Spirituality and Morality - Advice needed

  • Thread starter Thread starter BeatriceSmith
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

BeatriceSmith

Guest
I apologize if this is not the right place for this post, but it does pertain to spiritual matters, so I thought I’d take the chance and post it here.

As I’ve mentioned in my one other post of any length here, I was an atheist for ten years before I decided that I wanted (needed) deeper meaning to my life. It took about a year from that point to find the Catholic Church, but now that I have my entire life has changed for the better, and I can wait to start RCIA in another couple of weeks.

One of the ways my life has changed is that, after ending a relationship of three years in January of this year, I unexpectedly met a great guy who has been so supportive of my spiritual journey. He himself is a Catholic youth minister, and I honestly feel like God brought us together for a very good reason. We started seeing each other in April of this year, and our relationship has been good, though not perfect. (Perfection isn’t a requirement, though, luckily). I feel like he’s the kind of person I could choose to love everyday, though, which is the example I’ve gotten from my parents: that sometimes love is a choice you make, not a feeling. My parents have had a good, stable marriage despite the many hardships they’ve faced (poverty, cancer, job loss, etc.), so I look to their 38 years together as a model far more than more romantic depictions given to us by popular culture. I want what they have. But I digress.

One of the rules I had in my last relationship (the one that lasted three years) was no sex before marriage. I’d previously been in a long-term relationship when I was 20 (through age 23) in which I had sex with my boyfriend (we also lived together briefly), and the feelings I experienced when it ended (badly) were made worse by the fact that I’d given my virginity to a man who didn’t, in the end, value me the way I felt I deserved. I felt that I’d cheated myself. I vowed that I would not risk that again for anybody less than my husband. My last boyfriend respected that, and when we broke up, it was because of a physical distance that couldn’t be bridged without extreme sacrifces on both our parts. Our breakup was sane and kind and amicable and we are still great friends. I believe, fully, that the fact that we didn’t have sex contributed greatly to our ability to be such good friends, to build such a strong foundation which allowed us to respect and love each other beyond the physical, and I’m so happy we never crossed that line, even if it seems insane to some to date for so long without hopping into bed with him.

So now, as I said, I’m dating a Catholic (and a youth minister to boot). I’m now 28, and he just turned 30. We discussed not having sex before marriage before we dated and both agreed that it was what we should do. He has also previously had sex (five partners), the last time just a little over a year ago. (Before we met.) He has admitted to me that he struggles with lust and that sex is most definitely his greatest weakness. I don’t, of course, hold that against him. I’m glad to know that I have it within my power to be helpful to him by not encouraging him to sin through my own actions. We are very careful when we’re together not to test the limits. I don’t undress in front of him, and my clothing is pretty modest anyway, so I’m not running around in skimpy outfits or anything. We’ve never seen each other naked and decided early on that we shouldn’t until after marriage, as it might prove too tempting to have sex if we did. We have shared sleeping arrangements, but when we do, I’m careful not to wear any “cute” pajamas. I have an old pair of his sweats, and I wear oversized t-shirts, and I laugh that we’re going backwards: that he’ll only ever see me looking cute or sexy at bedtime after we get married and that the frumpy pajamas are being employed now, before we’re married.

Anyway, I’m not going to say that I never struggle with desrie. I find my boyfriend very attractive physically, and the more I know him, the more I’m attracted to him. We do kiss, of course, and there is certainly chemistry. I’ve gone out of my way at times to avoid kissing him too much, in fact. At times it has seemed like I struggled more than he did, but lately he’s admitted to me that he isn’t sure he wants to wait until marriage. Oh, he knows that it’s the right thing to do, and believe me, I’m not going to have sex with him just to “keep” him. But it would break my heart if sex became the reason we couldn’t be together anymore, if he chose the opportunity to sleep with someone who was willing over the opportunity to have a relationship with me, who is VERY willing to have sex, just not right now. I fear that he will give in to temptation, for he is most definitely surrounded by it (as are we all). I believe that he is a good and worthy man, and I pray for him all the time (for other reasons, too). But I want to know how I can support him and help him and encourage him to see the wisdom and the love in the decision to wait. I feel like praying for him silently won’t do enough, that I need to turn prayer into action.

