Some help for our Protestant friends

  • Thread starter Thread starter cyberjacques
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I agree with you wholeheartedly, 100%. I am trying to learn the beliefs and differences of interpretation and understanding that are different from my own. It would be nice to know what Church affiliation’s teachings that I am learning. There are too many for me to learn and remember all from each Church, but I would like to gain a better understanding of the major ones.
I’ve found “The Handbook of Denominations in the United States” to be helpful in this regard, although it has a curious view of the Catholic Church. It helps me to keep the major beliefs somewhat straight, although there are so many denominations represented on these forums it can only do so much.
 
The Bible was never the sole rule of faith and practice until the Reformation made it so. Just look at the changes that the Reformers made. Have you ever researched those changes to determine the need for those changes or the truth in those changes? I believe that non-C’s owe the early Church - the Catholic Church - a great debt for preserving and caring for the Biblical manuscripts because they understood them/interpreted them correctly enough/lived them through Sacred Tradition enough to preserve them for you. Your cite may be really great, and the person/people who wrote the information in it may be wonderful, God fearing people. BUT, Sola Scriptura is NOT biblical, was never Biblical and can NEVER be proven to be Biblical because it was created by a Reformer in the 1500’s. Jesus didn’t teach Sola Scriptura. The Apostles didn’t teach Sola Scriptura. The only time alone was mentioned was in refuting the practice.
 
Teflon 93,

Thank you for the quick support.
And your profile says “baptist” because…?
So at one time, apparently, Disciple 123’s profile said he/she was Baptist. That’s so funny because I was recently engaged in conversation with Baptists on a Baptist web site. They let me post there until I gave too much information in an attempt to answer their questions, and when I started quoting ECF’s the web-master quickly kicked me off, locking the thread’s I was involved in. The topic that led to my swift removal was based on their horror that I had called the Bible a Catholic book, “written by Catholics.” I mean this statement, totally freaked them out. They said I had commited blasphamy, and insulted the Holy Spirit.

I was reminded of this when I read Disciple 123’s short response to AFH saying that “catholics wrote the Bible.” D 123 is the one who said, “now I’ve heard everything” as if such a statement was unheard of before and unbelievable and as if we all don’t realize that the men, catholic men, were inspired by God by virtue of the fact that Christ breathed on the original 12 and delivered, as promised the Holy Spirit, as the Spirit of Truth to His one church and to his one church alone.

Thanks again. I love how one can put this down for the rest of the day and when you come back you can be sure the other catholics on the board have been pinch hitting for you.
 
Disciple 123 posted:
Ok, you have no idea who I am so how can you assume I “hate” the church. For your information I am a catholic,born raised and raised my children as catholics. I know that God didn’t sit down and pen the bible but the statement I was responding to made it sound like man wrote the bible.
First of all, I never even addressed 123 directly. I just used what 123 had said. So I never assumed 123 of having “hate for the church” unless 123 was a non-C who had been taught to hate the church, which is the profile I had used for those who hate the church.

I think you protest too much, D 123. If you are a Catholic then you shouldn’t be shocked when someone says the Bible was written by Catholics. Catholics the world over have this understanding as we believe the Catholic church was instituted by Christ, brought to life at Pentecost with the gift of the Holy Spirit and that all of the Apostles and their successors were and are Catholic by their faith. These men who wrote the Bible, were in fact, Baptised Catholic’s. No one in thier right mind, and Always for Him seems to be in his, would think for a moment that God didn’t inspire the Catholic men who penned the bible and that the words were then, the words of God and not the men who did the writting specifically.

So your objection seems a bit, shall we say, fruedian.

You say yourself that I don’t know you and that is the truth. I never claimed to and I still don’t, although you have declared now that you are catholic. But other’s on this board are saying that your profile started out with Baptist and now has been changed to N/A. so now I wonder, do you know yourself?
 
Always for Him,

You and I must be kindred spirits because you say what I think.

I have been asking your questions for years and I joined a reformed Baptist web site thinking I might get some answers. It was not to be as I explained, they started asking me all these questions and when I went about answering them, the more effecitve I was, the less they liked it and I ended up getting kicked off.

