So much focus on lust -- what about pride?

  • Thread starter Thread starter AlanFromWichita
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

AlanFromWichita

Guest
Since I started a class on the seven deadly sins I began to look at the sins categorized like Dante’s Mountain of Purgatory (I started a thread about the class)

But in Dante’s Mountain, lust comes in as the least weighty of the seven sins. In class we called Lust and gluttony, “sins of passion,” at the top of the mountain, and Anger, Envy, and Pride, “perverted passions,” at the base. The bottom one is Pride, which is at the base of all the other sins – and yet it is the one we seem to like to prop up more than cut down. So we judge excessive passion, but we actually revel in our perverted passions of pride.

We do have an occasional thread about anger. But when was the last thread anybody’s seen about losing faith due to problems with pride or envy, which in the Mountain are much more serious than lust? At least we seem to recognize and admit our anger, so we do have threads about it.

But it would seem that pride and envy are the “biggest elephants” in a room full of sinners, but we don’t have threads about “I’m losing my faith over pride.” Which it seems like we often should be.

For example, I think we do lose our faith over pride when we talk about how others behave at Mass. Or if not pride then maybe envy (how come they get away with that) or anger (“they are not like me – must bash them them until they conform or die”). And funny thing is, we can’t get our focus off the other. They may not even be sinning but we are in our judgment of them. And just as someone suggests to the OP that the OP needs to work on the plank in their own eye, someone else comes in and curses those who behave like the OP described to reinforce the pride. Doesn’t matter what behavior we mean – letting a baby cry, receiving Communion in the hand or while standing, using Orans position for Our Father or worse yet holding hands, leaving early after Mass, wearing the wrong clothes. All the things we sputter and spew about when others do them – you see the Church is a laboratory for us because she puts us near these sinners so we can see how we react. If we go to our anger, envy and pride programs and try to eliminate them or fix them or curse them – anything other than love, mercy, and welcome – then we actually reinforce our mountains of sin at the very base. So we go to the sinners’ hospital to use sins we perceive in others, in order to reinforce our own – doesn’t sound like a Good Strategy to me. :rolleyes:

Another one is in our haughty attitude toward non-Catholics. Pride in belonging to one group is the problem we have here, even though Jesus gave us clear teachings to the contrary. The Good Samaritan. The Pharisee and the tax collector. (Luke 18) The sinful woman washing Jesus’s feet. Every time one person looks askance at another because don’t belong to the right group, Jesus elevates the outsider above them. So much so that we take “Pharisee” to be a derogatory term and yet Jesus was a Pharisee. So when someone tells us we are Pharisees, doesn’t that mean we are “like Jesus?” :bigyikes: If not, then we do we think we are like Jesus because we are Catholic? Like the joke about being in the garage doesn’t make you a car. :whacky: And yet we love to get together in what frankly seems to be self-indulgence – almost group gratification or something – and congratulate ourselves for being Catholic and pity/vilify those who aren’t. We should be grateful and humble to have the gift of Catholicism, not haughty and proud like the Pharisee in Luke 18.

So if we have lust we know it, and we work on it. But if we have pride, we disguise it as being “good” or “100%” Catholic. I think the next time I see someone self-identify as “100% Catholic” I think I’ll ask them what it was like being lifted to heaven after getting off that Cross. Ah, but there goes my own judgment. Sticky wicket, I say. 😛

Alan
 
Pride is an illusion, a lie and a thief. And since it is a truth of faith that we are nothing, he who esteems himself and thinks that he is someone, ia a seducer who decieves himself.
St. John Eudes

Thus saith the Lord: Stand ye on the ways, and see, and ask for the old paths, which is the good way, and walk ye in it: and you will find refreshment for your souls.
Jeremiah 6:16
 
Perhaps a part of the issue is that pride can be hidden and disguised so that one does not see it. Elements that make up the various “deadly sins” can be things that are also good in the proper order of things. For instance, eating is good, but gluttony is bad. Sex is good, but lust is bad. Self love is good, pride is bad.

