Sola Scriptura Discussion/Debate

  • Thread starter Thread starter Church_Militant
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I agree. The difference is that certain sola scripturists claim there is no correlation, when in reality there is. In effect, you’ve supported my point that Sola Scriptura, defined as “Bible Only” cannot be practiced. Prima Scriptura is the norm, even if they claim to hold on to Sola.
What everyone has to remember is that “Sola Scriptura” and “Prima Scriptura” are simply labels. Sheesh, they don’t even have verbs and therefore are not complete thoughts.

I am not convinced that Sola Scriptura is the most accurate label. I am also not convinced that it is worth having a cow about an imprecise label (it is not like Catholicism doesn’t have its imprecise labels and phrases either).
 
What everyone has to remember is that “Sola Scriptura” and “Prima Scriptura” are simply labels. Sheesh, they don’t even have verbs and therefore are not complete thoughts.

I am not convinced that Sola Scriptura is the most accurate label. I am also not convinced that it is worth having a cow about an imprecise label (it is not like Catholicism doesn’t have its imprecise labels and phrases either).
I agree. Lots of folks get too worked up over labels that mean different things to different people. It is kind of unfortunate that so much energy is expended arguing poorly defined labels or slogans and generally talking past each other.

I do believe in some form of “Sola Scriptura”, but I don’t hesitate to acknowledge my heavy dependence on “tradition” in the whole scheme of things.
 
In realistic terms is not private interpretation all that can be relied on in day to day study and devotions? The Church can provide broad brush strokes to provide some structure in which to work, but in the crunch an individual must rely on his own judgement. Even if the Church is infallible, this only applies to it as whole, or to certain pronouncements of the Pope. It does not extend to members of the laity or even individual members of the clergy. If you have a question about some matter upon which the Church has not spoken, or even about how an infallible interpretation applies to your own particular individual situation, you have no choice but to rely on fallible resources. You can interpret on your own or you can take your problem to a priest, bishop or theologian. However if you go to someone else, you are still receiving fallible advice. Unless there is some method of an individual accessing the Pope or the Magisterium as a whole, for all practical purposes you must rely on fallible private interpretation.
 
In realistic terms is not private interpretation all that can be relied on in day to day study and devotions? The Church can provide broad brush strokes to provide some structure in which to work, but in the crunch an individual must rely on his own judgement.
Well said! And for RC’s it is necessary that they must use their private interpretation to reason their way to the RCC, just as I have used my private interpretation of Scripture to find a non-denominational church that I believe teaches and worships in the true biblical and God-honoring way.
 
Well said! And for RC’s it is necessary that they must use their private interpretation to reason their way to the RCC, just as I have used my private interpretation of Scripture to find a non-denominational church that I believe teaches and worships in the true biblical and God-honoring way.
I see this claim so much. It strikes me as nothing more than “yeah, well so are you!” 🙂

In the first place, coming to faith is not the same as knowing what God has taught and has left us. It’s just bizarre to link the two. And people don’t come to faith through private interpretation but through grace, however that might manifest itself. It’s not as if every Christian first poured over the scriptures to decide if they should become a Christian.

And when it comes to what God has actually taught us, one cannot ask the bible for further clarification, but one can ask the Church for further clarification, and in theory repeat the process as often as necessary.
 
I see this claim so much. It strikes me as nothing more than “yeah, well so are you!” 🙂

In the first place, coming to faith is not the same as knowing what God has taught and has left us. It’s just bizarre to link the two. And people don’t come to faith through private interpretation but through grace, however that might manifest itself. It’s not as if every Christian first poured over the scriptures to decide if they should become a Christian.

And when it comes to what God has actually taught us, one cannot ask the bible for further clarification, but one can ask the Church for further clarification, and in theory repeat the process as often as necessary.
sola scriptura? the Bible does not teach it, so why would I believe it? Also, it has caused more division in Christendom than anything else. the devil is certainly crafty, making a seemingly good sounding thing so infinitely evil and chaotic and divisive.
 