I want to be sure you aren’t holding your breath on this one:
I really look forward to real, true, honest answers to these and all of my questions.
because you will no doubt expire by morrning. No non-Catholic can really answer the well thought out questions you pose. Not without becoming conflicted about their own faith and converted to the Catholic faith any way, so don’t hold your breath.

The Lutheran on this board seems to be the closest to asking some of these questions of himherself but Lutheranism is not too far from Catholicism in it’s pure form. They believe in the true presence for example. Unfortunately they don’t have it because they don’t have valid orders and even more unfortunately, they don’t realize they don’t have it, but that is another topic for another thread, no doubt.

My point is, it would be more exciting if we could get a Baptist, or better yet a fundamentalist to answer your questions. They are the ones who won’t be inclined to, so again, please don’t be holding your breath.

Did you know that many Baptists believe their’s is the true church? They think that Baptist evangelizers got this whole ball of wax rolling, lo those many years ago and that they were somehow hidden in sects like the waldenses and the monatanists in the first few centuries, at least while they weren’t be burned at the stake by the evil catholic empire. There are a lot of web sites devoted to the different denominations and you can also get a lot of information right here on Catholic answers if you explore the site outside the forums. Use the “quick search” on the left side at the top of the home page and you can be kept busy reading for hours. Have fun. But don’t forget, I warned you about your frustration level going through the roof.
 
Sandusky,

You sent us to a Sola Scriptura manuscript that has this as it’s first line:

“The Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments, Having Been Given By Inspiration of God, Are the All-Sufficient and Only Rule of Faith and Practice, and Judge of Controversies.”

How can a written page be a judge? The written page must be interpreted, musn’t it? The one who interprets the written page, becomes the judge, doesn’t he?

How can a written page make a decision or enforce a law? Both these attributes are seen in judges. So how can a book, be the “Judge of controversies?” Who interprets the meaning the book? Who makes the decision as to it’s meaning? Who enforces the laws found within it’s pages? Hmmmm?

Why does that book say that the Church is the pilllar and foundation of truth? Tim3:15 Why doesn’t it say that the Bible, the written page, is the pillar and foundation of truth? Where does the Bible claim for itself that it is the Judge of controversies? Hmmm?

If the Bible is the sole rule of faith, shouldn’t the Bible tell us that so we all may know for sure that what this statement says is true? How do you know this statement is true? How do you know the Bible is true? Hmmmm?
 
40.png
MIZER:
Sandusky,

You sent us to a Sola Scriptura manuscript that has this as it’s first line:

“The Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments, Having Been Given By Inspiration of God, Are the All-Sufficient and Only Rule of Faith and Practice, and Judge of Controversies.”
40.png
MIZER:
How can a written page be a judge?
It’s plural—pages.

The pages don’t judge.
40.png
MIZER:
The written page must be interpreted, musn’t it?
Correct
40.png
MIZER:
The one who interprets the written page, becomes the judge, doesn’t he?
Correct.
40.png
MIZER:
How can a written page make a decision or enforce a law?
It can’t.
40.png
MIZER:
Both these attributes are seen in judges. So how can a book, be the “Judge of controversies?”
You’ve already asked that.
40.png
MIZER:
Who interprets the meaning the book?
Under what circumstances?
40.png
MIZER:
Who makes the decision as to it’s meaning?
There’s only one meaning, and that meaning is God’s meaning.
40.png
MIZER:
Who enforces the laws found within it’s pages? Hmmmm?
God and the Church.
40.png
MIZER:
Why does that book say that the Church is the pilllar and foundation of truth? Tim3:15
Because the Church is the pillar and foundation of the truth.
40.png
MIZER:
Why doesn’t it say that the Bible, the written page, is the pillar and foundation of truth?
Christ says that the word, the written page is the truth, and that’s what the Church, as the pillar and foundation, must uphold—the truth.
40.png
MIZER:
Where does the Bible claim for itself that it is the Judge of controversies? Hmmm?
It doesn’t make that direct claim.
40.png
MIZER:
If the Bible is the sole rule of faith, shouldn’t the Bible tell us that so we all may know for sure that what this statement says is true?
No.
40.png
MIZER:
How do you know this statement is true?
I think it’s self-evident. As Hodge says:Whatever God teaches or commands is of sovereign authority. Whatever conveys to us an infallible knowledge of his teachings and commands is an infallible rule. The Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments are the only organs through which, during the present dispensation, God conveys to us a knowledge of his will about what we are to believe concerning himself, and what duties he requires of us.
How do you know the Bible is true? Hmmmm?
I don’t really know; I take it on faith.