To be clear, we are serious about each other. He had previously been discerning a vocation to the priesthood (of which I was supportive), but when we started dating he began discerning a vocation to marriage with me. Neither one of us is into dating casually. (Though we agreed that we would date for a year to a year and a half before getting engaged.)

Also, to clarify matters more, I have never taken birth control and so, practically, would not risk sex before marriage (again) due to risk of pregnancy. I’m also proud of the amazing things my boyfriend does with his youth group kids, and it is of the utmost importance to me that he be able to approach them with integrity when he talks to them about avoiding temptation and being morally upright. To me, sex, as great as it can be (and, boy, can it ever be great) is not worth risking his career. Those kids adore him, as do their parents, the Msgr. at our church, and the others who work in faith formation with him. I know that we have both made mistakes, but I also believe that it is never too late to start making the right decisions, that we can be and have been forgiven.

How can I help my boyfriend with this struggle without stepping on his toes? I want to be supportive of him because I am so proud of him, and I feel like, as his girlfriend, I should admire and respect him (which I do) and encourage him to do the good things that come naturally to him while also understanding that he is as imperfect and human as I am.

Any advice?
 
How can I help my boyfriend with this struggle without stepping on his toes? I want to be supportive of him because I am so proud of him, and I feel like, as his girlfriend, I should admire and respect him (which I do) and encourage him to do the good things that come naturally to him while also understanding that he is as imperfect and human as I am.

Any advice?
I am responding as someone who would probably be considered part of the “liberal” half of the Catholic spectrum, for the most part.

I can, to some degree, appreciate the freedom some Catholics have of the constraints of our faith, i.e., what constitutes “adultery”.

However, I must say, are you guys for real? A Catholic Youth Minister who would sleep with his girlfriend and would give in to lust with yet another girl? What kind of model is this for the kids? Of course, your relationship is private, but what would the parents of the kids in his program think if any of this came out? Premarital sex is a “sin” for a reason, and, yes, we all think we won’t be subject to the consequences “it won’t happen to me!”

I would say the answer is to get married, but your worry about the conditional nature of your relationship, i.e. that sex would be necessary to keep his interest, says loud and clear that your communication and commitment level is not there yet, by a long shot.

Sorry to be so hard on you here, but it was time to be. And some of the things you are doing together will definitely “lead you to temptation”. Your age says “maturity”, but your commitment level says “not ready”. Sexual intimacy belongs in a relationship where the Sacrament of Matrimony has taken place - and nowhere else.
 
I am responding as someone who would probably be considered part of the “liberal” half of the Catholic spectrum, for the most part.

I can, to some degree, appreciate the freedom some Catholics have of the constraints of our faith, i.e., what constitutes “adultery”.

However, I must say, are you guys for real? A Catholic Youth Minister who would sleep with his girlfriend and would give in to lust with yet another girl? What kind of model is this for the kids? Of course, your relationship is private, but what would the parents of the kids in his program think if any of this came out? Premarital sex is a “sin” for a reason, and, yes, we all think we won’t be subject to the consequences “it won’t happen to me!”

I would say the answer is to get married, but your worry about the conditional nature of your relationship, i.e. that sex would be necessary to keep his interest, says loud and clear that your communication and commitment level is not there yet, by a long shot.

Sorry to be so hard on you here, but it was time to be. And some of the things you are doing together will definitely “lead you to temptation”. Your age says “maturity”, but your commitment level says “not ready”. Sexual intimacy belongs in a relationship where the Sacrament of Matrimony has taken place - and nowhere else.
I appreciate your reaction, but I need to clarify something. He was not a Catholic youth minister when he had sex. He converted to Catholicism and then became a youth minister after much prayer and consideration. He has done much to reform himself, and I am very proud of the conscious decisions he makes everyday not to give into the things he did before without thinking much about them. He struggles, but that doesn’t mean his failures should be held against him, nor should his great strides towards living a live for Christ be overlooked. He regrets his decisions to do what was popular rather than what was right more than anybody. He has failed to do what he knew was right, failed to live in a way that was honest and demonstrated integrity, and he is as aware of that as anybody.

