Some help for our Protestant friends

  • Thread starter Thread starter cyberjacques
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Ronald,
Besides these latest couple of posts, have you read the first 11 pages of this particular thread? Information is being re-written here for you that is on the first 11 pages of this thread. There was some REALLY good back and forth going. Please read them. I ask you to try to suspend the doubt and try to look at it a different way if you can. We didn’t make this up. It was taught, believed, understood and practiced by ALL Christians until and even through the Reformation. I think Martin Luther even believed it until he went off on his own ideology. I am pretty sure that works wasn’t an original point of contention for Luther? I need to look it up again, but I am sure he was more concerned about other behaviors and actions. There is just too much scripture that says that works and faith go together. It is through God’s grace that you show your love and concern for fellow man. We are supposed to help those in need. How many times are we commanded to do that in the Bible? A LOT!!! You have to see that when you pull just certain scriptures that appear to say no works out of the Bible and not put them in context with who is speaking them, who they are being spoken to, why they are being spoken and in context with the whole Bible, you won’t have the correct interpretation of scripture. We don’t believe in only works! They are just part of how we show our faith in God our Father and love for mankind. Jesus died on the cross for us. Isn’t that the ultimate Work done for us? Anything we could do for others pales in comparison to Jesus’ sacrifice on the cross.
 
May God richly bless all of the Catholics who are responding responsibly to my comments. The point I think failed to express is that, God forbid, that I give the opinion that works are unimportant. The major distinction is my impression that a Catholic’s beliefs on eternal life lie in great measure on the works performed through the eucharist, masses, novenas and the myriad of other demands. I have read the whole bible and am left with the impression that salvation is the unmerited free gift and that becoming “born again” Christians demands of us to perform good works as part of the routine ministry endowed as a result but not as a prerequisite. The distinction being must we perform good works in order to gain salvation or do we perform good works because of our zeal for the Lord to serve Him through good works
To me, the Catholic church is so bemuddled with synods, encyclicals, high mass low mass, mortal vs venial sin, meat or no meat on Friday, confession through a priest, the transubstantiation, church nomination of saints and many other issues. The response that is virtually assured whenever a Catholic is asked,” if you died today would you go to heaven", the inevitable answer is “I hope so” Try asking your Catholic brethren.
This is hardly the response one could or should expect when we possess the promise that “ye may KNOW that you have eternal life”. So do Catholics KNOW or HOPE, do they work for it or accept it as the free gift that it is. Do they need to burn in purgatory for indeterminate periods of time before entering heaven? Sincere thanks to all!
 
May God richly bless all of the Catholics who are responding responsibly to my comments. The point I think failed to express is that, God forbid, that I give the opinion that works are unimportant. The major distinction is my impression that a Catholic’s beliefs on eternal life lie in great measure on the works performed through the eucharist, masses, novenas and the myriad of other demands. I have read the whole bible and am left with the impression that salvation is the unmerited free gift and that becoming “born again” Christians demands of us to perform good works as part of the routine ministry endowed as a result but not as a prerequisite. The distinction being must we perform good works in order to gain salvation or do we perform good works because of our zeal for the Lord to serve Him through good works
To me, the Catholic church is so bemuddled with synods, encyclicals, high mass low mass, mortal vs venial sin, meat or no meat on Friday, confession through a priest, the transubstantiation, church nomination of saints and many other issues. The response that is virtually assured whenever a Catholic is asked,” if you died today would you go to heaven", the inevitable answer is “I hope so” Try asking your Catholic brethren.
This is hardly the response one could or should expect when we possess the promise that “ye may KNOW that you have eternal life”. So do Catholics KNOW or HOPE, do they work for it or accept it as the free gift that it is. Do they need to burn in purgatory for indeterminate periods of time before entering heaven? Sincere thanks to all!
This is very interesting, and it comes up all the time.
The problem in simple terms is;
the protestant is saved.
He does good works because he knows this.

