L
LilyM
Guest
Telling you to focus on the virtue that opposes your sin or telling you particular bible passages you can meditate on in order to help with a sin IS counselling you about (and yes, against) that sin :doh3:Spiritual Direction is not about counseling. A good director mostly listens and ask questions to help the directee come to his or her own decisions and conclusions. A director will not tell the directee what to do. If I were to ask about a particular sin, he would turn it back on me and ask me to use that as fodder for prayer and to focus on my particular sin in prayer. He also might say to foucus on the opposite virtue or suggest a scriptural passage that I can pray with. We don’t discuss how to overcome it or things I should do…in fact the word “should” never comes up…ever. Again, it is not about counseling.
Counselling in the secular world isn’t about giving orders either, you know, but having been through plenty of secular counselling I can tell you that SD is very definitely counselling. And I can tell you that secular counsellors, just like SDs, can very definitely let you know that what you’re currently doing is NOT helpful or beneficial without saying it in so many words.