I think St. Augustine sums things up quite nicely:

“The Catholic Church is the work of Divine Providence, achieved through the prophecies of the prophets, through the Incarnation and the teaching of Christ, through the journeys of the Apostles, through the suffering, the crosses, the blood and the death of the martyrs, through the admirable lives of the saints. When, then, we see so much help on God’s part, so much progress and so much fruit, shall we hesitate to bury ourselves in the bosom of that Church? For starting from the Apostolic Chair down through successions of bishops, even unto the open confession of all mankind, it has possessed the crown of teaching authority.”
The Advantage of Believing, 391 A.D.
 
I do believe in some form of “Sola Scriptura”, but I don’t hesitate to acknowledge my heavy dependence on “tradition” in the whole scheme of things.
At least you’re honest about it.

However, many sola scripturists deny they accept the authority of traditions or magisteriums, when they really do accept such authorities. I consider that to be intellectually dishonest, as sola scriptura cannot be practiced.
just as I have used my private interpretation of Scripture to find a non-denominational church that I believe teaches and worships in the true biblical and God-honoring way.
Ah, but are you sure they hold to the Apostolic interpretation of scripture?
 
And when it comes to what God has actually taught us, one cannot ask the bible for further clarification, but one can ask the Church for further clarification, and in theory repeat the process as often as necessary.
False dilemma, VociMike. It is not either the Bible or the Church. You left out the most important third party: God and the Spirit, which as I have pointed out, and you have just demonstrated, the Catholic church often forgets to emphasize and tell its members to follow.
Romans 7:6 But now, by dying to what once bound us, we have been released from the law so that we serve in the new way of the Spirit, and not in the old way of the written code.

Romans 8:14 because those who are led by the Spirit of God are sons of God.

1 Corinthians 2:14 The man without the Spirit does not accept the things that come from the Spirit of God, for they are foolishness to him, and he cannot understand them, because they are spiritually discerned.

2 Corinthians 3:6 He has made us competent as ministers of a new covenant—not of the letter but of the Spirit; for the letter kills, but the Spirit gives life.

Galatians 5:18 But if you are led by the Spirit, you are not under law.

Ephesians 1:17 I keep asking that the God of our Lord Jesus Christ, the glorious Father, may give you the Spirit of wisdom and revelation, so that you may know him better.

James 1:5 If any of you lacks wisdom, he should ask God, who gives generously to all without finding fault, and it will be given to him.

1 John 4:13 We know that we live in him and he in us, because he has given us of his Spirit.
*
 
One thing I feel I must say is this concerning Sola Scriptura and about the bible in general. The Bible is the infalliable word of God. That is agreed upon by most, Protestants and Catholics (although I must say that Protestant is a VERY VERY broad term and I my self, although according to the R.C church am a Protestant, I hate that term because it means nothing but not catholic or Eastern Orthodox). We agree that, through a literal interpratation of thei bible, that Jesus Christ is a personal saviour and died for our sins, that There is God the father, God the son, and God the Holy Spirit. We all beleive that the bible is 100% truthfull and in its entirty, does not contradict itself.

I must point out though that “protestants” (at least ones that believe what they believe out of true informedness, not out of being spoon fed by the once a week theater service that many call church. This is a problom with ALL christians) do not believe that the Bible is the ONLY source of truth, We beleive that it is an absolute test of truth. Lets say one person says a color is blue, then someone else says its purple, the solution is to take something that both persons agree to be purple and compare it. If a Pastor, Priest, or Evangelist says something, you dont just take his word for it, read the bible. Men Change, churchs change, culture changes, but the Bibles essential truths do not.

Take for example the countless papal decrees that were said to be from the authority of the holy spirit, that where later reversed or revised to fit the times. Never has the essential truths of the bible, nor the text of the bible ever changed. (unless your a Jehovahs Witness, and also Im not including subtle translational changes that had to be made inorder for non-greek speaking people could understand it). Im not trying to stire up papal infallibility debate, im just saying that the bible has, at its core, never changed. That is why us “protestants” look to it as our only source of infallible truth.

