Spirituality and detachment

  • Thread starter Thread starter Roger12345
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
R

Roger12345

Guest
I’ve noticed that almost every book I read on spirituality brings up the idea that detachment is necessary for spiritual growth. I’ve found this line of thought in the Dhammapada, The Bhagavad Gita, the Tao Te Ching, The Enchiridon, and now I’m reading The Way of Perfection by St Teresa and it says basically the same thing, that detachment from all created things is necessary for spiritual growth beyond a certain point. Can this detachment be achieved while we’re here on earth? It may be possible on a day to day basis as we go about our routine, but it would be another thing altogether to maintain a sense of detachment if you were in a war, natural disaster, homeless, etc.
 
+JMJ+
I’ve noticed that almost every book I read on spirituality brings up the idea that detachment is necessary for spiritual growth. I’ve found this line of thought in the Dhammapada, The Bhagavad Gita, the Tao Te Ching, The Enchiridon, and now I’m reading The Way of Perfection by St Teresa and it says basically the same thing, that detachment from all created things is necessary for spiritual growth beyond a certain point. Can this detachment be achieved while we’re here on earth? It may be possible on a day to day basis as we go about our routine, but it would be another thing altogether to maintain a sense of detachment if you were in a war, natural disaster, homeless, etc.
Detachment is not an end in itself, but a means to an end: it is to detach yourself from what are not important so you can attach yourself to what are.

St. Joan of Arc was known to cry for even her enemies while cradling them on her lap, trying to comfort them and pray for them, as they die.
 
Can this detachment be achieved while we’re here on earth? It may be possible on a day to day basis as we go about our routine, but it would be another thing altogether to maintain a sense of detachment if you were in a war, natural disaster, homeless, etc.
This detachment can be profound enough that you enter into the kingdom that Jesus talks about. Personally I don’t see as Good News, the notion that we can struggle all our lives and hopefully be happy after we die – the Good News for me is that Jesus showed me how to open my eyes and see this kingdom. He used many sources to get this done, both Catholic and non-Catholic.

But actually it is more likely to be backwards of what you mentioned. The detachment doesn’t become an issue during every day life. You use things all day and take them for granted. It is when we are tested by conditions we cannot control that we have to learn to accept and trust that the Lord will provide. Jesus actually went into a desert for 40 days, and was tempted to “take control” but refuse to, relying instead on His trust of the Lord.

There is no reason you can’t own things and still have this detachment, although it makes it more difficult. Jesus said it was very difficult for a rich man to enter the kingdom, and there is a story of a young man who was wealthy, and Jesus told him to go sell everything and give it away, and the man’s heart dropped. It wasn’t just that he owned those things; they owned him, too. Because they gave him the illusion of peace and security which were based in things that perish or can be destroyed.

Any time we become impatient with our computer, traffic, whatever, we are allowing those things to control our emotions. Therefore we know this is a symptom of attachment to the world – to physical things, to our wishes and schedules that don’t work out, etc.

That’s because Jesus gives us His peace, which is unconditional and eternal. But we don’t know that peace if we have anxiety because our happiness depends on Good Conditions that the World offers us. These good conditions are by definition, well, conditional, and they are temporary in that they last only as long as the conditions.

So if we live a comfortable life, we may not even challenge ourselves with “what if I really did lose this house? What if I lost my brother suddenly?” Or if we do think those things, we still then dismiss it as “unthinkable,” and if we consider it possible we look toward them in fear, which is anti-kingdom. But then when they happen, and we go through suffering, also during the suffering we learn that we can get through these things, and that it isn’t the end of the world when we lose something or someone – no matter how important they were, they cannot keep us from the peace of Christ.

When we detach, we let go of the sense that we “need” these things and suddenly it is a blessing and a gift, but not a “necessity” for life. We “mortify” ourselves, or “die to” the world, in that it’s like a dead person is not concerned over whether the coffee pot quit working, for example. When we are alive, and the coffeepot doesn’t work, if we get upset over it then it just controlled us so we know we still “aren’t there” in the mortification/detachment department. :takethat:

When our minds are programmed by society to get upset when things are out of control, then I have to think what our supposed “intelligence” is really doing for us, at the heart level. 🤓

Alan
 
I’ve noticed that almost every book I read on spirituality brings up the idea that detachment is necessary for spiritual growth. I’ve found this line of thought in the Dhammapada, The Bhagavad Gita, the Tao Te Ching, The Enchiridon, and now I’m reading The Way of Perfection by St Teresa and it says basically the same thing, that detachment from all created things is necessary for spiritual growth beyond a certain point. Can this detachment be achieved while we’re here on earth? It may be possible on a day to day basis as we go about our routine, but it would be another thing altogether to maintain a sense of detachment if you were in a war, natural disaster, homeless, etc.
Yes, it is possible. We have the Saints as proof of that. Yet, before anything else, we must believe in the One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church, all Her doctrines of faith, before we even consider a more proper prayer life!!!

