Spiritual Confusion

  • Thread starter Thread starter Taerilyn
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

Taerilyn

Guest
Hello Catholic Forums! I apologize if this is in the wrong place. If this is the case, please feel free to move it!

I’m seeking some guidance in my choice of religion. In the last year I’ve become so confused that I just don’t know what to do anymore. A brief overview:

I was “raised Catholic”, basically meaning grumpy agnostic.
I discovered Wicca halfway through High School, which resonated with me powerfully up until last year when my life was turned upside down and I felt all kinds of powerless and betrayed. It was then I turned to my local Catholic church.

My motives were shallow but since then I’ve not been able to get Christ out of my mind. I tried going back to Wicca but I just don’t feel the same about it anymore. I feel like I should be Christian but I don’t know which kind.

My strongly-held personal beliefs are as followed:
I believe wholeheartedly in evolution and all scientific discoveries to date.
I believe in a woman’s right to choose abortion, though I personally condemn it unless there are REALLY strong reasons for it (like rape, for example). In addition it should be done as early as is possible, ideally prior to the development of specific human traits.
I do not feel the need to worship communally on a weekly basis, and take offense to the notion that not doing so means I’ll go to hell. I have difficulty with the notion of ‘mortal sin’, to a degree.
I believe the bible is more of an allegorical nature, rather than literal word.
I believe in the validity of all religions, rather than the exclusivity of salvation in Christ.
I believe in the equality of men and women in all fields (as opposed to prescribed roles)
Hm, what else…it gets tough when it comes down to listing it all!

And yet through all this, I strongly believe in Jesus as the son of God who loved us enough to sacrifice himself. Hm.

I’ll add ideas as I think of them. In the meantime, I sincerely thank all help anyone can provide! Confusion is tiring.

Michelle
 
Hello Catholic Forums! I apologize if this is in the wrong place. If this is the case, please feel free to move it!

I’m seeking some guidance in my choice of religion. In the last year I’ve become so confused that I just don’t know what to do anymore. A brief overview:

I was “raised Catholic”, basically meaning grumpy agnostic.
I discovered Wicca halfway through High School, which resonated with me powerfully up until last year when my life was turned upside down and I felt all kinds of powerless and betrayed. It was then I turned to my local Catholic church.

My motives were shallow but since then I’ve not been able to get Christ out of my mind. I tried going back to Wicca but I just don’t feel the same about it anymore. I feel like I should be Christian but I don’t know which kind.

My strongly-held personal beliefs are as followed:
I believe wholeheartedly in evolution and all scientific discoveries to date.
I believe in a woman’s right to choose abortion, though I personally condemn it unless there are REALLY strong reasons for it (like rape, for example). In addition it should be done as early as is possible, ideally prior to the development of specific human traits.
I do not feel the need to worship communally on a weekly basis, and take offense to the notion that not doing so means I’ll go to hell. I have difficulty with the notion of ‘mortal sin’, to a degree.
I believe the bible is more of an allegorical nature, rather than literal word.
I believe in the validity of all religions, rather than the exclusivity of salvation in Christ.
I believe in the equality of men and women in all fields (as opposed to prescribed roles)
Hm, what else…it gets tough when it comes down to listing it all!

And yet through all this, I strongly believe in Jesus as the son of God who loved us enough to sacrifice himself. Hm.

I’ll add ideas as I think of them. In the meantime, I sincerely thank all help anyone can provide! Confusion is tiring.

Michelle
Honestly at this time I think you’d feel at home in a United Church…

The question shouldn’t be where you’ll be comfortable though - but where will you find truth? So do you seek truth or do you seek comfort?

I see a lot of ‘I believe’ statements in your post… I challenge you to explore beyond what you yourself believe and to explore why any Church believes what it believes.

For example, you balk at being told you must attend a worship service every week but do you know why this is mandatory?

You believe women should have the right to abort in extreme cases but do you know why the Catholic faith teaches ALL abortion is wrong? Etc. Etc.

Are you interested in knowing why the things you believe may or may not be correct? Or do you simply wish to find a home for now where you can learn and grow in Christ while not having your current beliefs constantly challenged?

Right now I’d suggest, if you’re not ready for further exploration, that you find the closest United Church and see what you think. 🙂 You might find a Christian family…
 
Hello Catholic Forums! I apologize if this is in the wrong place. If this is the case, please feel free to move it!

I’m seeking some guidance in my choice of religion. In the last year I’ve become so confused that I just don’t know what to do anymore. A brief overview:

I was “raised Catholic”, basically meaning grumpy agnostic.
I discovered Wicca halfway through High School, which resonated with me powerfully up until last year when my life was turned upside down and I felt all kinds of powerless and betrayed. It was then I turned to my local Catholic church.

My motives were shallow but since then I’ve not been able to get Christ out of my mind. I tried going back to Wicca but I just don’t feel the same about it anymore. I feel like I should be Christian but I don’t know which kind.
Welcome back - You’ll get a lot of good (name removed by moderator)ut.
My strongly-held personal beliefs are as followed:
I believe wholeheartedly in evolution and all scientific discoveries to date.
This is no problem. Science generally discovers the “hows” of things far less than the whys
I believe in a woman’s right to choose abortion, though I personally condemn it unless there are REALLY strong reasons for it (like rape, for example). In addition it should be done as early as is possible, ideally prior to the development of specific human traits.
This is a problem that many struggle with. I ask you to consider this. The first “human trait” is the number of Chromosomes that make up the developing child. Therefore, by your own definition the Child is human at conception.
Secondly - as regards “strong reasons” as soon as a person can show me a case where the child is guilty of a crime worthy of execution, then - and only then - can abortion be justified. The Child of rape or incest or whatever has committed no crime - Why should it deserve death? In cases of dire medical need (saving the life of the mother). every effort should be made to save both. If the child dies during that effort, then so be it, but the effort is aimed toward life, not death.
I do not feel the need to worship communally on a weekly basis, and take offense to the notion that not doing so means I’ll go to hell.
The Sunday obligation is a demonstration of the first commandment - Loving God above all things. That is why it is a discipline imposed on all of those who profess belief. After all, if you truly Love God, why would you NOT want to worship and receive Him as the first thing you do in a new week?
However - there are many cases where this obligation can be set aside so you should not place an excessive weight on the “miss mass= go to hell” argument.
I have difficulty with the notion of ‘mortal sin’, to a degree.
So do many others. Mortal sin is something that requires a flat rejection of God’s grace done either implicitly or explicitly.
I believe the bible is more of an allegorical nature, rather than literal word.
The bible contains both allegory and literal. The Church, in existence since the time of Christ and commissioned by Him, serves the faithful well in determining which is which. Protestants (many) do not have this advantage.
I believe in the validity of all religions, rather than the exclusivity of salvation in Christ.
This can be dangerous. However, one key to whether a faith has any validity in drawing one closer to God is whether it is founded on Love (Agape).
I believe in the equality of men and women in all fields (as opposed to prescribed roles)
This is no problem.
And yet through all this, I strongly believe in Jesus as the son of God who loved us enough to sacrifice himself. Hm.
Build from there. he will bring you home to His Catholic Church.
I’ll add ideas as I think of them. In the meantime, I sincerely thank all help anyone can provide! Confusion is tiring.
RCIA classes are starting in many places about now…It might be a good idea if you signed up for one.

Peace
James
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top