Pride, being at the core of so many other sins can be especially difficult because we are told to love our neighbor as our selves. So - loving ourselves cannot be seen a a bad thing in and of itself. But self love can begin to rub up against “pride” just as eating and enjoying food can rub up against gluttony.

That said…I appreciate your starting this thread. It is good to explore these things.

Peace
James
 
But self love can begin to rub up against “pride” just as eating and enjoying food can rub up against gluttony.
This is my favorite part of your post. I never thought to compare pride with self-love this way, but it makes a lot of sense. So here I go with a few stormy ideas, hopefully related…

The Mountain of Purgatory I used in my thread about my 7 sins class, categorized the sins a little bit differently than in class. They labeled Lust, Gluttony, and Greed as “love excessive,” Sloth as “love deficient,” and Anger, Envy, Pride as “love perverted.” So all the sins are sins against love.

For a bit of contrast, the difference between “love excessive” and “love perverted” could suggest that the difference between gluttony and love of eating, are matters of degree. Same as greed is wanting more than need.

Using this mountain as the model, pride wouldn’t just be an excess of self love, but a perversion of it. IOW, I don’t know that it’s possible to love too much, unless that’s what lust is. But see here I’m not sure I understand it because the greatest love you can show is to give your life and that isn’t normally something we lust after unless maybe we’re in deep depression. So maybe since Pride, Envy, and Anger are perversions of love that we can actually become pure from them? There is no “small size” version of behavior that reveals Pride, Envy, Anger that is acceptable to a Christian.

Could it be this is part of why Jesus hung around people who had sins of lust, and defended them against people who had sins of pride, envy, and anger? Because lust and gluttony are always right there to tempt us, so we cannot totally escape the environment that provides us the “tools” or “media” by which we express these sins.

Gluttony and lust can also be for things other than eating food and being oversexed. Could it be that we have seeds planted in us that draw us toward these things as matters of survival? And it’s how we cultivate them that matters? Where as with the other sins we want to eradicate them? So there may be something in common as they take real passion and substitute passion for physical things? Or how about a person who reads books excessively to the detriment of anything else? Would that be gluttony, or greed, or lust? Nobody needs to read books for survival, but what else would it be – sloth because we’re avoiding other things?

I’m just seeing where some thinking takes me. This isn’t an analysis or conclusion – just thinking out loud in the presence of other POV’s.

So maybe the sins of excess are matters of the flesh, and the sins of perversion are more closely related to matters of the spirit? Like Satan doesn’t have to tempt us to eat or reproduce, but he did have to lie to Eve to give us pride and envy and we have to have accepted those sins as our own mortality.

Alan
 
This is one of those threads I enjoy but have to keep reading, re-reading and thinking things over for a while. Some of the instances you refer to as examples of pride had not really crossed my mind before, so it is good to evaluate internally. There are times when I feel that we are judged as having pride over being Catholic and yet the very history of the Church and it’s origins are the driving force behind our feelings that we are the “true” faith. So, this is a place that has me stumped as to whether it is pride or fact when we say we are good Catholics. For me it has only meant that this person agrees with and does the best they can to follow the laws and truths of the faith, not that they are prideful of themselves. Oh well, I am way behind most of you when the conversations get philosophical. It’s good to challenge my mind for sure!
 
This is my favorite part of your post. I never thought to compare pride with self-love this way, but it makes a lot of sense. So here I go with a few stormy ideas, hopefully related…

The Mountain of Purgatory I used in my thread about my 7 sins class, categorized the sins a little bit differently than in class. They labeled Lust, Gluttony, and Greed as “love excessive,” Sloth as “love deficient,” and Anger, Envy, Pride as “love perverted.” So all the sins are sins against love.

For a bit of contrast, the difference between “love excessive” and “love perverted” could suggest that the difference between gluttony and love of eating, are matters of degree. Same as greed is wanting more than need.