The Catholic on the other hand would think it is presumptious to say she is saved - as life is long and we have free will, and Gods will be done - far be it from us to tell Him what He is obliged to do with us.
On the question of works - a Catholic would say that we have been Commanded to do good and the ultimate good work we are capable of is to give our lives for our friends. Giving up our life is just a basic duty of a Catholic.

Maybe its an American protestant trend to reduce ideas but historically I think Christianity used the good news to expand on ideas and allow good things to develop - go the extra mile, so to speak, as the Gospels tells us we must do, rather than try always to get away with the least effort and work.
 
May God richly bless all of the Catholics who are responding responsibly to my comments. The point I think failed to express is that, God forbid, that I give the opinion that works are unimportant. The major distinction is my impression that a Catholic’s beliefs on eternal life lie in great measure on the works performed through the eucharist, masses, novenas and the myriad of other demands. I have read the whole bible and am left with the impression that salvation is the unmerited free gift and that becoming “born again” Christians demands of us to perform good works as part of the routine ministry endowed as a result but not as a prerequisite. The distinction being must we perform good works in order to gain salvation or do we perform good works because of our zeal for the Lord to serve Him through good works
To me, the Catholic church is so bemuddled with synods, encyclicals, high mass low mass, mortal vs venial sin, meat or no meat on Friday, confession through a priest, the transubstantiation, church nomination of saints and many other issues. The response that is virtually assured whenever a Catholic is asked,” if you died today would you go to heaven", the inevitable answer is “I hope so” Try asking your Catholic brethren.
This is hardly the response one could or should expect when we possess the promise that “ye may KNOW that you have eternal life”. So do Catholics KNOW or HOPE, do they work for it or accept it as the free gift that it is. Do they need to burn in purgatory for indeterminate periods of time before entering heaven? Sincere thanks to all!
Sad to say, you have a true protestant idea of what Catholics believe.
I do HOPE I am going to Heaven but NO one can be 100% sure what tomorrow will bring. You simply do not understand what hope really is I guess. What did Jesus mean when he said to those he cured, “Your Faith has SAVED you, go and Sin NO MORE.” meaning they could loose all he did for them if they sinned, otherwise why would he have to warn them not to sin. Like I said before you have to read the bible as a whole and not pick out what you like. And we need the authority of the Catholic Church to guide us in the correct understanding of Sacred Scriptures. Other wise we are like fish out of water, flip, flopping around not knowing who is right. The Catholic Church gave us the Bible and it should NEVER have been separated from the Church. Thats why there are soooo many protestant denominations, (over 40,000) in 500 years, because they have no authority to guide them, its up to the preacher what to believe and how to interpret the bible or up to the impressions of the one reading it. Jesus founded the Catholic Church because HE knows and understands human frailties and weakneses and HE knew we needed the Church to guide us. No matter what you think you know about the Catholic Church, you will never have what we have unless you study and learn for yourself. I am NOT being arrogant when I say that, I am just speaking the truth. Study the 2,000 year history of the Catholic Church. if your really interested in learning the truth. Read the writings of the Early Church Fathers. The first Novena was when the Apostles spent 9 days in the upper room in prayer. But please don’t believe all the lies you hear about the Catholic Church without learning the truth.
 
I agree along the presumptian, we can only do our best and not get caught up into fooling ourselves into thinking that we have achieved salvation. It’s through humility one sais that they hope so, for it would be a grave error if we thought we have thought one thing, only to find out after the fact that we are in error.

I can say I love the Lord my God with all of my heart, soul, being and strength, and if I were to face him today, even if he decided to cast me down, I would go down explaining the same thing. Am I saved? I hope so, I try my best, it’s the “all falling short” element that should be on our minds, for it was mentioned for a reason, to prevent us from becomming too proud, to explain that there is nothing we can do on our own to achieve salvation, that we can only hope we are in alignment with God through Christ enough to satisfy his promise of salvation to us.