I also must point out that I my self look to writings of such great writers as C.S Lewis and Josh Mcdowell for spiritual lessons. But if ever im reading a book and it contradicts a biblical truth, I discount it and know not to head it.

Be blessed my brothers and sisters in Christ,

Pr. Brendan Marchione
 
False dilemma, VociMike. It is not either the Bible or the Church. You left out the most important third party: God and the Spirit, which as I have pointed out, and you have just demonstrated, the Catholic church often forgets to emphasize and tell its members to follow.
The problem is, every single heresiarch has felt that the Holy Spirit was guiding him to the truth. If you can’t ask the bible for clarification, how much less can you ask the Holy Spirit and know that the “answer” is really from God?

The Church does not have this problem, which is one of the reasons God granted the Church such authority.

You are incorrect in claiming that the Catholic Church forgets to emphasize the guidance of the Holy Spirit. She does emphasize it, but she recognizes that this guidance, as regards the deposit of faith, is given through the Church (thus becoming authoritative) and not through individual Catholics (which can never be authoritative).
 
The problem is, every single heresiarch has felt that the Holy Spirit was guiding him to the truth. If you can’t ask the bible for clarification, how much less can you ask the Holy Spirit and know that the “answer” is really from God?

The Church does not have this problem, which is one of the reasons God granted the Church such authority.

You are incorrect in claiming that the Catholic Church forgets to emphasize the guidance of the Holy Spirit. She does emphasize it, but she recognizes that this guidance, as regards the deposit of faith, is given through the Church (thus becoming authoritative) and not through individual Catholics (which can never be authoritative).
You have basically just implied that the Holy Spirit is impotent.

Your claim that being led by the Spirit is an authority given to the church is contrary to what the Bible teaches. Most of those passages I quoted speak of individuals being led by the Spirit. Do you, or do you not believe Jesus when he said we would know his followers “by their fruits”? Again, Jesus didn’t say we would know his followers, “by who submits to the Bishop of Rome.”
 
You have basically just implied that the Holy Spirit is impotent.
Oh stop it.
Your claim that being led by the Spirit is an authority given to the church is contrary to what the Bible teaches. Most of those passages I quoted speak of individuals being led by the Spirit. Do you, or do you not believe Jesus when he said we would know his followers “by their fruits”? Again, Jesus didn’t say we would know his followers, “by who submits to the Bishop of Rome.”
Answer this simple question. If someone says that the Holy Spirit convicted him that some doctrine X is true, is that a guarantee that X is true?

If you say no, are you implying that the Holy Spirit is impotent?
 
Oh stop it.
It’s what you implied by saying what you did. What use does the Spirit have if not leading individuals in truth as the Bible says it will?
Answer this simple question. If someone says that the Holy Spirit convicted him that some doctrine X is true, is that a guarantee that X is true?
If you say no, are you implying that the Holy Spirit is impotent?
You don’t answer my questions, and you expect me to answer yours? I won’t let you get away with that.
40.png
ckempston:
Do you, or do you not, believe Jesus when he said we would know his followers “by their fruits”?
Do you, or don’t you believe the passages I quoted?

My line of questioning is quite simple, and I can see why you’re avoiding it: do you believe the Word of God?

If you don’t then that’s your problem. If you do, then you should realize I have no need to defend what the Word of God says to another believer. The Word says the Spirit:

Convicts the world of guilt. John 16:8
Leads people to the truth. John 14:15-17
Lives in believers. 1 Cor 3:16
Produces fruit in a believer’s life. Gal 5:22

Either you believe these things, or you’re lost. It’s really that simple. Based on your questions and responses, I’m beginning to wonder if you believe these things.
 
