So why isn't Faustina considered crazy?

  • Thread starter Thread starter bingbang
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
From **the little research **I did apparently her fellow nuns and others around her at the time thought she was crazy.
You might want to think about doing **a little more **research before trying to cast aspersions on the life of a saint. 🙂

You are also not considering that being a visionary is not what leads to sainthood. There are undoubtedly many people who received valid visions who were never canonized. Even if a person’s visions were unauthentic when examined by modern psychiatric methods, he/she could still be a saint. There is nothing that precludes a person suffering from a mental disorder from sainthood. (and I am NOT saying that is the case with St. Faustina or any canonized saint) The visions are generally what opens the “cause” for sainthood but are not part of the canonization investigation.
 
Does your average crazy person live a life of heroic virtue or perform miracles?

I don’t know much about her but as she is a Saint she must have done both of the above.
 
From the little research I did apparently her fellow nuns and others around her at the time thought she was crazy.
I will say I know nothing about this saint at all.

I think I read something SOMEWHERE…and I have to confess I do not recall where…that St Bernadette en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bernadette_Soubirousmay have suffered from temporal lobe epilepsy, from the descriptions of her visions.
I need to find that reference.
Ah, I think this is where I heard it…
bytrent.demon.co.uk/neurotheology01.html
bbc.co.uk/science/horizon/2003/godonbraintrans.shtml
I mean no disrespect to anyone who reveres these saints…and, I do believe that the RC church goes on a bit more than what the person in question saw, yes?

I think they also look at the externals, how many miracles/prayers were answered in the saint’s name, the life this person had, how many people they influenced for good, etc. Am I right?
 
The Church sets very strict standards which a vision much meet before she declares visions worthy of belief by the faithful.
 
What a horrible response. So without Rome’s approval she would have been just another crazy. Rome should start looking for saints in psych wards.
Consider that your own response is horrible and might seem quite crazy and irrational. Consider that without Rome’s approval there would be no need for people like yourself who disrespect The Church’s leadership to get irrational and crazy over their decisions which they don’t respect in the first place. Pray-tell why are you really upset here? Do you or do you not respect the church? If you don’t then why get upset, crazy and disrespectful about anything she says or let it bother you? Seems crazy to me…

BF
 
Not for people who think.
Oh yeah - the ol’ think for yourself canard. 😦 Here is the problem - too many try to think without having all the information.

It is an insult to all Catholics to believe you and a few others are the only ones who think. Give me a break.
 
Not for people who think.
If those people think they are the end-all of wisdom, then perhaps not. For thinking people who have come to the conclusion that the Church is the repository of truth and possesses the authority of Christ Himself, “Rome said so” is quite enough to make it so.

Your comment is rude and disrespectful; it asserts that faithful Catholics do not or cannot discern truth because they submit to the authority of the Church. Please refrain from making such disparaging comments in the future.

Peace,
Dante
 
Oh yeah - the ol’ think for yourself canard. 😦 Here is the problem - too many try to think without having all the information.

It is an insult to all Catholics to believe you and a few others are the only ones who think. Give me a break.
I never said that. All I said is that “Because Rome said so” is not a sufficient answer for a thinking person. And my criticism isn’t because it’s the Catholic Church - there are plenty of people who believe anything Barack Obama says, and I’d say exactly the same thing to them.
 
I never said that. All I said is that “Because Rome said so” is not a sufficient answer for a thinking person. And my criticism isn’t because it’s the Catholic Church - there are plenty of people who believe anything Barack Obama says, and I’d say exactly the same thing to them.
If a thinking person understands and gives assent to the Catholic proposition, then Rome said so is enough. In that case the cumulative wisdom, teaching and knowledge of truth far surpasses any individual.
 
For a Catholic the, “Because Rome said so” is an extremely valid comment. The decrees of Rome, including canonization is protected under infallibility.

“Roma locuta, causa finita” (Rome has spoken, the matter is settled)
 
It should be noted that this site is not at all sympathetic to Catholicism, and not much to Christianity. William James, one of the main authors cited, was the father of Pragmatism, and Emile Durkeim was a sociologist. I think it’s fair to say this site is antagonistic towards God and believers. Just something to think about when you read it.

As to the question about Saint Faustina, Pope John Paul II had a theologian go through her diary: it was declared free from theological error.
 
If a thinking person understands and gives assent to the Catholic proposition, then Rome said so is enough. In that case the cumulative wisdom, teaching and knowledge of truth far surpasses any individual.
In other words, the classic “appeal to authority” fallacy.
 
Faustina wasn’t declared a saint because she received visions and messages. Her whole life was scrutinized for years after her death, and she found to have lived and practiced heroic virtue. Obedience and humility were her hallmarks. She’s a canonized saint because a careful study of her life, writings, countless interviews with those who knew her, etc, bore witness to the authenticity of her everyday holiness. The official canonization process was followed catholic-pages.com/saints/process.asp and miracles were verified. The vast number of people in heaven no doubt will never be officially declared Saints by the catholic church, and that’s okay. They’re chosen to be examples to follow if one so chooses.

Now, in regard to her special favors from God: She wouldn’t have even written down her accounts of visions if it wasn’t under the order of her superior or spiritual director or confessor (I can’t recall off the top of my head who ordered her to put these experiences to writing). She did only as she was ordered. That’s why we have any account of her visions. Faustina simply did exactly as she was told and left the decisions up to her superiors.
 
Thats fine, but what makes her different than people in psych wards that claim to see Jesus or hell or something like that?
Again, please read her diary, and not just hear of her diary and hear of her visions. And then read why it was suppressed.

Also, know that she was given mental testing and found to be completely normal in that regard.

God bless you.
 
Because Rome said so. Enough said.
But what did Rome say?

First, she has been canonised, infallibly declared a person of heroic sanctity. This doesn’t necessarily have anything to do with her visions. One could, I suppose, be delusional and a saint at the same time.

Second, the Church never defines private revelations are real, just whether they are safe – i.e. they won’t lead the faithful astray. No Catholic is bound to believe in any apparition, not even Lourdes or Fatima much less Sr Faustina.

To say, “Rome said so” implying that we must believe in Sr Faustina’s visions is misleading.
As you may guess I’m from Missouri but I don’t think it is fair to assume Sr Faustina is crazy even if her visions were not of Divine origin. They could have been a natural product of religious ecstasy or just her way of understanding the mysteries of God.
 
I never said that. All I said is that “Because Rome said so” is not a sufficient answer for a thinking person.
By thinking person you mean someone who expects Christ to follow them instead of following Him. This is not been a thinking person, it is a person who has made an idol of themselves and is to weak to trust and have faith.

St. Augustine was a thinking person and it was good enough for him, and it should be good enough for anyone who holds the Catholic Faith, that is what Faith is, believing though you do not see nor understand because you are humble enough to acknowledge there are things above your competence to judge and beyond your finite human reasoning to understand.
 
In other words, the classic “appeal to authority” fallacy.
Hello… If one gives assent to the Catholic proposition…

Appeal to experience, wisdom, truth, and the protection of the Holy Spirit. I am OK with the authority of God, who is truth.
 
I never said that. All I said is that “Because Rome said so” is not a sufficient answer for a thinking person.
“Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven” 🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top