Here is the hard part, in the end, none of us are rightous, none of our works, thoughts, or actions will be enough, yet we are still required something on our end to achieve salvation regardless. We still have to do something, we still must have faith, this is the part where one get’s caught up with. How much faith, how many works, what is the defining moment where we can proclaim that we have done enough. Honestly, we surely cannot, we don’t have that capacity to discern the mind of God at that level, so we simply say, “I hope so” and leave it there…
 
What did Jesus mean when he said to those he cured, “Your Faith has SAVED you, go and Sin NO MORE.” meaning they could loose all he did for them if they sinned, otherwise why would he have to warn them not to sin. And we need the Authority of the Catholic Church to guide us in the correct understanding of Sacred Scriptures. Other wise we are like fish out of water, not knowing who is right. The Catholic Church gave us the Bible and it should NEVER have been separated from the Church. Thats why there are soooo many protestant denominations, (over 40,000) in 500 years, because they have no authority to guide them, its up to the preacher what to believe and how to interpret the bible or up to the impressions of the one reading it. Jesus founded the Catholic Church because HE knows and understands human frailties and weakneses and HE knew we needed the Church to guide us.
Study the 2,000 year history of the Catholic Church. if your really interested in learning the truth.
Read the writings of the Early Church Fathers.
The first Novena was when the Apostles spent 9 days in the upper room in prayer.
This is said very well. Ronald and other Non-C’s, you have to come to believe that you need The Authority of the Catholic Church to guide you. It is by the Catholic Church that you have any scripture at all. Why is it that you think that we do not have the correct interpretation of the Holy Bible? We wrote it! Someone that came along in the 1500’s surely isn’t going to have a better understanding, especially when said person(s) made changes that split the One Church. We still are One Holy Apostolic Catholic Church with the same One belief and interpretation. Protestantism is 35,000 different churches with different beliefs and interpretations. We STILL hold the same teachings, interpretation, practices and understanding of scripture today as we did 2,000 years ago. I think you have to go all the way back to the Reformation, Trent, early writings of the Church, early and late writings of Luther and the other reformers to determine whether or not the protest is still valid. Do you know what Luther was protesting? Was he protesting any of your above written problems with the Church? Were these concerns of his early on when he wanted to remain Catholic, but wanted some reform, or concerns that came about when he started to believe his own interpretation, beliefs over what had been for 1500 years prior to him? He really became full of himself and re-created his own version of Christianity. That is not what you are taught. You are taught what Protestant Christianity has become - a church separated from the true teachings of Christ as recorded as the NT by the Catholic Church.
 
Memaw said something so perfectly that I have been trying to say and that is that in the last 500 years Protestantism has split into 35,000 different denominations of beliefs because there has been no Authoirty to guide them. Jesus taught One Truth to the Apostles and to the people of the time. Jesus founded One Church with Peter and the Apostles. He taught and led with Authority, and he gave his Authority to Peter and the Apostles to found his One Church to teach his One truth. He promised to continue to guide the Church - the Church he founded - the Catholic Church. We have always had THAT Authority to guide us and continue our teaching and interpretting that One Truth. The realization of that should give you chills. Man has made mistakes, but the Catholic Church has not been prevailed against and did NOT change it’s teachings or interpretation of scripture.
 
St Paul apparently took the prospect of lost salvation seriously enough to warn the Corinthians about it.

No need for such epistles if OSAS.

It’s not sufficient to simply read Scripture—one must engage it with the mind.
 
I can say I love the Lord my God with all of my heart, soul, being and strength, and if I were to face him today, even if he decided to cast me down, I would go down explaining the same thing. Am I saved? I hope so, I try my best, it’s the “all falling short” element that should be on our minds, for it was mentioned for a reason, to prevent us from becomming too proud, to explain that there is nothing we can do on our own to achieve salvation, that we can only hope we are in alignment with God through Christ enough to satisfy his promise of salvation to us.