And you? How do you know that the Bible is true?
 
Originally Posted by MIZER
Who makes the decision as to it’s meaning?

sandusky;3804584 said:
I am really baffled that you would answer Mizer’s question with this answer. The Protestant Churches have 35,000 different interpretations of God’s One, True meaning. That isn’t one meaning. It is the Roman Catholic Church that from the time of Jesus, Peter and the Apostles, that has always maintained One meaning, Jesus’ meaning as he left it with us.

Sandusky;3804584 Because the Church is the pillar and foundation of the truth. [/QUOTE said:
What Church are you agreeing to here? Your Church or the Catholic Church which is the early Church, which is the Church founded by Christ? You are right, it is the Church that is the pillar and foundation of truth - the Catholic Church.

I don’t know who Hodge is, but if he wasn’t around at the time of Jesus and the Apostles, then I don’t think he knows better than the people taught by Jesus and the Apostles.

I shouldn’t speak for other Catholics, but I can pretty safely tell you that we all have faith in the Bible, because it is our Catholic forefathers, guided by the Holy Spirit, that wrote One Bible for all Christians in 397AD. All Christians followed that same Bible until the Reformation. We still use that same Bible that was written in 397AD, unchanged and includes all inspired books. The Protestant Bible was written in the 1500’s, with changed doctrine, omitted seven inspired books among other things.
 
Always for Him,

You and I must be kindred spirits because you say what I think.
You might not want to admit that!!! I know I don’t always write so well and am not as knowledgable as you and the other Catholics on this thread!:o :o 😉

I guess I shouldn’t be surprised with the end result of your experience with the Baptist forum. That is what I was trying to convey when I said that it doesn’t seem like a lot of non-C’s know that the Bible was written by the protection and guidance of the Holy Spirit, by the Catholic Church. Someone responded very abruptly that I was mistaken. I grew up in the South, so you know that I REALLY experienced the Baptist beliefs. I wish you could have continued to teach them Truth and prove it to them. I guess, they just couldn’t face your truth. That is sad. I think it is so sad that they just have never been taught anything close to the Truth as it pertains to history or the Catholic Church.

I did not know the part about the Baptist’s beliefs of hidden sects, and since they were around so long ago, that they are the Original Church.

Thank you for the advice about finding information on this site outside of the forums. That is actually how I found the forum, but I don’t search much. I plan to hit the search questions soon.

Don’t worry, I remember your advise about how frustrating it can be, and I won’t hold my breath.
 
