Some help for our Protestant friends

  • Thread starter Thread starter cyberjacques
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
. More Scripture reading is in order here.

…
You’d better get to it, then—start with Matthew 25, then John 6, John 8, Matthew 19, etc.

Notice—Atemi didn’t have the honesty to admit his error regarding Catholic teaching. Worth bearing in mind.

Jesus doesn’t have to come to us for our judgment when we die—we go to him.

If Judgment doesn’t occur before the Last Judgment, Atemi will have to explain this other Scriptural passage:
1: And after six days Jesus taketh Peter, James, and John his brother, and bringeth them up into an high mountain apart,
2: And was transfigured before them: and his face did shine as the sun, and his raiment was white as the light.
3: And, behold, there appeared unto them Moses and Elias talking with him.
4: Then answered Peter, and said unto Jesus, Lord, it is good for us to be here: if thou wilt, let us make here three tabernacles; one for thee, and one for Moses, and one for Elias.
5: While he yet spake, behold, a bright cloud overshadowed them: and behold a voice out of the cloud, which said, This is my beloved Son, in whom I am well pleased; hear ye him.
6: And when the disciples heard it, they fell on their face, and were sore afraid.
7: And Jesus came and touched them, and said, Arise, and be not afraid.
8: And when they had lifted up their eyes, they saw no man, save Jesus only.
9: And as they came down from the mountain, Jesus charged them, saying, Tell the vision to no man, until the Son of man be risen again from the dead.
10: And his disciples asked him, saying, Why then say the scribes that Elias must first come?
11: And Jesus answered and said unto them, Elias truly shall first come, and restore all things.
12: But I say unto you, That Elias is come already, and they knew him not, but have done unto him whatsoever they listed. Likewise shall also the Son of man suffer of them.
Where’d Moses come from?
 
Hello Atemi, glad you’re back.
Thank you.
Quote:
**Belief in what and whom? **
Obviously, belief in Christ the savior. Trusting that salvation is merited us by His shed blood.
Yes. That is a start.

The demons do not believe that and tremble.
When I said faith alone is belief alone, you said “of course.”
Because faith and belief, as far as Scripture is concerned, are the same word. They mean the same thing.
Then you said I needed to study faith alone, as if I don’t understand what it means. Direct me to a web site that offers your understanding of faith alone (inasmuch as it does not mean “belief alone” or it means something more than belief alone in Christ) and I’ll read it.
A simple Google of Sole Fide will supply anything you need to know.

You said I redefined faith alone. If you understood what Sola Fide means, you would not have said that.
The point I was making is that once you start qualifying the word faith, it ceases to be faith alone.
Incorrect.

If one has a broken or inadequate understanding of what true faith is, then it must be qualified.

Some actually believe true faith is just believing something in the head and that’s it.

Some actually believe that mere affection is love.

Both those misconceptions water down what both love and faith really and truly are. Arguing from that kind of foundation leads to all sorts of errors and faulty assumptions.
If you call it “saving faith” or “obedient faith,” then that’s not “faith alone.”
I simply call it faith…or true faith where folks will attempt to water it down.

BTW, saving faith or obedient faith IS faith alone.

That is why I said you need to actually study Sola Fide before commenting on it.
You said faith is more than just believing IN God that it was believing God. Well, God doesn’t force anyone to believe in HIM or trust HIM (believe HIM).
Agreed.
Faith is our human response.
Agreed.
Athough our ability to respond in faith is a gift of Grace from God, it is not, an automatic “product” as you called it.
Works are a product of faith, by definition.

They are not “required” by faith, as that is a very awkward way to put it, but they are produced by faith.
“Believing IN God” and "believing God, require action on our part.
**“Require” action?
That is not the correct terminology.
“Produce” action is the correct terminology.**
We choose to believe or not believe, we choose to act or not act.
Agreed.
Choosing to believe in God and in the Sacrifice of HIS Son, choosing to trust Christ and the Church He established is a mental action on our part.
We are not called by the Spirit anywhere in Scripture to put our faith in Roman Catholic bishops.

God and God alone is the object of our faith.

Men fail. Men fall.

God remains always true.
Choosing to perform acts of charity is physical action which we initiate through the gift of Grace given freely by God. Believing and acting in love, together form what the Bible refers to as faith. It is our human response to God’s grace and it is not faith (belief) alone.
Actually it is.

One cannot have true faith and not act on it. That is impossible.

But it is our faith alone that justifies us before a Holy God, not the works we then proceed to do.

Why?

Because we can NEVER do enough good works to justify a sinner before a Holy God. That is why we are saved by His grace, not our works.

If anyone thinks they have done enough good works to merit eternal life from a Holy God is going to be sorely disappointed. God is not so easily impressed.

BTW, thank you for being one of the few Catholics here that behaves civily in the face of disagreement. It is very much appreciated.

…
 
40.png
Atemi:
Works are a product of faith, by definition.

They are not “required” by faith, as that is a very awkward way to put it, but they are produced by faith.
Faith without works is dead.
Funny how you are arguing Faith is; Faith + works.
But then argue works are not required.