Here is the hard part, in the end, none of us are rightous, none of our works, thoughts, or actions will be enough, yet we are still required something on our end to achieve salvation regardless. We still have to do something, we still must have faith, this is the part where one get’s caught up with. How much faith, how many works, what is the defining moment where we can proclaim that we have done enough. Honestly, we surely cannot, we don’t have that capacity to discern the mind of God at that level, so we simply say, “I hope so” and leave it there…
This brought tears to my eyes. It is so perfectly said Ronald, that I pray that you let this wash over you, into your heart as truth. We can fall into sin at any moment that we choose our will over God’s will. The selfish way may Christians live today, all who think they are saved, should put that into perspective for you. They hoard their money, don’t help others, take birth control, have abortions, live together outside of marriage, have affairs, divorce their spouse, etc… I know a lot of Christians that don’t see anyting wrong with these actions. Is it that Protestant churches approve of these actions? I know that the Catholic Church has never and won’t ever approve these actions. I know there are Catholics who take part in these kind of actions, but they have been taught better and are placing their will above God’s. It isn’t just the larger sinful actions, there are seemingly smaller sins that will put eternal salvation in peril. for example, being judgmental, giving scandal, etc…You cannot have these sins on your soul, not be truly sorry, and go to heaven just because you think you are saved. Do you remember being taught about the Sacrament of Reconciliation. Do you remember the three main elements to confession, True Sorrow and Remorse, Examination of Conscience, Firm Purpose of Amendment? Do you remember the grace you feel when you come out of the confessional? Are you saying that you really don’t believe in it anymore? The Catholic Church has ALWAYS taught it. Luther taught and believed in it. There were so many other original Catholic teachings that were adopted into Protestantism that have vanished over the last 500 years. Why? That kind of change alone has to make you second guess Protestantism’s split from Catholicism.
 
I’m not saying I don’t believe in it anymore, what I am saying is that we shouldn’t get to the stage fooling ourselves into thinking we have done enough. We’ll take how God takes into account those he considers rightous from the OT. Take note, in Job’s case for example, how he sacrificed to atone for his sins, he did extra for the sins he was unsure of, or what he could possibly have missed. This extra is the grey area that we need to be mindful over. We then go into the NT where Paul considers himself the least of the apostles because he used to persecute the followers of Jesus. He was saved, yet he still considered his past actions, of which were clearly forgiven to be something that yolked him down. Even up until the end, where he was crucified, he even went so far as to have them do it upside down because he didn’t consider himself worthy to be crucified right side up. This is the same scenereo, I think he thought that he was not saved, up until the last breath of his life.

Was he saved? In my opinion yes, and long before he drew his last breath, yet he was still concerned about his past actions, they haunted him his entire life. We as Catholics can take things along this nature too far, I’m guilty of that one in my youth, there is a specific spot where we must learn to let go, yet still not forget the past.
 
Brian, I wasn’t writing to you when I asked, “Do you not believe it that anymore.” It is what you wrote that made tears come to my eyes. I guess I just worded it wrong. I was saying that it was so perfect that Ronald, please read this and let it wash over you. Sorry for the confusion.
 
God forbid, that I give the opinion that works are unimportant. The major distinction is my impression that a Catholic’s beliefs on eternal life lie in great measure on the works performed through the eucharist, masses, novenas and the myriad of other demands.

I don’t understand what you are saying our belief on eternal life are in measure to works performed through the Eucharist or works performed through mass. We receive Holy Communion, we attend Mass. These aren’t works or at least the not works we are discussing in this thread. Some people say the rosary. Some people say novenas. Some people attend Mass every day. These things aren’t something we have to do. They are something that people choose to do.

I have read the whole bible and am left with the impression that salvation is the unmerited free gift and that becoming “born again”
Christians demands of us to perform good works as part of the routine ministry endowed as a result but not as a prerequisite. The distinction being must we perform good works in order to gain salvation or do we perform good works because of our zeal for the Lord to serve Him through good works.

