Smoking?

  • Thread starter Thread starter The_Catholic
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

The_Catholic

Guest
Is smoking tabacco a mortal sin, veinal sin, or is it even a sin? I don’t mean a few smokes a day but like a half a pack every day.

Also, is a person who smokes weed (I can’t spell the “M” word) only once a day to kick back and relax sinning?
 
Is smoking tabacco a mortal sin, veinal sin, or is it even a sin? I don’t mean a few smokes a day but like a half a pack every day.
There’s nothing intrinsically evil about smoking tobacco. Therefore it is neither mortal or venial sin. However, like all things, we must use prudence when partaking of such a thing. With the full knowledge of the damaging effects of tobacco, smoking excessively could indeed constitute sin. I would still think it to be venial sin though.
Also, is a person who smokes weed (I can’t spell the “M” word) only once a day to kick back and relax sinning?
Again, there’s nothing intrinsically wrong with smoking weed. However, it is indeed a sin to break the laws of a country, so long as those laws are not contrary to our Catholic faith. Therefore it would be a sin to smoke weed in any country where it is illegal to smoke weed.
 
both habits do irreparable harm to the body and the brain, so I would say, yes they are sinful violations of the 5th commandment, which means this discussion belongs in the moral theology forum, not here. it also means the topic has been done to death here (no pun intended) and I doubt very much if any more can be contributed than has already been said before.
 
I guess you can also say that eating too much junk food can be a sin too, right? Like eating pies and cakes excessivly to the point where you gain weight and begin to have high blood pressure. So yeah, it seems that smoking excessivly can be a sin. I see it as that. But I don’t think it is a sin to seperate you from God for all eternity. My father-in-law smokes alot and he is a devout Catholic. But I will not say that he’s sinning. I guess tobacco is just more than a “feel” good drug. It’s very addictive.

I understand what you’re saying about weed and I am not sticking up for “pot heads.” But there are many American laws that I feel are wrong and unorthodox to the orgin of the country and the Catholic Church seems to say nothing about this (at least that’s what I’ve seen). So I have a problem supporting these “American/liberal” laws and don’t care to.
 
There’s nothing intrinsically evil about smoking tobacco. Therefore it is neither mortal or venial sin. However, like all things, we must use prudence when partaking of such a thing. With the full knowledge of the damaging effects of tobacco, smoking excessively could indeed constitute sin. I would still think it to be venial sin though.

Again, there’s nothing intrinsically wrong with smoking weed. However, it is indeed a sin to break the laws of a country, so long as those laws are not contrary to our Catholic faith. Therefore it would be a sin to smoke weed in any country where it is illegal to smoke weed.
Regarding your last coment, many states in the country are setting up “No Smoking” zones all around. I can even imagine that in the future they could establish a “Smoke Free” America and make tobacco illegal (as silly as that sounds, I woun’t be surprised if that happened). So then I assume many smokers who find it hard to quit would go underground for tobacco just as people do now for weed. Does that mean that they’re sinning? Quiting these bad habits is easier said than done. And these questions are hard to answer.

Keep in mind I’m not arguing with you, just pondering the thought.
 
Keep in mind I’m not arguing with you, just pondering the thought.
No worries! This is how we learn. Back to your question…
Regarding your last coment, many states in the country are setting up “No Smoking” zones all around. I can even imagine that in the future they could establish a “Smoke Free” America and make tobacco illegal (as silly as that sounds, I woun’t be surprised if that happened). So then I assume many smokers who find it hard to quit would go underground for tobacco just as people do now for weed. Does that mean that they’re sinning? Quiting these bad habits is easier said than done. And these questions are hard to answer.
I think it would now be sin, as they would be breaking the law. It is a sin to break the law, unless you have just cause to do so (to reiterate, an example would be where the law is contrary to the Catholic faith). However, their culpability would be reduced due to their addiction. This is similar to those attached to any habitual sin.

I disagree with Annie who seems to be saying that any and all instances of smoking are sin. Although I hate the stuff (and I go on and on about it), I really think that it only becomes a sin if it is abused.
 
I quit smoking about 4-5 months ago. Nicotine addiction can be compaired to Heroin. It is a stimulant and produces some very powerful addiction. I was a heavy smoker and needed to quit for my health. Being a smoker is being an addict plain and simple. Is being an addict a mortal sin? Thats between you and God but I think he understands the level of difficulty.

