Something different- admirable qualities of other faiths

  • Thread starter Thread starter mark_a
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
moira:
What’s wrong with celebrating birthdays and Christmas? And I don’t mean Consumermas I mean Christmas!
I think there is something Paul wrote about every day being the same. So Christmas is the same as the fourth of October to them. My friend who’s a convert said they do something at Easter. Maybe a special service but they don’t celebrate Christmas or birthdays. She said it saves a lot on gifts for their fifteen grandkids.

Lisa N
 
40.png
moira:
What’s wrong with celebrating birthdays
Wait a few years and you’ll understand.
40.png
moira:
and Christmas? And I don’t mean Consumermas I mean Christmas!
The spiritual Christmas is great.

The “is this all I got?” christmas needs to go!
 
Hi all!

It’s 06:00 here & I’m off to morning prayers at synagogue. But before I dash off, HaigaSophia posted:
Jews - The emphasis on maintaining the cultural and religious traditions centered within the family and their history and their connectedness to one another. Their great works of community charity.
Thank you!

Be well!

ssv 👋
 
mark a:
Wait a few years and you’ll understand.

The spiritual Christmas is great.

The “is this all I got?” christmas needs to go!
I agree with “is this all I got” Christmas needs to go. That’s what I meant by consumermas. But what do you mean by wait a few years and I’ll understand birthdays? I’ve had 48 of them. Not that I want to have my 49th but it beats the alternative.
 
40.png
davidc2:
I’ve always thought the Mormons are particularly good with family values generally.
Yup. Whilst amongst the Christian communities the Catholic Church stands alone in the contraception issues, the Mormons oppose it as much as we do.
 
40.png
moira:
What’s wrong with celebrating birthdays and Christmas? And I don’t mean Consumermas I mean Christmas!
Isn’t it because they believe birthdays are pagan celebrations (as is Christmas)
 
I think Hindus are extremely spiritual people who spend time in prayer and meditation like we catholics should.
 
40.png
mrS4ntA:
Yup. Whilst amongst the Christian communities the Catholic Church stands alone in the contraception issues, the Mormons oppose it as much as we do.
My understanding is their opposition to contraception is based on their belief that there are souls in sort of a “limbo” waiting for an earthly body. So in having children you are freeing those souls. Anyone else hear that one? I had two aunts who converted to LDS from mainline Protestant denominations. They liked the sense of community and the way they care for each other. They are very serious about tithing and my aunts also helped with their gleaning projects.

Lisa N
 
40.png
digitonomy:
Don’t want to hijack this thread too far, but those what will be resurrected? If there’s no soul and the body’s decayed, what continues on to await resurrection or a new body?
From what I recall we believed that we would be in a “sleep state” aware of nothing and that our bodies would decay but Jehovah, at the appointed time would recall what we were like and bring us back again with new bodies. Yes, this is confusing. The “no soul” has to do with them believing that human souls are like animal souls - no difference. It’s just the person, not something seperate.

There is another poster to these forums who also used to be a JW - maybe he can explain it better than I have??
 
40.png
moira:
I agree with “is this all I got” Christmas needs to go. That’s what I meant by consumermas. But what do you mean by wait a few years and I’ll understand birthdays? I’ve had 48 of them. Not that I want to have my 49th but it beats the alternative.
Right. I’d like to skip only the celebrations.
 
Amish: Couldn’t care less what the gas prices are. Ditto with the latest fall fashions - also under those long black skirts, who cares how big my hips get???!!

Mormons: Manage to be nice to each other WITHOUT the morning cup of coffee! Wow! I’m impressed.

Scientology: Is able to attract very good look men despite it’s totally off the wall, wacked theology.
 
Baptists: fiery love of Our Lord and the Scriptures, though they can be quite anti-catholic at times.
 
40.png
puzzleannie:
I firmly believe God allows all the various denominations to spring up and grow because each of them, even in the midst of error, preserves something crucial to the universal truth of the kingdom as it will exist in perfection when the church is truly ONE, some truth that sometimes for historical, political or other entirely human reasons gets overlooked in Catholic practice from time to time. I will never believe the solution to disunity lies in cutting off and attacking those separated, but in bringing them to unity through the love expressed in the Eucharist.
That was just incredibley, beautifully said! Thank you!

In Christ,
Nancy 🙂
 
40.png
kage_ar:
Shortly after conversion, a “mission” came to our Parish. They were having a special service on Sunday Evening, and my son wanted to attend (the group had visited CCD classes and had the kids fired up). Well, we went, and I that was my first – and thus far only – experience with Charismatic Catholics. I so long for another chance to worship with Charismatic Catholics, but it looks like there are none in my area – I keep looking and praying!
Contact your diocese and ask if they have an office for the Catholic Charismatic Renewal. They should be able to point you in the right direction.

In Christ,
Nancy 🙂
 
carol marie:
For kids: Youth group, Vacation Bible School,
This is more an individual parish thing than a Catholic thing. My parish has these. I wish they all did.

In Christ,
Nancy 🙂
 
40.png
mrS4ntA:
Yup. Whilst amongst the Christian communities the Catholic Church stands alone in the contraception issues, the Mormons oppose it as much as we do.
That’s not correct. Mormons do not oppose contraception. Most Mormon married couples use it and their church’s teaching has no problem with it as long as they don’t abuse it to the point of never having children. Of the major Christian religions, the Catholic Church stands alone in its opposition to artificial birth control. I agree with our Catholic teaching against the use of artificial birth control, but unfortunately most Catholics do not. Even if they know its against church teaching, most still use it anyway.
 
sorry, slightly off topic, but how big of a no-no is artificial birth control? Both my sister in laws are Catholic - one told me that the “no birth control rule” was of her parents’ generation and no longer enforced (like no meat on Fridays) and the other sister in law’s husband just had a vasectomy and she said it was no big deal at all (they live in Minneapolis where I think it’s pretty liberal ?)
Anyhow, is the no birth control thing as big of a deal as missing mass?
 
carol marie:
sorry, slightly off topic, but how big of a no-no is artificial birth control? Both my sister in laws are Catholic - one told me that the “no birth control rule” was of her parents’ generation and no longer enforced (like no meat on Fridays) and the other sister in law’s husband just had a vasectomy and she said it was no big deal at all (they live in Minneapolis where I think it’s pretty liberal ?)
Anyhow, is the no birth control thing as big of a deal as missing mass?
Unfortunately they’re both wrong. Artificial birth control isw a grave sin. Sounds like your sisters are practicing Cafeteria Catholics.

In Christ,
Nancy 🙂
 
Mormons–the way they practice what they preach and the way they educate their members. My wife is LDS so I’ve had a good 3rd-person perspective on Mormonism for over a decade. Though I find their beliefs full of serious error, I do greatly admire their commitment to those beliefs, which honestly puts most of us Catholics to shame. Church-going Mormons dress appropriately for church, have reverent music in their worship (no matter where you go), and most importantly, know their faith a heck of a lot better than Catholics know Catholicism, which I believe is the single biggest reason why I keep running into ex-Catholics on their side.

Both adults and children go to Sunday school every Sunday, even through the summer. The bottom line is that the average Mormon is far more equipped to spread and defend their faith than we are. I wish we required (or at least highly encouraged) our adults to go to religious education every Sunday after Mass. I think we would have a lot more knowledgable and committed Catholics if we did. At the very least they would be able to defend our faith a lot better.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top