Have you been taught that we perform good works only to gain salvation? Or that we believe that is the only way to get to heaven? That is not all that they have wrongly taught you. You have to understand that Protestant Churches do not speak positive, loving words about the Catholic Church. For 500 years, they have done everything they can do to discredit us, have their congregations dislike, frown upon us so their members would never have a reason stray back to the One, Holy, Catholic, Apostolic Church.

To me, the Catholic church is so bemuddled with synods, encyclicals, high mass low mass, mortal vs venial sin, meat or no meat on Friday, confession through a priest, the transubstantiation, church nomination of saints and many other issues.

Jesus gave us the gift of his eternal body and blood at the Last Supper. Christians then knew what he was talking about, what he meant. The Apostles surely knew and understood what he meant. There would have been some kind of correction in the Apostles lifetimes had Jesus really meant something else. The Mass was designed shortly after that. It had to be led by the Holy Spirit because Jesus said he would guide us. So, someone comes along in the 1500’s and knows better?

Also, some of the ritualistic practices continued from the OT. They are not “made-up by the Catholic Church.” Isn’t the no meat on Fridays actually a compromise to fasting? The Sacrament of Reconciliation was established by Jesus. Everyone also believed and understood that to be Truth until sometime within the last couple of hundred years. Martin Luther brought that into Protestantism. How is it that Protestants are so against it now?
 
I am but a servant i have done nothing but what you want.Works do not merit salvation,but works done in faith are what gives life to the faith.( if we have no works our faith is dead:James 20:) …That which is dead can give no life.enternal life is what salvation means it is our hope.take a look at Jesus’s ministry is it not filled with good works,is that not how He showed His concern and love for us.even His dying on the cross was a work.
 
I guess the rhetoric on this issue could go on forever. With most Catholic retorts being sincere and helpful, I thank my Catholic friends for their open and sincere sharing of religious philosophy.
At the expense of repetition, I can not distinguish how Catholicism escapes works as a prerequisite for “earning” your way to heaven, with responses from learned Catholic respondents, I use snippets of Scripture to press a point, recognizing that you know the entire verse.
Purgatory remains an issue, “to be absent from the body is to be with Christ” –no mention of burning for atonement! “It is finished” “Today you will be with Me in paradise” No purgatory! No argument that we are expected to do good works, the crux is the role of good works in gaining heaven. Is a Catholic Hell bent one day and not the next? The Bible is often called “the blessed assurance”. What does it assure?
Holy Communion. “It is finished” Finished is finished. His supreme sacrifice was His broken body and shed blood. With a completed act that assured us of total remission of our sins, why the need for the eucharist and blood shedding thousands of times each day? And what does Holy Communion do? Does it place you in Heaven or is it another “works”?
The contentious enigma, that I perceive with Catholics is the ever perplexing, mystifying “hope”, never trusting, never sure from minute to minute, of eternal life.
 
Code:
The contentious enigma, that I perceive with Catholics is the ever perplexing, mystifying “hope”, never trusting, never sure from minute to minute, of eternal life.
Indeed, the trouble with we Catholics is quite often faith, hope, and charity. But then, that’s the trouble with everybody, isn’t it?

Your trouble might be an unfamiliarity with Church teaching.