We haven’t had sex. When I say that we’ve “slept” together, I don’t mean that it is something that we do regularly. We have been in situations where we have been coupled together as far as sleeping arrangements go, and we have shared a mattress. I should also have said that these situations have involved other people in the same room or in the next room, and our doing anything other than sleeping would have been impossible, not to mention inappropriate.

Rest assured that this man takes his role as a youth minister very seriously, as do I. He cannot stand in front of the kids and say that he has never sinned, but he can stand in front of them and speak honestly of the repercussions of failing to do God’s will and of the rewards of living a moral life.

And if we get married, believe that I would have made sure we didn’t need to have sex in order to keep his interest. My goodness, but that was an unfair assumption to make. I said we would date for at least a year before an engagement, and a wedding wouldn’t happen for at least another year. We’ve been dating for five months. There is a whole lot more talking and thinking and praying to be done. What I asked for was advice on how to approach him when he struggles. I am not looking to jump into marriage with him just so we can have sex. I am worth more than that. I expressed my fears based on experience and what I see as the pressure of a popular culture obsessed with sex and instant gratification. I worry he will give in and make a bad decision based on that, not based on anything he’s said to me about us having sex. He’s expressed only a worry about waiting, not any sort of threat about us not being together anymore unless we have sex. He’s never said anything of the sort. We just live in a culture that glorifies sex, cheating, and not thinking about consequences, and I am a consumer of pop culture (for a living). Like I said, I was expressing a fear, not an actual threat.

I can’t help but feel as though you’re comments assumed the worst of him (and me) and carried that over into his current life choices and occupations. It was perhaps my fault for not expressing the situation clearly, and for that I apologize.

Thank you for your comments.
 
As Catholics, you both know fornication is a serious sin. Therefore, by all means avoid any occasion of sin. Do not be in any place alone that may lead to action of sin. Go to Eucharistic Adoration together and pray the Rosary together.
 
As Catholics, you both know fornication is a serious sin. Therefore, by all means avoid any occasion of sin. Do not be in any place alone that may lead to action of sin. Go to Eucharistic Adoration together and pray the Rosary together.
Thank you very much. We have prayed the Rosary together, and we will continue to do so. We also attend Mass togther on Sundays (I go alone on weekdays, as we live one city apart).
 
I appreciate your reaction, but I need to clarify something. He was not a Catholic youth minister when he had sex. He converted to Catholicism and then became a youth minister after much prayer and consideration. He has done much to reform himself, and I am very proud of the conscious decisions he makes everyday not to give into the things he did before without thinking much about them. He struggles, but that doesn’t mean his failures should be held against him, nor should his great strides towards living a live for Christ be overlooked. He regrets his decisions to do what was popular rather than what was right more than anybody. He has failed to do what he knew was right, failed to live in a way that was honest and demonstrated integrity, and he is as aware of that as anybody.

We haven’t had sex. When I say that we’ve “slept” together, I don’t mean that it is something that we do regularly. We have been in situations where we have been coupled together as far as sleeping arrangements go, and we have shared a mattress. I should also have said that these situations have involved other people in the same room or in the next room, and our doing anything other than sleeping would have been impossible, not to mention inappropriate.

Rest assured that this man takes his role as a youth minister very seriously, as do I. He cannot stand in front of the kids and say that he has never sinned, but he can stand in front of them and speak honestly of the repercussions of failing to do God’s will and of the rewards of living a moral life.

And if we get married, believe that I would have made sure we didn’t need to have sex in order to keep his interest. My goodness, but that was an unfair assumption to make. I said we would date for at least a year before an engagement, and a wedding wouldn’t happen for at least another year. We’ve been dating for five months. There is a whole lot more talking and thinking and praying to be done. What I asked for was advice on how to approach him when he struggles. I am not looking to jump into marriage with him just so we can have sex. I am worth more than that. I expressed my fears based on experience and what I see as the pressure of a popular culture obsessed with sex and instant gratification. I worry he will give in and make a bad decision based on that, not based on anything he’s said to me about us having sex. He’s expressed only a worry about waiting, not any sort of threat about us not being together anymore unless we have sex. He’s never said anything of the sort. We just live in a culture that glorifies sex, cheating, and not thinking about consequences, and I am a consumer of pop culture (for a living). Like I said, I was expressing a fear, not an actual threat.

