So What is Wrong with Feminism?

  • Thread starter Thread starter TinaG
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I’m still left wondering why they call themselves ‘Feminists For Life’! 😃
Because they believe God gave women rights, dignity, purpose, etc.?

They don’t define feminism for me. Actually, I think it has been wonderfully expressed on this thread and the Inklings thread.

-Tina:)
 
Because they believe God gave women rights, dignity, purpose, etc.?

They don’t define feminism for me. Actually, I think it has been wonderfully expressed on this thread and the Inklings thread.

-Tina:)
I suppose that what I’m saying is that, should there be an organization called ‘Stamp Collectors For Life’, I’d expect a lot of ‘Life’ stuff but I’d also expect that there was some vague interest in matters generally important to stamp collectors.

Not so with ‘Feminists For Life’, so, I’d have thought that, if they wanted to communicate to Feminists rather than, say, Catholic right-wingers, it might be vaguely sensible to talk about something shared.
 
This is the primary form of feminism in existence today.

The National Organization for Women convinced some women to accept the role of eternal victim of the eternal enemy - men. Men were called male chauvenist pigs. Gloria Steinem said, “A woman needs a man like a fish needs a bicycle.” Betty Friedan wrote that the family is “a comfortable concentration camp.” What a vile thing to say.

Miss Steinem created Ms. magazine, which is the origin of that word.

The goal was to convince women that motherhood was bad, careers good. Killing your child in the womb, good. Being separated from men, good.

Instead of offering healing, understanding and cooperation, they preached the victim with the open wound who can never be healed from the assault of the enemy. Go ahead, look up NOW’s ‘position’ on prostitution. They turned women against their natural, God given state to a form of radicalism and class warfare.

It was and is anti-family, nihilistic, not solution oriented and purposely divisive.

Now, Sex and the City protrays female chauvenist pigs. Equality was never achieved.

Peace,
Ed
 
I’ve done so now and before.

I’m asking a serious question - where are any issues that a feminist might consider ‘feminist’? Where’s the stuff on domestic violence? Women in the workplace? Or all the other conventional feminist issues?

It does seem rather an empty shell on anything than ‘life issues’.
feministsforlife.org/taf/1998/summer/Summer98.pdf

Here is the Summer 1998 issue of their newsletter.
This is a “Work vs. Family” themed issue, and contents include: “The Challenges of Welfare to Work”, “Choosing Stay-at-Home Motherhood: One Mother’s Perspective”, “Motherhood in a Corporate Culture”, “Coping and Caring for Elderly Loved Ones”, and “Parenting Professors: Trailblazing Schools Support Family”

feministsforlife.org/taf/1998/fall/Fall98.pdf

This is the “Victory over Violence” issue, Fall 1998.
 
How do you people come up with this stuff? Please read through the thread and check out the links before responding further.

Thank you very much!

-Tina:)
You mean the 8 posts before mine, and the one link?

I come up with this stuff by watching the actions of those in the feminist movement. I watch when they ignore perverted and sometimes criminal behavior of public figures b/c they hold the right political positions. I watch as they attack women who believe differently than they do.

Quite simply, a politician can do absolutely ANYTHING and will NOT be attacked by N.O.W. as long as they are pro-abortion.
 
No, I’m making the point that they seem to think that abortion is the only issue.
Its not their only issue, its just their main issue hence they call themselves “feminists FOR LIFE” their website largely to show that feminists do not need to be pro abortion and that the first wave feminists were opposed to abortion and believed in motherhood
 
feministsforlife.org/taf/1998/summer/Summer98.pdf

Here is the Summer 1998 issue of their newsletter.
This is a “Work vs. Family” themed issue, and contents include: “The Challenges of Welfare to Work”, “Choosing Stay-at-Home Motherhood: One Mother’s Perspective”, “Motherhood in a Corporate Culture”, “Coping and Caring for Elderly Loved Ones”, and “Parenting Professors: Trailblazing Schools Support Family”

feministsforlife.org/taf/1998/fall/Fall98.pdf

This is the “Victory over Violence” issue, Fall 1998.
Well, it does look as if at least one of them was interested over a decade ago (though they do rather look like a conservative view of women’s issues rather than feminist view of women’s issues).

