes also have a Mass on Sunday evening as well, or different times on Sunday

if in doubt ask your priest in Confession 🙂

God bless
 
To clarify things beyond my control. I am in a period of transition where I am a new Catholic so I try to attend mass every week but at the same time, I go when I feel called or I want to go. I used to attend a Pentecostal church where it was very ingrained into the doctrine that it was necessary to attend church every week. I got tired of this “have to attitude” that when I began to explore the Catholic church, I went to mass because I enjoyed it and not because I had to attend -it’s for that reason that I don’t attend every week. I try but I am not perfect.

During the school year, there is a place that offers Saturday mass, so I would go then and then whatever happened on a Sunday happened. Now that school is finished for the summer, I’ve had a stream of things happening on a Saturday so I haven’t been able to attend a plan B location. On Sunday I try to go whenever I can but every once in a while I crave a Protestant service, or I want to support a friend so I attended her church or I have a family event. Plus my church isn’t in my city so if there is a lot of construction, sometimes I will go to a local protestant church or I will try for a weekday mass. The construction will triple my transportation time (one hour to three hours) My family is Protestant, I will sometimes attend church with them as well. The possibilities are endless.

I don’t like the idea of being forced to go. Sometimes I only have time for one service. It’s difficult because the Catholic teaching teach the importance of attending mass every week, yet realistically I can’t always when there are other things happening. I still attend a Christian church. It is still the word of God. I love my new home but I don’t want mass to become an obligation because if it does, I know I will rebel and stop going.
 
To clarify things beyond my control. I am in a period of transition where I am a new Catholic so I try to attend mass every week but at the same time, I go when I feel called or I want to go. I used to attend a Pentecostal church where it was very ingrained into the doctrine that it was necessary to attend church every week. I got tired of this “have to attitude” that when I began to explore the Catholic church, I went to mass because I enjoyed it and not because I had to attend -it’s for that reason that I don’t attend every week. I try but I am not perfect.

During the school year, there is a place that offers Saturday mass, so I would go then and then whatever happened on a Sunday happened. Now that school is finished for the summer, I’ve had a stream of things happening on a Saturday so I haven’t been able to attend a plan B location. On Sunday I try to go whenever I can but every once in a while I crave a Protestant service, or I want to support a friend so I attended her church or I have a family event. Plus my church isn’t in my city so if there is a lot of construction, sometimes I will go to a local protestant church or I will try for a weekday mass. The construction will triple my transportation time (one hour to three hours) My family is Protestant, I will sometimes attend church with them as well. The possibilities are endless.

I don’t like the idea of being forced to go. Sometimes I only have time for one service. It’s difficult because the Catholic teaching teach the importance of attending mass every week, yet realistically I can’t always when there are other things happening. I still attend a Christian church. It is still the word of God. I love my new home but I don’t want mass to become an obligation because if it does, I know I will rebel and stop going.
First and foremost: It is NOT Catholic teaching that Sunday Mass is an obligation. It is GOD’S teaching, “relayed” through the Church.

I understand how you don’t want the Mass to become something of a burden. But that’s the thing, it shouldn’t be. You should go not because you want to or because it feels good for you, and you shouldn’t go to a Pentecostal service in place of a Sunday Mass because you “crave it.” You should go to Mass because it is key to having a loving relationship with Christ. He wants nothing more than to be with you, so why would you turn away from the Eucharist, the Real Presence of Christ, for a Pentecostal, feel-good service? And, even though you may not want to hear it, part of being in that loving relationship IS going to Mass even when you don’t want to do so, or because it seems inconvenient. You don’t go because you have to; you go in order to show your love to God and show that you want to be with HIM just as he wants to be with you.

I cannot tell you that you are in a state of mortal sin, but I can tell you that NOT attending Sunday Mass every week IS grave matter. A Pentecostal service is NOT a Mass and DOES NOT and CAN NOT replace it (you CAN go in addition to Mass). Whether or not your justifications for travel restrictions are valid reasons for missing Mass, however, is an issue that you should take up with your pastor.

Go to Sunday Mass. Go to it even when you absolutely want to be somewhere else. I can attest to the amazing graces it will bring to your life, even though it may be a pain in the short-term. A year ago, I had already become pretty complacent and nonchalant about my faith, only 2 years after converting. Now I’m absolutely on fire again and I know that had I not gone to Mass on those days when I could barely leave my room - even if all I thought about during the entire liturgy was how much I didn’t want to be there - I would not be where I am now.
 