I can’t help but feel as though you’re comments assumed the worst of him (and me) and carried that over into his current life choices and occupations. It was perhaps my fault for not expressing the situation clearly, and for that I apologize.

Thank you for your comments.
I apologize for the assumptions. You may want to modify this line, and concentrate on this in your conversations with him:
… But it would break my heart if sex became the reason we couldn’t be together anymore, if he chose the opportunity to sleep with someone who was willing over the opportunity to have a relationship with me, who is VERY willing to have sex, just not right now. I fear that he will give in to temptation…
Here is my advice, for what its worth. Take this up with him. This part of your post sends up a lot of red flags to me. You are torn, but there is a big voice in you that says “wait”. Listen to that voice, not the other voice. If he can’t wait, then the relationship is not there anyway. Sorry to be so blunt, I am not usually like this. If your relationship has great potential, maybe your timeline for marriage is too long.

Standing up in front of a group of kids and admitting to sin is one thing. Standing in front of a group of kids and encouraging them to “wait for marriage”, and then going home and living the opposite is quite another.

By the way, my wife and I teach confirmation class in our parish and we will be celebrating 30 years of matrimony next month. There are really no words that can describe the impact of a life-commitment to a spouse. I learned more about God from our relationship than I could ever possibly learn from a book or belonging to a community.
 
Sweet friend, I think that you need to hear that you are doing a great job. We all have a past. It is important to acknowledge our mistakes, our weaknesses, and our temptations. It is equally important to counterbalance our mistakes with our goals, our strengths, and our intentions and hopes for the future.

Pray without ceasing for this man that you love. Pray for purity of heart, purity of mind, and strength. As a woman, you are called to help guide him to Heaven. As a man, he is called to do the same for you. Having sexual feelings for him is entirely natural and good, and not acting upon those feelings until marriage is the absolute best thing you can do.

Something that helped me with this situation (my husband and I did wait until marriage) was to remind myself that I love, cherish and care for the condition of his eternal spirit more than his physical body. That’s not to downplay my love of him physically, but it helped me keep it in perspective. Those feelings for the physical WILL be met, once married.

Bottom line: pray without ceasing! You are doing well! Stay strong. …You might want to put an end to overnight sleeping arrangements, because that could easily set up a situation of temptation.

I am praying for you!
 
I am sorry to rain the the parade but sex before marriage is mortal sin period. taking the birth control pill is sin period. While both of you made mistakes in the past does not justify it now.
Premarital sex sins against your own body and damages the marital bond when you do get married. both need to stop, either get married or break it off and move on and work on remaining pure. Praying the rosary together does not justify or spiritualize you having sex together. If he is having sex with you, he should not be a Catholic youth minister, he is setting a bad example for our youth. This is all wrong and to start any relationship out in mortal sin will not work and it will not last.
 
I apologize for the assumptions. You may want to modify this line, and concentrate on this in your conversations with him:

Here is my advice, for what its worth. Take this up with him. This part of your post sends up a lot of red flags to me. You are torn, but there is a big voice in you that says “wait”. Listen to that voice, not the other voice. If he can’t wait, then the relationship is not there anyway. Sorry to be so blunt, I am not usually like this. If your relationship has great potential, maybe your timeline for marriage is too long.

Standing up in front of a group of kids and admitting to sin is one thing. Standing in front of a group of kids and encouraging them to “wait for marriage”, and then going home and living the opposite is quite another.

By the way, my wife and I teach confirmation class in our parish and we will be celebrating 30 years of matrimony next month. There are really no words that can describe the impact of a life-commitment to a spouse. I learned more about God from our relationship than I could ever possibly learn from a book or belonging to a community.
Maybe you could give her some of the strategies that you used to prevent you and your wife from fornicating. How did you cope with the temptation and resist.
 
How can I help my boyfriend with this struggle without stepping on his toes? …
Any advice?
Stop sleeping in the same place, I don’t care how you are dressed.

Set a date.

You will both be very glad you did not have sex before marriage.
 
