F
fakename
Guest
I wondering in what way do many small thefts lead to a mortal sin if it is true that many venial sins don’t add up to a mortal sin?
Think of us hanging onto God with a rope. Now imaging one strand of the rope getting severed every time we commit a venial sin. With enough venial sins the rope is severed and we fall away from God’s grace and religion.I wondering in what way do many small thefts lead to a mortal sin if it is true that many venial sins don’t add up to a mortal sin?
Hi fakename,I wondering in what way do many small thefts lead to a mortal sin if it is true that many venial sins don’t add up to a mortal sin?
But then how does one explain this from the Catholic Encyclopedia?No, that’s actually not the case. You might use an analogy of a rope being severed to represent–I don’t know–our distancing ourselves from God and the habitual practice of sin. But from a strictly theological standpoint, no number of venial sins well ever tally up to one mortal sin.
Again, why the seeming “summation” of thefts to forge a theft of increased gravity?But then how does one explain this from the Catholic Encyclopedia?
"small pilferings perpetrated at different times, whether to the prejudice of one or of many owners, can eventually coalesce and reach a sum forbidden under pain of mortal sin.
This coalescence may be brought about by the specific intention of the thief in his petty stealing to ultimately arrive at a conspicuous amount.
One who hoards the proceeds of his petty thefts is chargeable with mortal sin when the sum accumulated is grave.
Even when he has disposed of his ill-gotten goods as fast as they were acquired, his thievings will still be held to coalesce unless there has been a considerable interval of time between them."
And what amount generally counts as a grave amount, because I’m pretty sure I must’ve taken 100 dollars from a corporation.
Are you asking how much you’re allowed to steal before you’re kicked from Purgatory to Hell?But then how does one explain this from the Catholic Encyclopedia?
"small pilferings perpetrated at different times, whether to the prejudice of one or of many owners, can eventually coalesce and reach a sum forbidden under pain of mortal sin.
This coalescence may be brought about by the specific intention of the thief in his petty stealing to ultimately arrive at a conspicuous amount.
One who hoards the proceeds of his petty thefts is chargeable with mortal sin when the sum accumulated is grave.
Even when he has disposed of his ill-gotten goods as fast as they were acquired, his thievings will still be held to coalesce unless there has been a considerable interval of time between them."
And what amount generally counts as a grave amount, because I’m pretty sure I must’ve taken 100 dollars from a corporation.
To the extent that statement may imply that I’m taking a mercenary view of religion, I wouldn’t say that was the question. But to the extent that any classification of venial vs. mortal implies that you now know how much of one thing leads from purgatory to hell, then I would say that is the question.Are you asking how much you’re allowed to steal before you’re kicked from Purgatory to Hell?
There is often both grave matter and venial matter…under the various commandments.I always thought stealing was a mortal sin since it’s one of the 10 commandments.
OK, fair enough.To the extent that statement may imply that I’m taking a mercenary view of religion, I wouldn’t say that was the question. But to the extent that any classification of venial vs. mortal implies that you now know how much of one thing leads from purgatory to hell, then I would say that is the question.
In a sense, I’ve thought of the RC distinction between venial and mortal sins as akin to secular misdemeanors and felonies. The general rule, at least in the US, I believe, is that no quantity of misdemeanors can equal a felony unless the law provides for it. So, if you commit misdemeanor Disorderly Conduct every night for a year, you have still not committed a felony. Now, with theft, there is a principle (very old, I believe) that a series of theft acts that constitute part of an overall plan or scheme (i.e. they weren’t just independent impulse thefts, but you had a plan all along to steal little by little) can be treated by the law as a single act of theft where the entire fruits of all the thefts were stolen at once, and they can add up the value and if it meets the threshold for felony grand theft then they can convict you of that.If it takes you twenty years to smuggle all the parts for a Cadillac out of the GM plant, it’s still grand theft auto.
Seriously, though, it depends. Of course gravity is a necessary component of mortal sin, but you can’t literally think of venials and mortals as if they were misdemeanors and felonies.
Actually, yes. A good priest friend of mine informed me that during seminary they actually were told dollar amounts as a guideline for determining whether theft was venial or mortal.Small theft is venial? I didn’t know that. Is there actually a monetary value placed on the difference between venial and mortal theft?
I know this is a few years old but I’m for some answers to some of this as well, mostly pertaining to this last partHello, I’m new to the forum, but I’m having a scrupulous problem here.
I was a revert back to the Church about a year ago. Now, before that I did some horrible things! When I came back to the church I made a general confession.
One of the sins I committed had to do with with stealing CD’s and DVD’s from a few major chain outlets… When I was finally caught and arrested I made a restitution in a money amount back to the store and I confessed my sins to a priest on this.
Now, I know my sins were absolved, but now I was just told the absolution may be only “conditional” ONLY if proper restitution was made. I don’t even remember what everything was worth., However, I have given probably hundreds of dollars worth of money to Church’s ,a few religious apostolates, and soup and clothes to poor communities…Where is the line drawn and when is it sufficient enough?
Also, Back when I was stealing these items I did not know it was a mortal sin and I didn’t reflect upon the grave matter when i did it…
How can one answer this to put my mind at ease!
Thanks!
Small pilferings perpetrated at different times, whether to the prejudice of one or of many owners, can eventually coalesce and reach a sum forbidden under pain of mortal sin.
I think that the issue here, is that the thief’s INTENT is to steal, say, a thousand dollars. The reason the thief doesn’t steal the thousand dollars outright is NOT because he has any concerns that “stealing a thousand dollars is mortal sin, but stealing one dollar is a venial sin”, but merely out of reasons of pragmatic expediency; someone who embezzles a thousand dollars at once might be easily exposed, but embezzling 1 or 2 dollars at a time might be hard to trace.This coalescence may be brought about by the specific intention of the thief in his petty stealing to ultimately arrive at a conspicuous amount.