Look, if a UK Tory can spot it as something of an intellectual empty shell that somebody thought of as a good idea at the time, just how long would it take an American liberal feminist?

Anybody can talk to the converted, anytime but, if you want to talk to your opponents, some common ground might be a good idea.
 
My observation is that people on CAF have a very narrow view of feminism, which has many different facets both historically and today. Some are particularly popular, and some less well known.

Ideally, “feminism” wouldn’t need to exist as such, any more than movements for racial equality. (Although in a perfect world one might still have women’s studies, that is, organizations dedicated to researching and helping women with things that are specific to them.)

For example, one not-so-popular group of feminists asserts that there are, in fact, no such thing as women and men, and that all there is is socially constructed gender identities and a continuum of individual differences (as we see more reasonably argued when discussing the idea of race.) It is pretty clear why this hasn’t really caught on I think.

But another view of feminism might be seen in an article that I read in a magazine directed to professional doulas (child-birth support people.) It was part of a research project being done by a young women in a feminist studies department. It was on what kind of social and government supports women receive after childbirth, and how it impacts their health, that of their infants, and the family dynamic as a whole. (She found, not surprisingly, that women in NA feel isolated and have little help from family or other sources, and this is a contributor to family problems, ppd, etc.) THis is not the idea of feminism most people think of immediately, but it is actually a very significant part of the feminist movement, which tends to be closely related to family issues.

But it isn’t that controversial, or sexy, and doesn’t make the news.

The type of feminism that is most well known is the kind that is about power, and money. I don’t think that should be a surprise, since those are in many ways the dominant concerns in our society. THey say a society gets the government it deserves, and the press it deserves, and maybe also the feminism it deserves too:rolleyes:. As a society, abortion, having small families, two-income families, are all part and parcel with high production and lots of consumption, lots of tax revenue, and being independent and getting along on your own two feet. I think that is why that variety of feminism is so big here.
 
Well, it does look as if at least one of them was interested over a decade ago (though they do rather look like a conservative view of women’s issues rather than feminist view of women’s issues).
Are you stipulating “feminism” as never conservative?
 
I admit I have a narrow experience of feminism and what I have narrowly experienced, in my very provincial town, is not positive and certainly not compatible with the Catholic Church.

I recently attended a “Gorilla Girl” event (story too long and complex to explain how I found myself in attendance) and was sickened at what college women define as feminisim. The Gorilla Girls tour the country spinning feminism threads here and there at as many college campuses that will have them.

It was robust with abortion awarness, loose sexuality issues, liberalism, crunchy granola topics, green this and that, and as many stereotypical topics that one might exepect - the men hating, lesbianism, we are alike in every way type of drival. They did not let me down in helping to firm up my opinion of the modern day feminist.

While that may certainly does not sound like the definition the OP has in mind, I submit that the word feminist conjurs up this very idea.

My step daughter also defines herself as a feminist. Right out of college -she despises the very notion that women should submit to their husbands. That a husband is the head of the household. It’s like pouring acid on her flesh. At Thanksgiving, I offered to serve my husband a slice of pie. Holy cow, I got the laser eyes of death boring a hole in my head for sugesting such. Dad can get his buttocks up and fetch his own pumpkin pie.

You know? I love serving my husband. I am not oppressed or depressed or forced to. He does not expect it - I don’t dote or wait on him. But we are certainly together to help each other and he does such amazingly nice things for me that I am almost ashamed I do not do more for him.

My idea of feminism is to let the man be the man.
 
I admit I have a narrow experience of feminism and what I have narrowly experienced, in my very provincial town, is not positive and certainly not compatible with the Catholic Church.

I recently attended a “Gorilla Girl” event (story too long and complex to explain how I found myself in attendance) and was sickened at what college women define as feminisim. The Gorilla Girls tour the country spinning feminism threads here and there at as many college campuses that will have them.