I am sorry to rain the the parade but sex before marriage is mortal sin period. taking the birth control pill is sin period. While both of you made mistakes in the past does not justify it now.
Premarital sex sins against your own body and damages the marital bond when you do get married. both need to stop, either get married or break it off and move on and work on remaining pure. Praying the rosary together does not justify or spiritualize you having sex together. If he is having sex with you, he should not be a Catholic youth minister, he is setting a bad example for our youth. This is all wrong and to start any relationship out in mortal sin will not work and it will not last.
You aren’t raining on anybody’s parade–doesn’t every comment in this thread agree with you that sex before marriage is a very serious mortal sin? Whose parade do you think you are raining on? 🙂

Unless I read the OP’s post incorrectly, she and her boyfriend are not having sex. She is asking for advise on how to keep him free from temptation and how to stay strong in her own temptations. 🤷
 
Maybe you could give her some of the strategies that you used to prevent you and your wife from fornicating. How did you cope with the temptation and resist.
you do not put yourself in situations where you are alone and private. You limit your physical affection to the very basics. You spend more time in groups and public settings. Since this has already been violated, they really should move on from each other. If they get married, it probably will not last if at all. Faithful in marriage starts before marriage. that is why there is such a high divorce rate for people that live together before marriage. Some youth ministry who has already had sex with 5 others should not even be a youth minister. He has a problem (along with the OP) and I would not want him around my youth.
 
You aren’t raining on anybody’s parade–doesn’t every comment in this thread agree with you that sex before marriage is a very serious mortal sin? Whose parade do you think you are raining on? 🙂

Unless I read the OP’s post incorrectly, she and her boyfriend are not having sex. She is asking for advise on how to keep him free from temptation and how to stay strong in her own temptations. 🤷
She is on birth control. That tell you something.
 
I apologize for the assumptions. You may want to modify this line, and concentrate on this in your conversations with him
You’re very right in that it makes my fear seem like a kind of omnipresent threat, like we’re on the verge of something. We’re not there yet, and I have dated other guys (briefly) who said they were fine with my decision to wait but who then put too much pressure on me. I didn’t give into them, and though I love my boyfriend very much, I wouldn’t give in to him, either. It would break my heart to let go of someone I care about so much, but not as much as it would break my heart to give too much of myself again to someone who couldn’t practice what he preached, not only to his youth group kids, but also to me when he said that he loved me, took my faith seriously, and wanted to wait for marriage himself. We were friends before we dated, and it came out very early on that I had waited with my ex (obviously we never got married and therefore never had sex) and that I would continue to wait. So there have been no surprises. I try to give him credit there, that he wouldn’t have gotten involved with me if he didn’t agree with my choices (which he’s also expressed are his own). But the fear is still there. And when he makes comments like, “I’m still not sure I want to wait,” I can’t help but interpret that as, “…So if I decide I don’t, we’re through, because I know you won’t have sex with me unless we’re married.”

So, really, this is as much about my insecurity as anything else. Not insecurity that I’m not worth waiting for (because I am, and so is he), but insecurity that comes with making a choice that is very much against the flow of society, one that invites ridicule, and which makes dating very difficult at times. I do feel called to marriage and family, and though I accept that it happens as God wills it, I can’t help feeling like I don’t want to get hurt by someone I love.

You and your wife are truly an inspiration. My own parents have been married 38 years, and their commitment to one another, their deep and abiding love and friendship is my model. I deviated from it with my first serious boyfriend (the one I did have sex with), and it was very much to my detriment. I haven’t deviated from it since, and though it’s been harder in some ways, I feel better about myself for it. (Even when I was an atheist and chose to wiat for marriage for reasons that aren’t religious at all.)
Standing up in front of a group of kids and admitting to sin is one thing. Standing in front of a group of kids and encouraging them to “wait for marriage”, and then going home and living the opposite is quite another.
I agree with you wholly here. I have told him time and again that his integrity as a youth minister, as a role model to kids, is so very important to me. It why I make a real effort not to tempt him, though I know it’s in my power to do so. I don’t need that kind of an ego boost; I don’t need him to want me sexually in order to feel loved by him, and I hope and pray he appreciates that. I know too many people who try to validate themselves through sexual attention, and that’s just not my bag. It doesn’t fulfill me. Been there, done that. But I digress. I never thought I’d wind up dating a youth minister, but before we started seeing one another, when I knew my feelings for him were stronger than friendship, I thought very long and hard, talked to my priest, and did a lot of reading to be sure that I was up for what would come along with being the girlfriend, fiancee, or wife of someone who worked for the church. It is not always easy, but I can’t complain that I’m scrutinized just as closely as he is, because it keeps me in mind of the decisions I make everyday, how they help me or hurt me, and how they help me or hurt him. I’m called to be a better Catholic and a better person, not to show off to anybody, but so I can stand up in front of the people who see me as an extention of my boyfriend and not be ashamed of myself or of him.
 