The difficult thing about this addiction is the psychological end of it. It’s difficult to re-program your head to understand that it’s stupid to suck forest fire into your lungs. A lot of people die from this and a lot of people make big money from this (including state governments). The whole thing is evil and needs to be outlawed. The important thing to remember is that you can’t quit until your ready. Unless you are totally commited you will fail miserably.

-D
 
I find it puzzling that people undergoing withdrawal from heroin and cocaine have formal residential programs with all kinds of medical and psychological support, but those on withdrawal from tobacco, which is equal in the tenacity of its grip and effect on all systems of body and mind, are expected to go it alone, without a support system. I think a “rehab” of some kind for smokers trying to quit would be a great idea for insurance companies to underwrite, and in the long run would save a lot of money.
 
This is actually a very interesting question that I’ve been looking into recently. It’s interesting because it’s one of those rare “grey areas” of morality in the Catholic Church. I’ve looked at a lot of threads on the boards, asked several priests, and this is what I conclude (although don’t take this as definitive).

Smoking is not intrinsically evil. To smoke a single cigarette will NOT give you cancer nor pose much individual risk to a person. It is not a sin to do so, and so it is no more a sin than having a glass of wine or a beer. However, because of the serious cumulative effects of smoking, to smoke to excess would be a venial sin, just as drinking to the point of intoxication is a sin. Both involve gluttony and harm to the body. BUT… here’s where it gets fuzzy… Smoking is also highly addictive, so once it got to the point of excess, you would also likely be an addict, and that removes much of the culpibility. So, it might not be a sin in that circumstance. Further, most people start smoking when they’re young, and in order to sin, one must understand that it is a sin. Many youth are not fully aware of the serious health consequences of smoking, and so the seriousness of the sin might be reduced, if not removed entirely. So, given the age that most people start, the fact that smoking in moderation is not a sin at all, and that addiction removes much of the accountability, it’s likely that a large number of people aren’t sinning when they smoke.

There are, of course, circumstances in which smoking most likely remains a sin. Smoking while pregnant, for example, would be a sin. Spending excessive money on smoking to the detriment of other things is a sin. Second-hand smoke may or may not be a sin, I haven’t really figured that one out yet.
 
Book: Catholicism for Dummies page 191:
Abusing drugs and alcohol is considered breaking the 5th Commandment, because it recklessly endangers the user’s life and potentially endangers others if someone is under the influence becomes violent and irrational. Drunk driving is considered a violation, because drunk drivers are jeopardizing their own life and the lives of others by using an auto under the influence.
So the questions to ask are:
Does smoking cigarettes mean you are abusing drugs?
Are you recklessly endangering your life or the life of others?

Answering yes to either question could mean that it’s sin.
 
This is actually a very interesting question that I’ve been looking into recently. It’s interesting because it’s one of those rare “grey areas” of morality in the Catholic Church. I’ve looked at a lot of threads on the boards, asked several priests, and this is what I conclude (although don’t take this as definitive).

Smoking is not intrinsically evil. To smoke a single cigarette will NOT give you cancer nor pose much individual risk to a person. It is not a sin to do so, and so it is no more a sin than having a glass of wine or a beer. However, because of the serious cumulative effects of smoking, to smoke to excess would be a venial sin, just as drinking to the point of intoxication is a sin. Both involve gluttony and harm to the body. BUT… here’s where it gets fuzzy… Smoking is also highly addictive, so once it got to the point of excess, you would also likely be an addict, and that removes much of the culpibility. So, it might not be a sin in that circumstance. Further, most people start smoking when they’re young, and in order to sin, one must understand that it is a sin. Many youth are not fully aware of the serious health consequences of smoking, and so the seriousness of the sin might be reduced, if not removed entirely. So, given the age that most people start, the fact that smoking in moderation is not a sin at all, and that addiction removes much of the accountability, it’s likely that a large number of people aren’t sinning when they smoke.

There are, of course, circumstances in which smoking most likely remains a sin. Smoking while pregnant, for example, would be a sin. Spending excessive money on smoking to the detriment of other things is a sin. Second-hand smoke may or may not be a sin, I haven’t really figured that one out yet.
This is the best answer I have ever heard on smoking.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top