Using this mountain as the model, pride wouldn’t just be an excess of self love, but a perversion of it. IOW, I don’t know that it’s possible to love too much, unless that’s what lust is. But see here I’m not sure I understand it because the greatest love you can show is to give your life and that isn’t normally something we lust after unless maybe we’re in deep depression. So maybe since Pride, Envy, and Anger are perversions of love that we can actually become pure from them? There is no “small size” version of behavior that reveals Pride, Envy, Anger that is acceptable to a Christian.

Could it be this is part of why Jesus hung around people who had sins of lust, and defended them against people who had sins of pride, envy, and anger? Because lust and gluttony are always right there to tempt us, so we cannot totally escape the environment that provides us the “tools” or “media” by which we express these sins.

Gluttony and lust can also be for things other than eating food and being oversexed. Could it be that we have seeds planted in us that draw us toward these things as matters of survival? And it’s how we cultivate them that matters? Where as with the other sins we want to eradicate them? So there may be something in common as they take real passion and substitute passion for physical things? Or how about a person who reads books excessively to the detriment of anything else? Would that be gluttony, or greed, or lust? Nobody needs to read books for survival, but what else would it be – sloth because we’re avoiding other things?

I’m just seeing where some thinking takes me. This isn’t an analysis or conclusion – just thinking out loud in the presence of other POV’s.

So maybe the sins of excess are matters of the flesh, and the sins of perversion are more closely related to matters of the spirit? Like Satan doesn’t have to tempt us to eat or reproduce, but he did have to lie to Eve to give us pride and envy and we have to have accepted those sins as our own mortality.

Alan
Alan,
Great post.
I like how the sins are classed in relation to Love…For Love is the core of all things.

Like mountee - I think I will need to read through you post a couple of more times and ponder a bit before I can offer any reply…When I do it will likely be in the same form as your post is offered…just some thoughts.

Peace
James
 
So, this is a place that has me stumped as to whether it is pride or fact when we say we are good Catholics. For me it has only meant that this person agrees with and does the best they can to follow the laws and truths of the faith, not that they are prideful of themselves.
I think you have a good point, because we want to be Good Catholics, and most of us do try to do the best we can. I don’t even exclude those who can’t get around certain teachings; as long as they leave themselves open to learning.

And to be fair, when I’ve seen people use a term like “100% Catholic,” they don’t mean they are perfect; they mean they (as opposed to Catholics who are not 100%) at least have a desire to accept all the Church has. IMO this is also a false distinction, made on pride because I think we all have a continuum of ideas about Church teachings and they cannot be segregated into categories that apply from one person to the next.

But the problem is if we self-identify as “Good Catholic,” that begs the question whether there are Catholics who are not “Good Catholics.” If I say, “I am Catholic,” then I am stating a fact. If I am saying “I am a Good Catholic,” then that implies there is at least one other Catholic that I’m better than.

So I think it’s safest just to identify as “Catholic.” Because any adjective or qualifier like that separates the Body of Christ into two categories – the one I’m in and the “other.”

I guess I can say I’m a Roman Catholic… :o
Oh well, I am way behind most of you when the conversations get philosophical. It’s good to challenge my mind for sure!
I liked your post. My favorite philosophical discussions are about people’s honest ideas and opinions, in addition to or even instead of “authoritative” sources. So many people talk about what certain elite say, and leaders and scholars. But funny thing how God does things; He brings Truth to us through a humble infant, not through kings and scholars.

Many of us in the US have been brought up knowing a story of a small child being the only one honest enough to say, “the emperor has no clothes,” when everybody else in town could see that but were all too afraid to be “politically incorrect” so they all cheered about his beautiful new clothes. I’m convinced this is why Jesus says the first shall be last, and all those things. Truth can come from anywhere, but Truth spoken from our own hearts can level all of us across all boundaries. 🙂

“Few are those who see with their own eyes and feel with their own hearts.” – Albert Einstein

Alan
 
Well, I think I got it, thanks for taking the time to elaborate. Thinking makes me tired:eek:
 
For the proud, humility is like a heavily armed guard who keeps a constant eye on the prison cell door. But for the righteous, humility is like the liberator who frees the helpless slave from the evil of his or her wicked master.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top