God: POOF You’re Saved!

Abraham: Like, - will you stop doing that, - who are you anyway?
 
Faith without works is dead.
Agreed.

It is unfortunate that you take this to mean that you are justified by your works before a Holy God.
Funny how you are arguing Faith is; Faith + works.
Actually, I am not.

Faith is faith.

Faith produces works, sure, but it does not suddenly become faith + works. It is still faith.

This is why folks should not comment on Sola Fide when they do not even know what it is.
But then argue works are not required.
“Required” for what?

For a sinner’s justification before an all Holy God?

How many
do you suppose God “requires” before He is impressed?
  • Some?
  • A bunch?
  • Lots?
  • Perpetual?
The next question is: have you done all the works “required” of you to justify you before our all Holy God if you died this very hour?

If yes, how on earth do you know?
If no, why not? (and how on earth do you know?)
God: POOF You’re Saved!
Abraham: Like, - will you stop doing that, - who are you anyway?
This mockery of Abraham’s justification before God betrays a lack of knowledge of God’s Word.

Rom 4

“If, in fact, Abraham was justified by works, he had something to boast about–but not before God. What does the Scripture say? “Abraham believed God, and it was credited to him as righteousness.”
Now when a man works, his wages are not credited to him as a gift, but as an obligation. However, to the man who does not work but trusts God who justifies the wicked, his faith is credited as righteousness.”

…
 
Agreed.

It is unfortunate that you take this to mean that you are justified by your works before a Holy God.
Actually, you said that not me.

Catholic position is, Faith + works, - because the Apostle St. James wrote same.

If you have Faith but no works your Faith is dead.

Love of God is a work, and is greater than Faith.

Without a Love of God your Faith is dead and will not save you.

Hence, Faith without works is dead.

How long do you have Faith alone before you realize it will not save you;
Until you add the work of Love of God to Faith it remains dead.
 
Actually, you said that not me.

Catholic position is, Faith + works, - because the Apostle St. James wrote same.
Let us assume this is true as the RCC defines it. You did not answer the question, however:

Have you done all the works “required” of you to justify you before our all Holy God if you died this very hour?
If you have Faith but no works your Faith is dead.
Agreed.

But this does not mean that we are thus justified before a Holy God by our good works…as if that were possible!
Love of God is a work, and is greater than Faith.
Love is not a work, anymore than faith or hope are, but I know it sounds good.
Without a Love of God your Faith is dead and will not save you.
One cannot have saving faith in God without loving Him.

Hence, Faith without works is dead.
How long do you have Faith alone before you realize it will not save you;
Until you add the work of Love of God to Faith it remains dead.
Let us again assume that what you say is true.

Again, the questions:

Do you presently have all the “love of God” required of you if you were to die this very hour?

…
 
Atemi,

I have much to respond to you on but I’m going to google Sola Fide first and see if, as you say, I’m not understanding you. This will be a quick answer to:
How many do you suppose God “requires” before He is impressed?
Some?
A bunch?
Lots?
Perpetual?
The next question is: have you done all the works “required” of you to justify you before our all Holy God if you died this very hour?
The word you are looking for is "until.’ I guess perpetual might work. We act out of love of neighbor and of self, UNTIL, we die to this life. That’s what faith is. Faith is our belief acting in charity. That is what God expects. That would be enough, if you need a measurment. We will all be judged according to our own gifts. Consequently there is no standard measurment which we might apply to everyone across the board. We all differ. You realize that don’t you? At times we all fall short. We sin. Our faith fails us but it does not fail God who is constantly present. This is illustrated in the NT when Peter denies Christ three times. He sins. He is later brought back to the fullness of faith when Christ asks Him three times if he loves Him. Peter repents His sin and is brought back into the fold. By your understanding, you would have to say that Peter never had faith in the first place. This is how fundamentalists/protestants explain sinfulness after being born again. It just doesn’t work Scripturaly.

More later.
 
Actually, you said that not me.

Catholic position is, Faith + works, - because the Apostle St. James wrote same.

If you have Faith but no works your Faith is dead.

Love of God is a work, and is greater than Faith.

Without a Love of God your Faith is dead and will not save you.

Hence, Faith without works is dead.

How long do you have Faith alone before you realize it will not save you;
Until you add the work of Love of God to Faith it remains dead.

This is my position.

40.png
Atemi:
Let us assume this is true as the RCC defines it. You did not answer the question, however:

Have you done all the works “required” of you to justify you before our all Holy God if you died this very hour?
You alone are obsessed with works alone. That ‘works alone’ is not Catholic Doctrine. My position is that both are needed - as above.
40.png
Thing:
If you have Faith but no works your Faith is dead.
40.png
Atemi:
Agreed.

But this does not mean that we are thus justified before a Holy God by our good works…as if that were possible!
This again is your own imagining. It is not the Catholic Doctrine.
Both are needed.
40.png
Atemi:
Love is not a work, anymore than faith or hope are, but I know it sounds good.
Is keeping the Commandments work - it used to be at least.