If we have not faith, how can we pray? If we have not hope, why do we pray? If we have not charity of heart, if we have not love, for whom do we pray?
 
Yet, before anything else, we must believe in the One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church, all Her doctrines of faith, before we even consider a more proper prayer life!!!
Sounds like you’re putting the head before the heart.
 
I’ve noticed that almost every book I read on spirituality brings up the idea that detachment is necessary for spiritual growth. I’ve found this line of thought in the Dhammapada, The Bhagavad Gita, the Tao Te Ching, The Enchiridon, and now I’m reading The Way of Perfection by St Teresa and it says basically the same thing, that detachment from all created things is necessary for spiritual growth beyond a certain point. Can this detachment be achieved while we’re here on earth? It may be possible on a day to day basis as we go about our routine, but it would be another thing altogether to maintain a sense of detachment if you were in a war, natural disaster, homeless, etc.
Can it be achieved? I would say yes…At least to a very large degree. We have the examples of some very great Saints in this regard. The degree of detachment that we are able to achieve may depend to some extent on our particular station in life and the degree of spiritual gifts we are blessed with. As to the matter of maintaining detachment in tines of great trial…I would say that the more detached one is in their day to day life, the more prepared they will be to remain detached in times of great trial.

The thing to recognize in this is that the detachment (from the world) is subsidiary to attachment to God. It should be a natural outgrowth of the development and growth of Agape Love in our hearts. Jesus refers to this idea, here…
"When the unclean spirit has gone out of a man, he passes through waterless places seeking rest, but he finds none. Then he says, ‘I will return to my house from which I came.’ And when he comes he finds it empty, swept, and put in order. Then he goes and brings with him seven other spirits more evil than himself, and they enter and dwell there; and the last state of that man becomes worse than the first. (Mt 12:43-45
If we only seek to “clean out” (detach) then we leave ourselves open to even worse things. But if the demon returns to find the house, not empty, but filled with God he cannot reenter. So it is that we should begin with Love, inviting God in with His Love and so displace all else that might be in our heart. Detachment from all that is not Love then comes naturally.

I say it is natural…but that does not mean it is easy. It does require effort. even “letting go” requires effort. Alan gives some good examples above of how we can be attached to the world in sometimes subtle ways. It takes prayer and reflection to come to a proper understanding of detachment from things while also still making proper use of them.

Peace
James
 
It’s not detachment from all created things, but a detachment from the self-serving ego-identity which seeks to possess.

We look at a beautiful sun rise and give thanks to God for the gift. However, do we try to possess it for the ego’s self-identification?

As an example, the person takes a photo of the beautiful sun rise, and then uses the photo for their own ego driven agenda in order to bring attention to themselves, rather than God who created the sun rise in the first place.

It’s detachment from this sort of ego drive agenda’s that we’re called to, if we seek to grow spiritually. We place nothing before union with God.

Jim
 
We must first hold the basic tenets of the Faith, which leads us to Jacob’s ladder to Heaven, before we use spirituality to climb.
You’re still putting the head before the heart. As a “must first” proposition, no less.

In fact, many spiritual masters advocate “unlearning” as a key to radical spiritual advancement. Learning, in and of itself, creates pride which pushes us away from God. But don’t take my word for it. Listen to St. Paul:

1 Cor 8:1b-3
knowledge inflates with pride, but love builds up. If anyone supposes he knows something, he does not yet know as he ought to know. But if one loves God, one is known by him.

If you’d written “while” instead of “before,” it might have helped, but the fact is you can be illiterate and have very little inkling of what’s going on, and yet have a perfect disposition and a kind and loving heart. That’s spirituality. Knowing stuff isn’t. That’s a problem with spirituality, is that some of us think that love can’t be without first having knowledge. Another problem is thinking that amassing knowledge will automatically bring us to love – like we pass a written test to qualify for heaven. That is why we need detachment, even detachment from what we think we “know.”