To clarify things beyond my control. I am in a period of transition where I am a new Catholic so I try to attend mass every week but at the same time, I go when I feel called or I want to go. I used to attend a Pentecostal church where it was very ingrained into the doctrine that it was necessary to attend church every week. I got tired of this “have to attitude” that when I began to explore the Catholic church, I went to mass because I enjoyed it and not because I had to attend -it’s for that reason that I don’t attend every week. I try but I am not perfect.

During the school year, there is a place that offers Saturday mass, so I would go then and then whatever happened on a Sunday happened. Now that school is finished for the summer, I’ve had a stream of things happening on a Saturday so I haven’t been able to attend a plan B location. On Sunday I try to go whenever I can but every once in a while I crave a Protestant service, or I want to support a friend so I attended her church or I have a family event. Plus my church isn’t in my city so if there is a lot of construction, sometimes I will go to a local protestant church or I will try for a weekday mass. The construction will triple my transportation time (one hour to three hours) My family is Protestant, I will sometimes attend church with them as well. The possibilities are endless.

I don’t like the idea of being forced to go. Sometimes I only have time for one service. It’s difficult because the Catholic teaching teach the importance of attending mass every week, yet realistically I can’t always when there are other things happening. I still attend a Christian church. It is still the word of God. I love my new home but I don’t want mass to become an obligation because if it does, I know I will rebel and stop going.
Something doesn’t sound right to me. Surely if you went through the RCIA program you must have known these teachings and you must have known you have to accept them. Why did you become a Catholic if you are not prepared to accept the teachings of the Church which are fully supported by Christ who gave the Church authority?
 
Please make an effort to get to Mass every Sunday (Saturday night through Sunday night). It is the request of Jesus that we be with him every week and another Christian service, while it may have great preaching or good music, does not have the real presence of Jesus our Lord and Savior.

Look through masstimes.org or your diocese website and find all the parishes that are convenient to you. You do not need to go to your territorial parish if the Mass schedule there isn’t convenient for you. But please, please do begin to get to Mass every week.
 
To clarify things beyond my control. I am in a period of transition where I am a new Catholic so I try to attend mass every week but at the same time, I go when I feel called or I want to go. I used to attend a Pentecostal church where it was very ingrained into the doctrine that it was necessary to attend church every week. I got tired of this “have to attitude” that when I began to explore the Catholic church, I went to mass because I enjoyed it and not because I had to attend -it’s for that reason that I don’t attend every week. I try but I am not perfect.

During the school year, there is a place that offers Saturday mass, so I would go then and then whatever happened on a Sunday happened. Now that school is finished for the summer, I’ve had a stream of things happening on a Saturday so I haven’t been able to attend a plan B location. On Sunday I try to go whenever I can but every once in a while I crave a Protestant service, or I want to support a friend so I attended her church or I have a family event. Plus my church isn’t in my city so if there is a lot of construction, sometimes I will go to a local protestant church or I will try for a weekday mass. The construction will triple my transportation time (one hour to three hours) My family is Protestant, I will sometimes attend church with them as well. The possibilities are endless.

I don’t like the idea of being forced to go. Sometimes I only have time for one service. It’s difficult because the Catholic teaching teach the importance of attending mass every week, yet realistically I can’t always when there are other things happening. I still attend a Christian church. It is still the word of God. I love my new home but I don’t want mass to become an obligation because if it does, I know I will rebel and stop going.
I suppose one thing to keep in mind is that as Catholics we do not attend Mass primarily for our own benefit – to grow in faith, to learn from the readings and the sermon, to join with the community, etc. We go to worship God. The other things are all great and should be fostered fervently, but they are definitely secondary. Thus the obligation exists not because the Church says, “This is good for you, whether you like it or not,” but because God has commanded our worship and reverence.
 
I attend church every week but I am not always able to attend a mass due to commitments beyond my control. I do not understand why not attending mass on the odd Sunday or not praying are considered a sin.

Can someone please help me with this?
Thanks SG
CCCC 453. How does one keep Sunday holy?
Christians keep Sunday and other days of obligation holy by participating in the Eucharist of the Lord and by refraining from those activities which impede the worship of God and disturb the joy proper to the day of the Lord or the necessary relaxation of mind and body. Activities are allowed on the Sabbath which are bound up with family needs or with important social service, provided that they do not lead to habits prejudicial to the holiness of Sunday, to family life and to health.


As for prayer - why can’t you pray? There’s always a time for prayer, during the day or night. You can even pray while you’re working or doing other activities, silently or otherwise.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top