30 And thou shalt love the Lord thy God, with thy whole heart, and with thy whole soul, and with thy whole mind, and with thy whole strength. This is the first commandment.
40.png
Atemi:
One cannot have saving faith in God without loving Him.

Hence, Faith without works is dead.
You just said that loving God was not a work.

Are there different types of Faith?
Dead Faith - with no works.
And the Catholic Doctrine - Faith and work - Faith and The Love of God.

One can have Faith without the Love of God;

“…if I should have all faith, so that I could remove mountains, and have not charity, I am nothing.”
40.png
Atemi:
Again, the questions:

Do you presently have all the “love of God” required of you if you were to die this very hour?
Nobody knows only God, Atemi, which is why we must always persevere and;

‘…with fear and trembling work out your salvation’.
 
Look Atemi,

I googled sola fide as you asked me to and this is the first site I found:
Sola Fide, Can It Work
Many protestant sects teach that all that is needed for salvation of their souls is Faith Only…
Sola Fide, saved by faith alone.
**All they need is to accept Jesus Christ as their Lord and savior **and no matter what they do after, they are assured they will go straight to heaven. Jesus Christ paid the price for all sins, past, present, and future. Jesus Christ took the test for us all and gave each of us a grade of 100%. Now doesn’t that sound good? Just think, you can do anything you want for the rest of your life and your irrevocable ticket to heaven was paid for with the blood of Christ almost 2000 years ago. What a gift! What a great blessing! What nonsense!!!
The primary error here, has its roots in the fact that protestant churches are built on the wrong foundation, therefore no matter how much work they do to their church, it will not help if the foundation is faulty. Which Church is built on ‘rock’ (Mt 16:18), and which Church is guided by the Holy Spirit (Jn 14:16-17)?
Fundamentalists look to Jn 5:24, “…he who hears My word, and believes Him who sent Me, has life everlasting, and does not come to judgment, but has passed from death to life.” They use Gal 2:20, “And the life that I now live in the flesh, I live in the faith of the Son of GOD who loved me and gave Himself up for me.” There are other verses which they use as well, such as Rom 4:4-8, and Eph 2:8-10.
These verses are all good, but the foundation upon which the interpretation of them is built, is faulty. The fault lies in the fact that there are two very different kinds of salvation, not one. This is stated very clearly in Jn 5:24 by the word ‘AND’ which makes that verse conditional on two fronts, not one. We have to ‘Hear’ His word, AND we have to ‘Believe’ in Him.
The error is in NOT ‘hearing’ the word, which means ‘doing’ the will of GOD. Fundamentalists accept the second part and ignore the first. The Bible is filled with verses about ‘doing’ the will of GOD. Those other verses I quoted are from the first kind, or 'Objective Salvation. Jesus Christ did in fact redeem all men by his sacrifice on the cross. He paid for the sins of all mankind, past, present, and future with His blood. He did His part, but He did not buy each of us a guaranteed foolproof, irrevocable ‘ticket’ to Heaven as some churches teach. He redeemed us and opened the gates of Heaven and gave us free will to decide for ourselves where we will spend eternity. He fulfilled ‘Objective Salvation’. Now we all have to do our part which is called ‘Subjective Salvation’. We must DO the will of GOD, and that is called ‘Works’. This is spelled out so clearly in Scripture.
Let us start with Phil 2:12, “…Work out your salvation with fear and trembling.” How can anyone respond to that one except subjectively? Did Jesus Christ really work it out for you? How about Rom 11:22, “See, then, the goodness and the severity of GOD: His severity toward those who have fallen, but the goodness of GOD toward you if you abide in His goodness, otherwise you also will be cut off.” That says keep GOD’s commandments or you will not make it to Heaven, and will be cut off. Then see 1Cor 9:27, “I chastise my body and bring it into subjection, lest perhaps after preaching to others I myself should be rejected.” Paul himself, teaching that even he, with all of his faith, could still be rejected.
Look at Lk 6:46, "But why do you call Me Lord, Lord, and do not do the things that I say? Doing the things which Jesus Christ says to do is ‘works’.
Heb 11:39-40, “And all these, though they had been approved by the testimony of faith, did not receive what was promised, for GOD had something better in view for us; so that they should not be perfected without us.”
Rev 2:26, “And to him who overcomes, and who keeps my works unto the end, I will give authority over the nations.”
Open your Bible to Acts 5:29-32… But Peter and the Apostles answered and said, “We must obey GOD rather than men…(32) and we are witnesses of these things, and so is the Holy Spirit, whom GOD has given to all who obey him.” Those verses are unmistakable that we have to do our part by obeying the commandments of GOD.
Then there is the dreaded (by Protestants) Jam 2:14-26 which starts with (14) “What will it profit, my brethren, if a man says he has faith, but does not have Works? Can the faith save him?..(17) So faith too, unless it has Works, is dead in itself…(20) Faith without Works is useless…(21) Was not Abraham our father justified by Works when he offered up Isaac his son upon the altar? (22) Do you not see that Faith worked along with his Works, and by the Works the faith was made perfect?..(24) You see that by Works a man is justified, and not by faith only…(26) For just as the body without the spirit is dead, so, Faith also without Works is Dead.” ‘Subjective Salvation’ in action, is shown for that whole section written by St. James. I could go on and on with verses like this, and could ask questions such as, why is there a need for the ten commandments, since we are ‘automatically saved’? I think you get the message from what I have shown.
Read Matt 25:31:46. It is all about doing good works in this life. Then there is Rev 14:13, “And I heard a voice from Heaven saying, ‘Write: blessed are the dead who die in the Lord henceforth. Yes, says the Spirit, let them rest from their labors, for their works follow them.’” Is that clear enough that works are needed in addition to faith? Still not convinced? Then how about another crystal clear verse? Rev 22:12, “Behold, I come quickly! And My reward is with Me, to render to each one according to his works.”
I must call it to your attention that the Bible mentions Faith Only,
once and only once, in one verse, and in that verse it says NOT by Faith Only.
James 2:24
Written by Bob Stanley, 1996
Updated June 26, 2007
Isn’t “accepting Christ as Lord and Savior,” faith alone? Furthermore, don’t you believe that when you do that, good works automatically follow? Faith alone means accepting Christ, believing in Christ, trusting Christ (however you want to say it) and then good works are a byproduct of that faith alone. As you said, good works are produced by that faith but are in no way, a part of that faith, which is belief alone. Is that right?
 