Here’s the Catechism on hope:
1817 Hope is the theological virtue by which we desire the kingdom of heaven and eternal life as our happiness, placing our trust in Christ’s promises and relying not on our own strength, but on the help of the grace of the Holy Spirit. "Let us hold fast the confession of our hope without wavering, for he who promised is faithful."84 "The Holy Spirit . . . he poured out upon us richly through Jesus Christ our Savior, so that we might be justified by his grace and become heirs in hope of eternal life."85
1818 The virtue of hope responds to the aspiration to happiness which God has placed in the heart of every man; it takes up the hopes that inspire men’s activities and purifies them so as to order them to the Kingdom of heaven; it keeps man from discouragement; it sustains him during times of abandonment; it opens up his heart in expectation of eternal beatitude. Buoyed up by hope, he is preserved from selfishness and led to the happiness that flows from charity.
1819 Christian hope takes up and fulfills the hope of the chosen people which has its origin and model in the hope of Abraham, who was blessed abundantly by the promises of God fulfilled in Isaac, and who was purified by the test of the sacrifice.86 "Hoping against hope, he believed, and thus became the father of many nations."87
1820 Christian hope unfolds from the beginning of Jesus’ preaching in the proclamation of the beatitudes. The beatitudes raise our hope toward heaven as the new Promised Land; they trace the path that leads through the trials that await the disciples of Jesus. But through the merits of Jesus Christ and of his Passion, God keeps us in the "hope that does not disappoint."88 Hope is the "sure and steadfast anchor of the soul . . . that enters . . . where Jesus has gone as a forerunner on our behalf."89 Hope is also a weapon that protects us in the struggle of salvation: "Let us . . . put on the breastplate of faith and charity, and for a helmet the hope of salvation."90 It affords us joy even under trial: "Rejoice in your hope, be patient in tribulation."91 Hope is expressed and nourished in prayer, especially in the Our Father, the summary of everything that hope leads us to desire.
1821 We can therefore hope in the glory of heaven promised by God to those who love him and do his will.92 In every circumstance, each one of us should hope, with the grace of God, to persevere "to the end"93 and to obtain the joy of heaven, as God’s eternal reward for the good works accomplished with the grace of Christ. In hope, the Church prays for "all men to be saved."94 She longs to be united with Christ, her Bridegroom, in the glory of heaven:
Hope, O my soul, hope. You know neither the day nor the hour. Watch carefully, for everything passes quickly, even though your impatience makes doubtful what is certain, and turns a very short time into a long one. Dream that the more you struggle, the more you prove the love that you bear your God, and the more you will rejoice one day with your Beloved, in a happiness and rapture that can never end.95
Perhaps some reflection on this might remove some obstacles to your understanding.
 
I guess the rhetoric on this issue could go on forever. With most Catholic retorts being sincere and helpful, I thank my Catholic friends for their open and sincere sharing of religious philosophy.
At the expense of repetition, I can not distinguish how Catholicism escapes works as a prerequisite for “earning” your way to heaven, with responses from learned Catholic respondents, I use snippets of Scripture to press a point, recognizing that you know the entire verse.
Purgatory remains an issue, “to be absent from the body is to be with Christ” –no mention of burning for atonement! “It is finished” “Today you will be with Me in paradise” No purgatory! No argument that we are expected to do good works, the crux is the role of good works in gaining heaven. Is a Catholic Hell bent one day and not the next? The Bible is often called “the blessed assurance”. What does it assure?
Holy Communion. “It is finished” Finished is finished. His supreme sacrifice was His broken body and shed blood. With a completed act that assured us of total remission of our sins, why the need for the eucharist and blood shedding thousands of times each day? And what does Holy Communion do? Does it place you in Heaven or is it another “works”?
The contentious enigma, that I perceive with Catholics is the ever perplexing, mystifying “hope”, never trusting, never sure from minute to minute, of eternal life.
You are sooo confused about Catholic teaching, it would be almost laughable, if it weren’t so tragic. I suggest you get some Scott Haun tapes, books, whatever to help you. He was at one time as anti-catholic as you seem to be. He believed all that garbage too before he truly started studying the bible and seeking the TRUTH. The TRUTH will set you free!! Jesus said, "I am the WAY, the TRUTH, and the LIFE.
What does the Last Supper mean to you? The Mass is the unbloody Sacrifice, just as the Last Supper was. And at Mass, the bread and wine become the Body and Blood of Jesus just as it did at the Last Supper. You have a lot to learn and I hope you start soon before you get to deep in those lies, you can’t see anything else.
 