It was robust with abortion awarness, loose sexuality issues, liberalism, crunchy granola topics, green this and that, and as many stereotypical topics that one might exepect - the men hating, lesbianism, we are alike in every way type of drival. They did not let me down in helping to firm up my opinion of the modern day feminist.

While that may certainly does not sound like the definition the OP has in mind, I submit that the word feminist conjurs up this very idea.

My step daughter also defines herself as a feminist. Right out of college -she despises the very notion that women should submit to their husbands. That a husband is the head of the household. It’s like pouring acid on her flesh. At Thanksgiving, I offered to serve my husband a slice of pie. Holy cow, I got the laser eyes of death boring a hole in my head for sugesting such. Dad can get his buttocks up and fetch his own pumpkin pie.

You know? I love serving my husband. I am not oppressed or depressed or forced to. He does not expect it - I don’t dote or wait on him. But we are certainly together to help each other and he does such amazingly nice things for me that I am almost ashamed I do not do more for him.

My idea of feminism is to let the man be the man.
Christian feminism has been hijacked. Jesus said to take every thought captive and He also promises to redeem all things. What that means is that Christians should stand for true feminism and recognize that this sort of thing - such as you describe - comes out of idea of the woman as autonomous rather than as the creation of a loving God, to whom she is answerable. Romans 1 comes to mind: God has given them over to unnatural passions and a depraved mind. Scary: judgement seems to be on them, and we should pray.

I think the picture of the woman washing Christ’s feet with her hair is one we should take to heart in serving each other, as when we do so, we are serving Him. What that means is that something is very wrong with my heart if I am unwilling to wash the feet of anyone I meet, especially the poor and the needy, with my hair.

It is common courtesy to be willing to serve other people. When someone is in my home, I offer them what will make them comfortable, usually coffee or tea or whatever. When someone enters my office to talk, I offer them the same and I get it myself for them, including the cream and sugar. Sometimes I take someone with me when I clean the coffeepot. This is a way to lower barriers, and the latter really works with women. We bond with those we do dishes with. As a manager some men are confused when I pour them coffee and so express that I am their servant - even though I am their boss. I seek to be Christ to people. I seek to love everyone - some of this is, I think, easier for women to do, but difficult when someone sees a willingness to serve as a mark of inferiority, suppression and sexual war. Christ came not to lord it over others. Some need to hear that message.

-Tina 🙂
 
I think that you’re rather missing my point.
I’m sorry, I suppose I am.
Well, it does look as if at least one of them was interested over a decade ago (though they do rather look like a conservative view of women’s issues rather than feminist view of women’s issues).

Look, if a UK Tory can spot it as something of an intellectual empty shell that somebody thought of as a good idea at the time, just how long would it take an American liberal feminist?

Anybody can talk to the converted, anytime but, if you want to talk to your opponents, some common ground might be a good idea.
I don’t really know how to answer this. Those 2 newsletters (from over a decade ago) did address issues that were not abortion, so I feel that it is a reasonable (or at least charitable) assumption that there would be more newsletters also themed.

On the other hand, I can see the value of focussing the group’s energy. They’re feminists, ok, there are many feminist groups. A certain subset of those groups will be conservative feminist groups (but am I right in seeing your post distinguish the conservative view from the feminist view?) And a certain subset of the conservative feminist groups might be cover several issues, some might focus on domestic violence, some might focus on women in the workplace. These feminists focus on abortion.

I suppose I just don’t see the need for this group to cover other issues in-depth, because I assume they are covered elsewhere. (and please note, it is an assumption. I am a man, I have not found it necessary to seek out these other groups)
 
When I was fifteen my friends and I got ahold of some feminist literature. We decided we would burn our bras and become lesbians. We decided to do the second thing first, and we sort of all stood around and looked at each other. Nobody was interested. We were all boy crazy and we knew it, and that didn’t work, so we turned to bra burning. Only all we had was a cigarette lighter and that didn’t work. They aren’t that easy to burn (these weren’t anyway - not that I’ve taken a scientific sample, or ever tried it again -maybe Mythbusters can do an episode on it). Later we all had to explain the scorch marks to our mothers, and that was the end of THAT.