**Let us assume this is true as the RCC defines it. You did not answer the question, however:
Have you done all the works “required” of you to justify you before our all Holy God if you died this very hour? **
That ‘works alone’ is not Catholic Doctrine. My position is that both are needed - as above.
The question assumes you have faith in Christ already. If you do not, then you have bigger fish to fry than this thread.

Faith is by no means excluded in the question.

Here it is again, so you don’t forget:

Have you done all the works “required” of you to justify you before our all Holy God if you died this very hour?

Surely if works are required for your justification, you would know what those works are.
**Love is not a work, anymore than faith or hope are, but I know it sounds good. **
Is keeping the Commandments work - it used to be at least.
30 And thou shalt love the Lord thy God, with thy whole heart, and with thy whole soul, and with thy whole mind, and with thy whole strength. This is the first commandment.
Not all Commandments are works. Some Commandments, for another example, demand that we do not covet another person’s possessions. Not coveting is not a work.
**One cannot have saving faith in God without loving Him.
Hence, Faith without works is dead.**
You just said that loving God was not a work.
Love, like both faith and hope, necessarily produce action, but they themselves are not action, as they deal with the heart of man.

They deal first and formost with the internals, not the externals.
Are there different types of Faith?
Yes…and different objects of faith.

Everyone has faith.
One can have Faith without the Love of God;
“…if I should have all faith, so that I could remove mountains, and have not charity, I am nothing.”
Agreed.

But that does not mean that works justify the sinner before an all Holy God.
**Do you presently have all the “love of God” required of you if you were to die this very hour? **
Nobody knows only God
So you insist that works justify sinners before a Holy God…but you do not even know what those works are.

That is troubling for sure.

You are here directing me on how to be saved and justified before a Holy God, but in the end, you do not even know how. You say “only God knows.”

How can you show others the way when you don’t even know it yourself?

It is like the Philippian jailor asking what he must do to be saved. Paul and Silas told him to believe in Jesus Christ, and he will definitely be saved.

Not “may be” saved. He will be saved.

That is the Gospel.

It is not the Gospel to say “may be.”

When I speak to Catholics on this subject, they always say, like you, that men must have faith + works to be justified before God.

When I then necessarily ask what works I must do to be justified before God…none of them know. They cannot even tell you what they insist is true. All they can do is shrug their shoulders.

Basically, this is what you are telling all of us who are not Catholic:

"Have faith in Christ and do an unknown amount and quality of good works, and maybe you will be saved"

That is not the Gospel. That is not the message the Apostles spread all over the known world and died for.

…
 
**How many do you suppose God “requires” before He is impressed?
Some?
A bunch?
Lots?
Perpetual?
The next question is: have you done all the works “required” of you to justify you before our all Holy God if you died this very hour?**
The word you are looking for is "until.’
No. The terms I am looking for are “how many” and “what kinds.”

Without that, the “until” is irrelevant. If you do not know that, you may arrive at “until” and be empty handed as far as a sinner’s justification before a Holy God is concerned.

I don’t want that to happen. Do you?
I guess perpetual might work. We act out of love of neighbor and of self, UNTIL, we die to this life.
By perpetual good works, I mean perpetual good works. Never ending…with no breaks in between and no interruptions.

I know the RCC does not teach men must need constant, never ending good works to be justified before a Holy God, so the amount must be somewhere between none and constant.
That’s what faith is. Faith is our belief acting in charity. That is what God expects. That would be enough, if you need a measurment.
How much acting in charity is enough?