Ronald Cote is steeped in the standard anti-catholic jargon
I guess the rhetoric on this issue could go on forever. With most Catholic retorts being sincere and helpful, I thank my Catholic friends for their open and sincere sharing of religious philosophy.
At the expense of repetition, I can not distinguish how Catholicism escapes works as a prerequisite for “earning” your way to heaven, with responses from learned Catholic respondents, I use snippets of Scripture to press a point, recognizing that you know the entire verse.
Purgatory remains an issue, “to be absent from the body is to be with Christ” –no mention of burning for atonement! “It is finished” “Today you will be with Me in paradise” No purgatory! No argument that we are expected to do good works, the crux is the role of good works in gaining heaven. Is a Catholic Hell bent one day and not the next? The Bible is often called “the blessed assurance”. What does it assure?
Holy Communion. “It is finished” Finished is finished. His supreme sacrifice was His broken body and shed blood. With a completed act that assured us of total remission of our sins, why the need for the eucharist and blood shedding thousands of times each day? And what does Holy Communion do? Does it place you in Heaven or is it another “works”?
The contentious enigma, that I perceive with Catholics is the ever perplexing, mystifying “hope”, never trusting, never sure from minute to minute, of eternal life.
The Catholics on this board could tear apart your post line by line correcting every error it holds, but why should we do your work for you? It would all be to no avail anyway as one must embark on the journey toward the truth by one’s own steam. If you were really intersested in learning the truth about the church Christ said he would build you could start right here on this website. There is a plethora of information at your fingertips. You have only to search the site. I’ll bet you’re not the slightest bit interested in learning and only seek to argue. That’s right isnt’ it?

,
 
I guess the rhetoric on this issue could go on forever. With most Catholic retorts being sincere and helpful, I thank my Catholic friends for their open and sincere sharing of religious philosophy.
At the expense of repetition, I can not distinguish how Catholicism escapes works as a prerequisite for “earning” your way to heaven, with responses from learned Catholic respondents, I use snippets of Scripture to press a point, recognizing that you know the entire verse.
Purgatory remains an issue, “to be absent from the body is to be with Christ” –no mention of burning for atonement! “It is finished” “Today you will be with Me in paradise” No purgatory! No argument that we are expected to do good works, the crux is the role of good works in gaining heaven. Is a Catholic Hell bent one day and not the next? The Bible is often called “the blessed assurance”. What does it assure?
Holy Communion. “It is finished” Finished is finished. His supreme sacrifice was His broken body and shed blood. With a completed act that assured us of total remission of our sins, why the need for the eucharist and blood shedding thousands of times each day? And what does Holy Communion do? Does it place you in Heaven or is it another “works”?
The contentious enigma, that I perceive with Catholics is the ever perplexing, mystifying “hope”, never trusting, never sure from minute to minute, of eternal life.
In the catacombs of the first century Christians, Catholics, they have carved on many tombs R.I.P. What do you think that means.? That is a prayer for that dead person, Asking God to let them Rest in Peace. If they were soooooo sure they went straight to Heaven why would they need it. Another thing that always puzzles me is why people that don’t want to believe in Purgatory or praying for the dead, then why do they put adds in the Obituary saying things like, ‘OH Johnny we miss you so much, its been 10 years and we still keep you in our hearts’, or something similar. They may not admit to believing in praying for the dead but what do you think that is??? Do they think Johnny can read the paper? Why pay lots of money for nothing? They are attempting to do what we Catholics do and they don’t even realize it. We pray for and with our loved ones whether living or dead. It is in the human heart to believe in what the Catholic Church calls the Communion of Saints. and yes that does include those who are in Purgatory. Read, Matt 5:26, or Matt 12:36,or 2 Mac 12:44-46 or 1Cor 3:15,and 2Tim 1: 16-18. You really NEED to learn to read the Bible correctly. It really baffles me as to how protestants can think they know the bible sooo well when they don’t really understand it.
You can use all the negative adjectives you want but you can’t prove a LIE. Or even a distorted 1/2 truth.
 