That’s not my kind of feminism.😃

So, in a roundabout way, I am asking, can feminism be compatible with Catholicism?
omg…that’s SO brilliant!!
You NEED to write mythbusters and tell them to burn bras.
I remember the same type of thing happening with me and my girlfriends…we all chickened out on the bra burning because those things are like FORTY BUCKS from Vic’s Secret!! Would you burn $40?
Exactly. We couldn’t either.
We decided to burn old underwear instead. It also wasn’t lighting. We figured if we doused it with gasoline that would be better. But we were afraid we would get in trouble, so we put the petrol and the old underwear into old bottls in our friend’s dad’s garage. This, my friend, if you aren’t aware, is what is called a malotov cocktail. We had no idea.
We are all SO LUCKY we didn’t kill ourselves.
And we ALL had to try the lesbian thing. Eh, it got us free drinks at the bar, so i guess it wasn’t a total loss. (We all had fake IDs too! What fun!)
Now on to your question YES YES YES.
Honestly, when I started to read especially JPII’s view of women, I was blown away.
here’s the radical view of the catholic church. Ready? It’s this - women are equal to men. Always and everywhere. Crazy, eh? And it’s not because we are LIKE men, it’s not because I DO the same job a man does, or because I can have affairs like men (although I coudln’t have affairs like Tiger Woods, how did that man even have time for GOLF?!?) or any of that.
I was just born that way. 🙂
I feel like we live in a society that is CONSTANTLY saying women are as good as men because they can do anything men can do. This is a lie on all counts. I’m as important as a man because I was CREATED that way, and I really and truly CAN’T do anything men can do. 🤷
And the church also has a radical view of sex which I don’t think you find in the culture at large. It is this:
Sex makes babies. If you make sex, you had better be okay with also making babies.
I mean, seriously, we live in this culture that keeps insisting that sex and babies are two different spheres. You can have sex without babies and babies without sex! it’s like it’s screamed from the mountain tops. But, that’s a lie. (I have twin daughters conceived on birth control as living proof to that!!)
I think the culture at large tells women that they need to be ‘sexy at any age’ and ‘these are the new tricks you can do in bed’ and ‘here’s how you can treat men like garbage’
But I don’t want to be sexy at 70. That would be creepy. And I don’t want to put a love swing in my bedroom. That would also be creepy. And I don’t want to treat anyone like garbage.
If I may make a suggestion, read the cathechism on women, or JPII on women. Don’t listen to what other people tell you the church teaches on women. Read what she ACTUALLY teaches. You may, like me, be pleasantly surprised.
🙂
Good luck and here’s to burning only the cheap flammable bras!!!
 
Those were the days.:rolleyes:

Unfortunately so many young women are caught up in this stuff and destroy any chance of a decent relationship, especially with a man. They look at it as a predator/prey relationship. This stuff is dangerous. Any personal autonomy is.

I’ve heard good things about Theology of the Body but also I heard JPII was quite philosophical, and that stuff (philosophy) can be completely unreadable.

-Tina
 
Like it or not, words have meaning and ideas have consequences.

Feminism, authentic feminism, is compatible with Church teaching. Susan B Anthony, Elizabeth Cady Stanton, and women of their caliber were authentically feminist.

However, a different sort of feminism co-opted the sufferagettes’ legitimate, authentic struggle for equality under the law and the dignity of women.

These new feminists perverted it and made it their own. They wrote books. They marched in marches. They created magazines like Ms. and Playgirl. They sought protections for abortion, divorce, contraception. prostitution, and pornography under the law. And, now feminism has a meaning in our society and its ideas have consequences. And all of them are bad.

Therefore, when we speak of authentic womanhood in the Church, we should strive to avoid such terms which now have specific meanings in our society. We should not strive to be “feminists” or “traditionalists” or whatever but rather Catholic.

The Church provides abundant guidance in her writings and abundant examples in her Saints.
Very well said.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top