Someone told me I was scrupulous

  • Thread starter Thread starter crenfro
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

crenfro

Guest
Hello.

A friend of mine strongly, and I mean STRONGLY, inferred to me the other day that she considers me scrupulous.

I think it has something to do with me requesting to have books removed from the adoration chapel - books which state that certain apparitions which haven’t been approved by the Catholic Church actually have been approved as well as other books which aren’t of the Catholic faith.

I’ve asked a priest several years ago about being scrupulous and he said “no, I don’t believe you are.”

Just because a person goes to weekly confession and doesn’t like misleading books in the adoration chapel does not make a person scrupulous. Sometimes I think we all, me included for sure, quite easily and willingly don’t look too closely at some things in our lives.

Anyway, I got irritated when I heard this very STRONG inference - I said something like “I guess some would call this scrupulous” and my friend replied “well, you are a bit, you know…”

I think sin is quite insidious and in this world with us imperfect humans, it’s hard to avoid.

And calling me scrupulous is sort of a temptation that tells me, oh, it’s okay. You can do that. You can ease up because remember, you’re scrupulous.

Just irritated, I guess. I’m a struggling Catholic, but not scrupulous. Just trying to live my faith.

Any thoughts? Please pray for me. I really need to especially work on my selfishness these days.
 
Having scruples is a good quality. Scrupulosity, however, is an excess of scruples and a terrible cross to bear. It is good to hesitate when in doubt of something being sinful. It is not good to obsess over it.

Praying for you, crenfro. I don’t believe you are scrupulous based solely on the incident you described above but I cannot speak for your overall spiritual condition because (1) I don’t know you, and (2) I’m not a spiritual guide or director.
 
I’m with UpUpAndAway, based on what you’ve said it’s not enough for me to judge you scrupulous. Your priest, who I assume is also your confessor (?), probably knows you better than the woman you spoke with.

I don’t look at the books in our Adoration Chapel (I bring my own) but if I’d noticed one from an un-approved apparition I’d bring my concerns to the Adoration Committee and leave it at that - unless I actually read the book and found some error in it. In that case, if it were not removed I’d bring my concerns to the pastor. It’s unlikely that I’d take the time to read such a book, though, because I don’t waste my time in such pursuits. The Catholic Church has a wealth of 2,000 years of approved writings to dive into, greater minds than mine can sort through the questionable stuff to find out if there are any gems in all that gravel.

Oh, and I go to confession every week, too, and I’m not scrupulous, either.
 
Having scruples is a good quality. Scrupulosity, however, is an excess of scruples and a terrible cross to bear…
Scruple there is simply being used in a different sense. Some use the term to mean “morals”.

It is not good to have scruples in sense of those scruples where one sees sin where sin does not exist etc.
 
Hello.

A friend of mine strongly, and I mean STRONGLY, inferred to me the other day that she considers me scrupulous.

I think it has something to do with me requesting to have books removed from the adoration chapel - books which state that certain apparitions which haven’t been approved by the Catholic Church actually have been approved as well as other books which aren’t of the Catholic faith.

I’ve asked a priest several years ago about being scrupulous and he said “no, I don’t believe you are.”

Just because a person goes to weekly confession and doesn’t like misleading books in the adoration chapel does not make a person scrupulous. Sometimes I think we all, me included for sure, quite easily and willingly don’t look too closely at some things in our lives.

Anyway, I got irritated when I heard this very STRONG inference - I said something like “I guess some would call this scrupulous” and my friend replied “well, you are a bit, you know…”
  1. What you describe is not a scruple but simply the case. Such ought not be in the back of Chapels.
  2. There are “degrees” of scruples. One could have “some tendency” towards scruples without being “scrupulous” per se. And there are different degrees and kinds - in those who do struggle with scruples on an ongoing way. There can even be “transitory scruples”.
  3. Some confuse having a “delicate conscience” that sees in a finer way (but calmly etc) what is sin and what is not - with scruples.
  4. Ones regular confessor can assist one if there is some question there. I am not saying you are being scrupulous in other things-or just cause a friend said such to you that you are -but only that he can guide one. It is also to be note that at times those who do struggle with scruples do not think they are. A regular confessor can assist one in an ongoing way -not only to determine there is any scruples or greater tendency to such and to guide one in such -but in simply progressing in following Christ.
 
Thank you all for your replies. God bless you all. These forums are and continue to be so helpful.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top