Sin to pray with non Catholics?

  • Thread starter Thread starter rosthesinner
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
On the contrary it is. It sin against 5 commandment. The suicide. Everything what saints did is not holy.
 
EX-lutheran said:
You are completly wrong . You have to give the evidence that your are right
Click to expand...
Cherry-picking does nothing to bolster your rejection of Church teaching. Also from Orientalium ecclesiarum, just two paragraphs down:
“Further, given the same principles, common participation by Catholics with their Eastern separated brethren in sacred functions, things and places is allowed for a just cause.”
 
Nobody said anything about suicide. If I jumped out my window I’d have a bruised knee.

And let’s also note that no pope has suggested anyone jump out a window.
 
Ok, this window thing is getting out of hand. No pope has suggested anything so ridiculous.

Praying with others is well within the purview of a pope’s authority. Your rejection of Church authority is what defines Protestantism.
 
It is not a failure of catechesis. Rather, it is not correct to say that the Judaism of today is not the same religion as ancient Judaism, any more than it is correct to say that the Catholicism of today is not the same religion as ancient Catholicism. The dogma and doctrines of both religions remain intact.
 
Last edited:
EX-lutheran said:
You probably did not read it at all.
Click to expand...
Why would you say that?

I was interested in why they thought anyone cared about their opinion. They did not get to that until the last section, and it was not much of an argument.
 
Not apples and oranges, but different kinds of apples. Where does the Catholic Church say that? If it does, which I doubt, either explicitly or implicitly, then it is wrong. Judaism knows more about the coherence of its own religion than the Church does. And Judaism does not depend on the Temple; it depends only on the Mosaic Law (Torah), inspired by G-d to Moses in 1440 B.C., which has not changed and will never change, even according to Jesus Himself. The religion itself, however, predates the Mosaic Law and is, as of this week, 5779 years old.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top