She is on birth control. That tell you something.
This is a quote from her post:
"Also, to clarify matters more, I have never taken birth control and so, practically, would not risk sex before marriage (again) due to risk of pregnancy."

How does that mean she is on birth control?

I know you mean well. We all mean well, and that is why we are encouraging her to stay strong and NOT have sex before marriage. Support from our brothers and sisters is a very, very good thing. 👍
 
She is on birth control. That tell you something.
No I am NOT on birth control. I said in my post that I have NEVER taken birth control. My mother was diagnosed with breast cancer when I was 18, and I made the decision then and there that I could not knowingly take something that messed with my hormones now that I knew very well the risk of cancer in my family line. Through the years my reasons for not taking BCP have expanded, but I have never, ever, ever used a contraceptive, not even for reasons that have nothing to do with avoiding pregnancy.
 
This is a quote from her post:
"Also, to clarify matters more, I have never taken birth control and so, practically, would not risk sex before marriage (again) due to risk of pregnancy."

How does that mean she is on birth control?

I know you mean well. We all mean well, and that is why we are encouraging her to stay strong and NOT have sex before marriage. Support from our brothers and sisters is a very, very good thing. 👍
Thank you! I was about to go back and make sure I’d said that; I thought I’d lost my mind!

I will stay strong. I want things to work out between me and my boyfriend; I don’t date casually. But if it comes down to having sex with him or losing him, I will let him go. I’ll be sad that he couldn’t be stronger for me, but I will not be sad that I didn’t give myself to somebody who wasn’t willing to respect my beliefs, my body, or my heart.
 
Leave this poor girl alone. She came here asking for help to strenghen herself and to help her boyfriend, not to be lectured for something that she is not even doing. She is not having premarital sex. I REPEAT< NOT HAVING PREMARITAL SEX> Leave her alone. or answer the question she is asking.
 
Sweet friend, I think that you need to hear that you are doing a great job. We all have a past. It is important to acknowledge our mistakes, our weaknesses, and our temptations. It is equally important to counterbalance our mistakes with our goals, our strengths, and our intentions and hopes for the future.

Pray without ceasing for this man that you love. Pray for purity of heart, purity of mind, and strength. As a woman, you are called to help guide him to Heaven. As a man, he is called to do the same for you. Having sexual feelings for him is entirely natural and good, and not acting upon those feelings until marriage is the absolute best thing you can do.

Something that helped me with this situation (my husband and I did wait until marriage) was to remind myself that I love, cherish and care for the condition of his eternal spirit more than his physical body. That’s not to downplay my love of him physically, but it helped me keep it in perspective. Those feelings for the physical WILL be met, once married.

Bottom line: pray without ceasing! You are doing well! Stay strong. …You might want to put an end to overnight sleeping arrangements, because that could easily set up a situation of temptation.

I am praying for you!
I have decided that we need to be more open with others about our decision to wait. I think people assume that we are having sex because, hey, EVERYBODY does! So they throw us together when we travel (we travel a lot; we enjoy taking weekend trips to cities, but since we’re both broke, we tend to stay with friends), and we try to make the best of it. I’m torn because I feel like this is private, but I do agree that, eventually, the sleeping arrangements will likely lead us to the brink of temptation if not all the way over it.

I’m not ashamed of our decision to wait at all, but sometimes I don’t know how much information is too much informtaion, and the few people in my life who know that I’m waiting demand an explanation or immediately get defensive and assume that our choice is a judgment on them for not having made the same choice (which it isn’t).

So, yeah, I’ll have to talk to the boyfriend about how to handle this in the future. Maybe we can say he snores and I grind my teeth and we just can’t stand to be in the same room together while we sleep. LOL 😛

As for the rest of your message, thank you so much! Wonderful advice. I’m going to pray on this tonight at Mass.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top