You say this is “enough,” but you fail to say what it is.

Then if you believe that is enough…have you acted in charity enough to justify you, a sinner, before a Holy God if you were to die this very hour?
We will all be judged according to our own gifts. Consequently there is no standard measurment which we might apply to everyone across the board. We all differ. You realize that don’t you?
That is why I asked only about you.

You know you, so no guesswork involved.
At times we all fall short. We sin. Our faith fails us but it does not fail God who is constantly present. This is illustrated in the NT when Peter denies Christ three times. He sins. He is later brought back to the fullness of faith when Christ asks Him three times if he loves Him. Peter repents His sin and is brought back into the fold. By your understanding, you would have to say that Peter never had faith in the first place. This is how fundamentalists/protestants explain sinfulness after being born again. It just doesn’t work Scripturaly.
So not only do you not understand what we mean by Sola Fide, but you do not understand how we view sin after regeneration.

Anyway, if you can answer the question I asked, that would be great. There are fewer more important questions than that. And if someone seeks to direct people to salvation through our Lord Jesus, then they should first know the exact way before pointing, don’t you think?

…
 
Look Atemi,

I googled sola fide as you asked me to and this is the first site I found:
Just forget it.

You do not learn about Sola Fide by reading a critique of what it is not by a Catholic that rejects it.

Stanley does well at destroying a splendid caricature, though.
Isn’t “accepting Christ as Lord and Savior,” faith alone?
“Accepting Christ as Lord and Savior” is NOT faith.

Accepting Christ as Lord and Savior is faith.
Furthermore, don’t you believe that when you do that, good works automatically follow?
By definition.

How can you truly accept Christ as LORD and not act on it? That is impossible.
Faith alone means accepting Christ, believing in Christ, trusting Christ (however you want to say it) and then good works are a byproduct of that faith alone.
They are a byproduct of that faith…just as they are in your life.
As you said, good works are produced by that faith but are in no way, a part of that faith, which is belief alone. Is that right?
Faith and works are distinct concepts that the Holy Spirit constantly contrasts in His Word.

Faith is not works and works is not faith.

The question is: what justifies the sinner before an all Holy God.

…
 
28 For we account a man to be justified by faith, without the works of the law.

20 But wilt thou know, O vain man, that faith without works is dead?

You seem to think I’m making this up; but, your Faith, Atemi, is dead without works - show me your works - according to the Apostle St. James.
You must argue your view against an Apostle.

Is keeping this Commandment work.

30 And thou shalt love the Lord thy God, with thy whole heart, and with thy whole soul, and with thy whole mind, and with thy whole strength. This is the first commandment.
40.png
Atemi:
Not all Commandments are works.
Just like there are sins of commission there are also sins of ommission.
This commandment definitely requires movement on your part, to lazily flap a hand and say ‘Oh. I don’t need to bother’ is a mistake.
Have you tried loving God with your whole mind and your whole strength, as well as your whole heart.
It cost 11 of the 12 Apostles their lives.

No greater Love can any man have than to lay down his life for his friends.
 
Atemi wants to know:
The question is: what justifies the sinner before an all Holy God.
Why don’t you just read the Bible and accept the answer? Or better yet, hear the church. It’s plain.* James 2:24. “So you see how you are justified by works and not by faith alone.”*

All your “how much works” “Do you have enough works to be saved if you died this hour?” etc…is diversionary.

Fundamentalists are in a constant position of having to judge each other. As if you could judge the faith of another. “First we must determine if he is a saved christian or not.” How many of us have heard this comming out of the mouth of a fundamentalist?

So can you answer the question, how much faith alone is necessary? If you died this hour would you have enough, faith alone?

You are demanding that we judge ourselves. Well guess what? We are not the judge.

God gives each “man” certain gifts through the power of the Holy Spirit. We are to act in charity (love) toward one another. We are to love our neighbor as we love ourselves. We are to love our enemies.

The catholics on this board shouldn’t be expected to re-write the Bible for you because you refuse to understand it’s true meaning, the result of your refusal to “hear the church.” If you want to know what we must do to be saved then hear the church!.

BTW…Do you realize that “what are we to do?” and “how much are we to do?” are two different questions?

In a nutsell the answer to the first one is, fear God and keep HIS commandments, and the answer to the second one is, as much as possible.

Those are the answers Atemi. You may either accept that or not but it is pointless to keep badgering us with the same question because you refuse to hear the answer. If you would take the Bible as a whole, this would be easier for you to understand.

Instead you concentrate on one verse at a time and as a result you get the wrong idea. For example: you use Paul’s response to the jailor as proof that we need do nothing but believe on Christ to be saved. But in another verse when someone asks Jesus what must I do? Jesus tells him “leave everything and follow me.” Leave and follow are verbs. They require action. In another verse still, someone else is told, “repent and be baptized.” Repenting requires mental action and, and Atemi, and, and, and, change in one’s behavior. (I tried to emphasize the word and because fundamentalists don’t seem to acknowlege that the word and exists.) Repent is a verb. To be baptized requires action. It is something we must do. Be is a linking verb. Whatever word follows, implies action. Be faithful, be kind, be loving, be strong, be helpful, be charitable, be hopeful, be…whatever. I suggest when you read your Bible you have a dictionary close at hand and you could better identify the verbs.