We think everything is about passing tests and qualifying to move on to the next step. The spiritual journey begins when we are still in diapers, and don’t know all these things you are saying.

1 Cor 13:2
And if I have the gift of prophecy and comprehend all mysteries and all knowledge; if I have all faith so as to move mountains but do not have love, I am nothing.

So amassing knowledge – even knowledge of all the Church teachings – is neither a necessary nor a sufficient condition for spirituality.

Matt 13:43b
Whoever has ears ought to hear.

Alan
 
+JMJ+

I hope you guys are not talking about Quietism here.
Not at all.

Here’s the definition of “Quietism,” which was condemned by the Church
Quietism (Latin quies, quietus, passivity) in the broadest sense is the doctrine which declares that man’s highest perfection consists in a sort of psychical self-annihilation and a consequent absorption of the soul into the Divine Essence even during the present life. In the state of “quietude” the mind is wholly inactive; it no longer thinks or wills on its own account, but remains passive while God acts within it. Quietism is thus generally speaking a sort of false or exaggerated mysticism, which under the guise of the loftiest spirituality contains erroneous notions which, if consistently followed, would prove fatal to morality.
Jim
 
You’re still putting the head before the heart. As a “must first” proposition, no less.

In fact, many spiritual masters advocate “unlearning” as a key to radical spiritual advancement. Learning, in and of itself, creates pride which pushes us away from God. But don’t take my word for it. Listen to St. Paul:

1 Cor 8:1b-3
knowledge inflates with pride, but love builds up. If anyone supposes he knows something, he does not yet know as he ought to know. But if one loves God, one is known by him.

If you’d written “while” instead of “before,” it might have helped, but the fact is you can be illiterate and have very little inkling of what’s going on, and yet have a perfect disposition and a kind and loving heart. That’s spirituality. Knowing stuff isn’t. That’s a problem with spirituality, is that some of us think that love can’t be without first having knowledge. Another problem is thinking that amassing knowledge will automatically bring us to love – like we pass a written test to qualify for heaven. That is why we need detachment, even detachment from what we think we “know.”

We think everything is about passing tests and qualifying to move on to the next step. The spiritual journey begins when we are still in diapers, and don’t know all these things you are saying.

1 Cor 13:2
And if I have the gift of prophecy and comprehend all mysteries and all knowledge; if I have all faith so as to move mountains but do not have love, I am nothing.

So amassing knowledge – even knowledge of all the Church teachings – is neither a necessary nor a sufficient condition for spirituality.

Matt 13:43b
Whoever has ears ought to hear.

Alan
Sorry, but if you don’t know certain things about spirituality, you can hardly reach heaven with your prayers. For example, if you didn’t know that you must avoid sin to make your prayers more efficacious, you wouldn’t get your prayers heard much.

Also, if you did not know the depth of the mysteries of the Holy Rosary, you would not ascend to the sublime heights of mental prayer.

Sorry, but knowledge adds to faith, not to pride.
 
I think we can gain some clarity by meditating on John 4:20-24

*Our fathers worshiped on this mountain, but you Jews claim that the place where we must worship is in Jerusalem.”

Jesus declared, “Believe me, woman, a time is coming when you will worship the Father neither on this mountain nor in Jerusalem. You Samaritans worship what you do not know; we worship what we do know, for salvation is from the Jews. Yet a time is coming and has now come when the true worshippers will worship the Father in spirit and truth, for they are the kind of worshippers the Father seeks. God is spirit, and his worshippers must worship in spirit and in truth.”* (John 4:20-24)

From the above it is clear that our Lord was differing from those who knew rightly as well those who got it wrong and suggests that true worship transcends both knowledge and ignorance. Then what is it? St.Paul would later teach is what is worship in spirit and in truth:

Therefore, I urge you, brothers, in view of God’s mercy, to offer your bodies as living sacrifices, holy and pleasing to God—this is your spiritual act of worship. (Rom 12:1)

In my understanding it is selfless love.
 
Sorry, but if you don’t know certain things about spirituality, you can hardly reach heaven with your prayers. For example, if you didn’t know that you must avoid sin to make your prayers more efficacious, you wouldn’t get your prayers heard much.
Yes, avoiding sin is good. But “avoiding sin” is an act of the will, not an act of surrender. So yes, what you’re talking about it good – but God has even better gifts in store for us, just waiting to be unwrapped.

