J
JP_Francis
Guest
I think the important thing to keep in mind is …does this bring me closer to Christ? 
I do not have that gift, but a lady down the street who goes to my parish does. I heard her speak tongue. It totally moved me. At one point I thought I was going to say everything she said while she was saying it.I was wondering whether anybody here had that gift or knew somebody who had. It’s not something that I would like to have ( i always ask for the gift of discernment) but I am curious to know what it is like.![]()
I do. I got it shortly after being baptized in the Spirit in 1974.I was wondering whether anybody here had that gift or knew somebody who had. It’s not something that I would like to have ( i always ask for the gift of discernment) but I am curious to know what it is like.![]()
I assume you meant “wary” rather than “weary.” Let me tell you a story that heppened to me. When I first got involved in the Catholic Charismatic community I was still in college studying anthropology. I was taking a class in anthropological linguistics. One Sunday my wife and I went to a Charismatic Day of Renewal which included prayer, teaching sessions and a Mass at teh end. That day I was sitting behind a man who, when we were praying in tongues, started making a bunch of clicking noises. I thought, this is nuts. This isn’t a real language. The next day in my linguistics class, we studied a family of African languages called Xausa. Guess what. Quite a few of the consonants in these languages are clicking noises.I have always been very weary of speaking in tongues. I know especially back when I was not religious, the idea of speaking in tongues made me feel incredibly uncomfortable. I have never been around it before, but I still have a hesitancy about it. However my girlfriend has been around it before and speaking to her has definitely eased my mind a bit, and I agreed to got a charismatic conference at some point just to try and experience it. However I definitely understand why a lot of people just don’t like it very much, though admittedly I feel that comes how secular our culture is.
Satan is smart enough not to counterfeit a $3.00 bill. On the other hand he will try to counterfeit anything that is from God.Keep in mind, demons can speak in tongues as well. Might want to read up on what Fr. Amorth has to say about speaking in tongues. It can be a very good thing, or a very bad thing.
I’m not quite sure what it is to be honest, maybe because I don’t have it myself… I still haven’t formed a precise opinion on it, to be honest. I just have some charismatic friends…they’re good Christians…Well? What is it and how do you know that they can speak in tongues?
I have read many a liturgical document and not once have I seen where there is an option for the faithful to spontaneously begin “speaking in tongues”. Can you provide a source from Rome that approves such things during the liturgy?My(me personal first) Mass. Charismatic masses usually have more singing, and people pray in tongues.It’s just like every other Mass we come to worship the Lord and eat his flesh and blood. Why would you think that we somehow don’t or shouldn’t be involved in the mass or we don’t hold Eucharist in high regard? At every prayer meeting we have the Eucharist is Present and the difference between having a meeting in a room and having it in the chapel with the Sacred Presence is palpable.What do you do at your Divine Liturgies?
There different forms of tongues.Some for the public and some personal prayer language-most people are just praising - and no- we don’t interrupt the Mass.In our Archdiocese(NY) there are a set of do’s and don’ts that we have to conform to - and we obey.
As far as I know there is no document that is specific as you wish however there is also no document that I know of that specifically prohibits it either. Popes Paul VI, John Paul II and Benedict XVI have all spoken favorably about the charismatic movement. If that’s not enough for you, then you have a problem.I have read many a liturgical document and not once have I seen where there is an option for the faithful to spontaneously begin “speaking in tongues”. Can you provide a source from Rome that approves such things during the liturgy?
What?Consider the tower of Babel. And then that Her Heart would be pierced so that that thoughts of many would be known. Thus we understand Babel, tongues, and the Communion. Nothing more needs to be said.
The Holy Father approving of a movement does not equal approval of liturgical abberations.As far as I know there is no document that is specific as you wish however there is also no document that I know of that specifically prohibits it either. Popes Paul VI, John Paul II and Benedict XVI have all spoken favorably about the charismatic movement. If that’s not enough for you, then you have a problem.
So you’re saying that not just the current Holy Father but two others before him approved of movements which promoted liturgical aberations. Why would they do such a thing? If they thought these were liturgical aberations, why not say something like “they’ve got some good ideas but …”The Holy Father approving of a movement does not equal approval of liturgical abberations.