First of all, I never even addressed 123 directly. I just used what 123 had said. So I never assumed 123 of having “hate for the church” unless 123 was a non-C who had been taught to hate the church, which is the profile I had used for those who hate the church.
You say yourself that I don’t know you and that is the truth. I never claimed to and I still don’t, although you have declared now that you are catholic. But other’s on this board are saying that your profile started out with Baptist and now has been changed to N/A. so now I wonder, do you know yourself?
First I want to thank you for your kind response. Most of the responsed I have recieved are a bit sarcastic and mean. It is nice to have someone willing to explain their position in an intellegent and non threatening way. I want to apoligize if I missinterpreted what you said about hating the “Catholic church”. It sounded to me like you were saying that anyone that didn’t follow the Catholic tradition was taught to “hate” the church. That was my mistaken interpertation of your words.
Second, Who am I? I was born and raised a Catholic in a very Italian/Catholic area(NY) for 47 years. To set the record straight, this forum is the first time I ever heard that the catholics penned the bible. I was never taught that in all my years of CCD or as an adult. I was taught alot of things I now know aren’t true. I taught religion classed for over 15 years and about 2 years ago during a teacher training session we were told by the CCD director that we could not talk about certian books in the bible to the children (I was teaching 6th grade). When asked why, she stated that these stories were just that stories (creation, noah’s ark, jonah… to name a few) We were to skip these as they are just stories written to teach principles. I then spoke to the priest and was told the same thing. Up until that point I was very active in my parish. After that my faith fell apart. I thought, if parts of the bible arent true then maybe it was all made up, maybe everything is a lie. For 2 years I lived in fear and unrest, I felt lost and weak, I stopped praying. I went to church and continued my volunteer work for the church just in case there was a God. I kept doing more and more to prove myself and all it did was cause so much stress and confusion. I moved out of NY state a year ago and deceided to go to different kinds of christian churches (in NY there is pretty much just Catholic and Jewish).What I found in some was a faith so strong, I wanted what they had. I wanted to know like they did that it wasn’t all man made. My daughter and I were invited to go on a mission trip with one of the churches (I never even heard of mission trips before this). We worked in a small town on a indian resevation and painted houses, fixed roofs… and showed God’s love to all the people we met. At night we would all meet (over 400 youth and adults) and talk about our day and pray. During one of the prayer meetings God touched my heart, He told me how much He loved me. He loved me?! Even though I doubted Him and didn’t always do the right things in my life. He said “My will not yours, My strength not yours”. My heart was so filled with love that I thought it would burst. I was left with a complete feeling of peace. After that I started really reading the bible and questioning things I was taught and what people say. I need to find the truth and not just believe blindly anymore. I even question the teachings in church. Do you understand where I am coming from?
Third, Never in all the churches I have gone to here have I ever heard anyone say “hate” words about the catholic church. I am not saying that it doesn’t happen, I just have not encountered it. I quess you were right when you said I was confused about what religion I am. I don’t really feel I am any “religion”, I am a christian = a follower of Jesus Christ. Jesus’ disciples weren’t “Catholic”, they were mostly Jews. The word Catholic (definition is univeral) as far as I have found didn’t come about until 107 well after the original disciples were dead and gone. Do you have any further information on that? Also I tried looking up about the Catholics writting the bible and I see that the books of the bible were written before 107 but then translated after that. Please send me any information you have on that too.
Thank you again for your patience.
 
Sandusky,

May we know what your faith background is? Are you a fundamentalist or a Baptist? Perhaps an independant fundamentalist baptist? Are you a member of a mainline Protestant church such as Lutheran or Methodist?

I quoted the manuscript you posted by link, on Sola Scriptura, which said that the Bible is the final, “judge of controversies,” and you write back that
The pages don’t judge.
Isn’t this a contradiction?

You go on to admit that the Bible (the written page(s)) must be interpreted and the one (the person) who makes that interpretation becomes the judge and when I asked who that person is you cryptically respond with:
Under what circumstances?
What do you mean, what circumstances? Under any circumstances. Who is the judge of controversies, if it is not as Hodge says, the Bible itself? Who has the authority to intepret the Bible and discern and then teach it’s one true meaning to the masses of people on the earth?

You admit there is only one meaning, that is one truth found in the Bible, and that it is God’s truth.
There’s only one meaning, and that meaning is God’s meaning.
and when I ask who enforces the law you state that it is
God and the Church.
Obviously this answer begs the question, what Church? Is it through the One Universal Church, the Catholic Church? Or is it your church? And what church is your church? Is it the invisible church that is found in the assembly souls of those various christians practicing in all the different churches who happen to have the one truth in thier minds? How might we find this invisible church so we can pick the brains of these particular individual’s (and does that include Hodges?) so we too may know the one truth?
Sadusky posted: Because the Church is the pillar and foundation of the truth.
Christ says that the word, the written page is the truth, and that’s what the Church, as the pillar and foundation, must uphold—the truth.
Here you’ve mentioned again “the church” so my question remains, what church? There are thousands of churches, each teaching a slightly different truth, you realize. How can we know which truth is God’s one truth?

If the Bible is the sole rule of truth, as Hodge claims, it is,… “All-Sufficient and Only Rule of Faith,” and yet you admit that the Bible itself doesn’t make the claim that it is the sole rule, as you admit:
It doesn’t make that direct claim.
Then aren’t you going by some other rule (the man Hodge, for example) and doesn’t that negate the claim that the bible is the sole rule? Isn’t this a contradiction in your system of faith? Aren’t you allowing Hodge to be in part, the rule of faith? Wouldn’t that mean the Bible is also then, only in part, a rule of faith?