May God richly bless all of the Catholics who are responding responsibly to my comments. The point I think failed to express is that, God forbid, that I give the opinion that works are unimportant. The major distinction is **my impression **that a Catholic’s beliefs on eternal life lie in great measure on the works performed through the eucharist, masses, novenas and the myriad of other demands.
It is good that you are here Ronald, so that you can get this erroneous impression corrected! Catholic belief on eternal life is that we are saved by grace, through faith, not of our own works, lest we should boast. Yet we are created anew in Christ that we may walk in the good works that he has prepared before the foundation of the world. the types of “works” you mention are acts of worship. Does God demand worship? He certainly commands it, and we, who are unworthy servants, should do all that He has commanded.
I have read the whole bible and am left with the impression that salvation is the unmerited free gift and that becoming “born again” Christians demands of us to perform good works as part of the routine ministry endowed as a result but not as a prerequisite.
I am glad that we agree that there are “demands” upon believers. It seems clear that, if you read the bible and came to this conclusion it is because the bible is a Catholic book, and that this is the teaching of the Catholic Church. 👍
The distinction being must we perform good works in order to gain salvation or do we perform good works because of our zeal for the Lord to serve Him through good works
I agree that this is the issue. I also agree that there are many people (both Catholic and Protestant) that don’t understand this correctly. There are many poorly catechized people out there.
Code:
To me, the Catholic church is so bemuddled with synods, encyclicals, high mass  low mass, mortal vs venial sin, meat or no meat on Friday, confession through a priest, the transubstantiation, church nomination of saints and many other issues. The response that is virtually assured whenever a Catholic is asked,” if you died today would you go to heaven", the inevitable answer is “I hope so” Try asking your Catholic brethren.
Most of what you have referenced here and classified as “muddled” belongs on another thread. Catholics believe that we are saved at baptism, and that, if we persist in that faith into which we have been born again, we will gain our hope of eternal life.
Code:
This is hardly the response one could or should expect when we possess the promise that “ye may KNOW that you have eternal life”. So do Catholics KNOW or HOPE, do they work for it or accept it as the free gift that it is. Do they need to burn in purgatory for indeterminate periods of time before entering heaven? Sincere thanks to all!
Catholics embrace what St. Paul calls a “mature” attitude toward salvation:

"Not that I have already obtained this or am already perfect; but I press on to make it my own, because Christ Jesus has made me his own. 13 Brethren, I do not consider that I have made it my own; but one thing I do, forgetting what lies behind and straining forward to what lies ahead, 14 I press on toward the goal for the prize of the upward call of God in Christ Jesus. 15 Let those of us who are mature be thus minded; and if in anything you are otherwise minded, God will reveal that also to you. 16 Only let us hold true to what we have attained. " Phil 3:12-16

We consider that we have been saved, are being saved, and will be saved.

As far as purgatory, that probably belongs on another thread also. Purgatory is outside of time, as are heaven and hell. Purgatory is a state in which we are purified before we enter heaven, since nothing impure can enter heaven, and we don’t all die in a perfect state of grace.
 
The Catholics on this board could tear apart your post line by line correcting every error it holds, but why should we do your work for you? It would all be to no avail anyway as one must embark on the journey toward the truth by one’s own steam. If you were really intersested in learning the truth about the church Christ said he would build you could start right here on this website. There is a plethora of information at your fingertips. You have only to search the site. I’ll bet you’re not the slightest bit interested in learning and only seek to argue. That’s right isnt’ it?
Mizer, I can assure you that when you are on your death bed, words are not being wasted just to argue or that my thoughts are “laughable”. What calloused comments!
If Catholics can “tear me apart’, that is what I was I was hoping for. I seek the truth from qualified learned Catholics using this best Catholic apologetic website
At any rate, I look forward to further continuation of this dialog with you in the presence of the Lord, in Heaven, not purgatory.
May God richly bless you as you continue in these ministries, Ron

,
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top