There’s no document that specifically states that a priest may not dress as a clown and play hopscotch on the altar but that doesn’t mean the priest is free to do so.![]()
No. What the popes approved of was devotion to the Holy Spirit and enthusiasm for the charismatic gifts. Unfortunately the Holy Father can not police every little thing the charismatics do and so when they feel like interjecting their own spirituality into the public worship of the Church little is done to correct it. There are a lot of unorthodox things that go on in the Church and the Pope can not or will not speak out against all of them. That isn’t a green light allowing these things to take place, but sadly they do. The Church is pretty precise as to what is and is not allowed in the Liturgy and so I go back to my original question which you never answered: how, according to the Church, do charismatics justify turning the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass into a charismatic praise and worship session?So you’re saying that not just the current Holy Father but two others before him approved of movements which promoted liturgical aberations. Why would they do such a thing? If they thought these were liturgical aberations, why not say something like “they’ve got some good ideas but …”
I have a hard time believing that, if the charismatics were guilty of liturgical abuse, the popes would have said anything positive about them. You seem to think that the popes would not have some investigating done before making a positive statement about them. If you are aware of what happens in a charismatic Mass, do you really think the pope wouldn’t be?No. What the popes approved of was devotion to the Holy Spirit and enthusiasm for the charismatic gifts. Unfortunately the Holy Father can not police every little thing the charismatics do and so when they feel like interjecting their own spirituality into the public worship of the Church little is done to correct it. There are a lot of unorthodox things that go on in the Church and the Pope can not or will not speak out against all of them. That isn’t a green light allowing these things to take place, but sadly they do. The Church is pretty precise as to what is and is not allowed in the Liturgy and so I go back to my original question which you never answered: how, according to the Church, do charismatics justify turning the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass into a charismatic praise and worship session?
I would imagine there are charismatics who are actually obedient to the Church and don’t allow or take part in abuses during the liturgy so I can’t say that ALL charismatic Masses are like that. But, I have been to several and they were all aweful. Again, you didn’t answer the question, you just made assumptions.I have a hard time believing that, if the charismatics were guilty of liturgical abuse, the popes would have said anything positive about them. You seem to think that the popes would not have some investigating done before making a positive statement about them. If you are aware of what happens in a charismatic Mass, do you really think the pope wouldn’t be?
First of all, you have not established that there are liturgical abuses in the charismatic Mass. So far you have given us nothing more than your opinion. Where, exactly, does it say that the congregation cannot pray or praise God. Have you ever been to a charismatic Mass? Where do you think these prayers are interjected?I would imagine there are charismatics who are actually obedient to the Church and don’t allow or take part in abuses during the liturgy so I can’t say that ALL charismatic Masses are like that. But, I have been to several and they were all aweful. Again, you didn’t answer the question, you just made assumptions.
And not to derail the thread, but Rome is not always on its toes in investingating groups or movements in the Church. In January, the Holy Father lifted the excommunications of the bishops of the Society of St. Pius X without properly investigating one of the group’s bishops who have some very controversial views. This little oversight caused a lot of scandal and stress to the pope.
Another example of a movement that was approved but later admonished is Lifeteen. There were several liturgical abuses taking place at these liturgies and yet John Paul II gave his approval. It was only several years later that authorities started to crack down on Lifeteen and they were told to stop several of their practices. Their founder is now excommunicated for various other reasons.
There are all sorts of groups, movements, and individuals which practice or believe something contrary to Church doctrine or disipline and unfortunately the Pope can not deal with all of it. Given the Holy Father’s example of beautiful and traditional liturgy, I would think it would be obvious that he wants to move the Church’s worship in a more Catholic direction. The “reform of the reform” does not include protestant styles of charismatic worship.
My confirmation teacher talked about praying in toungues last week. She did it for us. She just started out by saying “God, Jesus, Holy Spirit, We thank you and we give you glory” over and over, and then she started singing these praises of God, sort of like psalms.I was wondering whether anybody here had that gift or knew somebody who had. It’s not something that I would like to have ( i always ask for the gift of discernment) but I am curious to know what it is like.![]()