You think the teaching of Hodge is true because:
I think it’s self-evident.
As Hodge says:
**Whatever God teaches or commands is of sovereign authority. Whatever conveys to us an infallible knowledge of his teachings and commands is an infallible rule. The Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments are the only organs through which, during the present dispensation, God conveys to us a knowledge of his will about what we are to believe concerning himself, and what duties he requires of us.**QUOTE]
Then according to Tim3:15, Hodge is the church, which is the pillar and foundation of truth.
You quote Hodge to say that God conveys an infallible knowledge through the Bible which is (he believes) infallible. This is false teaching, Sandusky. False teaching is heresy. You are following a heretic. I realize the use of this politically incorrect language is harsh but the truth can sometimes be harsh. I do not mean to offend you, I hope if you are shocked by this, then that shock might force open your eyes.
The Bible, in and of itself, cannot be said to be infallible. It is inerrant, but not infallible because it must be interpreted.
 
It is possible to misinterpret the Bible (I’m sure you agree) and thus that misinterpretation, when it is taught, is capable of teaching error and so is not infallible. Only the one truth found in scripture, in other words, it’s one true interpretation can be said to be infallible. God conveys to us a knowledge of his will about what we are to believe concerning himself, and what duties he requires of us through the teaching body he established on Earth, that is through the magesterium of HIS One True Church. HE did not do this through the writing of the Bible. Jesus never wrote anything down, nor did He ever command the Apostles to write anything down. If He had, and if He had intended the Bible to be our sole rule of faith, in this age, then Bible would claim for itself to be that judge of controversies which Hodge claims it to be, we would call the Bible the “Body of Christ” and we would look to the Bible to solve our disagreements and Christ would have said, “Hear the Bible” instead of “Hear the Church” in the Gospel of Matthew.

Hodge claims that, The Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments are the only organs through which, during the present dispensation, God conveys to us a knowledge…

Again, this is false teaching. How do you know, in your mind, that this is not false teaching? Your faith, is in the wrong individual.

The Bible, your only rule of faith, does not make this statement. Who died and made Hodge the deliverer of God’s truth? As a Catholic I can state that Christ died and made His Church the deliverer of the truth and this is in keeping with what the Bible says, very plainly. Hodge is teaching a doctrine that conflicts with what that Church delivers as the truth. Hodge is clearly not the pillar and foundation of truth and neither is the written word of God, the Bible alone. If you wish to know the one truth of God, you must find the one Church Christ promised to build and then look to her for the one truth found in the written word. That is the Tradition given us by Christ.

What you and other non-C’s are doing is going to men (Hodge), following their tradition of finding support for what they first believe (the traditions of 16th century protesters) in the Bible and then building their own church on that foundation. This is not the foundation given us by Christ. Christ said the foundation, the rock upon which he would build His Church, was a man (Simon) and he made His Church visible (like a city on a hill or a net is visible) by establishing an office (a seat) for that man to govern from. Christ gave that man His own authority, God’s authority (symbolized by the keys to the Kingdom of Heaven) so that God’s authority would be present on Earth, passed down through the succession of those who would fill the office (the papacy) so that every generation could come to the knowlege of the one truth found in the Bible.

In order to prove this rendition false, you will have to look to the Bible, your sole rule, and find where it says Christ did not do this. I’ll be waiting for the verses you will cite.

Finally, you ask:
And you? How do you know that the Bible is true?
I know the Bible is true because I trust the promises of Christ. Christ promised that the gates of hell would not prevail against His One True Church. I know from history that the Apostles fullfilled the commission Christ gave them and went on, and continue going on through their successors, teaching all nations. They, (the Apostles and their successors) wrote some of their experiences and their teachings down on parchment and the Church Christ said he would build and preserve, gathered those writings together and infallibly declared which ones were to be considered “scripture,” the written word of God. I trust Christ, I trust the Church He founded, and so I trust that the Bible she wrote and cannonized is true. I don’t have to rely on faith, which is blind, I have proof the Bible is true. How can you go on as a Christian without this proof? How can you settle for not knowing for sure whether the interpretation of the Bible, the tradition you follow, is the truth or heresy?

That’s scary.
 
Disciple 123,

Thanks for responding back to me. I am trying very hard to be charitable on this board as the rules say we must be. I admit to being a bit abrasive by nature so it is a challenge to keep it kind in the written format.

