Singing hymns at Mass

  • Thread starter Thread starter dividus
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
We don’t sing hymns at our Church, nor do we have hymnals.
The choir sings during the entry procession and during Communion but nobody else sings.
Well, that makes things a lot easier, rather than worrying if someone isn’t singing because they don’t like the music or because you think people might not like your voice or think that you’re showing off, etc. 😃

That said, I do like singing the mass and during the mass.
 
😦 That would make me feel sad!!
The problem is time. On Sundays we have 10 Masses and they last for an hour without hymns. If we had hymns we could not have so many Masses. Our parish is 14,000 parishioners and we have an 80% Mass attendance so we need the 10 Masses to accommodate everyone.
 
The problem is time. On Sundays we have 10 Masses and they last for an hour without hymns. If we had hymns we could not have so many Masses. Our parish is 14,000 parishioners and we have an 80% Mass attendance so we need the 10 Masses to accommodate everyone.
Interesting.

Could hymns then actually be responsible for low Mass attendance elsewhere? Just a question.

Congrats on the 80% attendance.
 
I don’t know who it was that said on EWTN it but it applies to me:

God gave me a horrible singing voice and the inability to carry a tune. I remind him every Sunday at Mass.
 
My whole family sang in the church choir, except Mom, who couldn’t carry a tune in a bucket. However, she had the most beautiful speaking voice, with a lovely Midlands English accent that she never lost even years after emigrating. She lectored! When she lectored, the whole parish of thousands of people fell silent and were captivated by the beauty of the Scriptures being proclaimed to them. You could hear a pin drop.

She found another way to serve without singing. Follow your gifts. 👍
 
The problem is time. On Sundays we have 10 Masses and they last for an hour without hymns. If we had hymns we could not have so many Masses. Our parish is 14,000 parishioners and we have an 80% Mass attendance so we need the 10 Masses to accommodate everyone.
Now, that’s a “problem” I would love to have at so many parishes. It’s wonderful to hear.

Your info says you’re in the Philippines. My mother is from there and from what I’ve experienced, Filipinos (at least hear in the States) LOVE to sing and they are pretty good Catholics in terms of mass attendance, at least. Until their kids become “Americanized”. 😦
 
My whole family sang in the church choir, except Mom, who couldn’t carry a tune in a bucket. However, she had the most beautiful speaking voice, with a lovely Midlands English accent that she never lost even years after emigrating. She lectored! When she lectored, the whole parish of thousands of people fell silent and were captivated by the beauty of the Scriptures being proclaimed to them. You could hear a pin drop.

She found another way to serve without singing. Follow your gifts. 👍
“HE WHO SINGS, PRAYS TWICE.” St. Augustine.
 
Make a joyful noise unto the Lord, all ye lands. Serve the Lord with gladness: come before His presence with singing. Psalm 100: 1-2

Sing away!
I’m always grateful the Psalm says to make a ‘joyful’ noise, not a ‘tuneful’ one 😉 And I worked with a priest who was equally grateful for this wording (especially as the other 2 priests in that parish made very tuneful noises).
The problem is time. On Sundays we have 10 Masses and they last for an hour without hymns. If we had hymns we could not have so many Masses. Our parish is 14,000 parishioners and we have an 80% Mass attendance so we need the 10 Masses to accommodate everyone.
Sounds similar to ours, although we spread them over Friday, Saturday and Sunday. The Rosary is also said before every Mass. The very early ones have no music and last just over half an hour; later in the day and in the evening they are 1 hour, but we do sing at those. Often while there is Mass in one language in the main church, it is also being offered in the chapel and/or one of the halls in other languages. (Just checked my calendar, up to 24 “Sunday Masses” available between Friday morning and Sunday evening.)
 
…from what I’ve experienced, Filipinos (at least hear in the States) LOVE to sing and they are pretty good Catholics in terms of mass attendance, at least. Until their kids become “Americanized”. 😦
One Mass I attended sung by a Filipino choir had about 10 minutes of “It’s a Small World,” where about 10 people walked out before the Mass even started.
 
I remember singing “ O Sacred Head Ill-Used” with the school choir.It remains my favourite hymn even today,as it brings home to me the suffering of Our Lord Jesus more than any other.That glorious melody is from Bach’s St Matthew Passion. Bach was a good Lutheran and said towards the end of his life that every note he had ever written was “for the greater glory of God”.
 
You learn something new every day. I’ve heard that for years.
I must add, that I was taught the more one participates in the Mass, the more grace one gets from it. I always sing and I always give the proper responses. I figure if I go to the trouble to go to Mass I must get all I can out of it. It so easy to do, and yet many people attend Mass and just stand there with not a word for the entire service.
 
I must add, that I was taught the more one participates in the Mass, the more grace one gets from it. I always sing and I always give the proper responses. I figure if I go to the trouble to go to Mass I must get all I can out of it. It so easy to do, and yet many people attend Mass and just stand there with not a word for the entire service.
Well, there is this little thing called an obligation to attend. But you know that.
 
Well, there is this little thing called an obligation to attend. But you know that.
That’s a given! However, those standing in Church like zombies are there, I would assume, for that very reason. Don’t get me wrong, I think it’s great they are there, but it would be more interesting and meaningful for them if they participated.
 
One Mass I attended sung by a Filipino choir had about 10 minutes of “It’s a Small World,” where about 10 people walked out before the Mass even started.
That’s pretty bad. I would have walked out as well. The last Filipino mass I attended had a choir that sang some beautiful motets, as well as traditional tagalog hymns and mass parts. All depends on where you go.
 
That’s a given! However, those standing in Church like zombies are there, I would assume, for that very reason. Don’t get me wrong, I think it’s great they are there, but it would be more interesting and meaningful for them if they participated.
In the Spanish Mass, clapping to the music could be considered participation as well. Just saying.
 
I feel the same way too. I don’t even know what my singing voice sounds like even when I do sing the sound is gone with the rest of the people singing. Normally I stand in respect and eventually learned the words of the hymns and just say them and not look in the book because I like to watch the mass because I’m always in awe when I watch and when I look in the hymn book I feel like I’m missing out.
 
Interesting.

Could hymns then actually be responsible for low Mass attendance elsewhere? Just a question.

Congrats on the 80% attendance.
Generally here throughout the Philippines its a similar Mass attendance. Of course its a Catholic country and most people here are cradle Catholics.
People here live and breathe their faith daily. I have not gone through a day where Christ and Mary have not been in many conversations throughout the day and these are conversations not just with family but with friends and even strangers. Nobody feels awkward about discussing their faith here and nobody gets offended when its mentioned.
On Sundays many malls have Masses. Many of the office blocks in the business districts have chapels where workers on weekdays can have a quiet time to pray before starting work, or during a coffee break, at lunchtime or before they go home.
Catholics here are very devout. Sadly though many, if not most, seem to have been badly catechised. Even our priests at my local parish Church publicly mention from time to time that its strange seeing the Confession lines so short but the Communion lines so long.
I became a Catholic 21 years ago and it was after my RCIA classes when I went home to tell my wife about what had been discussed did I realise that although very devout my wife was ignorant about what the Church actually teaches. Over the years I have found that applies to almost all cradle Catholics I have met here.
I don’t know if the poor catechesis is the fault of the Church or the parents or both. I found it odd that as a convert I knew more about the Catholic faith than those born into it. I bought CCC’s for all my family and over the years have tried to help them by discussing the Church teachings. Anything I’m unsure of I talk to a priest and encourage them to do likewise.

Apologies to the OP for digressing. I’ll stop now.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top