And yes, there is a fundamental level of knowledge required to even have a conversation about spirituality, so I’m not against dualistic knowledge. But I know it can take a tough break, to crack open the dualistic mind to accept the non-dualistic teachings of Jesus. The problem is, “knowledge” is by its nature dualistic – so the more you know, or think you know, the harder it is to transcend the dualistic-only mindsets.

Again, 1 Cor 8:2
“If anyone supposes he knows something, he does not yet know as he ought to know.”

So it doesn’t say he doesn’t know anything, just that he doesn’t know as he ought. This is where the pride comes in.
Also, if you did not know the depth of the mysteries of the Holy Rosary, you would not ascend to the sublime heights of mental prayer.
Not saying the Rosary is not instrumental, but by “mental prayer” if you mean contemplative, that prayer is in silence. Are you talking about meditative prayer?
Sorry, but knowledge adds to faith, not to pride.
While you’re explaining things to me, explain to me how you can read this scripture:

“knowledge inflates with pride, but love builds up”

And make the statement you just made that knowledge does not add to pride. Doesn’t the scripture count as one of the areas of study – for knowledge seekers? Here we have the revealed Truth of God and you are directly contradicting it, as far as my mortal mind can tell. 🤓

“They” say if we repeat a lie often enough it becomes truth. Certainly, being knowledgeable, you have heard these scripture before and now I have repeated them myself. Do you still want to directly contradict revealed Truth, now that I have repeated it to you? :bible1:

If it sounds like I’m being hard on you, I’m not trying to; I’m trying to make a point. You can’t put new wine into old wineskins. :nope:

Summary: is learning bad, in and of itself? No. Is intellectual knowledge required to have love? No.

Alan
 
Yes, avoiding sin is good. But “avoiding sin” is an act of the will, not an act of surrender. So yes, what you’re talking about it good – but God has even better gifts in store for us, just waiting to be unwrapped.

Not saying the Rosary is not instrumental, but by “mental prayer” if you mean contemplative, that prayer is in silence. Are you talking about meditative prayer?

While you’re explaining things to me, explain to me how you can read this scripture:

“knowledge inflates with pride, but love builds up”

And make the statement you just made that knowledge does not add to pride. Doesn’t the scripture count as one of the areas of study – for knowledge seekers? Here we have the revealed Truth of God and you are directly contradicting it, as far as my mortal mind can tell. 🤓

“They” say if we repeat a lie often enough it becomes truth. Certainly, being knowledgeable, you have heard these scripture before and now I have repeated them myself. Do you still want to directly contradict revealed Truth, now that I have repeated it to you? :bible1:

If it sounds like I’m being hard on you, I’m not trying to; I’m trying to make a point. You can’t put new wine into old wineskins. :nope:

Alan
Hi Alan, I can show you other scriptures that suggest that knowledge makes you humble. My intention is not to argue or debate, but try and help share whatever clarity that I think I’ve gained. Every good has the potential to be perverted to something bad through distortion of purpose. The distortion comes from our interior defilement and not from the God created good thing. Food and wine meant for our good become poison only when we are gluttons or crave for sensual pleasure. You can actually see for yourself that they cause harm only to those who have the vice. So it is with knowledge or power.

Knowledge is a useful power that is gifted for achieving God’s purpose. Love is a virtue, i.e., a divine nature, which is a must for going to God. They both should never be compared. Satan is capable of distorting both. We may easily be deceived to exchange Agape for self-love.

This is how I differentiated for myself “spiritual gifts” and “virtues”. Spiritual gifts are bestowed by God to be used for His own purpose. It can be given to the good and bad alike and purely meant for His divine purpose. Babylon may receive power to punish Israel and a donkey may prophesy to humble a proud king. On the other hand, virtues are God’s own nature and we must acquire them without fail in order to live with Him.
 