You stated:
Most of the responsed I have recieved are a bit sarcastic and mean.
Because we are engaged in a written discourse it is easy to take what someone has written to be sarcastic and mean. We have no tone and some of us are not adept or patient enough to use the smiley faces. I should use them more.
It is nice to have someone willing to explain their position in an intellegent and non threatening way.
I try, but sometimes I wonder if I’m coming across that way. I never intend to offend the sensibilities of others. But isn’t it said that the road to hell is paved with good intentions?

This is why you need not apologize for missinterpreting what I’ve written. It is up to the author to write in a way that is not ambiguous.
I want to apoligize if I missinterpreted what you said about hating the “Catholic church”. It sounded to me like you were saying that anyone that didn’t follow the Catholic tradition was taught to “hate” the church. That was my mistaken interpertation of your words.
The fault is mine for leading you to this missinterpretation. This is why it is so important that we go to the Church Christ established to get the correct interpretation of the Bible. The author is present in The Church. HIS voice can be heard through the infallible teachings of HIS Son’s Bride.

Otherwise we are saying that the author of the Bible (God) didn’t take care to see to it that HIS written word could be interpreted.

Jesus died, rose and ascended into heaven. He is not here in human flesh to correct our misinterpretation of his word. He took care, however, to leave His infallible voice. He tells us in his written word, very plainly, to hear His voice, by hearing (His) The Church.
 
What you and other non-C’s are doing is going to men (Hodge), following their tradition of finding support for what they first believe (the traditions of 16th century protesters) in the Bible .
It appears to be a “tradition” that is much older than the 16th century.

St. Cyril

This seal have thou ever on thy mind; which now by way of summary has been touched on in its heads, and if the Lord grant, shall hereafter be set forth according to our power, with Scripture-proofs. For concerning the divine and sacred Mysteries of the Faith, we ought not to deliver even the most casual remark without the Holy Scriptures: nor be drawn aside by mere probabilities and the artifices of argument. **Do not then believe me because I tell thee these things, unless thou receive from the Holy Scriptures the proof of what is set forth: for this salvation, which is of our faith, is not by ingenious reasonings, but by proof from the Holy Scriptures **(A Library of the Fathers of the Holy Catholic Church (Oxford: Parker, 1845), The Catechetical Lectures of S. Cyril 4.17).

But take thou and hold that faith only as a learner and in profession, which is by the Church delivered to thee, and is established from all Scripture. For since all cannot read the Scripture, but some as being unlearned, others by business, are hindered from the knowledge of them; in order that the soul may not perish for lack of instruction, in the Articles which are few we comprehend the whole doctrine of Faith…And for the present, commit to memory the Faith, merely listening to the words; and expect at the fitting season the proof of each of its parts from the Divine Scriptures. For the Articles of the Faith were not composed at the good pleasure of men: but the most important points chosen from all Scriptures, make up the one teaching of the Faith. And, as the mustard seed in a little grain contains many branches, thus also this Faith, in a few words, hath enfolded in its bosom the whole knowledge of godliness contained both in the Old and New Testaments. Behold, therefore, brethren and hold the traditions which ye now receive, and write them on the table of your hearts (Ibid., Lecture 5.12).
 
40.png
MIZER:
May we know what your faith background is?
Ex-Catholic, reformed, our church is affiliated with the Alliance of Confessing Evangelicals.
40.png
MIZER:
Isn’t this a contradiction?
The pages of a book are inanimate; how is it you think that inanimate pages can judge?
40.png
MIZER:
What do you mean, what circumstances? Under any circumstances. Who is the judge of controversies, if it is not as Hodge says, the Bible itself? Who has the authority to intepret the Bible and discern and then teach it’s one true meaning to the masses of people on the earth?
There are different circumstances one encounters in which scripture is used. For instance, in study group, the one leading the group would be offering his teaching, or, in a counseling setting, the counselor would be interpreting and applying the lessons of scripture to the situation of the counselee, or, in a home setting, the husband would be doing the interpreting.
40.png
MIZER:
Obviously this answer begs the question, what Church?
The individual, local church.
40.png
MIZER:
If the Bible is the sole rule of truth, as Hodge claims, it is,… “All-Sufficient and Only Rule of Faith,” and yet you admit that the Bible itself doesn’t make the claim that it is the sole rule…then aren’t you going by some other rule (the man Hodge, for example) and doesn’t that negate the claim that the bible is the sole rule?
The Bible is the sole rule of faith.
40.png
MIZER:
Isn’t this a contradiction in your system of faith? Aren’t you allowing Hodge to be in part, the rule of faith?
Hodge died 122 years ago; nevertheless, his writings are still available, and valuable. God gives to the Church men gifted in teaching; that doesn’t make them the sole rule of faith, however, but teachers of the sole rule of faith.
40.png
MIZER:
You think the teaching of Hodge is true because:

Then according to Tim3:15, Hodge is the church, which is the pillar and foundation of truth.
That’s not what I said; go read what I said again.
40.png
MIZER:
You quote Hodge to say that God conveys an infallible knowledge through the Bible which is (he believes) infallible. This is false teaching, Sandusky. False teaching is heresy. You are following a heretic. I realize the use of this politically incorrect language is harsh but the truth can sometimes be harsh. I do not mean to offend you, I hope if you are shocked by this, then that shock might force open your eyes.
The sedevacantists claim you’re following a heretic. :hmmm:
40.png
MIZER:
It is possible to misinterpret the Bible (I’m sure you agree) and thus that misinterpretation, when it is taught, is capable of teaching error and so is not infallible.
Misinterpretations don’t teach—men do.
40.png
MIZER:
Only the one truth found in scripture, in other words, it’s one true interpretation can be said to be infallible.
Correct.
40.png
MIZER:
God conveys to us a knowledge of his will about what we are to believe concerning himself, and what duties he requires of us through the teaching body he established on Earth, that is through the magesterium of HIS One True Church.
That is the position of Rome.
40.png
MIZER:
HE did not do this through the writing of the Bible. Jesus never wrote anything down, nor did He ever command the Apostles to write anything down.
You ought to notice particularly and store in your memory that God wanted to lay a firm foundation in the scriptures against treacherous errors, a foundation against which no one dares to speak who would in any way be considered a Christian. For when He offered Himself to them to touch, this did not suffice Him unless He also confirmed the heart of the believers from the Scriptures, for He [Christ] foresaw that the time would come when we would not have anything to touch but would have something to read.

Augustine, *In Epistolam Johannis tractus, *2. See NPNF Series I. VII:469.
40.png
MIZER:
Hodge claims that, The Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments are the only organs through which, during the present dispensation, God conveys to us a knowledge…

Again, this is false teaching. How do you know, in your mind, that this is not false teaching? Your faith, is in the wrong individual.
My faith is in Christ, and He certainly is not the wrong individual in which to have faith; correct?

(continued below)
 
(continued from post # 273)
40.png
MIZER:
The Bible, your only rule of faith, does not make this statement. Who died and made Hodge the deliverer of God’s truth? As a Catholic I can state that Christ died and made His Church the deliverer of the truth and this is in keeping with what the Bible says, very plainly.
Isn’t that your interpretation? What makes your interpretation the correct interpretation?
40.png
MIZER:
I know the Bible is true because I trust the promises of Christ. Christ promised that the gates of hell would not prevail against His One True Church. I know from history that the Apostles fullfilled the commission Christ gave them and went on, and continue going on through their successors, teaching all nations. They, (the Apostles and their successors) wrote some of their experiences and their teachings down on parchment and the Church Christ said he would build and preserve, gathered those writings together and infallibly declared which ones were to be considered “scripture,” the written word of God. I trust Christ, I trust the Church He founded, and so I trust that the Bible she wrote and cannonized is true. I don’t have to rely on faith, which is blind, I have proof the Bible is true.
What method have you employed to arrive at your conclusion that you are in the one true Church?
 
Please remember that faith alone is what is needed for salvation and that those who are saved by faith alone in Christ are obedient to God. God has completed our salvation for us. Now all He askes of us is to obediently believe what He has done for us through Christ. Then after being saved we are to put our faith into practice. read Eph 2:8-10 to find the order of that is mention above.
 