Finally when you read the Bible you should consider how the nouns faith, hope and love, are treated. They are all treated as verbs. Do some Grammer study on line. There is a word that defines this, I just can’t think of it right know. Anyway, Saint Paul says 'love is patient, love is kind." Be is a verb. So to be patient requires action. To be kind, requires action. Saint Paul very clearly and definitively treats love as if it were a verb. The same thing is essentially done by Christ himself with the word faith. And the NT as a whole treats hope in the same fashion.

So Atemi, are you going to accept this as an answer or are you going to continue to argue against it? I’d put money on the later. Any takers?
 
Atemi,

Can you answer this question posted by Thing?
Is keeping this Commandment work.
30 And thou shalt love the Lord thy God, with thy whole heart, and with thy whole soul, and with thy whole mind, and with thy whole strength. This is the first commandment.
Can you tell us your interpretation of James 2:24? How does faith without works, equal anything but faith alone?

Do you still think I don’t understand what is meant by faith alone?
 
Can you tell us your interpretation of James 2:24? How does faith without works, equal anything but faith alone?

Do you still think I don’t understand what is meant by faith alone?
Yes, I dont think you understand.

**Does James Refute Paul or an Abuse of Paul’s Teaching? **

So the key question here is: Does James aim to refute the doctrine of Paul that justification is by faith alone, which would mean there is a massive contradiction in the Bible? Or does James aim to refute an abuse of Paul’s teaching and bring a corrective for the churches he was writing to? I want to try to show you that James is not contradicting Paul here but teaching something compatible with Paul’s teaching and correcting a misuse of Paul’s teaching.

Paul was very aware that his teaching of justification by faith alone was being distorted and misused by those who said, “Well, if we are justified while we are ungodly by faith alone, and this magnifies the grace of God, then let’s just keep sinning, because we are secure anyway and God’s grace will get more glory.” You can see this, for example, in Romans 3:8, “And why not say (as we are slanderously reported and as some claim that we say), ‘Let us do evil that good may come’? Their condemnation is just.” So he knows he is being slandered: “Paul teaches that the more evil you do the more good comes of it, because God’s grace is glorified in justifying the ungodly.”

Or consider Romans 5:20. Paul says, “The Law came in so that the transgression would increase; but where sin increased, grace abounded all the more.” Paul knows what some are saying, “Well, if grace abounds where sin increases what shall we say?” Romans 6:1, “What shall we say then? Are we to continue in sin so that grace may increase?” That’s what they were saying, “Let’s continue in sin that grace may increase.”

Now Paul has answers to this kind of superficial distortion and abuse of his teaching. He has answers in virtually all his letters to show how good works and love necessarily flow from real justifying faith. For example, in Galatians 5:13 Paul says, “You were called to freedom, brethren; only do not turn your freedom into an opportunity for the flesh, but through love serve one another.” So we have a wonderful freedom from the commandments of God as a means of justification. But does Paul then just lay the works of love on top of that freedom as a layer of legal duty? You got a good start through justification by faith alone, but now there is another way, besides faith, to do what you ought to do and become a loving person?

Faith Works through Love

No. Look at Galatians 5:6, a crucial text in seeing Paul and James in harmony with each other. “For in Christ Jesus neither circumcision nor uncircumcision means anything, but faith working through love.” So when Paul dealt with the abuse of his doctrine of justification by faith alone, he said: It’s not added works like circumcision that will win God’s favor. What then? It is “faith working through love.” Notice very carefully what he says. What counts with God? “Faith.” But what kind of faith? Faith that “works through love.” He does not say that want counts with God is “faith” plus a layer of loving works added to faith. He says that what counts with God is the kind of faith that by its nature produces love. But it is faith that gives us our right standing with God. The love that comes from it only shows that it is, in fact, real living, justifying faith.

Now that, I think, is what James was trying to get across to his churches. Loveless faith is absolutely useless; and anybody that comes along and says “We are justified by faith alone, and so you don’t have to be a loving person to go to heaven” is not telling the truth.

Let’s see how James corrects this distortion of Paul’s teaching. Here’s where you have to watch out for words - what does James mean by the words he uses? Even when his words may seem to be in conflict with Paul, is the meaning in conflict?

James’ concern is with a kind of counterfeit faith that does not produce love. This faith cannot justify anybody. Verse 14: “What use is it, my brethren, if someone says he has faith but he has no works? Can that faith save him?” You see his concern. “Can that faith save him?” Such faith is not going to save. What kind of works is James interested in? The same kind Paul is - the works of love. Verses 15-16: “If a brother or sister is without clothing and in need of daily food, and one of you says to them, ‘Go in peace, be warmed and be filled,’ and yet you do not give them what is necessary for their body, what use is that?” So James’ concern is that people have real saving faith, not counterfeit faith. And the difference is that the real faith produces loving behavior.

soundofgrace.com/piper99/8-8-99.htm
 
Yes, I dont think you understand.