Hi Alan, I can show you other scriptures that suggest that knowledge makes you humble. My intention is not to argue or debate, but try and help share whatever clarity that I think I’ve gained. Every good has the potential to be perverted to something bad through distortion of purpose. The distortion comes from our interior defilement and not from the God created good thing. Food and wine meant for our good become poison only when we are gluttons or crave for sensual pleasure. You can actually see for yourself that they cause harm only to those who have the vice. So it is with knowledge or power.
I think you make some good points. One reason I’m probably being so stubborn about all this, is that I have been very technical all my life so it hit me like a ton of bricks when my intellectual world totally crashed down, 11 years ago. In this case, of course I cannot prove it, but I’m sensing the poster has the same sort of outlook I used to have: that more study is the first solution to every problem. It scares me for people when I think they’re thinking like I was … but I also have to admit that their path is not mine, so just because they are like I was doesn’t mean they’ll undergo the same trials as a result.
Knowledge is a useful power that is gifted for achieving God’s purpose. Love is a virtue, i.e., a divine nature, which is a must for going to God. They both should never be compared. Satan is capable of distorting both. We may easily be deceived to exchange Agape for self-love.
I don’t understand what you mean by they shouldn’t be compared? Doesn’t 1 Cor 13 compares love to knowledge, and conclude that love prevails over knowledge?

Alan
 
…I don’t understand what you mean by they shouldn’t be compared? Doesn’t 1 Cor 13 compares love to knowledge, and conclude that love prevails over knowledge?

Alan
Read my edited post which provides additional clarity. I have the greatest respect for the Scriptures and St. Paul but I believe that while they are abundantly rich in truth they also include human shortcomings. Even the God appointed shepherds are mere humans in the flesh and not pure angels. The letters of St.Paul are too rich in spiritual truths and rightly declared canonical. Yet there is no one so great who may edit or doctor the contents to render it into cent percent truth. There is only one thing that I am sure of - no canonical text can lead you to hell and all human shortcomings that come with truth can do no harm. The Holy Spirit guides you to learn the truth needed.
 
Yes, it is possible. We have the Saints as proof of that. Yet, before anything else, we must believe in the One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church, all Her doctrines of faith, before we even consider a more proper prayer life!!!
This does not seem to line up with the Catechism which states…
“Those who, through no fault of their own, do not know the Gospel of Christ or his Church, but who nevertheless seek God with a sincere heart, and, moved by grace, try in their actions to do his will as they know it through the dictates of their conscience - those too may achieve eternal salvation.” (CCC 847)(LG-16)
So - if those who have never heard the Gospel are able to achieve Salvation - based on sincere heart, grace and conscience - it follows that your statement that we must believe in the One Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church…" is in error.
If we have not faith, how can we pray? If we have not hope, why do we pray? If we have not charity of heart, if we have not love, for whom do we pray?
👍👍
We must first hold the basic tenets of the Faith, which leads us to Jacob’s ladder to Heaven, before we use spirituality to climb.
See - here things start to get a bit confusing…First you say that, “we must believe in the One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church, all Her doctrines of faith, before we even consider a more proper prayer life” and here you say that one must hold to the, “basic tenets of Faith”. Which is it?
Sorry, but if you don’t know certain things about spirituality, you can hardly reach heaven with your prayers.
OK - now we moved a bit again…Now we must know something about spirituality…I’m getting more and more confused.
For example, if you didn’t know that you must avoid sin to make your prayers more efficacious, you wouldn’t get your prayers heard much.
Disagree here. All prayer is heard - even that of terrible sinners. It may well be [through prayer that one learns that they must avoid sin…
Also, if you did not know the depth of the mysteries of the Holy Rosary, you would not ascend to the sublime heights of mental prayer.
Again - this seems to be contrary to what is stated in the Catechism. Of course it may be that one can reach salvation without reaching the “sublime heights of mental prayer”.
Sorry, but knowledge adds to faith, not to pride.
I’m not so sure about this. Perhaps this is true in your case, but I don’t think that it is a blanket truth.
In a very basic sense, knowledge must subtract from faith since the more knowledge one has, the less they need to rely on faith. Paul speaks to this in 1 Cor 13 where he is talking about faith passing away because, once we are with God we will know - thus we will no longer need faith.
Likewise knowledge can and does lead to pride…Though that too is not a blanket truth in all cases.
Perhaps what is needed here is a better term. Wisdom.
Wisdom allows knowledge and faith to work together for the benefit of the soul.

Sorry if this seems somewhat disjointed…or like I’m picking you apart…That is not my intent.
I wonder if there is a disconnect between yourself and Alan and I in understanding what is meant by “spirituality”…

Peace
James
 
I wonder if there is a disconnect between yourself and Alan and I in understanding what is meant by “spirituality”…
Yes there is, I’m pretty sure. But …

… right now all this seems pretty unimportant, as I’m sitting in the recovery room with my daughter and son-in-law, after she delivered my first grandson this morning. :dancing:

Alan
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top