I see this claim so much. It strikes me as nothing more than “yeah, well so are you!” 🙂

In the first place, coming to faith is not the same as knowing what God has taught and has left us. It’s just bizarre to link the two.
True, but my point is that there are lots of so-called “churches” that claim to be the ONE true church. The dilemma for Catholics is that they reject sola Scriptura because they believe that the magisterium of Rome is the source of infallible doctrine. Isn’t it true that RC’s came to their conclusion by their own private interpretation just like Protestants do? On what objective basis is your private interpretation better than mine?
And people don’t come to faith through private interpretation but through grace, however that might manifest itself. It’s not as if every Christian first poured over the scriptures to decide if they should become a Christian.
I agree. And I would add that God’s grace doesn’t manifest itself by leading people to wolves and false teachers who will teach that we ought to trust in religious institutions that teach things that are contrary to the word of God.
And when it comes to what God has actually taught us, one cannot ask the bible for further clarification, but one can ask the Church for further clarification, and in theory repeat the process as often as necessary.
Yes. When we find something in the bible that needs clarification we ought to pray to God for His guidance and seek the help of knowledgeable and Godly men in the church.
 
"Sacred theology rests on the written word of God, together with sacred tradition, as its primary and perpetual foundation.”(Dei Verbum 24) You ask, are the scriptures enough to base one’s faith on, or are the traditions of the Church? It’s not one or the other; it’s both. “For both of them, flowing from the same divine wellspring, in a certain way merge into a unity and tend toward the same end. For Sacred Scripture is the word of God inasmuch as it is consigned to writing under the inspiration of the divine Spirit, while sacred tradition takes the word of God entrusted by Christ the Lord and the Holy Spirit to the Apostles, and hands it on to their successors in its full purity, so that led by the light of the Spirit of truth, they may in proclaiming it preserve this word of God faithfully, explain it, and make it more widely known….It is not from Sacred Scripture alone that the Church draws her certainty about everything which has been revealed. (ibid 9). Scripture and Tradition together convey the Word of God (ibid 10).

The Church has always taught, at least from the time of St. Paul, that scripture is to be read and interpreted in the light of the Church’s tradition. Remember, [Holy] Tradition pre-dates Scripture. No verse in scripture supports the idea that the bible is our only rule of faith. “Protestants must take 2 Timothy 3:16-17 out of context to arrive at the theory of sola scriptura. But when the passage is read in context, it becomes clear that it is teaching the importance of apostolic tradition!” catholic.com/library/Scri…_Tradition.asp

“The Catholic Church’s teaching on papal infallibility is one which is generally misunderstood by those outside the Church. In particular, Fundamentalists and other “Bible Christians” often confuse the charism of papal “infallibility” with “impeccability.” They imagine Catholics believe the pope cannot sin. Others, who avoid this elementary blunder, think the pope relies on some sort of amulet or magical incantation when an infallible definition is due.

Given these common misapprehensions regarding the basic tenets of papal infallibility, it is necessary to explain exactly what infallibility is not. Infallibility is not the absence of sin. Nor is it a charism that belongs only to the pope. Indeed, infallibility also belongs to the body of bishops as a whole, when, in moral unity, they solemnly teach a doctrine as true. We have this from Jesus himself, who promised the apostles and their successors the bishops, the magisterium of the Church: “He who hears you hears me” (Luke 10:16), and “Whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven” (Matt. 18:18).”
catholic.com/library/Papal_Infallibility.asp

Recommended reading:
Scripture and Tradition: catholic.com/library/Scri…_Tradition.asp
Papal Infallibility: catholic.com/library/Papal_Infallibility.asp
 
"Sacred theology rests on the written word of God, together with sacred tradition, as its primary and perpetual foundation.”(Dei Verbum 24) You ask, are the scriptures enough to base one’s faith on, or are the traditions of the Church? It’s not one or the other; it’s both. “For both of them, flowing from the same divine wellspring, in a certain way merge into a unity and tend toward the same end. For Sacred Scripture is the word of God inasmuch as it is consigned to writing under the inspiration of the divine Spirit, while sacred tradition takes the word of God entrusted by Christ the Lord and the Holy Spirit to the Apostles, and hands it on to their successors in its full purity, so that led by the light of the Spirit of truth, they may in proclaiming it preserve this word of God faithfully, explain it, and make it more widely known….It is not from Sacred Scripture alone that the Church draws her certainty about everything which has been revealed. (ibid 9). Scripture and Tradition together convey the Word of God (ibid 10).