**Does James Refute Paul or an Abuse of Paul’s Teaching? **

So the key question here is: Does James aim to refute the doctrine of Paul that justification is by faith alone, which would mean there is a massive contradiction in the Bible? Or does James aim to refute an abuse of Paul’s teaching and bring a corrective for the churches he was writing to? I want to try to show you that James is not contradicting Paul here but teaching something compatible with Paul’s teaching and correcting a misuse of Paul’s teaching.

Paul was very aware that his teaching of justification by faith alone was being distorted and misused by those who said, “Well, if we are justified while we are ungodly by faith alone, and this magnifies the grace of God, then let’s just keep sinning, because we are secure anyway and God’s grace will get more glory.” You can see this, for example, in Romans 3:8, “And why not say (as we are slanderously reported and as some claim that we say), ‘Let us do evil that good may come’? Their condemnation is just.” So he knows he is being slandered: “Paul teaches that the more evil you do the more good comes of it, because God’s grace is glorified in justifying the ungodly.”

Or consider Romans 5:20. Paul says, “The Law came in so that the transgression would increase; but where sin increased, grace abounded all the more.” Paul knows what some are saying, “Well, if grace abounds where sin increases what shall we say?” Romans 6:1, “What shall we say then? Are we to continue in sin so that grace may increase?” That’s what they were saying, “Let’s continue in sin that grace may increase.”

Now Paul has answers to this kind of superficial distortion and abuse of his teaching. He has answers in virtually all his letters to show how good works and love necessarily flow from real justifying faith. For example, in Galatians 5:13 Paul says, “You were called to freedom, brethren; only do not turn your freedom into an opportunity for the flesh, but through love serve one another.” So we have a wonderful freedom from the commandments of God as a means of justification. But does Paul then just lay the works of love on top of that freedom as a layer of legal duty? You got a good start through justification by faith alone, but now there is another way, besides faith, to do what you ought to do and become a loving person?

Faith Works through Love

No. Look at Galatians 5:6, a crucial text in seeing Paul and James in harmony with each other. “For in Christ Jesus neither circumcision nor uncircumcision means anything, but faith working through love.” So when Paul dealt with the abuse of his doctrine of justification by faith alone, he said: It’s not added works like circumcision that will win God’s favor. What then? It is “faith working through love.” Notice very carefully what he says. What counts with God? “Faith.” But what kind of faith? Faith that “works through love.” He does not say that want counts with God is “faith” plus a layer of loving works added to faith. He says that what counts with God is the kind of faith that by its nature produces love. But it is faith that gives us our right standing with God. The love that comes from it only shows that it is, in fact, real living, justifying faith.

Now that, I think, is what James was trying to get across to his churches. Loveless faith is absolutely useless; and anybody that comes along and says “We are justified by faith alone, and so you don’t have to be a loving person to go to heaven” is not telling the truth.

Let’s see how James corrects this distortion of Paul’s teaching. Here’s where you have to watch out for words - what does James mean by the words he uses? Even when his words may seem to be in conflict with Paul, is the meaning in conflict?

James’ concern is with a kind of counterfeit faith that does not produce love. This faith cannot justify anybody. Verse 14: “What use is it, my brethren, if someone says he has faith but he has no works? Can that faith save him?” You see his concern. “Can that faith save him?” Such faith is not going to save. What kind of works is James interested in? The same kind Paul is - the works of love. Verses 15-16: “If a brother or sister is without clothing and in need of daily food, and one of you says to them, ‘Go in peace, be warmed and be filled,’ and yet you do not give them what is necessary for their body, what use is that?” So James’ concern is that people have real saving faith, not counterfeit faith. And the difference is that the real faith produces loving behavior.

soundofgrace.com/piper99/8-8-99.htm
A clear example of how man-made tradition distorts Scripture to support itself.

The text itself refutes this notion:

James 2:
1: My brethren, have not the faith of our Lord Jesus Christ, the Lord of glory, with respect of persons.
2: For if there come unto your assembly a man with a gold ring, in goodly apparel, and there come in also a poor man in vile raiment;
3: And ye have respect to him that weareth the gay clothing, and say unto him, Sit thou here in a good place; and say to the poor, Stand thou there, or sit here under my footstool:
4: Are ye not then partial in yourselves, and are become judges of evil thoughts?
5: Hearken, my beloved brethren, Hath not God chosen the poor of this world rich in faith, and heirs of the kingdom which he hath promised to them that love him?
6: But ye have despised the poor. Do not rich men oppress you, and draw you before the judgment seats?
7: Do not they blaspheme that worthy name by the which ye are called?
8: If ye fulfill the royal law according to the scripture, Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself, ye do well:
9: But if ye have respect to persons, ye commit sin, and are convinced of the law as transgressors.
10: For whosoever shall keep the whole law, and yet offend in one point, he is guilty of all.
11: For he that said, Do not commit adultery, said also, Do not kill. Now if thou commit no adultery, yet if thou kill, thou art become a transgressor of the law.
12: So speak ye, and so do, as they that shall be judged by the law of liberty.
13: For he shall have judgment without mercy, that hath shewed no mercy; and mercy rejoiceth against judgment.
14: What doth it profit, my brethren, though a man say he hath faith, and have not works? can faith save him?
15: If a brother or sister be naked, and destitute of daily food,
16: And one of you say unto them, Depart in peace, be ye warmed and filled; notwithstanding ye give them not those things which are needful to the body; what doth it profit?
17: Even so faith, if it hath not works, is dead, being alone.
18: Yea, a man may say, Thou hast faith, and I have works: shew me thy faith without thy works, and I will shew thee my faith by my works.
19: Thou believest that there is one God; thou doest well: the devils also believe, and tremble.
20: But wilt thou know, O vain man, that faith without works is dead?
21: Was not Abraham our father justified by works, when he had offered Isaac his son upon the altar?
22: Seest thou how faith wrought with his works, and by works was faith made perfect?
23: And the scripture was fulfilled which saith, Abraham believed God, and it was imputed unto him for righteousness: and he was called the Friend of God.
**24: Ye see then how that by works a man is justified, and not by faith only. **
25: Likewise also was not Rahab the harlot justified by works, when she had received the messengers, and had sent them out another way?
26: For as the body without the spirit is dead, so faith without works is dead also.
So +10 points for innovation, kaycee, but -25 for reading comprehension.
 
A clear example of how man-made tradition distorts Scripture to support itself.

The text itself refutes this notion: James 2:
**Romans 6 is proof that it is Faith Alone.

In Romans 6 Paul anticipates the objection to Justification by Faith Alone, in that it undermines moral living.

This objection WOULD NOT exists if Paul is preaching Faith + Works = Justification.

Pauls answer to the objection in chapt 6 proves he is teaching Faith Alone.**

Paul, when he has completed his exposition of justification, anticipates in the opening verse of chapter 6, an objection that he is sure people will have to his teaching. The objection is that people will say that his doctrine – his teaching about the way sinners are made right with God – undermines moral living. "What shall we say, then? Shall we go on sinning so that grace may increase?"

That is, if I am made right with God by what Christ did for me and not by what I do;** if I am justified by faith in Christ and not by my own good works;** if my standing with God rests not on my moral accomplishments to any degree but solely on Christ’s for me and in my place; if the good works I do before or after I become a Christian have nothing to do with my being a child of God and do not make me a child of God, then what is to keep me from kicking up my heels and enjoying my sins. In a way, the more I sin I only make Christ’s righteousness and God’s grace seem the greater, for there is more sin for Christ to cover, more guilt for him to remove. Paul says, you will think that my view of justification cuts the legs out from under the demand to live a holy life, because you have just heard me say that how you live has nothing to do with your acceptance with God. YOU WILL THINK that I am left with no motive for a life of holiness and love.

**Now, Paul has an answer for that. He is going to say that sanctification and justification are inseparable in the salvation God gives to man. **God works not only to justify but to renew and restore, not only to change a person’s status before God (justification) but to transform his heart and life (sanctification). But that is not my point. My point is that Paul thought that folk would naturally object to his doctrine of justification because it seems to undermine moral living. And here is the point: No one objects to the Roman Catholic doctrine of justification for that reason. And the reason is that the Roman Catholic teaching is not subject to that objection. Precisely the reverse.

faithtacoma.org/sermons/Romancath/RC04.html
 
**

faithtacoma.org/sermons/Romancath/RC04.html**

You’ll forgive me for eschewing your colorful man-made tradition in favor of the text itself:
1: What shall we say then? Shall we continue in sin, that grace may abound?
2: God forbid. How shall we, that are dead to sin, live any longer therein?
3: Know ye not, that so many of us as were baptized into Jesus Christ were baptized into his death?
4: Therefore we are buried with him by baptism into death: that like as Christ was raised up from the dead by the glory of the Father, even so we also should walk in newness of life.
5: For if we have been planted together in the likeness of his death, we shall be also in the likeness of his resurrection:
6: Knowing this, that our old man is crucified with him, that the body of sin might be destroyed, that henceforth we should not serve sin.
7: For he that is dead is freed from sin.
8: Now if we be dead with Christ, we believe that we shall also live with him:
9: Knowing that Christ being raised from the dead dieth no more; death hath no more dominion over him.
10: For in that he died, he died unto sin once: but in that he liveth, he liveth unto God.
11: Likewise reckon ye also yourselves to be dead indeed unto sin, but alive unto God through Jesus Christ our Lord.
**12: Let not sin therefore reign in your mortal body, that ye should obey it in the lusts thereof.
13: Neither yield ye your members as instruments of unrighteousness unto sin: but yield yourselves unto God, as those that are alive from the dead, and your members as instruments of righteousness unto God.
14: For sin shall not have dominion over you: for ye are not under the law, but under grace. **
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top