Please remember that faith alone is what is needed for salvation and that those who are saved by faith alone in Christ are obedient to God. God has completed our salvation for us. Now all He askes of us is to obediently believe what He has done for us through Christ. Then after being saved we are to put our faith into practice. read Eph 2:8-10 to find the order of that is mention above.
It is NOT just by faith alone. That is a 16th century idea. It isn’t just what Eph 2:8-10 says. Anyone can take any particular verse and say, “It means this…” That is taking it out of context. That is just reading black print on white paper. The Catholic Church knew the interpretation of the Bible as it has been practicing it through Oral Tradition and Sacred Tradition before the Bible was ever written - through the Holy Spirit, by the Catholic Church. Our interpretation of scripture has NEVER changed. Do you really think we don’t have the correct understanding/interpretation of scripture, even though we are the ones that provided it for you and All Christians?
 
It is NOT just by faith alone. That is a 16th century idea.
Actually, I should have said it was an idea that had been present early on, but was always refuted by the Apostles and all subsequent councils. It only became doctrine in the 1500’s.
 
Please remember that faith alone is what is needed for salvation and that those who are saved by faith alone in Christ are obedient to God. God has completed our salvation for us. Now all He askes of us is to obediently believe what He has done for us through Christ. Then after being saved we are to put our faith into practice. read Eph 2:8-10 to find the order of that is mention above.
First, we must note that your entire paragraph above is nothing more than your manmade tradition. There is no Book of Salvation which contains your passage above.

In fact, much of it is contradicted by Scripture, particularly the “all he asks of us” portion.

Scripture being salvation history, one must consider ALL of it, not the handful of verses which are used as excuses for schism and disobedience on the part of the denominational leadership of so many communities.

Let’s look at all of Ephesians 2, rather than cherrypicking 3 verses ripped from context, shall we?
Code:
1: And you hath he quickened, who were dead in trespasses and sins;
2: Wherein in time past ye walked according to the course of this world, according to the prince of the power of the air, the spirit that now worketh in the children of disobedience:
3: Among whom also we all had our conversation in times past in the lusts of our flesh, fulfilling the desires of the flesh and of the mind; and were by nature the children of wrath, even as others.
4: But God, who is rich in mercy, for his great love wherewith he loved us,
5: Even when we were dead in sins, hath quickened us together with Christ, (by grace ye are saved;)
6: And hath raised us up together, and made us sit together in heavenly places in Christ Jesus:
7: That in the ages to come he might shew the exceeding riches of his grace in his kindness toward us through Christ Jesus.
8: For by grace are ye saved through faith; and that not of yourselves: it is the gift of God:
9: Not of works, lest any man should boast.
10: For we are his workmanship,** created in Christ Jesus unto good works**, which God hath before ordained **that we should walk in them. **
11: Wherefore remember, that ye being in time past Gentiles in the flesh, who are called Uncircumcision by that which is called the Circumcision in the flesh made by hands;
12: That at that time ye were without Christ, being aliens from the commonwealth of Israel, and strangers from the covenants of promise, having no hope, and without God in the world:
13: But now in Christ Jesus ye who sometimes were far off are made nigh by the blood of Christ.
14: For he is our peace, who hath made both one, and hath broken down the middle wall of partition between us;
15: Having abolished in his flesh the enmity, even the law of commandments contained in ordinances; for to make in himself of twain one new man, so making peace;
**16: And that he might reconcile both unto God in one body by the cross, having slain the enmity thereby: **
17: And came and preached peace to you which were afar off, and to them that were nigh.
18: For through him we both have access by one Spirit unto the Father.
19: Now therefore ye are no more strangers and foreigners, but fellowcitizens with the saints, and of the household of God;
20: And are built upon the foundation of the apostles and prophets, Jesus Christ himself being the chief corner stone;
21: In whom all the building fitly framed together groweth unto an holy temple in the Lord:
22: In whom ye also are builded together for an habitation of God through the Spirit.
We must first note here that this minor epsitle is most often quoted selectively by Protestants. We see this around here all the time; indeed, the portion DLC quoted is the most frequent out-of-context excerpt.

Is St Paul here condemning Christian works?

Obviously not, in that in 2:10 he notes that our whole purpose is toward this function.

Indeed, the reason for St Paul’s letter to the Ephesians is to encourage them in this effort. Ephesians is a call to arms for the newly-baptized to continue in sanctification. Note also the call to be one Body of Christ (2:16), to be unified as the Corinthians and others were divided, to be at peace and obedient to Christ, ending in a beautiful echo of Matthew 16:18. St Paul would be horrified by the fracturing of the Body of Christ driven by those beholden to temporal rulers rather than the apostles’ successors.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top