The Church has always taught, at least from the time of St. Paul, that scripture is to be read and interpreted in the light of the Church’s tradition. Remember, [Holy] Tradition pre-dates Scripture. No verse in scripture supports the idea that the bible is our only rule of faith. “Protestants must take 2 Timothy 3:16-17 out of context to arrive at the theory of sola scriptura. But when the passage is read in context, it becomes clear that it is teaching the importance of apostolic tradition!” catholic.com/library/Scri…_Tradition.asp

“The Catholic Church’s teaching on papal infallibility is one which is generally misunderstood by those outside the Church. In particular, Fundamentalists and other “Bible Christians” often confuse the charism of papal “infallibility” with “impeccability.” They imagine Catholics believe the pope cannot sin. Others, who avoid this elementary blunder, think the pope relies on some sort of amulet or magical incantation when an infallible definition is due.

Given these common misapprehensions regarding the basic tenets of papal infallibility, it is necessary to explain exactly what infallibility is not. Infallibility is not the absence of sin. Nor is it a charism that belongs only to the pope. Indeed, infallibility also belongs to the body of bishops as a whole, when, in moral unity, they solemnly teach a doctrine as true. We have this from Jesus himself, who promised the apostles and their successors the bishops, the magisterium of the Church: “He who hears you hears me” (Luke 10:16), and “Whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven” (Matt. 18:18).”
catholic.com/library/Papal_Infallibility.asp

Recommended reading:
Scripture and Tradition: catholic.com/library/Scri…_Tradition.asp
Papal Infallibility: catholic.com/library/Papal_Infallibility.asp
Hi Lampo,

How did you come to realize that the RCC is the one founded by Jesus and the apostles?
 
It’s what you implied by saying what you did. What use does the Spirit have if not leading individuals in truth as the Bible says it will?

You don’t answer my questions, and you expect me to answer yours? I won’t let you get away with that.

Do you, or don’t you believe the passages I quoted?

My line of questioning is quite simple, and I can see why you’re avoiding it: do you believe the Word of God?

If you don’t then that’s your problem. If you do, then you should realize I have no need to defend what the Word of God says to another believer. The Word says the Spirit:

…
Leads people to the truth. John 14:15-17
…

Either you believe these things, or you’re lost. It’s really that simple. Based on your questions and responses, I’m beginning to wonder if you believe these things.
No, you’re beginning to wonder if I believe your interpretation of those things. I don’t. I don’t because (a) the Church does not teach your interpretation, and (b) because your interpretation is unverifiable, and (c) because your interpretation immediately leads to contradictions.

Now, back to Preacher A, who declares that the Holy Spirit has convicted him of the truth of doctrine X. Is that a guarantee that X is true? Let’s now add Preacher B, who declares that the Holy Spirit tells him doctrine X is false. Is that a guarantee that X is false? Both claim the Holy Spirit, and they are contradicting each other.
 
True, but my point is that there are lots of so-called “churches” that claim to be the ONE true church. The dilemma for Catholics is that they reject sola Scriptura because they believe that the magisterium of Rome is the source of infallible doctrine. Isn’t it true that RC’s came to their conclusion by their own private interpretation just like Protestants do? On what objective basis is your private interpretation better than mine?
It’s not about my private interpretation. It’s about the organization called the Church, which has an unbroken connection to the events in question, unlike your interpretation or mine. We weren’t there, but the Church was. We didn’t discern what writings were inspired scripture, but the Church did.
 
No, you’re beginning to wonder if I believe your interpretation of those things. I don’t.

Now, back to Preacher A, who declares that the Holy Spirit has convicted him of the truth of doctrine X. Is that a guarantee that X is true?
Hi VoiciMike,

I know this question wasn’t directed to me, but I’m wondering what this question has to do with sola Scriptura. Let’s say that preacher A is wrong about doctrine X. All we can infer from that is that preacher A was not led to his understanding of doctrine X by the Holy Spirit.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top